FILE 340 / 26 November 2022 / 68 MIN / express

The Dorm Room Surprise

Booneville, MississippiListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Boonville, Mississippi, way up in the northeastern corner, about two hours to Memphis. about 0:03:48

History, in brief

Town note

The land was bought by B.B. Boon, a descendant of Colonel Ruben Holman Boon, who was said to be a relative of Daniel Boone.

about 0:05:21

Town note

The town was originally planned as a town beside the railroad and grew rapidly.

about 0:06:08

1861

It incorporated in 1861, just as the Civil War began, which slowed everything down.

about 0:06:15

Town note

Civil War armies advanced and retreated through the area; there were no battles, but there was a lot of burning and raiding.

about 0:06:24
All 7 history facts

Town note

The land was bought by B.B. Boon, a descendant of Colonel Ruben Holman Boon, who was said to be a relative of Daniel Boone.

about 0:05:21

Town note

The town was originally planned as a town beside the railroad and grew rapidly.

about 0:06:08

1861

It incorporated in 1861, just as the Civil War began, which slowed everything down.

about 0:06:15

Town note

Civil War armies advanced and retreated through the area; there were no battles, but there was a lot of burning and raiding.

about 0:06:24

Town note

Boonville is home to Northeast Mississippi Community College, a junior college and the tenth largest community college by enrollment in the state.

about 0:07:07

Town note

Boonville is one of 21 certified Mississippi retirement cities.

about 0:07:20

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$97,000
Median household income$28,594
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"8,400"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:28

College students

"about half the population"

Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:28

Community college enrollment

"tenth largest in the state"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:07:15

Median household income

"$28,594"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:56

Median home cost

"$97,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:05:01

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“A friendly town, but it is a college town that considers itself a retirement community and needs more things for students to do.”
about 0:07:45

5 stars

“The only problem is the 5,628 Karens; the reviewer loves it otherwise, but his wife will not let him come back because they were mugged and shot at in a five-minute period, and turkey hunters are warned off.”
about 0:08:00

1 star

“Meth and pill enthusiasts as far as the eye can see, not a cop who cares, locals mind your business for you, the town is proud of its football team and fast food, so just keep driving.”
about 0:09:16

1 star

“The sense of community is lost, people are not trusting or friendly, men yell at women and rev their engines, and the women range from fresh out of church to extremely trashy.”
about 0:10:08

In Mississippi

Closest episodes

  1. Four Letter MurderFalkner, Mississippi · 12 April 202540 km / 25 miShow on map
  2. The Cookie MonsterWalnut, Mississippi · 26 September 201945 km / 28 miShow on map
  3. My Ugly Came OutSelmer, Tennessee · 27 November 202556 km / 35 miShow on map
  4. Bush Blade In The Hog BucketParsons, Tennessee · 4 September 2026117 km / 73 miShow on map
  5. Fat Sam & Crazy CrystalLawrenceburg, Tennessee · 28 September 2023130 km / 81 miShow on map

The story

In the autumn of 1985 Stacy Diane Pannell, eighteen, arrived at Northeast Mississippi State College in Boonville, Mississippi, on a band and drill team scholarship. She had graduated fourth in a class of eighty-three at Ripley High and had been crowned fairest of the fair in Tippah County in 1982. She chose the junior college to stay near her father, Wiki Pannell, a Vietnam veteran being treated for a brain tumour, and because band members had to live on campus she moved into Murphy Hall, a dormitory of 136 girls.

On Monday October 7 she went to classes and band practice, played an intramural softball game in which she hurt her knee, ate pizza with friends and returned to the dorm about 11:15 that night, drunk and limping. She woke around 12:30 as Pannell and other girls came home, and later went next door to talk.

She locked the hall door, washed her hands and placed a pillow over Pannell's head. She cut the window screen with a steak knife, pulled Pannell's underwear down to suggest rape, wiped the rifle and wrapped its barrel in a towel, then burned the cut screen and her T-shirt, flushed the debris and sprayed Amy Wheeler's perfume to hide the smoke.

In the dim light she saw Pannell's skin and blood on the pillow, with her underwear pulled down, and ran for help. Police found Pannell on her back, one leg on the floor, naked from the waist down and a pillow over her head, with severe injuries to the left side of her head and blood spatter up to nine feet away. Her jewellery and money were untouched. A bloodstained wooden drill rifle with a towel around the barrel lay on the floor, and an eight- to ten-inch section had been cut out of the window screen.

The case went cold. Fifteen investigators worked it, more than 400 students were interviewed and the FBI produced a profile, but there were no usable fingerprints and no leads beyond a local sex offender and a jealous college boyfriend who failed a lie detector question. Nearly a year on, the family considered a private detective and even a psychic. In 1987 Steve Rhodes, police chief of East Hazel Crest, Illinois, and a lecturer in neurolinguistic programming, was brought in.

She also wrote an eleven-page letter to Randy Price, a boyfriend of a week, describing the killing. The defence argued that she was too small to inflict the wounds and that she had been in a hypnotic trance since being hypnotised a year earlier.

The case

Murder of Stacy Pannell

Victims

Stacy Diane Pannell (18). freshman on a band and drill team scholarship; graduated fourth in a class of 83 at Ripley High

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 26 November 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Amy Wheeler. Pannell's roommate, who found the body and raised the alarm
Belinda Posey. student who went in to check on Pannell
Edna Snyder. dorm mother who fetched a security guard
Bobby Lambert. Boonville police chief
Julia James. state crime scene specialist
Ricky Bishop. junior college band director
Steve Williams. criminal investigator for the Mississippi Highway Patrol
Steve Rhodes. police chief of East Hazel Crest, Illinois, brought in to interrogate
Tommy Osborne. student both women had been seeing
Wiki Pannell. Stacy's father, a Vietnam veteran with a brain tumour
Kim Pannell. Stacy's younger sister
Bradley Pannell. Stacy's younger brother, then 11

The timeline

  1. 1982 Stacy Pannell is crowned fairest of the fair in Tippah County (Tippah County)about 0:35:06
  2. the fall of 1985 Pannell enrols at Northeast Mississippi State College on a band and drill team scholarship and moves into Murphy Hall (Northeast Mississippi State College)about 0:25:06
  3. October 7, 1985 Pannell attends classes and band practice, then plays an intramural softball game and hurts her knee (Northeast Mississippi State College)about 0:26:39
  4. October 7, 1985 She has pizza with friends and returns to the dorm about 11:15 p.m. (Murphy Hall)about 0:27:53
  5. between 9 and 10.30 p.m., October 7, 1985 takes three codeine tablets for an ovarian infection and dozes off over her homework (Murphy Hall)about 0:53:52
  6. about 12:15 a.m., October 8, 1985 Pannell is last seen in the dorm hallway, drunk and limping from her bad knee (Murphy Hall)about 0:26:02
  7. about 12:30 a.m., October 8, 1985 wakes and hears Pannell and other girls returning to the adjoining room (Murphy Hall)about 0:54:21
  8. shortly after 12:30 a.m. goes into Pannell's room to talk and they argue about Tommy Osborne (Stacy Pannell's dorm room)about 0:55:20
  9. same night Pannell slaps , threatens to kill her and grabs her by the throat (Stacy Pannell's dorm room)about 0:56:19
  10. same night kicks free, picks up Pannell's wooden drill rifle and beats her about the head with it (Stacy Pannell's dorm room)about 0:57:42
  11. same night locks the hall door, washes her hands and places a pillow over Pannell's head (Stacy Pannell's dorm room)about 0:58:29
  12. same night She cuts the window screen with a steak knife and pulls Pannell's underwear down to suggest rape (Stacy Pannell's dorm room)about 0:58:44
  13. same night She wipes the rifle, wraps its barrel in a towel, burns the cut screen and her T-shirt, flushes the debris and sprays perfume around the room (Stacy Pannell's dorm room)about 0:59:08
  14. 2:30 a.m., October 8, 1985 Amy Wheeler returns, finds herself locked out and goes through room and the shared bathroom into her own room (Murphy Hall)about 0:12:57
  15. 2:30 a.m., October 8, 1985 Wheeler finds Pannell bloodied on the bed with her underwear pulled down and runs into the hallway screaming (Stacy Pannell's dorm room)about 0:16:43
  16. shortly afterwards Belinda Posey finds the door locked again; Edna Snyder fetches a security guard to open it (Murphy Hall)about 0:18:13
  17. October 8, 1985 Police find Pannell dead with a pillow over her head, a bloodied drill rifle on the floor and a section cut out of the window screen (Stacy Pannell's dorm room)about 0:20:05

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode