FILE 523 / 29 August 2024 / 165 MIN / full

Beauty And The Beast

Marion, IndianaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

The case takes place at addresses in La Fontaine, but La Fontaine is counted as part of Marion, so we're gonna use Marion; this is in east central Indiana, Grant County. about 0:05:11

History, in brief

1831

Grant County was formed in 1831 and is not named after Ulysses S. Grant.

about 0:05:55

Town note

A nearby river supplied water, power and drainage.

about 0:06:12

Town note

Marion is named after Francis Marion, a Revolutionary War general known as the Swamp Fox of South Carolina.

about 0:06:18
All 13 history facts

1831

Grant County was formed in 1831 and is not named after Ulysses S. Grant.

about 0:05:55

Town note

A nearby river supplied water, power and drainage.

about 0:06:12

Town note

Marion is named after Francis Marion, a Revolutionary War general known as the Swamp Fox of South Carolina.

about 0:06:18

1955

The town's prosperity peaked between the First World War and 1955, driven by a natural gas boom.

about 0:07:25

Town note

A General Motors stamping and tool plant created many jobs and helped the town grow.

about 0:07:32

Town note

The Marion Giants, eight-time state basketball champions, are the reason for the City of Champions motto.

about 0:07:42

Town note

The Marion Giants play in a 7,500-seat arena.

about 0:08:00

1926

The Giants' previous home was built after their first state basketball title in 1926.

about 0:08:18

Town note

The Hostess House is a large mansion that can be rented for social functions.

about 0:08:48

Town note

Jim Davis, the creator of Garfield, is from Marion.

about 0:08:48

Town note

Julia Roberts and Lyle Lovett were married in Marion.

about 0:09:16

The figures, as told

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ more than one third above the national average

about 0:23:21

Violent crime
right at average

about 0:23:35

Money

Median home value$103,900
Two-bedroom rent$780
Median household income$37,835 a year
Cost of living68

For sale

$234,000

Three-bedroom mixed-use building listing

about 0:18:26

For sale

$350,000

Four-bedroom house on three acres listing

about 0:18:52
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Property crime

"more than one third above the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:23:21

Violent crime

"right at average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2024 about 0:23:35

Population

"27,757"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:13

Female share

"54%"

Comparison: "about the highest the hosts have seen". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:29

Median age

"36"

Comparison: "normal". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:34

Married

"32%"

Comparison: "low marriage rate because of the college". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:42

Single with children

"27%"

Comparison: "usually 10%". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:44

Unemployment rate

"a little above the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:13:52

Median household income

"$37,835 a year"

Comparison: "a little more than half the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:06

Cost of living index

"68"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:18

Housing index

"29 out of 100"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:25

Median home cost

"$103,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:14:29

Average two-bedroom rent

"$780"

Comparison: "about $500 below the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:15:55

Four-bedroom home listing

"$13,000"

Comparison: "in need of total renovation". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:17:19

Three-bedroom mixed-use building listing

"$234,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:18:26

Four-bedroom house on three acres listing

"$350,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:18:52

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“Police patrol the neighbourhood every night, which makes the reviewer feel safe, and the officers are helpful when keys are locked in a car.”
about 0:09:41

4 stars

“Marion is not the worst place in Indiana to live; it sits between Indianapolis and Fort Wayne, so people go to one of those for entertainment.”
about 0:10:05

3 stars

“Parts of town are falling apart, once beautiful homes and buildings are overgrown, and drug addicts are visible in public places; the reviewer wants rehabilitation rather than more jail.”
about 0:11:03

2 stars

“Marion was better when factory jobs were there; small businesses struggle, there is little entertainment beyond Walmart, and the town is in the opioid crisis, though Indiana Wesleyan University and the city park garden are nice.”
about 0:11:43

1 star

“Marion is a scary place with a very high crime rate, and the reviewer notes it was the last town to hold a public hanging.”
about 0:12:44

In Indiana

Closest episodes

  1. Cold Blooded, Not Blue BloodedPeru, Indiana · 19 December 201842 km / 26 miShow on map
  2. Guilty Google Search MurderWinchester, Indiana · 25 September 202672 km / 45 miShow on map
  3. The Oatmeal KillerCarmel, Indiana · 13 April 202477 km / 48 miShow on map
  4. Death In The FamilyWilliamsburg, Indiana · 6 December 202587 km / 54 miShow on map
  5. The Head Of The SerpentLafayette, Indiana · 29 October 2020103 km / 64 miShow on map

The story

Lisa Young was born on 16 November 1972 in Philadelphia, the middle of three daughters of Jerry and Lucille Young. The family later moved, and she graduated from high school in Farrells Hills, Pennsylvania, in 1990 before attending the Philadelphia Art Institute. She had her son, Dylan McCoy, in 1991, while she was still in college, and raised him largely on her own. She moved to Indiana for work, lived for a time in Swayzee and went back to college to study marketing. She worked at the JC Penney in the Five Points Mall in Marion while she studied, and later became marketing and sales director at WXXC Radio and then marketing director of the mall itself. Friends described her as relentlessly cheerful, loyal and busy, a member of the Ambassadors Club of Marion, the Grant County Chamber of Commerce and the Marion Rotary Club, and a regular at the Treaty Church of Christ.

Patterson, born in November 1969, was a fitness enthusiast who owned a roofing company and, by his own account, worked as a Jean-Claude Van Dam lookalike. He gave her a business card. They married on 24 August 1996 in an extravagant Beauty and the Beast themed wedding at which Patterson dressed as the Beast. Around 1999 or 2000 they moved into a four-bedroom, three-bathroom, 4,700 square foot house at 5581 East 800 S in La Fontaine, Indiana. Dylan eventually called Patterson Dad, but Lisa's family never warmed to him. They found him self-centred and harsh with Dylan, and her sister doubted that he loved Lisa as she deserved.

Patterson began an affair around 2006 or 2007 with Stacy Henderson, a well-known local woman who had been chief of staff to Marion's mayor, Wayne Seabold, and whose husband was a police officer. Lisa discovered it in 2008. Patterson apologised and said it was over, but the affair resumed about three months later. In November 2008 he asked a real estate appraiser, Marie Lloyd, to value the house without telling his wife, saying he did not know whether he could afford a divorce. That winter Dylan saw Patterson shove Lisa during an argument, the only time he saw him put hands on her. On 31 December 2008 a sheriff's deputy was called to the house over a civil dispute about property and took Dylan to a friend's house for the night.

In February 2009 Patterson told Lisa's friend Lea Fraser that he would not give Lisa 50 per cent of his business, and he telephoned Lisa's mother, Lucille, to say that Lisa no longer trusted him and that he wanted her and Dylan out of the house. Lucille told him he was free to leave; he hung up. On 20 March 2009 he filed for divorce. Lisa hired a lawyer and obtained a continuance; Patterson obtained another, pushing the hearing to 7 August. The family did not know the hearing had been postponed. On 20 June Lisa visited her sister Christine in Virginia and, with Christine acting as her financial adviser, changed her $450,000 life insurance policy so that Dylan was the sole beneficiary instead of an even split with Patterson. By late June the wedding photographs were down and the house was for sale. Patterson told Stacy Henderson the divorce was going through.

On the morning of 2 July 2009 Patterson said he left home before 5 a.m., went to the landfill and returned around 6.30 a.m. to collect Dylan and another employee for a roofing job in Swayzee. The prosecution later established from the home surveillance system that he came back to the house at 8.32 a.m., and that cameras recorded him entering and leaving at 9.56, 10.03, 10.07 and 11.38. His account to police was that he ran errands, returned around 11.30, could not find Lisa, went to the basement and found her under the weight bar of a Smith machine with 140 pounds on it. At 12.14 p.m. he called 911, said his wife had had an accident at home and asked for a police escort. An ambulance and police intercepted the truck, and Lisa arrived at Marion General Hospital at 12.44 p.m. She was pronounced dead at 12.49 p.m. She was 37.

The first reading was a freak accident. There was a bruise on her neck and an abrasion on her left shoulder, and Patterson had no scratches or defensive marks. The machine was a Smith machine with guide bars and hooks, and the two safety stoppers were not in place. A detective who lay on the bench found that the bar lined up with his neck rather than his chest. But the machine showed little wear and no mechanical fault, and the investigator could not make it fail.

The autopsy changed the picture. Lisa had bruising around her neck, cuts and scrapes on the bridge of her nose and left shoulder, and petechiae across her body. The cause of death was asphyxiation due to compression of the neck. Her larynx and voice box were compressed but not crushed, which the pathologist said was inconsistent with 140 pounds falling any distance; in his view the bar could not have fallen more than an inch or two. The petechiae were consistent with someone straddling her torso or with great weight pressing on it. He believed she died before 10 a.m., and that a healthy woman should have been able to escape the machine, which offered at least seven ways out. Dylan testified that he had seen his mother use the bench press only once, with Patterson spotting her, and that she otherwise used the treadmill and five-pound hand weights. A neck injury from an earlier car accident made heavy lifting difficult.

On 3 July Patterson telephoned Christine to ask about the insurance policy and was stunned to learn that Dylan was the sole beneficiary. The same day he texted Stacy Henderson asking whether her husband was trying to get closer to her now that he was free. He sought guardianship of Dylan, but a judge allowed Dylan, then a week and a half from turning eighteen, to choose where to live. Dylan moved to Virginia to live with an aunt and uncle and finished his senior year there.

On 15 July an employee of Koorsen, the company that installed the surveillance system, told police that the system recorded to an internal hard drive and that the DVD slot was only for copying. A search warrant produced footage showing Patterson home at 8.32 a.m. and around the house through the morning. His phone records placed calls near the house between 9.57 and 12.14, and he and Stacy Henderson exchanged 130 text messages that day, including a three-letter message sent while he waited for the ambulance.

The state argued motive, opportunity and lies, and relied on the surveillance timeline. Dylan testified; Stacy Henderson testified under immunity after admitting a false statement in her deposition. A tree and bench were dedicated to Lisa at the Five Points Mall on 17 July 2010, and a Dateline episode aired on 25 February 2011.

The case

Murder of Lisa Young Patterson

Victims

Lisa Young Patterson (37). marketing director at the Five Points Mall and mother of Dylan McCoy

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 29 August 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Dylan McCoy. Lisa's son, who testified against Patterson
Lucille. Lisa's mother
Jerry Young. Lisa's father, living in New Mexico
Christine. Lisa's older sister and financial adviser
Lea Fraser. Lisa's best friend, who worked at JC Penney
Marie Lloyd. real estate appraiser Patterson asked to value the house
Stanley Campbell. Patterson's defence attorney
Michael Davis. detective on the case
Dr. Gregory Davis. state medical examiner
Dr. Roger Fraser. Hartford City doctor who prescribed Lisa weight-loss pills
Leroy Striker. Wabash County sheriff
Wayne Seabold. Marion mayor

The timeline

  1. November 16th, 1972 Lisa Young is born to Jerry and Lucille Young (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania)about 0:23:44
  2. 1991 Lisa's son Dylan McCoy is bornabout 0:28:43
  3. 1995 Lisa meets on a rare night out with girlfriends (a bar in the Marion area)about 0:32:02
  4. August 24th, 1996 Lisa and marry in a Beauty and the Beast themed wedding (Marion, Indiana)about 0:37:02
  5. 1999 or 2000 The family moves into the house at 5581 East 800 S (Patterson house)about 0:48:17
  6. 2001 The Wabash County Sheriff's Department receives a report that was looking for someone to kill Lisa (Wabash County Sheriff's Department)about 1:38:17
  7. July 2002 Lisa begins seeing Dr. Roger Fraser for weight-loss pills; she visits twelve times before July 2009 (Dr. Roger Fraser's office)about 1:35:25
  8. 2006 or 2007 begins an affair with Stacy Henderson (Marion, Indiana)about 0:53:55
  9. 2008 Lisa discovers the affair; says it is over, but it resumes about three months later (Patterson house)about 0:55:45

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode