FILE 308 / 11 August 2022 / 170 MIN / full

The Killing Of A Bad Man

Hooksett, New HampshireListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

staying up north in Hookset, New Hampshire, which is south-central New Hampshire... This is in Merrimack County about 0:04:18

History, in brief

Town note

First known as Chester Woods, probably after a man named Chester and the surrounding woods.

about 0:05:11

Town note

Known as Hooksett for nearly 50 years before it became an official town named Hooksett.

about 0:05:20

Town note

Named after a hook-shaped island that early fishermen called Hookline Falls.

about 0:05:28
All 5 history facts

Town note

First known as Chester Woods, probably after a man named Chester and the surrounding woods.

about 0:05:11

Town note

Known as Hooksett for nearly 50 years before it became an official town named Hooksett.

about 0:05:20

Town note

Named after a hook-shaped island that early fishermen called Hookline Falls.

about 0:05:28

1974

In 1974 the lottery-funded Hooksett Canal became part of the transportation facilities.

about 0:05:37

The figures, as told

Religious

31%

Biggest faith: Jewish, 0.3%

about 0:11:24

Who lives here

White 93.1% · Black 0.8% · Asian 0.8% · Hispanic 3.2%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
average

about 0:18:58

Violent crime
▼ under half

about 0:19:31

Money

Median home value$365,600
Two-bedroom rent$1,237
Median household income$82,725 a year
Cost of living103.5
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"14,703"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:10:44

Median age

"41"

Comparison: "three or four years older than normal". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:10:53

Voted Democratic in the last county election

"53.8%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:11:45

Voted Republican in the last county election

"44.1%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:11:45

Voted Independent in the last county election

"2.1%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:11:45

Unemployment rate

"3%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:11:58

Median household income

"$82,725 a year"

Comparison: "almost $30,000 more than the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:12:05

Cost of living

"103.5"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:12:19

Median home cost

"$365,600"

Comparison: "high, but not for the area". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:12:29

Average two-bedroom rental

"$1,237"

Comparison: "right around the national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2022 about 0:12:53

Property crime

"average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2022 about 0:18:58

Violent crime

"under half"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:19:31

The reviews

3.6 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“Best selection of beer on tap anywhere, with 120 taps and local brews; diverse menu; a back room for bands, comedy and trivia; a deck that seats 300.”
about 0:06:21

4 stars

“Office across the street from the apartment, close to both major cities, quiet, and a good place to start a family.”
about 0:08:14

4 stars

“Just needs to stop snowing; five feet is too much.”
about 0:08:39

3 stars

“Don't use it, but it's there.”
about 0:09:04

2 stars

“Two great farm stands but ugly car lots and businesses on the main drag; one great bar, the Tap House or Murphy's, and the Bavarian restaurant; a wasteland at night; good sports field and library; convenient box stores but no local retailers; good location, poor government; a new community centre but no high school.”
about 0:09:40

In New Hampshire

Closest episodes

  1. The Dumbest Murder ConspiracyDeerfield, New Hampshire · 10 April 202617 km / 11 miShow on map
  2. The Murder And The MiracleMont Vernon, New Hampshire · 2 October 202528 km / 17 miShow on map
  3. Killing, Cover Up & A LOT of Sex ToysFremont, New Hampshire · 14 November 201929 km / 18 miShow on map
  4. The Orbit Of A KillerEpping, New Hampshire · 11 October 201730 km / 19 miShow on map
  5. Overwhelming Evidence Of OverkillBelmont, New Hampshire · 13 December 201839 km / 24 miShow on map

The story

Danny Paquette was born in Manchester, New Hampshire, in 1949, the youngest of six children of Arthur and Rena Paquette. The family ran a small dairy farm at South Brown Avenue, on land that stretched from Manchester into Londonderry. Arthur had left before daybreak for work. Danny said his mother had not woken him for school and that he could not find her, so he called the police. His uncle, an off-duty Manchester police officer, came to help search. They found the shack burned out and Rena's body charred inside. She was wearing only a light dress and a pair of loafers, although there was snow on the ground. The attorney general, William Maynard, announced that the death of the fifty-two-year-old mother of five had been ruled a suicide by cremation, saying she had been despondent over the assassination of President Kennedy and over the murder of a fourteen-year-old girl in the area. Her family rejected that. There was no fuel container at the scene, her body was not found in a position suggesting she had been alive in the fire, and she had been doing her own amateur investigation into the girl's murder. In 1991 the body was exhumed and the cause of death changed to undetermined. A retired Manchester officer, David Lord, said detectives had never believed it was suicide and had been ordered to forget their suspicions.

The fourteen-year-old was Pamela Mason. She disappeared on 13 January 1964 after getting into a car outside her house to go to a babysitting job. Her body was found on 21 January in a ditch beside Route 93, face down. She had been shot twice, stabbed four times, had her throat cut and had been raped. Her underwear was missing and her school books were scattered in the snow. The episode also notes the similar 1960 murder of eighteen-year-old Sandra Velotti, who was abducted near Manchester and found mutilated in the same way.

Danny's own life was violent and chaotic. In 1966 he began a relationship with a neighbour, Denise Messier, who became pregnant. Her family sent her away and the baby was adopted, and she was forbidden to see him again. He was drafted in 1968 and sent to Germany rather than Vietnam. He married a Manchester woman named Stephanie, and they had a daughter, Jennifer, but the marriage broke down. Stephanie said he became possessive and angry, and after he threw her into a full bath during an argument they divorced in 1971. In 1973 he met Denise again. In 1978 they incorporated Paquette Welding. By 1980 the marriage was collapsing. Denise left with the girls, and in June 1980 Danny forced his way into her home, threw her on the couch and covered her mouth and nose while the children watched. She obtained a restraining order. He chased her in his truck and threatened to kill her, and when he appeared in court he lunged across the table at the judge. He was committed to a state mental hospital for a year.

In 1985 Danny was living in Hooksett and seeing Ruth Zeleste, a woman from western Pennsylvania with three teenage sons, Vincent, Mark and Hal. The boys disliked him, and there had been repeated arguments and at least one fight. In August 1985 Danny traded punches with Mark and ended up with a broken nose. On the morning of Saturday 9 November 1985 Ruth was at his house. Richard Duarte, a friend who was repairing a 1954 Ford in Danny's garage, arrived around nine o'clock and found the couple laughing together. Court Burton, a seventeen-year-old who helped Danny, came later, and two Canadian customers collected a fuel tank. At about half past eleven Danny was welding a plate onto a bulldozer while Court held it. Duarte heard a loud crack, went outside and found Danny on the ground. Danny had been shot once through the chest. He died at the hospital.

The investigation struggled. There was no bullet, no witness to a shooter, and it was the first day of hunting season, so the woods were full of guns. A utility worker eventually found the bullet lodged in a phone cable down the street, carrying bone and blood with it. The autopsy showed the shot had come from a steep angle, about thirty degrees, and a fish and game officer calculated that the only clear line to Danny in the bulldozer cab came from due north. A sandpit used for target practice lay about a mile away, but its ground was 307 feet lower than the Paquette house, so the shot could not have come from there.

On 1 January 1986 he told his brother Trapper that he had shot Danny. They ran back to the car and drove away. Many people in the area thought Danny deserved it.

It held for years. In 2002 and 2003 detectives re-canvassed the neighbourhood and a woman remembered a dark Volkswagen parked in a dirt cutout near the property on the day of the shooting. Victor Paquette confronted him with a photograph of Danny and opposed release. The Paquette family remains angry and distrustful of the New Hampshire justice system.

The case

Murder of Danny Paquette

Victims

Danny Paquette (36). welder and carpenter, youngest of six, father of Jennifer, , Carolyn and Audrey

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 11 August 2022.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Ruth Zeleste. Danny's girlfriend, mother of Vincent, Mark and Hal
Vincent. Ruth's oldest son, who clashed with Danny
Mark. Ruth's middle son, who fought Danny in August 1985
Hal. Ruth's youngest son, the one Danny liked
Richard Duarte. friend and customer who found Danny after the shooting
Court Burton. 17-year-old helper who went for help
Victor Paquette. Danny's older brother, a biker who pressed police for years
Denise Paquette. Danny's second wife, mother of , Carolyn and Audrey
Stephanie. Danny's first wife, mother of Jennifer
Bobby Doob. friend who told police about Danny's trouble with Ruth's sons
John Oliver. Hooksett police chief
Roland Lammy. police sergeant who took Victor's annual calls
Jimma Bolduc. biker named in a Crimestoppers tip

The timeline

  1. 1949 Danny Paquette is born in Manchester, the youngest of six children. (Paquette dairy farm)about 0:23:56
  2. 1966 Danny begins seeing the neighbour girl Denise Messier, who becomes pregnant and is sent away; her parents forbid her to see him again. (Paquette dairy farm)about 1:22:40
  3. 1968 Danny is drafted into the Army and is sent to Germany rather than Vietnam.about 1:23:57
  4. 1969 Danny marries Stephanie; their daughter Jennifer is born in New Hampshire.about 1:24:48
  5. 1971 Danny returns from the Army; he throws Stephanie into a full bath during an argument and they divorce.about 1:26:18
  6. 1973 Danny meets Denise again and they resume their relationship.about 1:26:47
  7. 1974 Danny marries Denise; he adopts her daughter and they later have Carolyn and Audrey.about 1:28:35
  8. 1978 Danny and Denise incorporate Paquette Welding Incorporated.about 1:28:52
  9. March 1980 Denise takes the girls and leaves, looking for an apartment in Manchester and a divorce.about 1:29:11
  10. June 1980 Danny forces his way into Denise's home, throws her on the couch and covers her mouth and nose while the children watch.about 1:29:39
  11. June 1980 Denise files for a restraining order; the next day Danny chases her in his truck and threatens to kill her.about 1:30:33
  12. 1980 At the court hearing Danny lunges across the table at the judge and is committed to a state mental hospital for a year. (New Hampshire Hospital)about 1:31:50
  13. June 1985 Ruth moves into Danny's house. (Danny Paquette house)about 0:55:28
  14. August 1985 Danny and Ruth's son Mark fight; Danny ends up with a broken nose and calls police to have the drunk Ruth removed. (Danny Paquette house)about 0:59:12
  15. November 8th, 1985 Ruth spends the night at Danny's house while her sons stay at her apartment. (Danny Paquette house)about 0:31:49
  16. November 9th, 1985 Richard Duarte arrives around 9 a.m. to work on his 1954 Ford; Danny and Ruth are laughing in the garage. (Danny Paquette house)about 0:32:36
  17. November 9th, 1985 The Canadian customers collect a fuel tank and Court Burton arrives to help weld and paint. (Danny Paquette house)about 0:37:42
  18. November 9th, 1985 At about 11.30 a.m. Danny is shot once through the chest while welding a plate on the bulldozer. (Danny Paquette house)about 1:44:21

Death of Rena Paquette

Victims

Rena Paquette (52). Danny's mother, mother of six, wife of Arthur Paquette Sr

Outcome

Other people

Arthur Paquette Sr. Rena's husband, who left for work before daybreak
William Maynard. New Hampshire attorney general who ruled the death a suicide by cremation
David Lord. retired Manchester police officer who said detectives were ordered to forget their murder suspicions

The timeline

  1. February 3rd, 1964 Arthur leaves the farm before daybreak; Danny, 15, wakes late, cannot find his mother and calls the police. (Paquette dairy farm)about 1:03:06
  2. February 3rd, 1964 Danny's uncle, an off-duty Manchester police officer, helps search and they find the burned pigsty half a mile into the woods with Rena's charred body inside. (pigsty shack)about 1:04:41

Murder of Pamela Mason

Victims

Pamela Mason (14). high school freshman and honour student, killed while going to a babysitting job

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 11 August 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

George Sharland. bakery truck driver who found the body
Lionel Lavoie. Hillsborough County medical examiner who compared the case to the Velotti murder

The timeline

  1. January 13th, 1964 Pamela Mason leaves her house to go to a babysitting job and is seen getting into a car with an unidentified man. (Pamela Mason house)about 1:11:58
  2. January 21st, 1964 A bakery truck driver, George Sharland, finds her body face down in a ditch beside Route 93, with school books and papers scattered in the snow. (Route 93 ditch)about 1:11:24

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode