FILE 583 / 27 March 2025 / 177 MIN / full

Charming Serial Killer

Kirkland, WashingtonListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Kirkland, Washington... this is in King County about 0:05:06

History, in brief

1886

In 1886 Peter Kirk, a British-born businessman, wanted to expand his family's steel production company and came to Washington after hearing that iron deposits had been found in the Cascade Mountains.

about 0:06:11

1888

In 1888 his Kirkland Land and Development Company bought thousands of acres of what is now downtown Kirkland and began building a steel mill.

about 0:06:31

Town note

Kirk said the town would be the 'Pittsburgh of the West', but the company came to nothing and another steel company took what it wanted.

about 0:06:46

Town note

The town was named after Peter Kirk anyway.

about 0:07:03
All 5 history facts

1886

In 1886 Peter Kirk, a British-born businessman, wanted to expand his family's steel production company and came to Washington after hearing that iron deposits had been found in the Cascade Mountains.

about 0:06:11

1888

In 1888 his Kirkland Land and Development Company bought thousands of acres of what is now downtown Kirkland and began building a steel mill.

about 0:06:31

Town note

Kirk said the town would be the 'Pittsburgh of the West', but the company came to nothing and another steel company took what it wanted.

about 0:06:46

Town note

The town was named after Peter Kirk anyway.

about 0:07:03

Town note

Costco was formerly headquartered in Kirkland and kept the name for its Kirkland Signature store brand.

about 0:07:08

The figures, as told

Religious

about 38%

Biggest faith: Catholics, 15.5%

about 0:10:52

Who lives here

White 72.6% · Black 1.1% · Asian 14% · Hispanic 7%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
about average

about 0:20:01

Violent crime
▼ one third

about 0:20:10

Money

Median home value$1,055,900
Two-bedroom rent$2,680
Median household income$121,998
Cost of living158

For sale

$1,775,000

Six-bedroom, three-bath house, 3,059 square feet

about 0:13:23

For sale

$2,800,000

Four-bedroom, four-bath house, 3,520 square feet on 0.32 acres

about 0:14:10

For sale

$12,950,000

Three-bedroom, five-bath waterfront house, 3,990 square feet on 0.69 acres

about 0:14:54
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Property crime

"about average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2025 about 0:20:01

Violent crime

"one third"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:20:10

Population

"91,656"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:12

Male and female split

"exactly 50-50"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:21

Median age

"37.8"

Comparison: "national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:26

Religious

"about 38%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:52

Catholics

"15.5%"

Comparison: "largest religious group". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:57

Unemployment

"about average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:16

Median household income

"$121,998"

Comparison: "national average of $69,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:27

Cost of living index

"158"

Comparison: "100 is regular in the United States". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:43

Housing index

"329 out of 100"

Comparison: "100 is regular in the United States". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:50

Median home cost

"$1,055,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:53

Average two-bedroom rent

"$2,680"

Comparison: "almost Manhattan prices". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:30

Six-bedroom, three-bath house, 3,059 square feet

"$1,775,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:23

Four-bedroom, four-bath house, 3,520 square feet on 0.32 acres

"$2,800,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:10

Three-bedroom, five-bath waterfront house, 3,990 square feet on 0.69 acres

"$12,950,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:54

The reviews

3.8 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“A beautiful small city on the east side of Lake Washington, with a lively downtown, friendly locals and a weekly summer farmers' market.”
about 0:08:22

5 stars

“A lifelong resident loves the nature, friendly neighbours, food and clean parks; a quiet place to raise a family but poor for nightlife and the rent is inflated.”
about 0:08:53

3 stars

“Waterfront property is expensive but very nice, mostly apartments and very few abandoned properties.”
about 0:09:33

2 stars

“Street lights are not great for nighttime driving.”
about 0:09:49

In Washington

Closest episodes

  1. Just Being MyselfClearview, Washington · 4 April 201915 km / 9 miShow on map
  2. Beauty Queen Conspiracy MurderFreeland, Washington · 22 August 202545 km / 28 miShow on map
  3. Need Any Ostriches?Sequim, Washington · 14 January 202378 km / 48 miShow on map
  4. Taming The BeastShelton, Washington · 2 January 202086 km / 53 miShow on map
  5. Turning A Husband Into FlowersLopez Island, Washington · 23 May 2024103 km / 64 miShow on map

The story

Kirkland, Washington, is a suburb on the east side of Lake Washington, in King County, about twenty minutes from Seattle. Shortly after five in the morning on 23 June 1990 a McDonald's employee taking rubbish out to the dumpsters shared with the Black Angus restaurant found the naked body of a young woman in the parking lot. She was Mary Ann Polrike, twenty-seven, who worked at a medical device manufacturing company. She had no gunshot or stab wounds. Her body had been posed: she lay on her back with her left foot crossed over her right ankle, her head turned to the left, her arms folded over her stomach, a dip container resting over her right eye and a Douglas fir pine cone in her hand. The post-mortem found that she had been manually strangled, that her skull was fractured and her face badly beaten, that her liver had been split by kicks, and that a non-human object had caused an anal tear. Her blood alcohol was 0.14.

Polrike had gone to Papagayo's, a singles bar in Bellevue, on the evening of 22 June with two friends. They left at about 9.30 pm; she stayed. McLean waited at the Overlake Denny's until about 5.30 am and then found a ride home. He later told McLean that he had been the one who was sick, and that he had driven a woman home. Polrike's Camaro, purse and sweater were still at the bar.

His parents separated when he was about six months old; his mother, Joyce, left him with her own mother and went to college. The family was the only black family in their neighbourhood. In his early teens he was a burglar and a car thief, and he spent hours at the Mercer Island police station, where officers gave him chores and let him hang around. In 1987 he was diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder. In 1988 he skimmed $23,000 from the Nintendo Arcade in eight months.

On 8 August 1990 Carol Marie Beath, thirty-five, a bartender at Cucina Cucina in Bellevue and the mother of two daughters, aged nine and thirteen, spent the evening out. She spoke to her ex-husband Paul at 9.30 pm and her boyfriend Mike Sewell at 10.30, then met friends at the Keg, where John Comfort was tending bar. She left a little after two in the morning, drove home, and was seen by a neighbour unlocking her front door at about 2.30, alone and a little tipsy. She showered and lay down at about three. At 4.30 her thirteen-year-old daughter Kelly heard someone in the hall and saw a torch beam move from the bathroom into her sister's room and then her own; she assumed it was her mother's boyfriend and went back to sleep. At 8.30 she found her mother's bedroom door locked, went round to the sliding glass door and saw the body. Her father came and entered through that door. Carol was on her back on the bed, the bedspread pulled to the foot, naked except for red high-heeled shoes. Her legs were apart and bent, blood had been smeared on them as if finger-painted, and her own .22 rifle had been placed between her legs with the barrel inserted five and a half inches into her vagina. A pillow covered her face; beneath it a dry-cleaning bag was over her head, held by a belt around her neck. She had been beaten to death with an instrument that left Y-shaped marks and crushed the left side of her skull. She had bite marks, broken ribs that penetrated the chest cavity, and a lacerated liver. Two wedding ring sets and six small Crown Royal bags containing silver dollars and tip money were missing.

On 30 August 1990 Andrea Levine, twenty-four, who went by Randy, met her boyfriend at a restaurant in Kirkland to discuss a trip to the San Juan Islands, had a drink with girlfriends at the Maple Gardens, left not long after midnight and drove home at about 1.30 am to her basement apartment in the home of Robert Hayes. At five the next morning Hayes let his dogs out, saw a dark figure about thirty feet away near Randy's basement window and chased him off. The following Monday his wife went into the apartment because Randy's cat was crying, smelled old blood and found the body. Randy had been struck repeatedly on the head with an iron bar or an aluminium bat. She had 231 small knife wounds, inflicted after death, some in patterns. She was posed on her back with a copy of The Joy of Sex under her left forearm and a plastic dildo in her mouth. Her amethyst ring and every knife in the kitchen were gone.

He denied the murders and refused to give a DNA or hair sample. He asked a roommate to bring him his copy of a crime scene search handbook.

On 11 October 1990 police stripped the interior of McLean's truck. Randy's amethyst ring was recovered from a pawn shop in Canada and identified by her sister-in-law.

Jack Olsen's 1995 book Charmer covered the case, and it has been dramatised in several television series.

The case

Murders of Mary Ann Polrike, Carol Beath and Andrea Levine

Victims

Mary Ann Polrike (27). Worked at a medical device manufacturing company; found naked and posed by the dumpsters between the McDonald's and the Black Angus.
Carol Marie Beath (35). Bartender at Cucina Cucina in Bellevue and mother of two daughters; beaten to death and posed in her condo.
Andrea 'Randy' Levine (24). Rented a basement apartment in Kirkland; beaten and stabbed after death in her bed.

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 27 March 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Boris Brockett. childhood friend on Mercer Island
Joyce. his mother, a college professor
Dr. Wonzell Mobley. his stepfather, a dental surgeon
Chris. his stepmother
Erica. his half-sister
Tom Hagar. childhood friend
Smith McLean. friend whose truck borrowed
John Comfort. bartender at the Keg questioned by police
Mike Sewell. Carol Beath's boyfriend
Paul. Carol Beath's ex-husband
Kelly. Carol Beath's thirteen-year-old daughter
Robert Hayes. Randy Levine's landlord
Matt McCawley. sixteen-year-old neighbour of Carol Beath
Dr. Michael Washington. dentist who took in
Miriam Schwartz. public defender
Brad Hampton. public defender
John Douglas. FBI profiler who testified
Robert Keppel. investigator and profiler who testified
Sergeant Glendon Booth. Mercer Island police sergeant
Jimmy. McDonald's employee who found the body

The timeline

  1. April 1958 is born in Florida.about 0:28:55
  2. about six months later His parents separate; his mother Joyce leaves him with her mother and goes to college.about 0:29:16
  3. 1964 Joyce returns with a diploma and a new husband, Dr. Wonzell Mobley, and takes to Mercer Island, Washington.about 0:30:24
  4. about 1970 In seventh grade meets Boris Brockett.about 0:34:07
  5. about 1971-72 Police find him peering through blackberry bushes and pick him up for truancy; he becomes a fixture at the Mercer Island police station. (Mercer Island police station)about 0:48:08
  6. about 1973 He tells classmates he wants to be a policeman.about 0:50:41
  7. 1973 or 1974 He sneaks nine friends into a Led Zeppelin concert at the Kingdome using a parking attendant's jacket. (Kingdome)about 1:10:01
  8. just before Christmas 1974 Joyce and his half-sister Erica move to Maryland; is left with his stepfather.about 1:15:21
  9. shortly after Christmas 1974 Dr. Mobley marries Chris.about 1:15:43
  10. about 1975 Juvenile police files leak to his high school; the police bar him from the station. (Mercer Island police station)about 1:18:05
  11. about 1975 Caught sneaking into his stepmother's room, he is thrown out and sent to Dr. Michael Washington's house. (Dr. Michael Washington's house)about 1:19:27
  12. about 1976 He returns to Mercer Island and drops out of high school in his senior year.about 1:30:15
  13. 1978 He is hired as assistant manager of the teen disco Tonight's the Night. (Tonight's the Night)about 1:40:45
  14. over the next couple of years He steals thousands of dollars from Tonight's the Night. (Tonight's the Night)about 1:42:04
  15. about 1980 He rolls a friend's BMW on West Mercer Way. (West Mercer Way)about 1:43:46
  16. about 1980 He crashes a friend's Datsun on Interstate 5 near Redding, California, fracturing his femur. (Interstate 5 near Redding)about 1:44:07
  17. 1982 to 1985 He molests a fourteen-year-old girl and later forces her to perform oral sex.about 1:49:05
  18. about 1987 He is banned permanently from Denny's for stealing tips from tables.about 1:53:40
  19. 1988 Hired at the Nintendo Arcade, he skims $23,000 in eight months. (Nintendo Arcade)about 1:54:19
  20. 1989 Fired for stealing, he claims to be a born-again Christian, moves in with Mindy and begins abusing her.about 1:54:59
  21. March 1990 He is banned from the Black Angus restaurant. (Black Angus restaurant)about 1:56:21
  22. June 22nd, 1990 Mary Ann Polrike goes to Papagayo's in Bellevue with friends; they leave at 9.30 pm and she stays on. (Papagayo's)about 1:56:48
  23. June 22nd, 1990 borrows Smith McLean's truck at Papagayo's and drives off. (Papagayo's)about 1:57:45
  24. June 23rd, 1990, about 5 am A McDonald's worker finds Polrike's body by the dumpsters shared with the Black Angus. (McDonald's parking lot)about 0:20:23

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode