FILE 508 / 6 July 2024 / 72 MIN / express

Stopping A Serial Killer

East Providence, Rhode IslandListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

So here we found East Providence, Rhode Island, which has water between Providence and East Providence; it is in its own little panhandle in north-eastern Rhode Island. about 0:03:45

History, in brief

1775

In 1775 the area was home to a four-cannon fort used to protect the harbour in the event of a British attack.

about 0:04:51

Town note

The area was first part of Rehoboth, then part of Seekonk, Massachusetts.

about 0:05:11

1862

East Providence became an independent Rhode Island town in 1862.

about 0:05:37

Town note

The town is broken into five neighbourhoods: Phillipsdale, Rumford, Watchemoket, Kent Heights and Riverside.

about 0:05:42
All 4 history facts

1775

In 1775 the area was home to a four-cannon fort used to protect the harbour in the event of a British attack.

about 0:04:51

Town note

The area was first part of Rehoboth, then part of Seekonk, Massachusetts.

about 0:05:11

1862

East Providence became an independent Rhode Island town in 1862.

about 0:05:37

Town note

The town is broken into five neighbourhoods: Phillipsdale, Rumford, Watchemoket, Kent Heights and Riverside.

about 0:05:42

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$356,300
Median household income$65,016
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Population

"47,171"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:21

Median household income

"$65,016"

Comparison: "pretty close to the national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:36

Median home cost

"$356,300"

Comparison: "around the average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:42

The reviews

3.2 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“Lived there all their life; great public school district, good sports teams and other programmes for kids, close to Providence and not far from Boston.”
about 0:06:23

3 stars

“Quiet and safe, but an overactive police force with a large amount of extra tax funding that makes too much money from traffic stops and speeding tickets.”
about 0:07:01

3 stars

“Not many incidents of criminal activity, and when there have been the police responded quickly and effectively.”
about 0:07:27

3 stars

“The mayor does not invest enough in the people, the roads are terrible and the priorities are in the wrong areas, but it has always been home.”
about 0:07:54

2 stars

“Wishes there were more late-night dining places; unique restaurants but the nightlife is dull.”
about 0:08:08

In Rhode Island

Closest episodes

  1. Smart People, Stupid MurderBarrington, Rhode Island · 6 August 20228 km / 5 miShow on map
  2. Horrors In The GraveyardPawtucket, Rhode Island · 6 January 20248 km / 5 miShow on map
  3. The Tuxedo KillerCranston, Rhode Island · 6 August 202611 km / 7 miShow on map
  4. Not Much Of A PlanWarren, Rhode Island · 6 July 201812 km / 7 miShow on map
  5. Death Party Crime SpreeNorth Smithfield, Rhode Island · 14 February 202625 km / 16 miShow on map

The story

On the morning of 22 December 1961 Nancy Ann Frenier, nineteen years old and the mother of a six-month-old son, drove her husband William to work in the family car and left the baby with her mother. She planned to do the laundry and then go Christmas shopping. She never came back. Her husband waited for her after work, telephoned her mother, and reported her missing.

The next day her car was found abandoned in a wooded, gravelly spot in East Providence, close to the reservoir. Inside were a basket of washed and folded clothes, a Mammoth Mart paper bag and wrapped Christmas presents. The car was locked with her purse still in it and there was no blood. A man and a girl told police they had seen a man and a woman walking from the car towards the reservoir on the day she vanished and had heard the woman cry out. A Massachusetts storekeeper later said she had come into his shop between five and six that evening, bought cigarettes and asked the way to New Bedford. At about noon she had stopped at a house on Slocum Road in North Dartmouth to use the telephone, and the family there said she seemed upset. Two ten-year-old boys reported seeing a man and a woman walk into woods in Rumford at about two in the afternoon.

Her husband took a lie detector test and passed it; his only lie was that he had given his mother's address in Seekonk rather than his own in Pawtucket, hoping local police would take more interest. Over Christmas the police searched snow-covered woods and went house to house in two states, and dragging crews cut rectangles through eleven inches of ice on the reservoir. On 19 March 1962, when the reservoir thawed, her body floated up in about a foot of water. She had been sexually assaulted and stabbed, and her throat was cut. Her torn clothing lay about five feet away. She was identified by her Attleboro High School class of 1959 ring, a diamond ring, a wedding band and a hairpin engraved with her name. The knife was never found.

On 26 January 1963 Edith Martin, thirty-eight, a bookkeeper at the Allied Anodizing Company in Pawtucket, came home for lunch in South Attleboro, Massachusetts. A heavy-set man of about thirty drove up in a blue 1958 Chevrolet with Rhode Island plates, left the engine running and went inside. At about half past one he came out of the kitchen door and drove off. At half past two her fifteen-year-old daughter Elaine found her in a pool of blood. The house had been wrecked in a struggle. Edith had thirty-one stab wounds; seven knives lay around her, five of them broken, and her skirt and jacket were folded on her bed. There was no sexual assault and nothing had been taken. A man found dead of an overdose in a Pawtucket gas station was quickly ruled out.

Checking 1,144 blue 1958 Chevrolets, of which 117 were local, police reached the third name: a seventeen-year-old with a juvenile record who had twice pulled a knife on women in cars, once three weeks before Nancy Frenier died. His green jacket and shoes were stained with blood. At the station he said he did not want to do it again, admitted killing the woman in Attleboro, and then volunteered that he wished he had been caught before he killed the other woman. He described taking his father's car, pulling knives from a steak set and stabbing Edith Martin as she fought and ran through the house, then throwing his bloodied clothes into woods. The next day he re-enacted the Frenier killing at the reservoir, where he had hit her with a log, cut her throat, pushed her under the ice and a week later pulled her out again.

Family court waived him to adult court.

The case

Murder of Nancy Ann Frenier

Victims

Nancy Ann Frenier (19). housewife and mother of a six-month-old son; Attleboro High School class of 1959

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 6 July 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

William Frenier. her husband, 22, a vending machine salesman; passed a lie detector test
Theodore C. Hilton. detective captain who led the inquiry and called it a sex perverted murder
Doris Baker. woman murdered in Barre, Vermont, whose case was checked for similarities

The timeline

  1. December 22nd, 1961 Nancy drives her husband to work, drops her baby with her mother, plans laundry and Christmas shoppingabout 0:15:12
  2. December 22nd, 1961, about noon She stops at a house on Slocum Road to use the telephone and appears quite upset (Slocum Road house)about 0:20:19
  3. December 22nd, 1961, about 2 p.m. Two ten-year-old boys see a man and a woman walk into the woods in Rumfordabout 0:23:12
  4. December 22nd, 1961 gets into her car at the Mammoth Mart, forces her to drive to the reservoir and walks her into the woods (Mammoth Mart)about 0:48:13
  5. December 22nd, 1961 At the reservoir he rapes her, hits her twice on the back of the head with a log, cuts her throat and pushes her body through a hole in the ice (East Providence Reservoir)about 0:49:11

Murder of Edith Martin

Victims

Edith Martin (38). bookkeeper at the Allied Anodizing Company in Pawtucket; wife of a milk truck driver and mother of a fifteen-year-old daughter

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 6 July 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Elaine Martin. her fifteen-year-old daughter, who came home from school and found the body
John Martin. her husband, a milk truck driver for his father's dairy
Gene Roberts. 21-year-old nurse abducted in 1961, a case police wanted to question about

The timeline

  1. 1961 Police want to question about the abduction of Gene Roberts, a 21-year-old nurse robbed of two dollarsabout 0:39:44
  2. January 14th, 1962 He jumps into a seventeen-year-old girl's car after she leaves church, holds a knife to her throat and orders her to drive to Slater Park; she screams and he runs (Slater Park)about 0:38:19
  3. January 26th, 1963, about 12.30 p.m. Edith Martin comes home for lunch, later than usual (Martin house)about 0:35:09
  4. January 26th, 1963, about 1.15 p.m. A heavy-set man of about thirty drives up in a blue 1958 Chevrolet with Rhode Island plates, leaves the engine running and goes inside (Martin house)about 0:35:32
  5. January 26th, 1963, about 1.30 p.m. The man comes out of the kitchen door and drives away (Martin house)about 0:35:54
  6. January 26th, 1963, about 2.30 p.m. Elaine Martin comes home from school and finds her mother in a pool of blood on the kitchen floor (Martin house)about 0:30:05
  7. January 26th, 1963 Police find the house wrecked and the body face down with thirty-one stab wounds and seven knives around it, five of them broken (Martin house)about 0:32:55

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode