FILE 498 / 1 June 2024 / 72 MIN / express

The Mysterious Disappearing Murderer

Jackson, New HampshireListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

it's jackson new hampshire ... in far eastern new hampshire near the main border ... in the white mountains about 0:04:01

History, in brief

Town note

The town was first named New Madberry, after Madberry in the UK.

about 0:05:49

1800

By 1800 the community was renamed Adams after President John Adams.

about 0:06:29
All 8 history facts

Town note

The town was first named New Madberry, after Madberry in the UK.

about 0:05:49

1800

By 1800 the community was renamed Adams after President John Adams.

about 0:06:29

1829

In 1829 it was renamed Jackson after Andrew Jackson, the hero of the Battle of New Orleans; only one vote was cast against the change.

about 0:07:02

2021

In 2021 residents said the name now honours geologist Charles Thomas Jackson.

about 0:07:28

1876

The red covered bridge known as the Honeymoon Bridge was built in 1876 and is one of the most photographed things in the state.

about 0:08:20

Town note

The town motto is 'Bridging the Centuries'.

about 0:05:32

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$541,500
Median household income$70,341
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Median household income

"$70,341"

Comparison: "about the national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:05:21

Median home price

"$541,500"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:05:27

The reviews

4.5 / 5 · average of 2

5 stars

“A quintessential New England town, easy to meet new friends, a wonderful community, great restaurants, close to hiking and skiing, great views and lots of activities; medical services are lacking, the grocery store has limited choices, it is overrun with tourists at times and the closest airport is a few hours' drive.”
about 0:08:56

4 stars

“I love this town: it is small and outdoorsy and people take a lot of pride in it, but I wish there were more affordable housing options.”
about 0:09:39

In New Hampshire

Closest episodes

  1. The Shining, But More QuaintNewry, Maine · 27 June 201944 km / 27 miShow on map
  2. Serial Killer Happy MealPlymouth, New Hampshire · 16 December 202166 km / 41 miShow on map
  3. Menage a Nope in St Johnsbury, VermontSt. Johnsbury, Vermont · 11 July 201973 km / 45 miShow on map
  4. Kitchen Table MurderBurke, Vermont · 1 November 201778 km / 48 miShow on map
  5. Overwhelming Evidence Of OverkillBelmont, New Hampshire · 13 December 201887 km / 54 miShow on map

The story

In the far east of New Hampshire, close to the Maine border and inside the White Mountains, sits Jackson, a town of 998 people in Carroll County. Malcolm Jennings, known as Mal, and his wife Elizabeth, known as Betty, had run the Dana Place Inn in Pinkham Notch since 1960. Their son Christopher was born in 1961 and their daughter Page in 1964. Page was a tall, athletic honour student and a champion javelin thrower. He was still married to Debbie Alderfer. Page was twenty. Late in 1983 the couple moved to a duplex at Palm Harbor, Texas, near Rockport, where Page got a job as a sports writer on the Rockport Pilot. The couple moved to Florida, where Page worked at the Stacks Restaurant inside a Holiday Inn. On January 11, 1985, Christopher told them both to leave. They took a room at the Gator Court Motel, and Page went back to collect her half of the apartment deposit. On January 12 he booked a room at an inn in Brattleboro, and the following night he checked into the Bridgeport Motor Inn in Connecticut. On January 13 he telephoned Christopher and claimed that he and Page were on honeymoon in Miami. On January 14 or 15 he pawned more of her jewellery in Portland, Maine. On January 15, 1985, a fire broke out in the caretaker's cottage at the Dana Place Inn. Firefighters found Mal and Betty Jennings in separate bedrooms, bound and gagged with nylon rope, their throats slashed and their bodies repeatedly stabbed. The cottage was not the inn itself but the smaller building where they stayed. The town was terrified. Richard 'Dick' Patch, who owned Patches Gun Shop, said residents talked of nothing else and that he was selling a great deal of ammunition. He said that he and Page had made all their arrangements and were ready to do what Page thought was the only way they could be together for all time. He described their love since their eyes first met in Alaska, complained of her family's meddling, and said Page had asked him to burn the New Hampshire home so that no mementoes were left. He described putting a chokehold on Page, releasing her when she began to move, then holding her again until she stopped breathing; when she twitched he hit her with a large stone. He said he would rope himself down before using a shotgun, then set the fire. On January 28, 1985, the Alachua County sheriff's office received a call about a suspicious car in a field off State Road 236 and 93 at High Springs, outside Gainesville. Sergeant Danny Brown found an abandoned blue Fiat with the keys in the ignition, neatly folded men's and women's clothing behind the seat, and an envelope on the dashboard addressed to the Gainesville police homicide bureau. The letter inside said that near the car was a burned shack containing the remains of two people. About a hundred feet away, in a clearing at the edge of a cornfield, deputies found the burned structure and two skeletons, one larger and one smaller, reduced mostly to fragments and dust. There were two melted one-gallon fuel cans, a melted shotgun, a sprayer and more than ten thousand bone fragments. Dr William Maples, a forensic anthropologist, reconstructed the remains. Florida concluded in 1987 that the smaller skeleton was Page's, and that the male had died of a shotgun wound to the head. Christopher Jennings sold the Dana Place Inn the next year. Page and her parents appear to be buried in the Kearsarge Cemetery in North Conway, New Hampshire.

The case

Murders of Malcolm and Elizabeth Jennings

Victims

Malcolm 'Mal' Jennings (54). ran the Dana Place Inn with his wife
Elizabeth 'Betty' Jennings (47). ran the Dana Place Inn with her husband

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 1 June 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Christopher Jennings. son of Mal and Betty; ran the inn after their deaths
Page Jennings. daughter of Mal and Betty; girlfriend
Debbie Alderfer. wife, who left him
Dr William Maples. forensic anthropologist who reconstructed the remains
Sergeant Danny Brown. Alachua County sheriff's deputy who found the car
Richard 'Dick' Patch. owner of Patches Gun Shop
William Payne. attorney
Betsy. Page's friend

The timeline

  1. 1935 is born in Pasco, Washington.about 0:19:08
  2. 1959 marries his first wife.about 0:24:33
  3. 1960 Mal and Betty Jennings buy and start running the Dana Place Inn. (Dana Place Inn)about 0:14:41
  4. 1961 Their son Christopher is born.about 0:13:49
  5. 1962 is caught after burgling businesses in Walla Walla and Seattle.about 0:24:53
  6. 1964 divorces his first wife and abandons their two sons.about 0:24:33
  7. 1964 Their daughter Page is born.about 0:13:55
  8. 1972 mother Pearl commits suicide by carbon monoxide in her car.about 0:26:31
  9. 1983 and Debbie Alderfer move to Alaska hoping to pan for gold.about 0:30:13
  10. fall 1983 meets Page Jennings at the Seal Bay lodge, where he is the caretaker and she works in the kitchen. (Seal Bay lodge)about 0:30:36
  11. fall 1983 , Page and Debbie leave Alaska together.about 0:33:45
  12. October 1983 Page takes home to Jackson to meet her parents, who are horrified by him. (Dana Place Inn)about 0:34:14
  13. late 1983 The couple moves into a duplex in Palm Harbor, Texas, near Rockport. (Palm Harbor duplex)about 0:35:30
  14. fall 1984 Page's parents issue an ultimatum, and the couple moves to Florida, where Page works at the Stacks Restaurant. (Stacks Restaurant)about 0:36:59
  15. December 1984 moves into Christopher Jennings's apartment in Gainesville. (Christopher Jennings's apartment)about 0:39:18
  16. January 11, 1985 Christopher tells Page and to get out; they take a room at the Gator Court Motel. (Gator Court Motel)about 0:39:42
  17. January 12, 1985 heads north without Page, leaving her in Florida.about 0:40:57
  18. January 12, 1985 books a room at an inn in Brattleboro. (Brattleboro inn)about 0:41:03
  19. January 13, 1985 checks into the Bridgeport Motor Inn in Connecticut and telephones Christopher, claiming he and Page are on honeymoon in Miami. (Bridgeport Motor Inn)about 0:41:03
  20. January 14, 1985 is seen in Hartford trying to pawn Page's jewellery. (Hartford pawnbroker)about 0:41:49
  21. January 14 or 15, 1985 pawns some of Page's jewellery in Portland, Maine. (Portland pawn shop)about 0:41:36
  22. January 15, 1985 A fire destroys the caretaker's cottage at the Dana Place Inn; Mal and Betty Jennings are found bound, gagged, stabbed and with their throats slashed. (Caretaker's cottage at Dana Place Inn)about 0:42:30

Murder of Page Jennings

Victims

Page Jennings (21). daughter of Mal and Betty Jennings; girlfriend

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 1 June 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Christopher Jennings. Page's brother
Dr William Maples. forensic anthropologist who reconstructed the remains
Betsy. Page's friend

The timeline

  1. fall 1983 Page Jennings meets at the Seal Bay lodge in Alaska. (Seal Bay lodge)about 0:30:36
  2. October 1983 Page brings to the Dana Place Inn to meet her parents. (Dana Place Inn)about 0:34:14
  3. fall 1984 A co-worker sees bruises on Page's face from a fight with . (Stacks Restaurant)about 0:36:46
  4. December 1984 Page moves into her brother Christopher's apartment in Gainesville. (Christopher Jennings's apartment)about 0:39:18
  5. January 11, 1985 Page and are told to leave Christopher's apartment and take a room at the Gator Court Motel. (Gator Court Motel)about 0:39:42
  6. January 1985 puts Page in a chokehold until she dies, hits her with a stone when she twitches, and burns her body on a platform in the shack. (Burned shack near High Springs)about 0:59:35

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode