FILE 443 / 23 November 2023 / 178 MIN / full

Writing Your Murder Script

Lempster, New HampshireListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Lempster, New Hampshire ... this is in Sullivan County. about 0:04:43

History, in brief

1735

Granted as a township by colonial governor Jonathan Belcher in 1735 and named Number Nine.

about 0:05:35

Town note

Number Nine because it was the ninth in a line of forts to guard against Indian attacks.

about 0:05:54

1753

Regranted in 1753 as Duplin, after Scottish Lord Thomas Hay, the Viscount Duplin.

about 0:06:07

1767

Regranted a final time in 1767 as Lempster, after Sir Thomas Firmer, the second Baron Leominster.

about 0:06:23
All 5 history facts

1735

Granted as a township by colonial governor Jonathan Belcher in 1735 and named Number Nine.

about 0:05:35

Town note

Number Nine because it was the ninth in a line of forts to guard against Indian attacks.

about 0:05:54

1753

Regranted in 1753 as Duplin, after Scottish Lord Thomas Hay, the Viscount Duplin.

about 0:06:07

1767

Regranted a final time in 1767 as Lempster, after Sir Thomas Firmer, the second Baron Leominster.

about 0:06:23

The figures, as told

Religious

23.3%

Biggest faith: Catholic, 14.2%

about 0:11:42

Who lives here

White 96.7% · Black 0.0% · Asian 2.3%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ about one third

about 0:21:51

Violent crime
▼ about two-thirds

about 0:21:59

Money

Median home value$275,300
Two-bedroom rent$1,280
Median household income$76,250 a year
Cost of living89

For sale

$237,900

Three-bedroom, one-bath, 1,800 square foot house on a five-acre lot

about 0:15:31

For sale

$1,190,000

Three-bedroom, three-bath, 2,114 square foot house on 71 acres

about 0:16:30
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

White residents

"96.7%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:11:17

Black residents

"0.0%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:11:22

Asian residents

"2.3%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:11:22

Two or more races

"0.9%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:11:28

Religious residents

"23.3%"

Comparison: "usually 50-50 is the normal". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:11:42

Democratic vote in Sullivan County

"50.7%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:12:12

Republican vote in Sullivan County

"47.1%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:12:12

Independent vote in Sullivan County

"2.2%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:12:12

Unemployment rate

"2.7%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:12:21

Median household income

"$76,250 a year"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:12:37

Cost of living index

"89"

Comparison: "100 is the regular average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:12:41

Median home cost

"$275,300"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:12:59

Average two-bedroom rental

"$1,280"

Comparison: "the national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:13:27

15 acres of land

"$150,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:14:10

Three-bedroom, one-bath, 1,800 square foot house on a five-acre lot

"$237,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:15:31

Three-bedroom, three-bath, 2,114 square foot house on 71 acres

"$1,190,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:30

Lempster Goshen gravel pit material

"1.5 million yards"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:01

Property crime

"about one third"

Comparison: "under the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:21:51

Violent crime

"about two-thirds"

Comparison: "under the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:21:59

The reviews

4.0 / 5 · average of 1

4 stars

“Great town with a small but friendly community; the only thing that could improve would be the middle school.”
about 0:08:06

In New Hampshire

Closest episodes

  1. The Murder Blame GameGrafton, Vermont · 24 October 202535 km / 22 miShow on map
  2. Never Saw That ComingTownshend, Vermont · 22 July 202345 km / 28 miShow on map
  3. Stairway To HeavenNewfane, Vermont · 16 November 202447 km / 29 miShow on map
  4. The Murder And The MiracleMont Vernon, New Hampshire · 2 October 202554 km / 34 miShow on map
  5. The Killing Of A Bad ManHooksett, New Hampshire · 11 August 202261 km / 38 miShow on map

The story

Edith Meyer, known to everyone as Pen, was born in Boston on 4 July 1949, one of eleven children of a wealthy industrialist. The family had money, homes and a trust fund, but Pen was frightened of her disciplinarian father and left as soon as she could. She went to the Pingry School in South Hamilton, Massachusetts, then to Colby Sawyer College in New London, New Hampshire, graduating in 1970. In 1971 she married Colin Campbell, the man she had met at college, and they settled in Wilmot, New Hampshire, where they had three children, Justin, Kiera and Haley. Pen learned to weave and became a well-known figure in the state's artisan community, making napkins, mats and table runners. She and Colin divorced in 1985, and she moved back to New London, working part-time as a gardener and flower arranger. In 2001 she married Richard Rankin, a landscaper from Goshen. The marriage was unhappy: he was jealous, controlling and drank heavily, and they separated within three years. Pen bought a small rural house near the water in Goshen, made it her own, and supported herself with her weaving and yarn dyeing, selling at the Norwich farmers market. She was active in the Lake Sunapee Protective Association and the Friends of Mount Sunapee. She lived alone with her beloved sheepdog, Fluff, and was known for hiking, swimming, canoeing and for the snow angels she made in neighbours' gardens.

Pen had struggled privately with alcohol, which she later said was her way of coping with sexual abuse suffered in childhood. In the mid-1990s she was hospitalised after a nervous breakdown, began therapy, gave up drinking for good and joined Alcoholics Anonymous. She remained a committed member, supporting other women in recovery. In 2004, after her separation from Rankin, she began a relationship with Jonathan Purick, a man she met at an Al-Anon meeting in Newport.

His parents, Bud and Bernice, later bought a drive-in cinema. Ken was popular, a strong football player, and by his own account liked hitting people. He married and divorced twice, had a son, moved between construction and labouring jobs, and stopped drinking in 1981. He became a keen AA member and sponsor, though friends noticed that he used meetings to meet vulnerable women. In 2000 he began dating Harvey, known as Harv, a nurse's aide and devout churchgoer, and they married in 2003 at Millie's Place, an AA meeting venue in a Newport strip mall. They moved to a cottage in Lempster. When confronted by the loss-prevention officer, Terry Casey, he told her 'this never happened', offered her stolen crisps and then suggested sex with no strings attached.

He was attracted to her vulnerability, told her his marriage was over and began an affair, though he never left Harv. He followed her, turned up at her home and at her workplace, and was warned by her brother Greg and by Newport police. On 9 December a temporary protective order was granted, made permanent on 13 December. On 4 January 2005 he pushed his way into the home of Frederick Evans, angry about the stalking petition.

Witnesses at AA said he called her a traitor, pulled a man away from her for hugging her, and on three occasions Pen reported him to Goshen police, once after he followed her home and screamed at her. On the morning of 23 February 2005 he put his plan into action. She mentioned a chainsaw accident. Sandra could not make sense of it. Pen then failed to collect her friend Joanne DeFord for a dental appointment, something utterly out of character. That evening Jonathan Purick let himself into Pen's house, found her car in the garage, the lights on and Fluff inside, but no Pen. Nothing was disturbed and there was no blood. He played her answering machine and heard Sandra's message about the 'bombshell' of the morning call.

A neighbour reported seeing him burning brush on 24 February and hauling it an unusual distance to the pit beside his house. The box, at Lake Sunapee Bank, held Pen's jewellery, silverware and will.

On 3 March Sandra received a package postmarked 25 February containing a typed agreement, purportedly signed by Pen, transferring all her property to Sandra, and a $400 cheque marked 'for dog sitting'. Police also found orange duct tape matching the tape on the pay phone. In a blizzard they searched the fire pit in his yard, finding charred bone fragments, a ring, the frame of a pair of glasses, Pen's keys and distinctive jewellery. A medical examiner assembled about a third of a skeleton and concluded the remains were those of a small woman weighing 100 to 110 pounds. In a shed was a backpack containing gloves, a torch, a belt, superglue, a lighter, a lock, condoms, knives and tie-down cords.

It obsessed over Sandra and CSI, raged at Pen's interference, and contained drafts of the script Pen had read on the phone, including the pilot, the trip abroad and the instruction to drop the restraining order. There were also letters written as if from Pen, a sketch of a stick figure with a gun and a fire, and the line 'I never meant for it to go this far'. Harv admitted burning three notebooks in the wood stove and destroying other evidence, was granted immunity and testified. She also led police to a notepad and a Honda key hidden behind insulation, the key starting Pen's car.

The medical examiner stood by the combination of bones, dental records, jewellery and a gunshot wound to the back of the skull. Pen's ashes were never buried and their resting place is unknown.

The case

Murder of Edith 'Pen' Meyer

Victims

Edith 'Pen' Meyer. weaver and yarn dyer, born in Boston, lived alone with her sheepdog Fluff

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 23 November 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Sandra Merritt. girlfriend, the target of his harassment and restraining orders
Jonathan Purick. Pen's boyfriend, who found her house empty
Joanne DeFord. Pen's friend, waiting for a lift to a dental appointment
Greg Merritt. Sandra's brother, who confronted
Jim Swan. AA member told about the affair
Frederick Evans. AA acquaintance visited before the stalking petition was served
Nicholas and Dot Monahan. AA friends who hosted the house blessing

The timeline

  1. July 4, 1949 Edith Meyer is born in Boston, one of eleven children.about 0:46:25
  2. August 1951 is born in Greenfield, Massachusetts.about 1:12:57
  3. 1970 Pen graduates from Colby Sawyer College. (Colby Sawyer College)about 0:50:41
  4. 1971 Pen marries Colin Campbell.about 0:50:59
  5. 1981 stops drinking and joins AA.about 1:19:24
  6. 1985 Pen divorces Colin Campbell and moves back to New London.about 0:51:43
  7. the mid-1990s Pen is hospitalised with a nervous breakdown and later gives up drinking for good.about 0:55:08
  8. July 2000 starts dating Harv.about 1:22:29
  9. 2001 Pen marries Richard Rankin, a landscaper from Goshen.about 0:57:04
  10. 2003 and Harv marry at Millie's Place. (Millie's Place)about 1:28:23
  11. January 23, 2004 Sandra Merritt returns to AA and meets at Millie's Place. (Millie's Place)about 1:30:27
  12. September 15, 2004 Pen's divorce from Richard Rankin is finalised.about 1:06:57
  13. October 2004 is caught shoplifting from Walmart and loses his job. (Walmart)about 1:42:13
  14. November 14, 2004 The Monahans hold an alcohol-free house blessing, where Pen sees with his wife. (Monahan house)about 1:47:08
  15. November 17, 2004 Sandra ends her relationship with .about 1:50:23
  16. November 18, 2004 turns up at Sandra's apartment and is kicked out.about 1:51:56
  17. the day after Thanksgiving 2004 drives at Pen, Joanne and Jonathan outside the video store, screaming at Pen. (video store)about 1:54:56
  18. November 28, 2004 follows Sandra from Millie's Place and later bangs on her door; her brother warns him off. (Millie's Place)about 1:56:57
  19. November 30, 2004 Sandra tells a police officer about harassment. (Newport Police Department)about 2:00:08
  20. December 4, 2004 Sandra reports that is still turning up at her house.about 2:01:23
  21. December 9, 2004 A temporary order of protection is issued, with a hearing set for January 4. (court)about 2:04:34
  22. December 13, 2004 A permanent protective order is issued against . (court)about 2:06:01
  23. January 4, 2005 pushes into Frederick Evans's kitchen, angry about the stalking petition. (Frederick Evans house)about 2:04:43
  24. February 23, 2005 At 7:30 a.m. Pen calls Sandra and, as later evidence shows, reads a script wrote. (Meyer house)about 0:31:29
  25. February 23, 2005 Pen fails to collect Joanne for her dental appointment and is never seen again.about 0:23:14
  26. February 23, 2005 At about 9:30 p.m. Jonathan finds Pen's car in the garage, the dog inside and no Pen. (Meyer house)about 1:09:23
  27. February 23, 2005 Prosecutors later conclude Pen was shot in the head with a small-calibre bullet and her body burned. ( cottage)about 2:29:46

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode