FILE 413 / 10 August 2023 / 176 MIN / full

Judging The Devil By His Horns

Pittsfield, MassachusettsListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Pittsfield here it's in western Massachusetts, north western Massachusetts... So this is in Berkshire County, area code 413. about 0:06:15

History, in brief

Town note

The city motto is 'Benigno Lumine', which James says is Latin for benign power.

about 0:06:19

Town note

The city website calls Pittsfield 'the heart of the Berkshires'.

about 0:06:39

1902

On September 3rd, 1902, at 10.15 a.m., a congressman campaigning with President Theodore Roosevelt collided head-on with a trolley while travelling from downtown Pittsfield to the Pittsfield Country Club.

about 0:07:02

Town note

Roosevelt's bodyguard William Craig was killed, the first Secret Service agent killed while on a presidential protection detail.

about 0:08:45
All 11 history facts

Town note

The city motto is 'Benigno Lumine', which James says is Latin for benign power.

about 0:06:19

Town note

The city website calls Pittsfield 'the heart of the Berkshires'.

about 0:06:39

1902

On September 3rd, 1902, at 10.15 a.m., a congressman campaigning with President Theodore Roosevelt collided head-on with a trolley while travelling from downtown Pittsfield to the Pittsfield Country Club.

about 0:07:02

Town note

Roosevelt's bodyguard William Craig was killed, the first Secret Service agent killed while on a presidential protection detail.

about 0:08:45

Town note

The trolley driver, Euclid Madden, was charged with manslaughter, pleaded guilty and served six months in jail.

about 0:08:52

1791

A historian found a 1791 law prohibiting anyone from playing baseball within eighty yards of the new meeting house in Pittsfield, which James calls the earliest reference to baseball in the United States.

about 0:10:16

Town note

Emily Robison of the Dixie Chicks is from Pittsfield.

about 0:11:09

Town note

Brian Piccolo, the Chicago Bear of Brian's Song, is from Pittsfield.

about 0:11:30

Town note

Herman Melville wrote Moby Dick while he was living in Pittsfield.

about 0:11:43

Town note

Robin Williams had a summer house in Pittsfield.

about 0:11:57

The figures, as told

Religious

about 50-50

Biggest faith: Catholic, 38.3%

about 0:18:49

Who lives here

White 84.4% · Black 4.4% · Asian 2% · Hispanic 6%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ slightly above average

about 0:25:03

Violent crime
▲ a little bit high

about 0:25:09

Money

Median home value$263,800
Two-bedroom rent$1,480
Median household income$43,489
Cost of living88

For sale

$399,000

Five-bedroom, four-bath house listing

about 0:22:15

For sale

$1,685,000

Six-bedroom, six-bath mansion listing

about 0:22:59
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

Population

"43,890"

Comparison: "top end of where the show usually goes". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:41

Median age

"44 and a half"

Comparison: "slightly above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:54

Voted Democrat

"72.4%"

Comparison: "last election in Berkshire County". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:19:30

Voted Republican

"25.3%"

Comparison: "last election in Berkshire County". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:19:30

Voted independent

"2.3%"

Comparison: "last election in Berkshire County". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:19:30

Religious

"about 50-50"

Comparison: "national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:18:49

Median household income

"$43,489"

Comparison: "national average $54,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:19:55

Cost of living

"88"

Comparison: "100 average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:20:04

Median home cost

"$263,800"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:20:04

Average two-bedroom rent

"$1,480"

Comparison: "above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:20:48

Two-bedroom trailer listing

"$54,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:21:45

Five-bedroom, four-bath house listing

"$399,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:22:15

Six-bedroom, six-bath mansion listing

"$1,685,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:22:59

Property crime

"slightly above average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:25:03

Violent crime

"a little bit high"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:25:09

The reviews

2.4 / 5 · average of 7

4 stars

“Your typical town has everything your childhood town should, with schools all the way to high school and good out-of-district transport.”
about 0:12:31

4 stars

“Low crime incidents, I feel safe.”
about 0:13:16

3 stars

“Pittsfield is a weird place, like the weird aunt no one wants to bring to Thanksgiving but who is still part of the Berkshire family.”
about 0:13:37

2 stars

“The police department is having to buff itself up after a recent rise in shootings, and there is too much crime for the number of officers, including a gunman who entered the local hospital.”
about 0:14:03

2 stars

“All that is left are retail jobs for someone who will have a degree for an essentially academic job, such as anthropology.”
about 0:15:49

1 star

“Don't listen to fake statistics; the crime per capita is well above the state average and it is not a good place to raise a family, it is a good place to leave.”
about 0:16:30

1 star

“Some nice bars, but the people who tend to go to those bars are not so nice.”
about 0:17:12

In Massachusetts

Closest episodes

  1. The Devil Whispers In My EarNorth Adams, Massachusetts · 7 April 202227 km / 17 miShow on map
  2. The Bear King KillsHillsdale, New York · 19 August 202133 km / 21 miShow on map
  3. "Serial Killer" Doesn't Even Describe ItNorthampton, Massachusetts · 21 February 201850 km / 31 miShow on map
  4. The Ax Murder ZombieDelmar, New York · 10 September 202651 km / 32 miShow on map
  5. Michael Myers Is My IdolGreenfield, Massachusetts · 11 February 202357 km / 35 miShow on map

The story

Pittsfield, Massachusetts, is a town of about 43,900 people in Berkshire County, in the north-western corner of the state, roughly two and a half hours from Boston. In August 2011 three men disappeared from a first-floor apartment there, and their dismembered bodies were later dug out of a grave in Beckett.

The two sparred in the living room for about fifteen minutes, and when Ryser asked to stop, everyone else in the room set on him. They beat him with fists, feet and a wooden board with nails in it for three to five hours. He blacked out and woke covered in blood. The next day he was in too much pain to eat, and when he got home his mother flipped out. He told doctors and police he had been jumped at the Pittsfield Common. He had a punctured lung, a broken arm, severe head trauma and bruises over 75 per cent of his body.

A spark from the water heater set off a flash fire. Ryser faded into obscurity.

David er, 44, a handyman with mental and physical difficulties and diabetes, did odd jobs for him in exchange for cocaine. er went to Berkshire Medical Center and then to the police barracks, where he asked whether the state police had a witness protection programme. He was told to call if anything else happened.

Nicole Brooks, one of his s, told New York police that er had robbed her at gunpoint and shot at her. Scott Langdon, another friend, got er to drive him to Wells and planted the gun and Brooks's wallet in the truck.

er was terrified. He asked the district attorney's office for protection, and his friends said later that he was told nothing could be done until something happened. The office said it offered to relocate him twice and that he chose to stay in his apartment, and that he never asked again once the case was under way.

The victim needed 32 stitches.

On 27th August 2011 tropical storm Irene dumped rain on the area. er, his roommate Edward Frampton, 58, and their friend Robert Chadwell, 47, stayed in the apartment. A neighbour asked er to move his truck sometime after 10 p.m., and Chadwell spoke to his boyfriend at about 11.20 p.m. That was the last anyone heard from them. Shortly after midnight the upstairs neighbour heard banging on the door.

At 5.30 a.m. he was at a convenience store buying sweets, cigars and cigarettes with wet cash, his boots and jeans soaked and mud on his shirt. He said his gun misfired, that er ran into the woods, that one of the others shot him and brought him back, that er begged for his life, and that he then shot him and the three were dismembered and gutted in the rain.

That evening the Buick, holding the remains in plastic bags, was left at a property in Beckett. The three men were reported missing on the Monday; Frampton's case worker had found the apartment empty, the television on, his medication and wallet left behind and a cushion on the floor. The calendar stopped at Saturday 27th August.

The bodies were found on 7th September 2011 and dug up on 9th and 10th September. The prosecution described the torture, the stabbing, the shooting and er being made to watch his friends die, and the defence said there was no physical evidence and that the witnesses were hoping for leniency.

The case

Murders of David er, Edward Frampton and Robert Chadwell

Victims

David er (44). handyman with mental and physical difficulties and diabetes; the intended target and a key witness against
Edward Frampton (58). er's roommate, mildly mentally cenged, a Special Olympics basketball player and disability advocate
Robert Chadwell (47). their friend, a former counsellor for adolescents with drug and alcohol problems

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 10 August 2023.

Accused

Accused

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Alexandra Eli. and the mother of one of his children; helped in the frame-up
Scott Langdon. friend, who planted the gun and Brooks's wallet in er's truck
Leslie Chadwell. Robert Chadwell's brother, who reported him missing
Willie Haywood Jr.. Robert Chadwell's boyfriend, who last spoke to him at about 11.20 p.m.
Andrew Johnston. friend of Robert Chadwell
Donna Randoff. er's friend, whom he called mom
Aaron Forebush. Frampton's disability case worker, who found the apartment empty
Rose Dawson. , whose phone he borrowed at 1.30 a.m.
Karen Sutton. woman later told about arriving at the apartment
Stephen Hinman. friend in Lenox to whom showed his firearms
Daniel Col. owner of the Beckett property where the bodies were buried
Capeless. Berkshire District Attorney

The timeline

  1. July 21st, 2009 beats David er with a wooden baseball bat at his property on Route 143 in Peru over a carburettor and forces him to sign over his truck. (Route 143 property)about 0:52:14
  2. July 23rd, 2009 is taken into custody in Pittsfield by the Berkshire County Drug Task Force.about 0:56:25
  3. July 2009 is arraigned at Central Berkshire District Court on armed robbery, assault and battery with a dangerous weapon, witness intimidation, extortion and kidnapping, and held without bail for up to 90 days. (Central Berkshire District Court)about 0:57:15
  4. August 2010 arranges for Nicole Brooks to accuse er of robbing and shooting at her, and fires three rounds into a tree in rural upstate New York to support the story.about 0:59:36
  5. August 14th, 2010 Scott Langdon, at direction, gets er to drive him to Wells and plants a gun and Brooks's wallet in the truck. (Wells)about 2:28:43
  6. August 27th, 2011 Tropical storm Irene hits the area and er, Frampton and Chadwell stay in the apartment. (er and Frampton apartment)about 1:06:32
  7. August 27th, 2011 An upstairs neighbour asks er to move his truck after 10 p.m.; the three men are last seen outside doing it. (er and Frampton apartment)about 1:58:22
  8. August 27th, 2011 Chadwell speaks to Willie Haywood Jr. at about 11.20 p.m., the last time any of the three is heard from. (er and Frampton apartment)about 1:58:32
  9. August 28th, 2011 Shortly after midnight a neighbour hears banging on er's front door; , and have arrived. (er and Frampton apartment)about 1:58:38
  10. August 28th, 2011 At about 1.30 a.m. borrows Rose Dawson's phone and later tells her to delete the calls. (Sutton residence)about 1:59:45
  11. August 28th, 2011 At about 5.30 a.m. buys three candy bars, Black and Mild cigars and Marlboro cigarettes with wet cash, his boots and jeans soaked and mud on his shirt. (convenience store)about 2:00:17
  12. August 28th, 2011 tells in Canaan, New York that he killed er and two other men, describing the misfire, the chase into the woods and the dismemberment. ( home)about 2:04:00

Beating of Kevin Ryser

Victims

Kevin Ryser (18). beaten for three to five hours; punctured lung, broken arm, severe head trauma and bruises over 75% of his body

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 10 August 2023.

Accused

Accused

Accused

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

The timeline

  1. October 7th, 1980 Diana Sue uses a petrol-soaked rag to remove roofing tar from her four and two-year-old children; a spark from the water heater sets off a flash fire that dests the home. ( home)about 0:39:58
  2. October 1980 Mary , aged two, dies fifteen days after suffering third-degree burns over 100% of her body; , aged four, survives with burns over 85%. ( home)about 0:41:57

Assault of a 16-year-old girl in Maine

Victims

Unnamed 16-year-old girl (16). lured into a motel room and slashed across the back with a razor blade; needed 32 stitches

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 10 August 2023.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

The timeline

  1. 1999 , 19, and his 16-year-old lure a 16-year-old girl into a motel room in Maine, where the slashes her back with a razor blade and the two lick the blood and kiss.about 1:31:54
  2. 1999 The victim needs 32 stitches to close the wound.about 1:33:36
  3. 2008 He legally changes his name to .about 1:28:15
  4. July 8th, 2010 He is discharged from probation.about 1:42:33
  5. 2010 After his release he has facial tattoos, 666 on his forehead, horn implants, pointed ears, sharpened teeth and a split tongue.about 1:43:00

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

er and Frampton apartment

crime scene

about 1:04:13

Heard in this episode