FILE 144 / 7 November 2019 / 163 MIN / full

One In A Ditch & One In A Bed

Forest City, IowaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

James: 'we're going to Forest City Iowa', north central Iowa on the Minnesota border, in both Hancock and Winnebago counties about 0:06:03

History, in brief

Town note

Forest City is in north central Iowa, in the top row of counties on the Minnesota border, in both Hancock and Winnebago counties. It is about two hours five minutes from Des Moines and two hours ten minutes from Minneapolis.

about 0:06:06

Town note

Zip code 50436, area code 641, about four and a half square miles. The town motto is 'where nature's close and friends are closer'.

about 0:10:50

1855

The town was first settled around 1855 and platted in 1856. Its first name was Pucker Brush.

about 0:12:28

1870

The official founder is Robert Clark, who laid out the plat and built the first log cabin, which stood until 1870. Another settler, A. T. Cole, brought the first family in 1856.

about 0:14:27
All 14 history facts

Town note

Forest City is in north central Iowa, in the top row of counties on the Minnesota border, in both Hancock and Winnebago counties. It is about two hours five minutes from Des Moines and two hours ten minutes from Minneapolis.

about 0:06:06

Town note

Zip code 50436, area code 641, about four and a half square miles. The town motto is 'where nature's close and friends are closer'.

about 0:10:50

1855

The town was first settled around 1855 and platted in 1856. Its first name was Pucker Brush.

about 0:12:28

1870

The official founder is Robert Clark, who laid out the plat and built the first log cabin, which stood until 1870. Another settler, A. T. Cole, brought the first family in 1856.

about 0:14:27

1856

A log store was built in 1856, then a hotel on a corner lot that cost five dollars; Clark's hotel was an 18 by 24 foot structure.

about 0:16:12

1879

The Civil War slowed growth, but the land attracted immigrants. In 1879 a rail line between St. Louis and Minneapolis came through, bringing Swedish, Norwegian, German and Danish settlers.

about 0:16:59

1878

Forest City was incorporated in 1878. The first train arrived in 1879 at 3.30 p.m. with the whole town out to watch.

about 0:17:42

1879

Two passenger trains and two freight trains left the depots daily. The first telegraph message went out on Christmas Day 1879.

about 0:18:43

1916

The Farmers Cooperative formed in 1916. In 2007 the county grew the largest average corn yield per acre of any county in Iowa.

about 0:19:20

1998

Forest City community schools built a wind turbine for their facilities in 1998, as a physics project for the high school class.

about 0:19:56

Town note

The town's former hotel became a college (Waldorf College).

about 0:19:11

1975

Notable people: Bob Baker, a singing cowboy in Western films who died in 1975, and Mike Stensrud, a defensive lineman for the Oilers and Vikings who retired in 1989.

about 0:22:31

Town note

Tree City Music Festival used to book large country acts; Country Thunder took it over after a lawsuit by a Nashville production company and a chapter seven bankruptcy by the owner of the other festival.

about 0:29:49

Town note

Pucker Brush Days is a three-day annual celebration named after the dense burred bush that once surrounded the town, with face painting, a pet parade, a salad luncheon, DJs and fireworks.

about 0:30:33

The figures, as told

Religious

66%

Biggest faith: Baptists, 0%

about 0:25:26

Who lives here

White 92% · Black 1.4% · Asian 1.2%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ under half

about 0:32:52

Violent crime
about two-thirds

about 0:33:04

Money

Median home value99300 bucks
Two-bedroom rentabout $664 a month
Median household income47,000
Cost of living81

For sale

$49,500

Listing: three-bedroom, one bath, 1,563 square foot house

about 0:28:22

For sale

$89,500

Listing: four-bedroom, two bath, 2,256 square foot house

about 0:28:45

For sale

$284,500

Listing: three-bedroom, four bath, 2,153 square foot house on four acres

about 0:28:59
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2019

Population in 1920

"2,100"

Comparison: "stayed about the same for roughly 40 to 50 years". No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:23:51

Current population

"4,083"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:24:00

Population change since 1990

"down eight percent"

Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:24:03

Share aged 85 and older

"double"

Comparison: "the normal share". Direction: above.

As told in 2019 about 0:24:08

Married population

"a little less than normal"

Comparison: "normal". Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:24:27

Share who are religious

"66%"

Comparison: "normally 50-50". Direction: above.

As told in 2019 about 0:25:26

Winnebago County vote, Democrat

"33%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:01

Winnebago County vote, Republican

"59%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:01

Winnebago County vote, independent

"7.1%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:01

Unemployment rate

"2.8%"

Comparison: "low". Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:14

Household income

"47,000"

Comparison: "usually about 58,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:18

Jobs in manufacturing

"35%"

Comparison: "normally 10%". No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:29

Cost of living index

"81"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:27:27

Housing cost index

"58"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:27:27

Median home cost

"99300 bucks"

Comparison: "very far below the national figure". Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:27:27

Average two-bedroom rental

"about $664 a month"

Comparison: "half the average in the nation". Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:28:13

Listing: three-bedroom, one bath, 1,563 square foot house

"$49,500"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:28:22

Listing: four-bedroom, two bath, 2,256 square foot house

"$89,500"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:28:45

Listing: three-bedroom, four bath, 2,153 square foot house on four acres

"$284,500"

Comparison: "about the most expensive thing around". No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:28:59

Property crime

"under half"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:32:52

Violent crime

"about two-thirds"

Comparison: "national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:33:04

The reviews

No rated reviews

two stars

“The area is pretty and the locals friendly enough, but the town is controlled by the local factories and the local college, and student athletes have no regard for the community, which creates friction.”
about 0:20:40

In Iowa

Closest episodes

  1. Breaking BadderMason City, Iowa · 6 November 202537 km / 23 miShow on map
  2. Losing Streak LoisBlooming Prairie, Minnesota · 9 January 202583 km / 52 miShow on map
  3. The No Regrets MurdererMontgomery, Minnesota · 7 August 2026132 km / 82 miShow on map
  4. The Warlock TestEyota, Minnesota · 23 October 2022139 km / 86 miShow on map
  5. Cold Blooded "Hero"Early, Iowa · 2 April 2026152 km / 94 miShow on map

The story

Small Town Murder episode 144 covers Forest City, Iowa, a town of 4,083 people in north central Iowa, in Hancock and Winnebago counties. It was founded around 1855, platted in 1856 and first called Pucker Brush; Robert Clark is its official founder. A railway came through in 1879 and the Winnebago motorhome plant is the main employer, with 35% of jobs in manufacturing. The town is 92% white, 66% religious, has low crime and a median home price of about $99,300.

The story begins in 1985 with Jennifer and Bradley Robert 'Rob' Johnson, known as Rob. Rob, 22, was a third-generation farmer's son who had briefly worked at the Winnebago plant, spent six months in Wyoming, and returned to farming. Jennifer, 19, nicknamed Giggles, had graduated from Forest City High School in 1983, begun a teaching course at the University of Northern Iowa and moved to Waldorf College in Forest City after the couple married in June 1984. They lived in a rural farmhouse on the edge of town. Friends said she worked in a church nursery and never touched drugs. Rob, however, sold cocaine from the farmhouse, supplied by two Greek men, Zoas and Aris, from the Iowa Falls area, and many of his customers worked at the Winnebago plant. The house was a social hub for young people.

On Saturday 9 February 1985 Rob was trying to collect about 2,900 dollars to pay his suppliers, who he said broke legs. Friends saw the couple through the day. At 6.30 p.m. a babysitter was told not to come over, which was unusual. At 6.40 Rob phoned a friend in Mason City. At 7.10 a passer-by saw four cars and every light on at the house. At 7.15 Zoas phoned and an unidentified male voice answered and said the Johnsons were not home; Zoas thought it resembled a man he knew as Bubba. At 7.30 only two cars were there and by 8.30 the house was locked with lights and the television on. At 8.40 friends saw a shadow behind the kitchen drape.

On the morning of 10 February friends went in through an unlocked door and found Jennifer naked and face down on the bed in a pool of blood, stabbed more than five times in the back and neck, with a wound that pierced her heart. There was no sexual assault and no murder weapon. Rob was missing. Police ruled out robbery, since nothing of value was gone and both cars were in the garage. They searched by ground and air and set up traffic checks near the house. Rob's pastor said he had been trying to stop using.

On 14 March 1985 utility workers found Rob's frozen body in a ditch six and a half miles from the house, near the Deal home. He was fully clothed and had been shot four times in the back of the head at close range, somewhere else. No gun was found. The pathologist found noodles and vegetables in both victims' stomachs, showing they ate the same meal together, and concluded Rob died first. Police interviewed over a hundred people, from as far south as Iowa Falls. The two Greek suppliers were given immunity and moved to a secret location after investigators decided they were not involved. Friends said Rob owed the suppliers around 4,000 dollars, and a helper, William Trosper, had been carrying money to Iowa Falls.

He was on sick leave from his Winnebago job. His parents and wife said he was in Estherville that evening, arriving between seven and seven thirty, and that his mother did his taxes.

The state pointed to the car, which had four round headlights and rectangular tail lights like the one seen near the Deal house, to gunpowder residue on the passenger side, to cash and to a missing Buck knife. There was no blood in the car.

Newly discovered evidence linked the Greeks to Joel Smitherman, on whose farm Richard Tassler's body was found in 1990. Rob and Jennifer are buried together at Oakland Cemetery in Forest City, sharing a tombstone.

The case

Murders of Jennifer and Rob Johnson

Victims

Jennifer Johnson (19). nicknamed Giggles, student at Waldorf College who wanted to teach first or second grade, stabbed in her bed
Bradley Robert 'Rob' Johnson (22). her husband, farmer and former Winnebago worker who sold cocaine, shot four times in the back of the head and dumped in a ditch

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 7 November 2019.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Zoas Skevelintis. Greek cocaine supplier who phoned the Johnson house at 7.15 p.m. and heard an unidentified male voice, which he said resembled a man he knew as Bubba
Aris Slavakova. the other Greek supplier
Terry Eenhuis ('Bubba'). man whose voice the caller thought he heard
William Trosper. 24, Rob's partner or helper in dealing, who stayed at the house
Doug Book. Forest City police chief
Dennis Hawkins. Iowa Falls police chief
Todd Barens. high school student staying with the s who testified said he killed two people in California while in the Marines
Dean Youngworth. witness who said told him he shot Rob
Michael Hudson. witness who said told him he put a man out of his misery
Crystal Deal. saw a car with four round headlights stop near her house on the night of February 9
Mike Mallory. Iowa Falls man who bragged to several people that he committed the murders; never investigated by the defence
Mary Joe Payne and Billy Payne. witnesses about Mallory's statements
David Grind. later attorney, took the case pro bono, later a magistrate
Holly Steckle. babysitter who spoke to Rob at 6.30 p.m.
Joel Smitherman. man linked to the Greeks; Richard Tassler's body was found on his farm in spring 1990

The timeline

  1. 1961 Sam is born in Estherville, Iowaabout 1:32:56
  2. 1965 Jennifer is born in Mason Cityabout 0:37:50
  3. 1982 earns an honourable discharge as a private first class and finishes high schoolabout 1:33:57
  4. 1983 Jennifer graduates from Forest City High School (Forest City High School)about 0:37:21
  5. July 1983 marries Karen Myers; they have a daughter, Leaabout 1:34:36
  6. the fall of 1983 Jennifer enrols at the University of Northern Iowa in Cedar Falls to study teaching (University of Northern Iowa)about 0:43:30
  7. after Rob graduated high school Rob and Jennifer break up for a while and Rob goes to Wyoming for six monthsabout 0:40:39
  8. June 1984 Rob and Jennifer marry and move to a farmhouse; she enrols at Waldorf College (Johnson farmhouse)about 0:44:37
  9. February 9, 1985, morning A one-minute phone call at 10.22 a.m. from the Johnson house to residence; friends visit the Johnsons through the day (Johnson farmhouse)about 1:57:23
  10. February 9, 1985, afternoon Rob visits apartment demanding payment for cocaine so he can pay the Greeks about three thousand dollars that evening ('s apartment)about 1:36:40
  11. February 9, 1985, between four and five A friend finds Rob and Jennifer eating supper at home (Johnson farmhouse)about 2:02:50
  12. February 9, 1985, 6.30 p.m. A babysitter calls and Rob tells her not to come over; last confirmed contact (Johnson farmhouse)about 0:55:34
  13. February 9, 1985, 7.10 p.m. Marjorie Hall drives past and sees four cars and every light on at the house (Johnson farmhouse)about 2:04:01
  14. February 9, 1985, 7.15 p.m. Zoas phones the Johnsons and an unidentified man answers, saying they are not home (Johnson farmhouse)about 0:57:12
  15. February 9, 1985, 7.30 p.m. A friend drives past and sees two cars, neither (Johnson farmhouse)about 2:04:36
  16. February 9, 1985, between six and nine Crystal Deal sees a car with four round headlights slow or stop near her house, south of which Rob's body was later found (Deal house)about 1:57:56

Last meals

  • Jennifer Johnson. noodles and vegetables, eaten one to one and a half but not more than two hours before her death stomach contents at autopsyabout 1:19:00
  • Rob Johnson. noodles and vegetables, the same meal as Jennifer, eaten at the same time stomach contents at autopsy; he died before Jenniferabout 1:17:33

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode