FILE 368 / 4 March 2023 / 67 MIN / express

Good Fences, Dead Neighbors

Monterey, TennesseeListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

we're going down to monterey tennessee as a matter of fact about 0:03:50

History, in brief

Town note

Monterey grew from a settlement around a landmark known as the Standing Stone.

about 0:05:18

Town note

The stone was a guidepost for travellers along Avery's Trace in the late 1700s.

about 0:05:31

Town note

It is believed to have earlier served as a boundary marker between Cherokee and Shawnee territory.

about 0:05:42

1805

By 1805 three families had settled permanently and the Standing Stone Inn was established for travellers.

about 0:05:58
All 6 history facts

Town note

Monterey grew from a settlement around a landmark known as the Standing Stone.

about 0:05:18

Town note

The stone was a guidepost for travellers along Avery's Trace in the late 1700s.

about 0:05:31

Town note

It is believed to have earlier served as a boundary marker between Cherokee and Shawnee territory.

about 0:05:42

1805

By 1805 three families had settled permanently and the Standing Stone Inn was established for travellers.

about 0:05:58

Town note

The Cumberland Mountain Coal Company bought a large amount of property and the rights to the coal under people's land.

about 0:06:16

Town note

A contest was held to name the town; Major Robert John Moe Scrip submitted Monterey, meaning king of the mountains, because coal was king.

about 0:06:38

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$174,300
Median household income$24,770
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

Population

"2,889"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:26

Median household income

"$24,770"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:26

Median home cost

"$174,300"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:57

The reviews

2.8 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“A small town of 3,500 at 2,000 feet on the Cumberland Plateau with mild summers; it is extending water and sewer service, needs businesses and jobs, and is more of a bedroom community.”
about 0:07:17

4 stars

“A small town where most everyone is nice, though as with all towns there are areas and people to avoid; there is not a lot to do but it is peaceful and comfortable.”
about 0:07:52

2 stars

“The reviewer's home area has gradually decayed with drug use and apathy towards education, and they plan to move once they finish their education.”
about 0:08:09

2 stars

“Not a lot to do but peaceful and quiet, with a close-knit community sceptical of outsiders; the new train museum is nice but only takes 40 minutes.”
about 0:08:29

1 star

“Places are not clean or sanitary looking, business organisation is sloppy and customer service is not a priority because customers have to shop there.”
about 0:09:07

In Tennessee

Closest episodes

  1. Lust, Unexplained Wounds & Weak ExcusesGainesboro, Tennessee · 13 September 201842 km / 26 miShow on map
  2. It's About The OpportunitiesWhitley City, Kentucky · 16 May 201995 km / 59 miShow on map
  3. Murder Breadcrumb TrailTullahoma, Tennessee · 9 April 2026122 km / 76 miShow on map
  4. Dirty Desires In The BackwoodsTellico Plains, Tennessee · 3 March 2022123 km / 76 miShow on map
  5. You Want One Of Her Bones?Whiteside, Tennessee · 4 February 2021129 km / 80 miShow on map

The story

In May 2009 the small town of Monterey, Tennessee, on the Cumberland Plateau between Nashville and Knoxville, was the setting for a family quarrel that turned into a double murder and arson. Vita Clark lived at Hasler Road with her youngest son, Roy Clark. Susan said he had stopped taking his medication as prescribed, that his personality changed, and that a doctor then switched him to what she called the opposite of what he had been taking, which really messed with him.

On 12 May 2009 Susan came home from work at about 5.30 p.m. to find a new fence with yellow bags on it across the only driveway to the house. She said the sight made her physically ill and that she had to drive up a field, nearly damaging her car. There she overheard Vita, Roy and Sharon Miller whispering, snickering and laughing. At nine o'clock she woke him as usual and told him. He said she was kidding, looked out, and called Jerry. Jerry told him to finish the second driveway he had started and avoid trouble. He told Susan he could not worry about it now because he had to go to work.

At the plant he complained to a co-worker, William 'Billy Tim' Brockett, about the fence and said that if it was still up when he got home he would kill his brother. Brockett thought he was blowing off steam and gave him the name of an attorney.

Vita called 911 and said her son had come to her house at Hasler Road and shot both of them, and that her arm was almost blown off. Neighbours called 911 too. Paul Walker had been woken by gunshots at about 6.30 or 7 a.m.; Jewel Bell Melton saw smoke and said the house had blowed up or something. Jerry Clark drove over, saw his mother lying wounded in the driveway and the house in flames, and left without helping her. Overton County sheriff's deputies arrived, found Vita's body three or four feet from the burning house and dragged it away. He told them to fall back. Sergeant Robert Garrett heard what sounded like .22-calibre shots and then a larger boom; Deputy Derrick Ledbetter was hit in the shoulder, but his vest saved him.

They recovered a Ruger .22 and a Winchester pump-action 12-gauge shotgun. Shells and a slug were in his pocket, and his boots and clothing carried gunshot residue. A fire investigator, Agent Greg Whitaker of the Tennessee Bomb and Arson unit, found an unusual burn pattern, gasoline in jars and foam materials, and ruled the fire incendiary. Roy Clark's body was in the kitchen. The autopsy showed he had been shot in the back with a shotgun and was dead before the fire; his feet had burned off and part of his skull was gone. Vita had at least two shotgun wounds and burns. One blast to the back of her neck severed her spinal cord and left vertebral artery and knocked out teeth. The doctor said she could not have spoken after that wound, so she must have made the 911 call before the neck shot.

Every witness he asked to be subpoenaed refused to help him. The district attorney said he faced a minimum of 51 calendar years for first-degree murder in one case.

The case

Murders of Vita Clark and Roy Clark

Victims

Vita Clark. mother, who lived with her youngest son Roy
Roy Clark. younger brother, who lived with their mother

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 4 March 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Susan Beth Clark. wife, who found the fence, overheard the family in the back field and called Jerry and the pastor
Michael Hartung. former brother-in-law, who helped build house and said threatened him
William 'Billy Tim' Brockett. co-worker at the Perdue Farms plant
Robert Garrett. Overton County sheriff's sergeant who approached the house
Derrick Ledbetter. deputy shot in the shoulder, saved by his ballistic vest
John Mackie. deputy at the scene
Jewel Bell Melton. neighbour who called 911 after seeing smoke
Paul Walker. neighbour awakened by gunshots
Sharon Miller. person in the back field with Vita and Roy
Dr. Deering. doctor who performed the autopsies
Greg Whitaker. Tennessee Bomb and Arson investigator

The timeline

  1. May 12, 2009 Susan Clark comes home from work at about 5:30 p.m. to find a new fence with yellow bags across the only driveway to the house (Fence across the driveway)about 0:20:17
  2. May 12, 2009 Susan goes to the back field to scrape out scrap food and overhears Vita, Roy and Sharon Miller whispering and laughing (Back field)about 0:25:21
  3. May 12, 2009 At nine o'clock Susan wakes for his shift and tells him about the fence ('s house)about 0:28:16
  4. May 12, 2009 calls Jerry, who suggests finishing the second driveway; says he will hire a lawyer, then says he will take care of it himself ('s house)about 0:28:47
  5. the night of May 12, 2009 At work tells Billy Tim Brockett that if the fence is still up when he gets home he will kill his brother (Perdue Farms chicken processing plant)about 0:33:11
  6. May 13, 2009 leaves his shift before 5 a.m. (Perdue Farms chicken processing plant)about 0:35:43
  7. May 13, 2009 shoots his mother and brother at Hasler Road and sets their house on fire (Vita Clark's house)about 0:54:00
  8. May 13, 2009 At about 6:35 a.m. calls Susan and says it has been took care of, that he called the fire and police departments and that they are not going to take him aliveabout 0:37:09
  9. May 13, 2009 Vita Clark calls 911 and says her son came to her residence and shot both of them, and that her arm is about blowed off (Vita Clark's house)about 0:40:09

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode