FILE 310 / 18 August 2022 / 173 MIN / full

The Bloodbath Brothers

Pulaski, TennesseeListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

going down to Pulaski, Tennessee, in Giles County, near the Alabama line about 0:04:49

History, in brief

Town note

A lot of Civil War fighting took place in and around Pulaski.

about 0:06:27

Town note

The area was fertile ground for the Ku Klux Klan after the Civil War; James calls it a KKK cauldron.

about 0:07:04
All 2 history facts

Town note

A lot of Civil War fighting took place in and around Pulaski.

about 0:06:27

Town note

The area was fertile ground for the Ku Klux Klan after the Civil War; James calls it a KKK cauldron.

about 0:07:04

The figures, as told

Religious

66.6%

Biggest faith: Baptist, 36%

about 0:11:45

Who lives here

White 66% · Black 24.1% · Asian 0.7% · Hispanic 3.8%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ almost double

about 0:23:52

Violent crime
▲ about a third higher

about 0:24:04

Money

Median home value$134,800
Two-bedroom rent$686
Median household income$29,019
Cost of livingabout 77

For sale

$75,000

Two-bedroom, one-bath house, 864 sq ft

about 0:14:06

For sale

$429,000

Five-bedroom, three-bath house, 3,370 sq ft

about 0:15:05

For sale

$1,200,000

Four-bedroom, three-bath house, 4,162 sq ft

about 0:15:47
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Property crime

"almost double"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:23:52

Violent crime

"about a third higher"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:24:04

Population

"7,524"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:10:32

Median age

"about 38"

Comparison: "about average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2022 about 0:10:47

Asian

"0.7%"

Comparison: "usually 5% in the rest of the country". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:11:19

Hispanic

"3.8%"

Comparison: "usually 18%". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:11:36

Religious

"66.6%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:11:45

Median household income

"$29,019"

Comparison: "about $54,000 nationally". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:12:38

Cost of living index

"about 77"

Comparison: "100 is the average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:12:52

Median home cost

"$134,800"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:12:59

Average two-bedroom rent

"$686"

Comparison: "about half the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:13:25

Two-bedroom, one-bath house, 864 sq ft

"$75,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:14:06

Five-bedroom, three-bath house, 3,370 sq ft

"$429,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:15:05

Four-bedroom, three-bath house, 4,162 sq ft

"$1,200,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:15:47

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“A lifelong resident says the town has grown, has lots of new businesses and is friendly and inviting, and recommends it to anyone.”
about 0:07:12

4 stars

“Small and quaint, good for families, gorgeous scenery and a rich history, though there is little entertainment and teenagers have little to do but get into trouble.”
about 0:07:35

3 stars

“There is nothing to do or see, and only drug stores and tobacco outlets get built.”
about 0:08:35

2 stars

“Too small, people only start drama, and the police mostly do nothing.”
about 0:08:56

1 star

“The town loses money because people spend it in bigger cities, it would suit a retirement community, and the worst crimes are DUIs and unpaid child support.”
about 0:09:30

In Tennessee

Closest episodes

  1. Fat Sam & Crazy CrystalLawrenceburg, Tennessee · 28 September 202328 km / 17 miShow on map
  2. Til Dismemberment Do Us PartDecatur, Alabama · 14 May 202069 km / 43 miShow on map
  3. Murder Breadcrumb TrailTullahoma, Tennessee · 9 April 202677 km / 48 miShow on map
  4. A Closet Full Of MurderBrentwood, Tennessee · 18 October 201892 km / 57 miShow on map
  5. Where Is The Head??Dickson, Tennessee · 24 October 2019101 km / 63 miShow on map

The story

Pulaski sits in Giles County in southern Tennessee, close to the Alabama line, about an hour and a quarter from Nashville. At the time of the episode it had a population of 7,524. James notes that the area saw a great deal of Civil War fighting and that it was fertile ground for the Ku Klux Klan after the war, a cauldron with a K. The story he tells, though, is centred on a run-down farmhouse in nearby Elkton, where two brothers drew young people in with drugs and drink.

The boys were heavy from an early age, more than 250 pounds each by the seventh grade and about 350 pounds as adults. They were bullied for their weight and then became bullies themselves, and they learned to cultivate a reputation for being strange: they buried neighbourhood cats in the yard and ran a lawnmower over their heads, and they ate handfuls of raw mince to shock people. Polly defended them against every complaint. By high school they had found drugs, and dealing made them popular.

They graduated in 1973.

He later claimed the two Rogers had robbed him at knifepoint and threatened to kill him, and that he grabbed a screwdriver from a dresser and stabbed them both in self-defence. Roger Mills died from 46 stab wounds, 40 of them inflicted with the screwdriver. Roger Sellers survived.

Young people came and went. In May 1986 Gwen Dugger, a 24-year-old single mother and the daughter of tavern owner David Dugger, came to the farmhouse with her brother Ken to collect Ken's repaired car. Danice later said Gwen bought Valium and Placidyl, got high and was close to passing out. She left, returned half an hour later, and found Gwen naked and unconscious on a mattress. They wrapped the body in garbage bags, stuffed it head first into a 55-gallon barrel behind the house and burned it all night with the mattress, her clothes and rubber from the Pulaski Rubber Company. The bones were crushed and later dumped in the Elk River.

By then Gwen was simply missing. The wallet held Matthew's disability cheque and cash. In fact, as the investigation later established, a man named Billy Wade Bass had found the wallet on the floor of the Western Lounge and stolen the contents. They drove the remains to their parents' house in West Point, Tennessee, and burned them about five feet outside the back door, using rubber from work; it took two and a half days. He gave her a share of Gaines's money, which he called her third of the burial expenses.

On 20 October Joyce Gaines came home for clothes and found the carpets cut around the furniture, the phone gone, beer cans everywhere and comforters and her daughter's jewellery box and television missing. Gaines was reported missing only after the fire. Danice, who had been given full immunity, gave a written statement on 1 May 1990 and described both killings. In May 1990 forensic anthropologists searched the West Point property; an accelerant dog alerted on the burn site, and Danice led police to the barrel behind the farmhouse, where the only trace of Gwen left was a nappy pin she kept on her shoe in honour of her son. Dr William Bass of the University of Tennessee examined burned cranial fragments from the West Point site.

The case

Murder of Roger Mills

Victims

Roger Mills (21). roommate; died of 46 stab wounds, 40 of them from a screwdriver
Roger Sellers (24). the other roommate; stabbed repeatedly but survived

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 18 August 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Sandy. Roger Sellers's 17-year-old girlfriend; came back from buying cigarettes to find the men stabbed
Carol. Sandy's friend, at the apartment

The timeline

  1. April 3rd, 1955 and are born, twinsabout 0:24:52
  2. late 1960s The family settles in Elkton, Tennessee (Elkton)about 0:27:40
  3. 1973 The twins graduate from high schoolabout 0:56:28
  4. September 1973 joins the U.S. Army and is honourably discharged after a month and a dayabout 0:58:08
  5. August 24th, 1974 stabs Roger Mills and Roger Sellers in the Cincinnati apartment (Cincinnati apartment)about 0:59:57
  6. August 24th, 1974 Sandy and Carol return from buying cigarettes at about 10:30 or 11 p.m. and find the men stabbed (Cincinnati apartment)about 1:07:19
  7. August 24th, 1974 flags down police in the street and admits stabbing the men (Cincinnati)about 1:05:39
  8. January 10th, 1975 arrives at the State Reformatory in Mansfield, Ohio (State Reformatory, Mansfield, Ohio)about 1:12:11

Murder of Gwen Dugger

Victims

Gwen Dugger (24). single mother of a young son; daughter of tavern owner David Dugger

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 18 August 2022.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Gary Hardon. friend at the farmhouse; made a pass at Gwen and was warned off with a pistol
Dwayne Howell. friend at the farmhouse; left and invited strippers back to the farm
Ken Dugger. Gwen's brother, who left her at the farmhouse
David Dugger. Gwen's father, owner of the tavern

The timeline

  1. April 3rd, 1955 and are born, twinsabout 0:24:52
  2. late 1960s The family settles in Elkton, Tennessee (Elkton)about 0:27:40
  3. 1973 The twins graduate from high schoolabout 0:56:28
  4. 1983 marries Daniceabout 1:17:10
  5. August 1986 and Danice separate after a fight; she goes to Alabama for two monthsabout 1:17:16
  6. May 1986 Gwen Dugger and her brother Ken come to the farmhouse to collect Ken's repaired car; Gwen stays to party ( farmhouse)about 1:19:53
  7. May 1986 Gwen buys Valium and Placidyl from the brothers and gets high, close to passing out ( farmhouse)about 1:20:58
  8. May 1986 rapes Gwen in the bathroom and joins in; they move her to a bedroom and later to the barn ( farmhouse)about 1:22:37
  9. May 1986 Danice walks in on raping Gwen, hits Gwen and , then goes back to the kitchen to finish cooking ( farmhouse)about 1:24:12
  10. May 1986 Danice leaves and returns half an hour later to find Gwen naked and unconscious; beats her ten to twelve times with an axe handle ( farmhouse)about 1:26:18
  11. May 1986 has sex with Gwen again as she loses control of her bodily functions; shoots her twice in the head with a .22 ( farmhouse)about 1:27:20
  12. May 1986 Gwen's body is wrapped in garbage bags, put head first into a 55-gallon barrel behind the house and burned all night (Gwen Dugger's barrel)about 1:28:04

Murder of William Ronnie 'Hippie' Gaines

Victims

William Ronnie 'Hippie' Gaines. co-worker at the Pulaski Rubber Company and friend; husband of Joyce Gaines

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 18 August 2022.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Joyce Gaines. Gaines's wife, who had left him after a fight
Ann McGill. Gaines's sister, who found his house burned down
Billy Wade Bass. the man who actually found and stole wallet at the Western Lounge
Mark Marrow. called at the Shady Lawn truck stop to fetch
Rodney Randoff. friend at the farmhouse who saw the smoking remains
Terry Lynn Clark. girlfriend and his alibi for the night Gaines disappeared
Lane Roberts. detective sergeant with the Pulaski police who investigated the fire and disappearance
Jerry Dickey. State Fire Marshal's investigator
Michael Chapman. detective who inherited the case in 1989
Dr William Bass. head of anthropology at the University of Tennessee, who examined the burned bone fragments
Bobby Massey. defence attorney for the brothers

The timeline

  1. 1973 and Hippie Gaines begin working together at the Pulaski Rubber Company (Pulaski Rubber Company)about 1:30:57
  2. September 1986 tells Danice his wallet was stolen while he was drinking with Gaines after workabout 1:31:07
  3. October 1986 tells Danice that Gaines took the wallet, which held Matthew's disability cheque and cashabout 1:31:51
  4. about a month before Gaines disappeared Billy Wade Bass finds wallet on the floor of the Western Lounge, steals the cash and endorsed cheque, and throws the wallet away (Western Lounge)about 1:49:03
  5. October 17th, 1986 Gaines works his last shift; his pay cheque dated that day is endorsed by him and and cashed the same day (Pulaski Rubber Company)about 1:45:53
  6. October 17th, 1986 accuses Gaines of cheating at cards and of stealing the wallet and beats him for over 30 minutes with a small rocking chair until he is dead (Hippie Gaines's house)about 1:34:36

Death of Terry Lynn Clark

Victims

Terry Lynn Clark. girlfriend and his alibi for the night Gaines disappeared

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 18 August 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Rodney Randoff. living at the house when Clark died

The timeline

  1. October 1986 Terry Lynn Clark, girlfriend, becomes his alibi for the night Gaines disappearedabout 1:55:01

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode