FILE 484 / 13 April 2024 / 71 MIN / express

The Oatmeal Killer

Carmel, IndianaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

"we are going to indiana here... we're going to carmel indiana... this is actually just in the northern suburbs of indianapolis" and "this is in hamilton county" about 0:02:43

History, in brief

Town note

Originally called Bethlehem; the original settlers were Quakers.

about 0:05:02

1846

Renamed Carmel in 1846 because there was already a Bethlehem post office in Indiana.

about 0:05:08

1924

One of the first automatic traffic signals in the U.S. was installed at an intersection off Main Street in 1924.

about 0:05:43
All 4 history facts

Town note

Originally called Bethlehem; the original settlers were Quakers.

about 0:05:02

1846

Renamed Carmel in 1846 because there was already a Bethlehem post office in Indiana.

about 0:05:08

1924

One of the first automatic traffic signals in the U.S. was installed at an intersection off Main Street in 1924.

about 0:05:43

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value493,000
Median household income119,772
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Population

"98,137"

Comparison: "about 25,000 to 30,000 in 2000". No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:03:47

Median household income

"119,772"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:22

Median home price

"493,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:22

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“A great place to own a house, but you will have to work in Indianapolis and commute for 40 minutes; Carmel is very safe even at night.”
about 0:06:30

3 stars

“Traffic is awful; a laid-back, low-maintenance person will not feel comfortable with the high pace, though people are nice and the schools are great.”
about 0:06:43

1 star

“Superficial and egotistical environment; a nice place to live but too competitive and materialistic, which brings people, especially teenagers, down.”
about 0:07:05

In Indiana

Closest episodes

  1. A Grossly Insane Tale Of DeathMarion, Indiana · 27 January 202277 km / 48 miShow on map
  2. Beauty And The BeastMarion, Indiana · 29 August 202477 km / 48 miShow on map
  3. The Head Of The SerpentLafayette, Indiana · 29 October 202078 km / 48 miShow on map
  4. Poison Pudding ProblemsColumbus, Indiana · 23 April 202686 km / 53 miShow on map
  5. Cold Blooded, Not Blue BloodedPeru, Indiana · 19 December 201888 km / 55 miShow on map

The story

Francis Kelly was 46 years old in 2019. Born in Cleveland, Ohio, he went to St Ignatius High School and Ohio State University and took a master's degree at Butler University in 2007. A hearing was set for 27 January 2021.

They refused.

He ate it, became ill and recovered, putting it down to the soup going cold.

On 27 October 2020 a man telephoned the Clark County Sheriff's Office in Ohio at 9.42 p.m. to say that a crime which could take a life was going to happen in Zionsville, Indiana. He promised to call back with her address and never did. The calls went to the wrong counties; the Carmel police in Hamilton County, where Kelly lived, were never told, and the administrative lines did not record caller ID.

On 15 January he sent his last texts, about custody, and was not heard from again.

That evening the two women drove to the house. He was breathing abnormally and gasping.

Kelly's ex, Courtney Nugent, the mother of his nine-year-old daughter, raised the alarm when he failed to collect the girl on her birthday. The Carmel police carried out a welfare check, knocked, got no answer and left. Nugent broke in on 18 January and found him dead on the couch; he had been dead for three days. The autopsy found blunt force trauma to the eye and head and gave the cause of death as asphyxia from strangulation and neck compression, with acute fentanyl intoxication a contributing factor.

The judge barred her from contact with Kelly's two children, including her own daughter.

The case

Murder of Francis Kelly

Victims

Francis Kelly (46). Father of young daughter, fighting her in court for custody and parenting time; born in Cleveland, Ohio.

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 13 April 2024.

Accused

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Courtney Nugent. Kelly's ex and mother of his nine-year-old daughter; raised the alarm and found his body
Brinley. Kelly and daughter, born in 2019

The timeline

  1. Francis Kelly is born in Cleveland, Ohioabout 0:12:21
  2. Kelly attends St Ignatius High School and Ohio State University (St. Ignatius High School)about 0:12:28
  3. 2007 Kelly obtains a master's degree from Butler University (Butler University)about 0:12:36
  4. 2019 Kelly, 46, and , 42, have a daughter, Brinleyabout 0:14:45
  5. March 2020 Kelly files court papers seeking better custody and complaining that violates the parenting time orderabout 0:24:19
  6. asks two of her adult daughters to help her buy drugs to poison Kelly; both refuseabout 0:24:37
  7. asks for poison and fentanyl, promising a share of the baby's life insurance; agrees and recruits about 0:25:09
  8. October 2020 brings Kelly miso soup laced with fentanyl; he eats it, gets sick but does not die (Kelly house)about 0:26:40
  9. October 2020 asks for a hitman and gives him $2,500 as a down payment; he keeps the money and spends it on motels and drugsabout 0:30:14
  10. October 27th, 2020, 9.42 p.m. A male caller tells the Clark County Sheriff's Office that a crime that could take a life is going to happen in Zionsville, Indiana (Clark County Sheriff's Office)about 0:17:03
  11. October 27th, 2020, 10.27 p.m. The same caller tells the Boone County Sheriff's Office that a man may be killed over a custody issue and names ; he promises to call back with her address and never does (Boone County Sheriff's Office)about 0:17:22
  12. January 14th, 2021 and buy more fentanyl; lures Kelly out shopping while climbs through a window and laces the oatmeal in his fridge with fentanyl (Kelly house)about 0:34:52
  13. January 14th, 2021 Kelly texts asking whether she did something to the oatmeal in his fridge and says he feels lightheadedabout 0:31:28
  14. January 15th, 2021 Kelly exchanges his last texts with about custody and is not heard from againabout 0:34:00
  15. January 15th, 2021 and drive to the house; sees Kelly lying on the kitchen floor, enters through a window and opens the front door (Kelly house)about 0:35:37
  16. January 15th, 2021 puts one of Kelly's neckties round his neck, lifts him two or three feet and slams his head into the floor several times, then strangles him with the tie (Kelly house)about 0:36:50
  17. January 15th, 2021 waits in the car for ten minutes; the pair drive to a restaurant where throws the necktie into a dumpsterabout 0:49:28
  18. January 16th, 2021 Kelly fails to collect his nine-year-old daughter on her birthdayabout 0:39:00
  19. January 18th, 2021 One of relatives calls police to say she has made incriminating statements, including that Kelly was better off dead and that she did not mean to kill him last timeabout 0:39:27

Last meals

  • Francis Kelly. steel-cut oatmeal from his fridge, laced with fentanyl eaten at home shortly before he was killed, January 2021about 0:34:52

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode