Town note
The town came into existence when the Southern Pacific and Houston-Shreveport railroads met on land owned by the Keith brothers in the 1880s.
about 0:04:33Spoilers are covered until your reading preferences load.
FILE 518 / 10 August 2024 / 75 MIN / express
We are going to Keithville, Louisiana... this is outside of Shreveport; the reviews are for the whole parish, Caddo Parish about 0:03:15
The town came into existence when the Southern Pacific and Houston-Shreveport railroads met on land owned by the Keith brothers in the 1880s.
about 0:04:33One of the Keith brothers, Perry Polk Keith, served four terms as a state representative.
about 0:04:52The Keith brothers donated land for the construction of the Keithville United Methodist Church.
about 0:05:00The town came into existence when the Southern Pacific and Houston-Shreveport railroads met on land owned by the Keith brothers in the 1880s.
about 0:04:33One of the Keith brothers, Perry Polk Keith, served four terms as a state representative.
about 0:04:52The Keith brothers donated land for the construction of the Keithville United Methodist Church.
about 0:05:00Suicide by gun
about 150% more likely
"11,727"
No direction stated.
As told in 2024 about 0:03:58
"about $50,000"
Comparison: "national average of $69,000". No direction stated.
As told in 2024 about 0:04:12
"$175,500"
Comparison: "way below the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2024 about 0:04:19
"$170,000"
No direction stated.
As told in 2024 about 0:24:41
"about 150% more likely"
Comparison: "people who own guns". No direction stated.
As told in 2024 about 0:13:01
3.4 / 5 · average of 5
“There is a sheriff's station nearby and, because of the close proximity to the high school, a constant police presence.”about 0:05:40
“It is not any worse than where I used to live and I am satisfied with the area.”about 0:05:54
“The neighbourhood in Keithville is really safe, but there are places in Shreveport that are not safe at all.”about 0:06:10
“Not sure what most people are doing other than running errands, sitting in a stuffy office all day or waiting for the rest of the world to get out of the way.”about 0:06:27
“I like an international flavour and a cosmopolitan atmosphere; there isn't one here.”about 0:07:13
Ernest Luttrell was born on September 11th, 1936. He served as a paratrooper in the Korean War, worked for the Borden dairy company for decades and retired about ten years before his death. After retiring he built a log cabin himself on a small farm on State Highway 169 in Keithville, in Caddo Parish, and raised hay. Each had a child from an earlier relationship.
In the 2000s Ernest sold the mineral rights under his 60-acre farm for $400,000, bought a $300,000 annuity in both their names and placed the rest in certificates of deposit.
In 2009 both were tested for dementia. Ernest declined to prosecute and set up a repayment plan instead.
Ernest was taken to hospital and committed to the psychiatric ward. The joint accounts were closed and $24,535.69 was moved, leaving Ernest $397.37.
They drove around and she offered him $1,000 to kill her boss's husband. They went to a motel, ordered pizza, drank, took pills and had sex, and she gave him a snub-nosed .44 magnum, telling him it had to be done the next morning.
Firefighters arrived first and withdrew; deputies Robert Chatman and Mike King swept the house. Ernest had been shot in the left eye, stomach and hip. The gun cabinet had been ransacked and an empty Smith & Wesson .44 registered to Ernest was found. A distinctive bloody bootprint was recovered.
The truck was found within walking distance and his boots matched the bloody print.
A search of her house found a handwritten map of the Luttrell home with details not made public.
In the end, the episode says, Ernest's sister Mildred kept everything.
July 25, 2010 / his home on State Highway 169, Keithville, Louisiana
As told in the episode, on 10 August 2024.
Accused
Accused
Accused
Accused
Public places are marked on the map.
crime scene
about 0:11:43other
about 0:21:47church
about 0:05:00church
about 0:45:31business
about 0:33:33business
about 0:39:43business
about 0:41:46business
about 0:45:12home
about 0:57:28hospital
about 0:32:30hospital
about 1:08:04police
about 0:12:11