FILE 642 / 24 October 2025 / 74 MIN / express

The Murder Blame Game

Grafton, VermontListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

This is Grafton, Vermont... in Windham County, area code 802. about 0:03:47

History, in brief

Town note

In the early 1800s sheep raising became popular and wool mills sprang up along the rivers.

about 0:04:48

1801

The Grafton Inn, formerly the old Tavern Inn, was founded in 1801 and remains one of the oldest continually operating hotels in the United States.

about 0:05:26

Town note

Before the Civil War the town had about 1,500 people.

about 0:05:37
All 7 history facts

Town note

In the early 1800s sheep raising became popular and wool mills sprang up along the rivers.

about 0:04:48

1801

The Grafton Inn, formerly the old Tavern Inn, was founded in 1801 and remains one of the oldest continually operating hotels in the United States.

about 0:05:26

Town note

Before the Civil War the town had about 1,500 people.

about 0:05:37

Town note

The town's able-bodied men who went to the Civil War were wiped out at once, and local cemeteries hold many tombstones of Gettysburg casualties.

about 0:05:58

Town note

The soapstone quarry was depleted and closed in the late 1800s.

about 0:06:22

Town note

Around the time of the Great Depression the town's population was less than 400, and tourism later brought it back.

about 0:06:27

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$395,800
Median household income$68,125
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"587"

Comparison: "permanent population". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:18

Median household income

"$68,125"

Comparison: "national average, within a thousand dollars". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:24

Median home cost

"$395,800"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:38

Population before the Civil War

"about 1,500"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:05:37

Population around the Great Depression

"less than 400"

Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:06:27

The reviews

4.5 / 5 · average of 2

5 stars

“A beautiful town where they make you feel welcome, with a community garden and trails for hiking, skiing and snowmobiling; a child's paradise.”
about 0:06:31

4 stars

“A small town with a tight knit community, but there is little in terms of jobs besides the inn.”
about 0:07:22

In Vermont

Closest episodes

  1. Never Saw That ComingTownshend, Vermont · 22 July 202314 km / 9 miShow on map
  2. Stairway To HeavenNewfane, Vermont · 16 November 202421 km / 13 miShow on map
  3. Writing Your Murder ScriptLempster, New Hampshire · 23 November 202335 km / 22 miShow on map
  4. The Murdered Murderer MurdersRutland, Vermont · 16 September 202157 km / 35 miShow on map
  5. Myers Is My IdolGreenfield, Massachusetts · 11 February 202362 km / 39 miShow on map

The story

Grafton is a small town in Windham County, southern Vermont, with a permanent population of 587 and a median household income of $68,125, about the national average. In June 2002 it was the setting for the murders of Greg Enus and Colleen Davis, two people from poorer towns nearby whose bodies were found in a state forest a few miles from the village.

Greg Enus was born on 24 July 1968 in Bridgeport, Connecticut, and grew up in Vermont, attending Newfane High School and Leland High School in Townshend. He worked around lumber yards, including the Alard Lumber Company and CNS Wholesale Grocers in Brattleboro, and lived in Brattleboro on Eliot Street with a woman named Sandra.

Colleen Davis was 33, the same age as Enus. She was divorced, with three children, Jesse, Rusty and Amanda, one of the boys in a wheelchair. She had moved to Vermont from Maine in 2001 and lived with the children in a trailer at the Tenny Mobile Home Park in Athens, a collection of five dilapidated trailers in a meadow that had earlier been the scene of a heroin bust.

The men's green Ford Explorer had stuck in mud on a four-wheeler trail; a logger had pulled it out between 7.30 and 8.30 that morning and been paid with a shotgun because they had no cash. Enus and Davis drove the pair to Bellows Falls, stopped at a gas station in the Red Light Hill area for beer, cigarettes and marijuana, and agreed to go back to the state forest to party and help free the truck.

At the Mali Beedy State Forest, near an old Civilian Conservation Corps stone camp used by teenage drinkers, they drank and smoked. What happened next is disputed. A fight followed. Enus was beaten about the head and stabbed 21 times; Davis was beaten to death, her skull fractured. The fire went out.

At about 12.30 p.m. on Tuesday 25 June a man collecting returnable bottles and cans found the bodies in Enus's 1986 light blue Nissan pickup: Davis's upper body pushed through the small rear window, Enus upside down under the steering wheel.

Each said the other did the killing; each said he only pretended to strike Davis, hitting the truck instead.

The case

Murders of Greg Enus and Colleen Davis

Victims

Greg Enus (33). Born in Bridgeport, Connecticut, grew up in Vermont; worked in lumber and wholesale groceries; lived in Brattleboro.
Colleen Davis (33). Divorced single mother of three who moved to Vermont from Maine in 2001 and lived in a trailer at the Tenny Mobile Home Park in Athens.

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 24 October 2025.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Jesse, Rusty and Amanda. Colleen's three children
Deborah Dodi. said her son was best friend and described as meek and mild
Judge Hudson. judge who considered recusing himself because a key witness was his son's supervisor
Lieutenant Raymond Keith. patrol commander of the Bethel Barracks and a detective at the time of the murders, due to testify

The timeline

  1. July 24th, 1968 Greg Enus is born in Bridgeport, Connecticutabout 0:09:42
  2. July 1959 '' is bornabout 0:15:40
  3. 1982 is born in Brooklyn, New Yorkabout 0:16:51
  4. 2001 Colleen Davis moves from Maine to Vermont with her three childrenabout 0:12:26
  5. May 17th, 2002 Pat 'Packman' Williams beats about the head and face with a baseball batabout 0:57:12
  6. June 24th, 2002 Greg Enus and Colleen Davis pick up two hitchhikers, and , while out for a drive, and drive them to Bellows Falls to buy beerabout 0:14:03
  7. between 7.30 and 8.30 a.m., June 24th, 2002 A logger pulls the two men's green Ford Explorer out of a muddy four-wheeler trail and is paid with a shotgun (Mali Beedy State Forest)about 0:28:24
  8. June 24th, 2002 They stop at a gas station in the Red Light Hill area for beer, cigarettes and marijuana, then decide to return to the state forest to party and free the stuck truck (Red Light Hill gas station)about 0:36:48
  9. June 24th, 2002 At the camp, Enus and walk off to look at the truck while and Davis stay at a picnic table (CCC camp stone shelter)about 0:37:20
  10. June 24th, 2002 Enus and Davis are killed: Enus suffers blunt force trauma and 21 stab wounds, Davis a fractured skull from blunt force (CCC camp stone shelter)about 0:26:39

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode