FILE 570 / 8 February 2025 / 71 MIN / express

Twelve Scary Hours

Westport, ConnecticutListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to Connecticut this week here, Westport, Connecticut ... Westport is in southwestern Connecticut ... This is in Fairfield County about 0:02:42

History, in brief

1835

Officially incorporated in 1835, taking land from Fairfield, Weston and Norwalk.

about 0:04:39

Town note

Daniel Nash led 130 people to petition the town of Fairfield for Westport's incorporation, to protect its seaport's economic viability against neighbouring town seaports.

about 0:04:48

Town note

For several decades it was a big agricultural community and the leading onion growing centre in the United States.

about 0:05:11

Town note

It became a shipping centre in part to transport the onions.

about 0:05:26
All 10 history facts

1835

Officially incorporated in 1835, taking land from Fairfield, Weston and Norwalk.

about 0:04:39

Town note

Daniel Nash led 130 people to petition the town of Fairfield for Westport's incorporation, to protect its seaport's economic viability against neighbouring town seaports.

about 0:04:48

Town note

For several decades it was a big agricultural community and the leading onion growing centre in the United States.

about 0:05:11

Town note

It became a shipping centre in part to transport the onions.

about 0:05:26

Town note

After the collapse of the onion industry, mills and factories replaced farming.

about 0:05:32

1910

Starting about 1910, New Yorkers discovered the town and artists and musicians began moving here.

about 0:05:41

Town note

It gained a reputation as an art centre and was called a creative heaven.

about 0:06:29

Town note

Twentieth-century industrialisation brought fashionable people; farmers sold land for housing developments and it changed from farms to suburbs.

about 0:06:37

1960

Paul Newman moved here in 1960 and lived there until he died; his wife Joanne Woodward stayed after his death.

about 0:07:01

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$1,473,500
Median household income$236,892
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"27,168"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:03:29

Median household income

"$236,892"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:03:53

Median home cost

"$1,473,500"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:04:02

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“Appreciates the location, an hour from New York City, with a beach, a nice downtown, a public pool, sports courts and fields, and a high school with amazing sports, theatre and music facilities.”
about 0:07:22

3 stars

“Beautiful town and relatively nice people, but people can be spoiled, arrogant and extremely out of touch.”
about 0:08:03

1 star

“A very nasty town run by an insiders' clique of real estate people, hedge fund people and showbiz types, where anyone not an insider is a sub-citizen; the police are thugs for the real estate people and the realtors engage in serious blacklisting.”
about 0:08:18

In Connecticut

Closest episodes

  1. A Blaze Of GloryRedding, Connecticut · 25 July 201821 km / 13 miShow on map
  2. Blood Among FriendsNorthport, New York · 24 February 202224 km / 15 miShow on map
  3. Open & Not So ShutBelle Terre, New York · 4 June 202029 km / 18 miShow on map
  4. Wood Chipping The WifeNewtown, Connecticut · 30 March 202432 km / 20 miShow on map
  5. Murder By MoonlightChappaqua, New York · 12 June 202536 km / 22 miShow on map

The story

In November 1962 Westport, Connecticut, was a wealthy, leafy suburb on Long Island Sound. Pierre Sillan, a textile designer, lived at Stony Brook Road with his wife Isabel, 50, and their 14-year-old daughter Gale. Their older sons were away: Paul, 24, was in the army in Germany, and Pierre Jr., 20, was at college.

Monday 12 November 1962 was Veterans Day, so Gale was home from school, but Pierre left at about 7 a.m. for the commuter train to New York, going out through the kitchen door and not bothering to lock it. Isabel and Gale were asleep.

At about 8.45 a.m. Gale woke and went into the upstairs hallway to check the grandfather clock. A tall white man was standing there. She recognised him as a handyman who had worked in the house about two weeks earlier. He grabbed her by the neck, pulled her into her bedroom and choked her until she passed out. Her mother knocked and asked if everything was all right, but Gale could not answer. When Gale came round she went downstairs and found the man on top of her mother, choking her with a cord. He dragged both of them into the parents' bedroom, tied them with clothesline and choked them repeatedly. Asked why he was doing it, he said: 'You wouldn't understand.' He tied Gale hand and foot, made her change her nightgown, wrapped her in a quilt, carried her out and put her on the floor of the back seat of his car. He had not turned up for work that Monday, the first time he had ever missed a scheduled day. He drove around for hours. He put her in the trunk, drove on and eventually stopped at the Calypso Tavern, where he offered her a chicken sandwich. He then tied her by the hands to the rear door handle, went in to order food, came back, untied her, raped her and left her tied on the floor while he collected the sandwich. Gale tore the ropes off her hands, opened the door with her head and fell out face first. With her hands still tied and her nightgown soaked in blood, she ran to the nearest house, in Norwalk, and kicked the door until Mary Burgo opened it. It was about 6 p.m. At 6.30 p.m. Pierre came home to a dark house in disarray. He found Isabel in the bathroom, in her nightgown, posed sitting on the toilet with her head against the wall. She had been dead for hours, strangled with a rope or clothesline. Gale was taken to hospital and kept under guard. She slept through Tuesday, and not until Wednesday did her father tell her that her mother was dead. On Friday 16 November Isabel was buried in Terrytown; the police kept Gale in hospital and she missed the funeral.

He and Lucille, his common-law wife, left at about 9.30 the night after the killing and drove south. On 16 November word reached the sheriff that a turquoise and cream 1956 Mercury with Connecticut plates was at his mother's house outside Soperton, Georgia. In the car were a red bathrobe belt, clothing, blankets from the Sillan house and a narrow-brimmed hat of the kind Gale had described.

He also said: 'If everybody says I did it, then I must have,' and that he was sorry for what he had done to that woman.

The car had been searched in Georgia and again in Connecticut without a warrant. Hair identified as Gale's was found on the crank handle of the rear window and on the rear seat and floor, and blood of her type on the seat cover.

Judge John M. Comley called the crime particularly revolting and atrocious but held that the evidence could not stand.

Pierre took Gale on a long trip to Europe and then moved with her to an apartment in Manhattan. Gale studied at the New York School of Interior Design and worked for many years as an interior designer at Vital Enterprises in Vista, New York. The house was later valued at $4,651,000.

The case

Murder of Isabel Sillan

Victims

Isabel Sillan (50). Pierre Sillan's wife and Gale's mother, strangled at home
Gale Sillan (14). their daughter, choked, bound, kidnapped and raped, survived and escaped

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 8 February 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Pierre Sillan. Isabel's husband, a textile designer who commuted to New York City
Paul Sillan. their 24-year-old son, in the army in Germany
Pierre Sillan Jr.. their 20-year-old son, away at college
Mary Jones. mother, known as Aunt Mary, in Soperton, Georgia
Mary Burgo. the Norwalk woman who took in Gale after her escape and called the police
Hermann and Clyde Whitmore. owners of the landscaping and housekeeping firm worked for
Elizabeth Richard. landlady, who told police he and his wife had left
Jack Royal. deputy police chief in Sarasota, who described earlier record
John M. Comley. judge who spoke for the Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors in 1965
John Shustack. state representative who backed a bill to register domestic staff and landscapers
Martha Daniel. US commissioner in Georgia who arraigned the couple

The timeline

  1. about 1930 is born in Soperton, Georgia, the oldest of seven children. (Soperton)about 1:07:09
  2. 1953 , then a turpentine worker, marries Jimmy Sue.about 0:21:02
  3. the first year of their marriage tries to rape his aunt; his uncle shoots at him and he runs away.about 0:21:50
  4. while Jimmy Sue was pregnant goes to Florida and does not return until their son Willy James is two months old.about 0:22:36
  5. 1957 abandons Jimmy Sue.about 0:22:57
  6. October and November 1962 works on the Sillan property at least six times and on the adjoining property four times. (Sillan house)about 0:18:01
  7. November 10th, 1962 is told on Saturday that he must work on the Monday, and then fails to report for the first time ever.about 0:18:19
  8. November 12th, 1962, about 7 a.m. Pierre Sillan leaves for the commuter train to New York, closing but not locking the kitchen door. (Sillan house)about 0:15:16
  9. November 12th, 1962, about 8.45 a.m. Gale Sillan finds standing in the upstairs hallway and he grabs her by the neck. (Sillan house)about 0:16:40
  10. November 12th, 1962, morning chokes Gale unconscious, then attacks Isabel when she comes to the door, choking and binding both of them. (Sillan house)about 0:16:51
  11. November 12th, 1962, about 9.15 a.m. wraps Gale in a quilt, carries her out and drives away with her in his car. (Sillan house)about 0:29:11
  12. November 12th, 1962, daytime drives around for hours, puts Gale in the trunk, stops at the Calypso Tavern, offers her a chicken sandwich and rapes her. (Calypso Tavern)about 0:30:35
  13. November 12th, 1962, about 6 p.m. Gale tears off her bonds, opens the car door with her head, escapes and reaches Mary Burgo's house in Norwalk. (Mary Burgo house)about 0:34:26
  14. November 12th, 1962, 6.30 p.m. Pierre Sillan comes home to a dark, disordered house and finds Isabel dead in the bathroom, posed on the toilet. (Sillan house)about 0:29:20

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode