FILE 431 / 12 October 2023 / 173 MIN / full

My Daddybrother Did It

Clayton, GeorgiaListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Clayton, Georgia, in northeast Georgia, about an hour forty five from Atlanta, in Rabun County. about 0:06:45

History, in brief

1823

Originally called Claytonsville; the name was shortened to Clayton when it was incorporated in 1823.

about 0:07:13

Town note

Named after Augustin S. Clayton, a lawyer, congressman and judge who served in the Georgia House of Representatives and Senate and two terms as a U.S. representative.

about 0:07:33

1824

In 1824, 67 acres were bought for $150, and a courthouse site, streets and Main Street were laid out.

about 0:08:50
All 9 history facts

1823

Originally called Claytonsville; the name was shortened to Clayton when it was incorporated in 1823.

about 0:07:13

Town note

Named after Augustin S. Clayton, a lawyer, congressman and judge who served in the Georgia House of Representatives and Senate and two terms as a U.S. representative.

about 0:07:33

1824

In 1824, 67 acres were bought for $150, and a courthouse site, streets and Main Street were laid out.

about 0:08:50

1936

In 1936 Clayton recorded 30 inches of snowfall, the highest annual total for anywhere in Georgia.

about 0:09:14

1957

Part of the Disney film Old Yeller was shot in Clayton in 1957.

about 0:10:43

1975

The B-movie Grizzly was filmed on location in the 1970s with local residents in supporting roles; production was around Thanksgiving 1975.

about 0:11:14

1976

Grizzly was released in May 1976 and became the most financially successful independent film of its time, holding the record until Halloween in 1978.

about 0:11:33

Town note

Billy Redden, the actor who played the banjo player in Deliverance, is from Clayton.

about 0:12:22

The figures, as told

Religious

82.9%

Biggest faith: Baptist, 41%

about 0:17:17

Who lives here

White 74.3% · Black 3.3% · Asian 0.0% · Hispanic 19.3%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ about one third over

about 0:24:44

Violent crime
▼ about 25% below

about 0:24:51

Money

Median home value$339,300
Two-bedroom rent$870
Median household income$46,875 a year
Cost of living88

For sale

$399,000

House listing, three bedrooms, two bathrooms

about 0:19:55

For sale

$499,000

House listing, two bedrooms, two bathrooms

about 0:21:23

For sale

$1,795,000

House listing, four bedrooms, five bathrooms

about 0:22:24
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

Population

"2,157"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:15:55

Median age

"about 44"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:07

People aged 75 to 84

"twice as many as usual"

Comparison: "usual rate". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:15

People aged 85 and over

"three times as many as usual"

Comparison: "usual rate". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:15

Married people

"27%"

Comparison: "less than normal". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:45

Divorced people

"twice as many as normal"

Comparison: "normal rate". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:45

Single people with children

"28%"

Comparison: "three times the normal rate". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:45

White residents

"74.3%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:00

Black residents

"3.3%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:00

Asian residents

"0.0%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:00

Hispanic residents

"19.3%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:00

Religious people

"82.9%"

Comparison: "50-50 is the normal". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:17

Eastern faith

"8.9%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:48

Unemployment rate

"a little bit lower"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:18:32

Median household income

"$46,875 a year"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:18:41

Cost of living

"88"

Comparison: "100 is normal". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:18:49

Median home cost

"$339,300"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:18:51

Average two-bedroom rent

"$870"

Comparison: "about $400 less than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:19:22

House listing, three bedrooms, two bathrooms

"$399,000"

Comparison: "2,220 square feet on 4.3 acres". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:19:55

House listing, two bedrooms, two bathrooms

"$499,000"

Comparison: "1.19 acres". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:21:23

House listing, four bedrooms, five bathrooms

"$1,795,000"

Comparison: "4,628 square feet on 1.14 acres". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:22:24

Property crime

"about one third over"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:24:44

Violent crime

"about 25% below"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:24:51

The reviews

4.5 / 5 · average of 2

5 stars

“Come visit this wonderful, gorgeous Hallmark town; well-maintained views, hiking, whitewater rafting, biking and farm-to-table restaurants.”
about 0:13:11

4 stars

“A great town surrounded by the Blue Ridge Mountains, with hiking on Black Rock Mountain, kayaking on the Chattooga River and plenty of great places to eat.”
about 0:14:02

“Lived in the county twelve years full-time and thirty-one part-time; beautiful but governed by locals and hard to break in, with builders and conservationists in conflict, county commissioners filled with relatives, lake areas suffering from county neglect, and newcomers needing to care about county government and taxes.”
about 0:14:26

In Georgia

Closest episodes

  1. Saving It For LaterTownville, South Carolina · 20 June 201958 km / 36 miShow on map
  2. An Unexpected SlaughterEasley, South Carolina · 27 December 201775 km / 47 miShow on map
  3. The Tinkerbell Witchcraft DelusionCherry Log, Georgia · 12 March 202690 km / 56 miShow on map
  4. Baby-Faced & DeadlyTraveler's Rest, South Carolina · 5 February 202690 km / 56 miShow on map
  5. Dirty Desires In The BackwoodsTellico Plains, Tennessee · 3 March 202298 km / 61 miShow on map

The story

Clayton is a small town in Rabun County in the north-east corner of Georgia, about an hour and forty-five minutes from Atlanta and five hours and fifteen minutes from Savannah. At the time of the episode its population was 2,157. The story James tells begins not in Clayton itself but with a family whose violence ran across generations. He was a truck driver and a Baptist, and he had children by several women. Dale did not remember the family home fondly. In May 1976 Roger came into the family trailer in Toccoa, about fifteen miles south of Clayton, and found Fay in bed with a man named George Hunt. Roger took a .22 revolver and shot Hunt in the head, killing him. Fay ran, and Roger shot at her and hit her, though she survived. He spent a year in Florida, then returned and Fay took him back. What followed, according to Dale, was sustained abuse. Roger threw hot coffee in Fay's face more than once, choked her, gave her black eyes and beat her with a 64-ounce Hunt's ketchup bottle, glass Coca-Cola bottles and frying pans. At one point he stamped on her until one of her lungs collapsed. Dale also said that in the early 1980s his father sexually abused him, and that he was too frightened to tell his mother because he expected her to be beaten in return. Roger made the boy drive him from bar to bar before Dale had a licence. He chased Dale with shotguns, pulled handguns on him and once dragged him behind a car. Dale jumped between them and she shot the back of Roger's 1971 Ford LTD as he drove away. Fay and Roger eventually separated during the 1980s. Dale's own record began early. Roger had meanwhile met Kathy Van Hook, sixteen years his junior, and married her within a year. They were raising Erica Marie Hayes, Roger's daughter by his former wife Desiree, known as Deszy, who was born about 1990. Roger's lawyer, Richard 'Dick' Tunkle, described him as a changed man who had found God, read Erica bedtime stories and kept a clean home. In about 1995 or 1996 Deszy and Dale left, taking Erica with them. Deszy and Dale married in October 1997. A judge granted Roger and Kathy full custody of Erica, allowed Deszy only supervised visits and barred Dale from being near the child. The judge heard that Dale and Deszy had been caught driving 100 miles an hour the wrong way along a highway with Erica in the back seat. On 9 December 1997 Dale spent the day drinking: five fifths, four beers, a bottle of wine and then three fifths of vodka. His sixteen-year-old nephew, David Andrew 'Drew' Parson, was living with him and Deszy in a dilapidated trailer on U.S. Highway 76 and drank with him. The two played a knife-throwing game. Dale went out on the porch to be sick, came back wiping his mouth and said, 'I gotta go hurt somebody and hurt them bad.' He and Drew drove in Dale's blue Ford Probe to Roger's mobile home on Leatherwood Lane, a few miles outside Clayton. Dale cut the telephone line before going in. He carried two knives. Erica, who was seven, woke when the trailer door was pulled open. Drew said he grabbed her and told her to go back to her room. From the next bedroom Roger said, 'Son, I forgive you for what you're doing.' Kathy was heard calling out, 'Dear Lord Jesus, help us.' Dale told his father he was going to die and asked whether he wanted to be cut or shot; he asked Kathy whether she wanted to live or die. Kathy said she wanted to live to raise Erica, and Dale replied that she had said the wrong thing. He stabbed Roger twenty-three times, including wounds to the scalp and ear, and cut his throat. He stabbed Kathy eighteen times and cut her throat. The bedroom was covered in blood. A clock radio went off at 5.50 a.m. Dale gave Drew the keys and told him to take Erica to her mother. He drove to Fay's house a few miles away, covered in blood and drunk, and told her he thought he had killed Roger and Kathy. Fay telephoned Dale's trailer, where Drew answered, and warned him to get out. Dale stopped at the trailer, then he and Drew drove towards South Carolina and back into Georgia. Near the bridge over the Chattooga River Dale threw a bloody knife into the woods. He took Roger's Monte Carlo down a muddy road, doused it with petrol and burned it. Police found blood by the front door, the cut phone lines and both bodies in the bedroom. A pocket knife and a silver cross had been placed on Roger's chest. The burned Monte Carlo was found near Toccoa. The next day the sheriff and a GBI agent found Dale hiding between a bed and the wall in his mother's guest room. He said he had been drunk and did not remember, but was not sad that Roger was dead. The truck was found abandoned in a restaurant car park in Batavia, Illinois, on 20 February. He was flown back to Georgia. Erica was placed in the custody of the county Department of Family and Children Services, and Deszy filed for divorce.

The case

Murder of George Hunt

Victims

George Hunt. Fay Hayes's lover, shot in the head in the trailer

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 12 October 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Fay Hayes. Roger's wife, shot and wounded during the attack; later took him back
George Hunt. the man found in bed with Fay; prosecutors said he was there to sell her a car

The timeline

  1. 1940 is born in Franklin County, Georgia.about 0:26:24
  2. 1967 Roger's son , known as Dale, is born.about 0:31:29
  3. May 1976 Roger walks into the family trailer in Toccoa, finds Fay in bed with George Hunt, shoots Hunt dead with a .22 revolver and wounds Fay as she runs. (Trailer in Toccoa)about 0:33:52

Murders of Roger and Kathy Hayes

Victims

Roger Hayes. Dale's father; stabbed twenty-three times and had his throat cut
Kathy Rosemary Hayes. Roger's wife; stabbed eighteen times and had her throat cut

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 12 October 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Desiree 'Deszy' Hayes. Roger's ex-wife and Dale's wife; Erica's mother; filed for divorce after the murders
Fay Hayes. Dale's mother and Roger's ex-wife; he came to her house covered in blood after the murders
Richard 'Dick' Tunkle. Roger's divorce attorney

The timeline

  1. 1940 Roger Hayes is born in Franklin County, Georgia.about 0:26:24
  2. 1967 Dale Hayes is born to Roger and Fay.about 0:31:29
  3. when Dale was 12 or 13 Dale is made to drive his drunken father from bar to bar before he has a licence.about 0:43:07
  4. early 1980s Roger begins sexually abusing Dale, according to Dale.about 0:53:31
  5. 1980 Fay tries to shoot Roger at the Toccoa unemployment office; Dale jumps between them and she shoots the car as Roger drives away. (Toccoa unemployment office)about 0:55:53
  6. through the 1980s Fay and Roger eventually separate.about 0:59:00
  7. while on work detail Dale escapes by stealing a white pickup truck and is recaptured a few weeks later.about 1:05:37
  8. less than a month later Dale walks out of an unlocked room, hides in bushes while bloodhounds search, reaches the Appalachian Trail, steals a red Honda, buys a red Chevelle with its checkbook and burns the Honda. (Appalachian Trail)about 1:07:30
  9. three months later Dale is found asleep on the couch at Roger's trailer and recaptured. (Roger Hayes's mobile home)about 1:16:00
  10. about 1990 Erica Marie Hayes is born to Roger and Deszy.about 1:19:38
  11. after Dale gets out of prison Dale moves in with Roger, Deszy and the baby Erica. (Roger Hayes's mobile home)about 1:21:05
  12. 1995 or 1996 Deszy and Dale leave, taking Erica with them.about 1:23:59
  13. October 1997 Dale and Deszy marry.about 1:35:21
  14. October 1997 A judge grants Roger and Kathy full custody of Erica, allows Deszy only supervised visits and bars Dale from the child's presence.about 1:35:58
  15. December 9th, 1997 Dale drinks heavily and plays a knife-throwing game with Drew at his trailer on U.S. Highway 76 before saying he has to hurt somebody badly. (Dale and Deszy's trailer)about 1:40:20
  16. December 9th, 1997, about 5 a.m. Dale and Drew arrive at Roger's mobile home on Leatherwood Lane; Dale cuts the telephone line and goes in carrying two knives. (Roger Hayes's mobile home)about 1:46:18
  17. December 9th, 1997, about 5 a.m. Dale stabs Roger twenty-three times and Kathy eighteen times and cuts both their throats. (Roger Hayes's mobile home)about 1:50:53
  18. December 9th, 1997, 5:50 a.m. The alarm clock goes off in the bedroom after the killings. (Roger Hayes's mobile home)about 1:57:33
  19. December 9th, 1997 Dale gives Drew the keys and tells him to take Erica to her mother, then drives to Fay's house covered in blood and says he thinks he killed Roger and Kathy. (Fay Hayes's house)about 1:58:24

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode