FILE 178 / 2 July 2020 / 157 MIN / full

Proud To Be Cruel

Middle River, MarylandListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Middle River, yeah, it's north central Maryland... 25 minutes to Baltimore; later, this is in Baltimore County, as a matter of fact about 0:05:00

History, in brief

Town note

Middle River was once known as Little Appalachia.

about 0:06:23

Town note

Families came down from West Virginia and the hills for factory and wartime jobs in Baltimore in the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s, then stayed.

about 0:07:40

Town note

The town butts up against Essex, and Eastern Avenue in Essex was once made of oyster shells.

about 0:09:24

Town note

One of the big groves served a fish sandwich and a glass of beer for five cents.

about 0:10:07
All 12 history facts

Town note

Middle River was once known as Little Appalachia.

about 0:06:23

Town note

Families came down from West Virginia and the hills for factory and wartime jobs in Baltimore in the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s, then stayed.

about 0:07:40

Town note

The town butts up against Essex, and Eastern Avenue in Essex was once made of oyster shells.

about 0:09:24

Town note

One of the big groves served a fish sandwich and a glass of beer for five cents.

about 0:10:07

Town note

Lewis Holzneck came back from the First World War and with his brothers built an ice plant.

about 0:10:20

Town note

Before that, the Highland town ice company cut ice from a pond in freezing winters and stored it in an ice house.

about 0:10:29

1909

President Taft was inaugurated in 1909 during a huge blizzard here.

about 0:11:02

Town note

Local lore has a roadhouse saving a freezing man's life; he asked for a priest and last rites, then died anyway.

about 0:11:08

1933

During the flood of August 1933 boats were washed up on the car tracks over Back River and the bridge was condemned.

about 0:11:31

Town note

The last car over the bridge was half full of water and the occupants did not know how they crossed it.

about 0:11:47

Town note

A piano washed off Pleasure Island at Bay Shore all the way around the bay to Porter's Bar, and a new house was washed overboard at Bowley's Quarters.

about 0:12:03

Town note

Street cars were overturned in the flood, and afterwards a new bridge was built.

about 0:12:15

The figures, as told

Religious

41%

Biggest faith: Catholic, 19%

about 0:17:32

Who lives here

White 61% · Black 26.4% · Asian 3.7% · Hispanic 6.1%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ about 50% high

about 0:27:28

Violent crime
▲ about 25% high

about 0:27:40

Money

Median home value$205,300
Two-bedroom rentabout $1,270
Median household income$59,113
Cost of living101

For sale

$24,999

Three-bedroom two-bath manufactured home, 1,344 square feet

about 0:19:32

For sale

$245,000

Three-bedroom two-bath house, 1,328 square feet

about 0:20:02

For sale

$890,000

Five-bedroom four-bath house, 4,777 square feet

about 0:20:48
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2020

Population

"25,654"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:16:26

Population growth

"up 4.2%"

Comparison: "since 1990". Direction: above.

As told in 2020 about 0:16:35

Median age

"38"

Comparison: "about normal". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2020 about 0:16:39

White

"61%"

Comparison: "national average 61.5%". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:16:54

Black

"26.4%"

Comparison: "a little over double the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2020 about 0:17:01

Asian

"3.7%"

Comparison: "national average 5.3%". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:17:01

County vote for the Democrats

"56%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:02

County vote for the Republicans

"38%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:02

County vote independent

"about 6%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:02

Unemployment

"about average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:02

Religious

"41%"

Comparison: "50-50 is the normal". Direction: below.

As told in 2020 about 0:17:32

Median household income

"$59,113"

Comparison: "normally about $57,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:20

Cost of living

"101"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:31

Median home cost

"$205,300"

Comparison: "a little under the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:35

Average two-bedroom rent

"about $1,270"

Comparison: "right at the national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2020 about 0:19:03

Three-bedroom two-bath manufactured home, 1,344 square feet

"$24,999"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:19:32

Three-bedroom two-bath house, 1,328 square feet

"$245,000"

Comparison: "about the national average for a home". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2020 about 0:20:02

Five-bedroom four-bath house, 4,777 square feet

"$890,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:20:48

Property crime

"about 50% high"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2020 about 0:27:28

Violent crime

"about 25% high"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2020 about 0:27:40

The reviews

2.2 / 5 · average of 6

3 stars

“Schools are in walking distance, but the area does not seem like a safe place for a kid to be walking around alone.”
about 0:12:38

2 stars

“Some neighbours are nice, but many people degrade the area and litter; people are loud and obnoxious, it is a poor area with no manners, overall below average.”
about 0:13:20

2 stars

“Kids are constantly throwing stuff into people's yards and harassing the neighbours' animals.”
about 0:13:52

2 stars

“I would not move here if I had the opportunity and would continue to search for a new place.”
about 0:14:17

2 stars

“Unhealthy lifestyles are common, with doped-up people walking into the grocery store, many obese people and bad hygiene.”
about 0:14:41

2 stars

“People here are rude and trashy and it is not uncommon to see multiple people on the news being murdered; the problem is safety.”
about 0:15:40

In Maryland

Closest episodes

  1. The Social Media Loving CannibalJoppatowne, Maryland · 18 November 202311 km / 7 miShow on map
  2. The Mannequin MurdersElkridge, Maryland · 15 March 201831 km / 19 miShow on map
  3. Adopting MurderCape St. Claire, Maryland · 18 April 202433 km / 21 miShow on map
  4. The Sex Crazed Killer AccountantWestminster, Maryland · 2 June 202256 km / 35 miShow on map
  5. Lust, Blood, Cruelty & SnakesLothian, Maryland · 4 May 202359 km / 37 miShow on map

The story

Middle River is an unincorporated community in Baltimore County, Maryland, about 25 minutes from Baltimore and roughly 95 minutes from Philadelphia. The episode gives its population as 25,654. James Pietragallo explains that the area was once known as Little Appalachia, because families came down from West Virginia and the surrounding hills for factory and wartime work in Baltimore in the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s and then stayed. He reads out online reviews that call the area unsafe, noisy and trashy, and gives crime figures about 50 per cent above the national average for property crime and about 25 per cent above it for violent crime.

His mother was a mountain girl from Virginia who laid bricks and worked factory shifts. His father was a shell-shocked Second World War veteran who drove a truck for Lever Brothers and, by his mother's account, beat and terrorised the children. She believed her son's problems began when his father sat on his head for some time when he was two months old. A social worker later testified that the father would cut the power at night and whisper through the heating vents that he was the devil and was coming for Freddy. He also put sleeping pills in his wife's coffee so that he could sexually abuse the couple's daughter in the bedroom Freddy shared with her.

At fourteen he was sent to Boys Village in Prince George's County for car theft, ran away repeatedly, was moved to the Maryland Training School for Boys at Cub Hill, ran away again and wrecked a stolen car. He was diagnosed as schizophrenic at seventeen, later described as having borderline personality disorder, and other inmates abused and sodomised him because of his small size.

He escaped by hiding in a laundry basket, was recaptured at Montebello Hospital in north-east Baltimore and given five more years.

He sent her 21 sexually explicit and threatening letters.

He worked as a bricklayer in Bel Air, quit on July 12th and moved to Salisbury to live with a girlfriend, and on July 30th started a night shift at the Perdue chicken processing plant. In August he rented a room at the Hotel Esther in Salisbury for $60 a week. He saw his probation officer there on August 23rd. On August 25th he hitchhiked to his mother's house; she noticed his jaw was crooked and he said a car had hit him. She drove him to the Trailways terminal and he took a noon bus to Salisbury. The next day he telephoned her, talked wildly about buying an assault rifle and having a shootout with police, and threatened to kill her. She called the state police, who said nothing could be done.

On August 27th he quit his job. On August 29th he cashed his pay cheque, bought a .22 calibre semi-automatic rifle at a Salisbury gun shop for $160 and sawed down the barrel. That day he took a taxi driven by Milton Marcy, robbed him of $66, made him get into the boot and drove off; Marcy escaped by banging on the boot until a barking dog brought the police.

He took five dollars from the wallet and the car, then bought hair dye and coloured his hair black.

On September 1st he robbed a convenience store in Salisbury and shot the clerk in the head at close range; the bullet only grazed him. On September 2nd he went to the mini mart of a Big Red petrol station, where 16-year-old Billy Winebrenner was working and his 14-year-old girlfriend Melody Pistorio was keeping him company. When he returned with the money the watch was at Melody's house, so he pulled out the rifle, made them fill his doctor's bag with cash and shot them both twice in the head.

An anonymous tip at about 8 p.m. led Salisbury police to follow the Festiva along US 13. He abandoned the car near Route 454A, flagged down Edward Mason, a Laurel, Delaware resident driving a black Chevrolet Beretta, and forced him north at gunpoint to a Wendy's in Smyrna, Delaware. There a shootout developed in the car park. Mason was grazed on the finger; nobody else was hurt.

He said he was pissed off at the world, that it was not his responsibility to be sorry, and that he had wanted to kill in order to be killed. He led detectives to Taylor's body. He said he had almost spared Taylor because he seemed so innocent, but his twisted mind kept twisting. Of the teenagers he said they had done nothing to provoke him and had treated him perfectly well. In court he shouted at the judge, refused a lawyer and waived his preliminary hearing, and was held without bond.

In June 1992, after his lawyers presented psychiatric and corrections evidence he did not want, he made a 15-minute speech in which he said there were no innocent people, that he would murder the brats again if he could bring them back, and that he would dig up their bones and beat them to powder.

He asked that his body be donated to science. His last words were get on with it, adios and here it comes now.

The case

Murder spree of

Victims

Gregory Allen Taylor Jr. (18). apprentice welder from Hebron, picked up hitchhiking in a blue Ford Festiva
Billy Winebrenner (16). clerk at the Big Red gas station, son of the store manager
Melody Pistorio (14). Billy's girlfriend, keeping him company at the gas station

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 2 July 2020.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Rosalind E. Loftin. correctional officer at Eastern Correctional Institution and the object of his obsession; he sent her 21 letters and later blamed her for the murders
Milton Marcy. Salisbury cab driver he robbed of $66 and shut in the boot of his cab
Edward Mason. Laurel, Delaware resident whose black Chevrolet Beretta he hijacked at gunpoint
Richard Messick. Smyrna resident buying a Frosty when the shootout began at Wendy's
Sandra A. O'Connor. Baltimore County state's attorney who prosecuted him
Randy Coates. Worcester County state's attorney who said deserved his fate
Glenn Small. Baltimore Sun reporter he wrote to and asked for $200 for an interview

The timeline

  1. March 28th, 1949 is born, the oldest of four children.about 0:30:11
  2. about two months old His father sits on his head for some time in the living room; his mother later blames this for his problems.about 0:44:23
  3. May 1986 He holds up a Harford County convenience store and is caught after a chase; he tells police he should have started killing police when he got out. (Harford County convenience store)about 1:03:19
  4. 1989 He becomes obsessed with correctional officer Rosalind E. Loftin and begins sending her letters. (Eastern Correctional Institution)about 0:36:30
  5. January 1990 He writes the poem calling himself the Hound of Hell, Beelzebub and Satan. (Eastern Correctional Institution)about 0:33:37
  6. July 12th, 1990 He quits his bricklaying job in Bel Air and goes to Salisbury to live with his girlfriend.about 1:14:55
  7. July 30th, 1990 He starts a night shift as a packer at the Perdue chicken processing plant. (Perdue chicken processing plant)about 1:15:34
  8. late July 1990 A woman on the Eastern Shore accuses him of exposing himself after giving him a ride.about 1:16:32
  9. August 1990 He rents a $60-a-week room at the Hotel Esther in Salisbury, telling the owner he has left his girlfriend. (Hotel Esther)about 1:17:29
  10. August 23rd, 1990 His probation officer sees him at the Hotel Esther. (Hotel Esther)about 1:18:40
  11. August 25th, 1990 He hitchhikes from Salisbury to his mother's house; she notices his jaw is crooked and drives him to the Trailways terminal for a noon bus to Salisbury. (Trailways bus terminal)about 1:18:56
  12. August 26th, 1990 He telephones his mother from Salisbury, talks of buying an assault rifle and having a shootout with police, and threatens to kill her; the state police say nothing can be done.about 1:20:11
  13. August 27th, 1990 He abruptly quits his job at the Perdue plant. (Perdue chicken processing plant)about 1:21:36
  14. August 28th, 1990 He leaves the Hotel Esther, saying he has to leave town in a hurry. (Hotel Esther)about 1:18:08
  15. August 29th, 1990 He cashes his pay cheque, buys a .22 calibre semi-automatic rifle at a Salisbury gun shop for $160 and saws down the barrel. (Salisbury gun shop)about 1:21:56
  16. August 29th, 1990 He takes Milton Marcy's cab, robs him of $66, makes him get in the boot and abandons him; Marcy escapes by banging on the boot until a dog barks and police come.about 1:23:57
  17. August 31st, 1990 Picked up hitchhiking by Gregory Taylor Jr., he makes him drive to a deserted logging road and shoots him three times in the head, taking five dollars and the Festiva. (Logging road)about 1:27:44
  18. September 1st, 1990 He robs a convenience store in Salisbury and shoots the clerk in the head; the bullet only grazes him. (Salisbury convenience store)about 1:28:59
  19. September 2nd, 1990 At the Big Red gas station he shoots Billy Winebrenner and Melody Pistorio twice each in the head after they fill his bag with cash. (Big Red gas station)about 1:32:28
  20. September 2nd, 1990 An anonymous tip leads police to follow the Festiva along US 13; at a roadblock at Delmar he fires on two patrol cars, hits nobody and escapes. (Delmar roadblock)about 1:33:28
  21. September 2nd, 1990 He ditches the car near Route 454A, hijacks Edward Mason's Chevrolet Beretta and forces him north to a Wendy's in Smyrna, Delaware, where a shootout ends when he runs out of ammunition and surrenders. (Wendy's)about 1:35:57
  22. September 1990 Melody Pistorio's funeral is held in Essex and about 120 people attend, including the local congressman.about 1:32:59
  23. September 9th, 1990 He tells a Salisbury television reporter that Rosalind Loftin drove him to the crimes.about 1:47:15

Last meals

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode