FILE 254 / 16 December 2021 / 164 MIN / full

Serial Killer Happy Meal

Plymouth, New HampshireListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

This is Plymouth, New Hampshire, in eastern central New Hampshire, in Grafton County, area code 603. about 0:06:07

History, in brief

1712

The town was originally the site of an Abenaki village, burned to the ground by Captain Thomas Baker in 1712 during Queen Anne's War.

about 0:07:11

Town note

Part of the land was first named New Plymouth after the Plymouth colony in Massachusetts, then shortened to Plymouth.

about 0:08:06

Town note

Some of the first settlers came from Plymouth, Massachusetts.

about 0:08:19
All 8 history facts

1712

The town was originally the site of an Abenaki village, burned to the ground by Captain Thomas Baker in 1712 during Queen Anne's War.

about 0:07:11

Town note

Part of the land was first named New Plymouth after the Plymouth colony in Massachusetts, then shortened to Plymouth.

about 0:08:06

Town note

Some of the first settlers came from Plymouth, Massachusetts.

about 0:08:19

1845

It annexed parts of other towns in 1845 and 1860.

about 0:08:36

1806

In 1806 Daniel Webster lost his first criminal case at the Plymouth Courthouse.

about 0:08:45

1864

Nathaniel Hawthorne was on holiday in Plymouth in 1864 with former president Franklin Pierce and died there in a house that later burned down.

about 0:08:49

Town note

In the early 1900s the Draper and Maynard Sporting Goods Company sold products directly to the Boston Red Sox, and Babe Ruth came to the store to choose bats and gloves.

about 0:09:58

The figures, as told

Religious

22.8%

Biggest faith: Catholic, 11%

about 0:15:16

Who lives here

White 90.3% · Black 1.2% · Asian 2.3% · Hispanic 2.9%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ about 10% high

about 0:25:47

Violent crime
about average

about 0:25:53

Money

Median home value$258,400
Two-bedroom rent$1,063
Median household income$42,000 a year
Cost of living88.7
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2021

Property crime

"about 10% high"

Comparison: "in the range of normal". Direction: above.

As told in 2021 about 0:25:47

Violent crime

"about average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2021 about 0:25:53

Population

"6,916"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:13:09

Population change

"up 17%"

Comparison: "since 2000". Direction: above.

As told in 2021 about 0:13:39

Average age

"22.2"

Comparison: "15 years under the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:13:47

Married population

"26%"

Comparison: "about half of normal". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:14:02

Single with no children

"22.5%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:14:22

White population

"90.3%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:14:30

Black population

"1.2%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:14:38

Asian population

"2.3%"

Comparison: "about half". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:14:38

Hispanic population

"2.9%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:14:38

Religious population

"22.8%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:15:16

Catholic

"11%"

Comparison: "the highest religious group". No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:15:26

Unemployment rate

"about half"

Comparison: "the rest of the country". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:16:19

Household income

"$42,000 a year"

Comparison: "about $15,000 less than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:16:23

Cost of living

"88.7"

Comparison: "100 is the regular average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:16:49

Median home cost

"$258,400"

Comparison: "about $33,000 lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:16:55

Average two-bedroom rental

"$1,063"

Comparison: "about $200 less than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:17:42

Four-bedroom house listing

"$99,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:18:44

Two-bedroom house listing

"$251,500"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:19:08

Six-bedroom house listing

"$700,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:19:35

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“A quiet but very nice town with a lot of places to eat and a post office right next to the reviewer's home.”
about 0:10:33

4 stars

“Family-first community with an adorable main street, great schools and community events, but it lacks diversity and true neighbourhoods and caters to an older demographic.”
about 0:11:00

3 stars

“Winters are harsh, cold and snowy, summers are hot and humid, some seasons have a lot of rain, but overall the weather is adaptable.”
about 0:11:41

2 stars

“Little to no public transportation, taxis hardly exist, and there are no trains or Segways.”
about 0:12:29

In New Hampshire

Closest episodes

  1. Overwhelming Evidence Of OverkillBelmont, New Hampshire · 13 December 201838 km / 24 miShow on map
  2. The Mysterious Disappearing MurdererJackson, New Hampshire · 1 June 202466 km / 41 miShow on map
  3. Writing Your Murder ScriptLempster, New Hampshire · 23 November 202368 km / 42 miShow on map
  4. Til Murder Do Us PartLebanon, Maine · 30 January 202574 km / 46 miShow on map
  5. The Killing Of A Bad ManHooksett, New Hampshire · 11 August 202274 km / 46 miShow on map

The story

Plymouth, New Hampshire, sits in Grafton County in the eastern central part of the state, a town of 6,916 people and 28 square miles of woods with Plymouth State College at its centre. Its motto is 'bridging the lakes region and the white mountains'. It was incorporated in 1763 on the site of an Abenaki village burned by Captain Thomas Baker in 1712. In the early 1900s the Draper and Maynard Sporting Goods Company sold equipment directly to the Boston Red Sox, and Babe Ruth came to the store to pick out bats and gloves.

The first murder came in 1991. Theresa Ann Reed, known as Tess, was 30 and worked as assistant registrar at Plymouth State College, which she had graduated from with a business degree in 1983. She lived alone in an apartment in a three-apartment building a short walk from her job. She did not turn up for work, and after two days she was checked on and found inside, wedged between her bed and the wall, with nine stab wounds. The town panicked. The state police major crimes unit took over, students and then hundreds of other people were interviewed, dorms were locked around the clock, escorts were provided and shops sold out of door locks and mace. Investigators could not establish a time of death, ruled out a disgruntled student and had nothing else to go on. The case went cold, and for more than 20 years Theresa Reed's family had no answer.

Three years later, on 3 December 1994, Mary Lou Sale, a 49-year-old tax accountant, was killed in Lexington, Massachusetts, about 25 minutes outside Boston. She had moved from Los Angeles a few months earlier, worked at the firm of Friedberg and Garlic in Wellesley, and rented a two-storey house at Massachusetts Avenue. Her daughter was a student at Wheaton College in Norton. That night she went up to her second-floor bedroom, put on her pyjamas, read and fell asleep. Neighbours noticed her lights went off around 9:30 p.m. One was woken by breaking glass between 11:30 p.m. and 12:15 a.m. She did not appear at work on 5 or 6 December, and on the morning of 6 December police did a check. A pane in the back door was shattered. They found her on the bedroom floor between the bed and the wall, almost naked, her pyjama top ripped open and two buttons torn off, one never recovered. A nylon stocking was tied around her neck and her skull had been struck seven times. The cause of death was blunt force trauma and strangulation. Tests for sexual assault were negative. Jewellery was scattered, two purses, her wallet, credit cards and some jewellery were missing, and there was blood on the bottom drawers of her dresser that was not hers.

He had asked her out several times and been refused, and he had a fiancee. He told a tenant that Mary Lou had probably gone to California. When police asked what he had seen in the drawer he had opened while pretending to move a dresser, he replied: 'Why, was she strangled with a nylon stocking?' That detail had been withheld from the public. He said he had been at an office holiday party in Braintree from seven to ten and home by midnight, but his fiancee had fallen asleep at 11:30 and did not see him until 10 the next morning. He described himself as an insomniac who drove around at night. He agreed to give fingerprints, then refused a polygraph and a DNA test, and he left town. He later moved to Oregon and invoked the Fifth Amendment rather than testify.

The fingerprint evidence pointed elsewhere. He lived five doors from Mary Lou at Massachusetts Avenue and had a record for a 1990 sexual assault in Concord. He had been picked up drunk in the McDonald's car park more than once, and on 8 December he was found wandering there drinking and disoriented and taken to the Bedford VA Hospital, where he was fingerprinted. On 29 December a latent print from Mary Lou's bedroom matched his left ring finger, and a palm print matched the bedroom door. He first said he had never been in the house; then he said he had gone in after hearing a scream, found her dead, felt for a pulse, washed his hands and left because he did not want to get involved.

On 23 August 1992 he had been suspended from McDonald's, needed money, and broke into the basement apartment of a yellow bungalow on Ridge Road, where Catholine Dempsey, a 31-year-old graphic and textile designer, was asleep. She woke and begged him not to hurt her. He pressed her face into the mattress, put a pillow over her head and stabbed her 17 times in the neck and torso with a pocket knife, slashing her diaphragm and aiming at her kidneys. He left around 5:30 a.m. She managed to call 911 and say 'I've been attacked', but the part-time dispatcher, Kenneth Robishaw, could not understand her address and treated the call as a hoax. The next shift's dispatcher worked out the address at about 10 a.m., and police arrived at 10:57 to find her dead near the foot of the bed, still holding the phone. Her family settled with the town of Lexington for $100,000, the cap, and the state brought in enhanced 911 so that dispatchers automatically see the caller's address.

He also told the police to contact New Hampshire. He said he had gone to her apartment one night in September 1991 to burgle it, chose it at random after a police car frightened him away from a larger house, and stabbed her when she screamed. He said he was in the apartment for about two minutes, then slept in the woods and walked to his parents' house in Dorchester the next day.

He asked whether he could have the death penalty instead; it was not available for a crime committed in 1991. The family said the case had never been on the back burner. He remains in the Massachusetts system, with an agreement that he may be transferred to New Hampshire.

The case

Murder of Theresa Ann 'Tess' Reed

Victims

Theresa Ann 'Tess' Reed (30). assistant registrar at Plymouth State College

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 16 December 2021.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Joseph Reed. Theresa's father
Timothy Keith. dean of students at Plymouth State College

The timeline

  1. 1983 Theresa Reed graduates from Plymouth State College with a business degree. (Plymouth State College)about 0:27:00
  2. Reed takes a job as assistant registrar at the college and lives alone in an apartment a short walk away. (Reed apartment)about 0:27:14
  3. September 1991 breaks into Reed's apartment to burgle it and stabs her nine times when she screams. (Reed apartment)about 2:09:53
  4. Reed fails to appear for work.about 0:27:37
  5. after two days She is checked on and found dead between the bed and the wall. (Reed apartment)about 0:27:49
  6. The state police major crimes unit takes over, dozens and then hundreds of people are interviewed, and the case goes cold.about 0:38:16

Murder of Mary Lou Sale

Victims

Mary Lou Sale (49). tax accountant who had recently moved from Los Angeles

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 16 December 2021.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Barbara Tucker. girlfriend and co-worker
Justine Moon. witness who said stared at her at the bus stop
Thomas Connolly. carpenter who saw a man with reddish hair cover his head near the house
Mary McLarry. Lang's former fiancée
Susan Oak. former president of Lang's company

The timeline

  1. a few months before December 1994 Mary Lou Sale moves from Los Angeles to Lexington and rents the house at Massachusetts Avenue. (Sale house)about 0:40:47
  2. December 3rd, 1994 Sale goes up to her second-floor bedroom, puts on pyjamas, reads and falls asleep. (Sale house)about 0:40:54
  3. about 9:30 p.m., December 3rd, 1994 Neighbours see her lights on until about 9:30 p.m. (Sale house)about 0:41:44
  4. December 3rd to 4th, 1994 Sale is struck seven times on the head and strangled with a nylon stocking. (Sale house)about 0:47:52

Murder of Catholine Dempsey

Victims

Catholine Dempsey (31). graphic and textile designer, also called Kathleen

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 16 December 2021.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Evelyn Tobin. Dempsey's mother, who founded Boston's Garden of Peace
Kenneth Robishaw. part-time dispatcher who treated the 911 call as a hoax
Walter Bullock. next-shift dispatcher who deciphered the address

The timeline

  1. August 23rd, 1992 , suspended from McDonald's and needing money, breaks into Dempsey's basement apartment. (Dempsey apartment)about 1:58:32
  2. about 5:30 a.m., August 23rd, 1992 stabs Dempsey 17 times in the neck and torso with a pocket knife and leaves. (Dempsey apartment)about 1:59:04
  3. 5:30 a.m., August 23rd, 1992 Dempsey calls 911 and says, 'I've been attacked'. (Dempsey apartment)about 2:00:32
  4. morning of August 23rd, 1992 Part-time dispatcher Kenneth Robishaw cannot understand her address and disregards the call as a hoax. (Lexington Fire Department)about 2:00:49
  5. 10 a.m., August 23rd, 1992 The next shift's dispatcher, Walter Bullock, reviews the call logs and deciphers the address. (Lexington Fire Department)about 2:01:04
  6. 10:57 a.m., August 23rd, 1992 Police arrive and find Dempsey dead near the foot of her bed, still holding the telephone. (Dempsey apartment)about 2:01:16

Murder at a Manchester flower shop

Victims

Unidentified woman. the woman working behind the counter

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 16 December 2021.

Accused

Outcome

The timeline

  1. 1989 breaks into a flower shop in Manchester, strangles the woman behind the counter, robs her and flees. (Manchester flower shop)about 2:13:30
  2. 2012 tells investigators about the flower shop killing. (Massachusetts prison)about 2:13:42

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode