FILE 601 / 5 June 2025 / 179 MIN / full

Angriest Serial Killer Around

Chester, PennsylvaniaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

James says this is Chester, Pennsylvania, about 25 minutes outside of Philly, in southeastern Pennsylvania, and that it is in Delaware County about 0:04:57

History, in brief

1644

Chester is the oldest city in Pennsylvania, founded in 1644 by Swedish settlers.

about 0:06:14

Town note

The town motto is 'What Chester makes, makes Chester'.

about 0:05:53

1681

In 1681 William Penn acquired the colonial settlement as a safe haven for Quakers.

about 0:06:38

Town note

A year later Penn landed on the ship Welcome and renamed the settlement Chester after a city in England.

about 0:07:13
All 5 history facts

1644

Chester is the oldest city in Pennsylvania, founded in 1644 by Swedish settlers.

about 0:06:14

Town note

The town motto is 'What Chester makes, makes Chester'.

about 0:05:53

1681

In 1681 William Penn acquired the colonial settlement as a safe haven for Quakers.

about 0:06:38

Town note

A year later Penn landed on the ship Welcome and renamed the settlement Chester after a city in England.

about 0:07:13

2022

As of 2022 the town of Chester declared bankruptcy.

about 0:07:26

The figures, as told

Who lives here

White 16% · Black 68.7% · Asian 0.8% · Hispanic 11.9%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ slightly above average

about 0:18:15

Violent crime
▼ about three and a half times

about 0:18:24

Money

Median home value$92,000
Two-bedroom rentabout $1,120 a month
Median household income$35,751
Cost of living$106,000

For sale

$65,000

Listing: three-bed, one-bath, 1,200 sq ft on a 1,300 sq ft lot

about 0:13:00

For sale

$93,000

Listing: six-bed, two-bath, 3,400 sq ft

about 0:14:13

For sale

$323,000

Listing: four-bed, two-bath, 1,608 sq ft

about 0:14:58
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"32,819"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:32

Median age

"32.5"

Comparison: "usually about 38". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:10:56

Married share

"about 20%"

Comparison: "50-50 is the normal in the rest of the country". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:02

Single with children

"42%"

Comparison: "normally 10% is normal". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:15

Native American

"0.2%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:24

Unemployment rate

"14%"

Comparison: "more than double the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:46

Median household income

"$35,751"

Comparison: "about half the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:11:54

Cost of living

"$106,000"

Comparison: "$100,000 is the average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:05

Median home cost

"$92,000"

Comparison: "rest of the country $338,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:12

Average two-bedroom rental

"about $1,120 a month"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:51

Listing: three-bed, one-bath, 1,200 sq ft on a 1,300 sq ft lot

"$65,000"

Comparison: "cut $15,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:00

Listing: six-bed, two-bath, 3,400 sq ft

"$93,000"

Comparison: "cut $7,000 from $100,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:13

Listing: four-bed, two-bath, 1,608 sq ft

"$323,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:58

Property crime

"slightly above average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:18:15

Violent crime

"about three and a half times"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:18:24

The reviews

2.2 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“Chester is an interesting place with its seedy sides, but the majority of residents are decent working people.”
about 0:07:50

3 stars

“The reviewer was almost attacked by a street gang at night by the Lamokin Project on Central Avenue and her ex-vet boyfriend handled the situation. She also describes visiting a coworker on Third Street whose old row house had no roof, and the tearing down of the old Sun Hotel and Indian burial grounds.”
about 0:08:23

1 star

“Chester is a terrible, dangerous wasteland, at least on the west side: trash-strewn streets, dilapidated abandoned houses, a god-awful stench and constant gunshots. The one positive is that the immediate neighbours are exceptionally nice.”
about 0:09:42

1 star

“Chester is extremely violent; the reviewer only goes there for college and would not recommend the area to anyone.”
about 0:10:19

1 star

“It is next to Penn and has alcohol, the only two reasons to enter; it is not worth the trip if you do not live nearby, it is expensive and dark inside and the pitchers are watered down. The owner replied that they are next to Penn, have alcohol, that nobody gets to call them Smokes, and asked where the reviewer comes from if they think the place is expensive.”
about 0:32:02

In Pennsylvania

Closest episodes

  1. Dead In A DitchClaymont, Delaware · 9 September 20239 km / 6 miShow on map
  2. One Too Many GirlfriendsWilmington, Delaware · 14 March 202418 km / 11 miShow on map
  3. A Scary Story On A Quiet StreetPitman, New Jersey · 31 October 201924 km / 15 miShow on map
  4. Murder MathNew Castle, Delaware · 14 September 202426 km / 16 miShow on map
  5. The Horny Teacher's LoungeUpper Merion Township, Pennsylvania · 13 July 202327 km / 17 miShow on map

The story

Chester, Pennsylvania, is the oldest city in the state, founded in 1644 by Swedish settlers and renamed by William Penn in 1682 after a city in England. It sits in Delaware County about twenty-five minutes outside Philadelphia, and by 2022 the town had declared bankruptcy. At the time of the episode its population was 32,819; violent crime ran at about three and a half times the national average.

Amy Ellen Willard was born on June 8th, 1974, the youngest of three children. Her mother, Gail, was a nurse at Riddle Memorial Hospital in Lima, and her father, Paul, was a Chester police officer who rose to captain; the couple divorced but stayed close. Amy was a gifted athlete, a star at lacrosse and soccer at Notre Dame de Namur, an all-girls private school in Villanova, and she won a full scholarship to George Mason University in Fairfax, Virginia. In 1996 she set school records with 50 goals and 29 assists and was named to all-conference teams in both sports. She was studying physical education and wanted to become a teacher and high school lacrosse coach.

She came home for the summer of 1996 between her junior and senior years. On June 19th her friends talked her into going to Smokey Joe's, a bar in Wayne she had never visited, and she drove her mother's blue 1995 Honda Civic. She arrived at about 10.30 p.m. and left at about 1.40 a.m., heading for Interstate 476. At about 2 a.m. an ambulance crew found the Civic abandoned on the exit ramp leading to Route 1. The engine was running, the driver's door was open, the lights and radio were on, and there was nobody around. There was a pool of blood in front of the car with a trail of drops leading away that stopped, a bloodstained tire iron, blood on the guardrail and tyre impressions nearby. The rear bumper was damaged, and her father later confirmed the damage had not been there when she took the car. He believed someone had bumped her at the traffic light and attacked her when she got out.

The next morning police found a pair of her underwear and her sneakers about half a mile away. They were dry although it had rained overnight, and the detective concluded they had been brought back and planted after the car was found. At about 5 p.m. on June 20th children playing in a vacant, trash-strewn lot at 16th Street and Indiana Avenue in Philadelphia found her body. She was naked, face down, with two plastic bags over her head. She had been beaten about the head with great force, strangled, burned with a patterned hot object and sexually assaulted; a tree branch had been forced into her vagina. There was no blood at the lot, so she had been killed elsewhere. The medical examiner gave the cause of death as multiple blunt force injuries to the head and face and estimated that she died at about seven in the morning.

A twenty-three-year-old tow truck driver named Andrew Kobach came forward to say he had seen something suspicious near her car. He had been at the scene, his employer's yard was three blocks from the body site, and he was intensely interested in the case. He later sued news organisations over their coverage.

The case went cold for a year. In June 1997 a woman in Ardmore called police at 6.45 a.m. about a man ringing her doorbell. The plate on the Honda had come from his own green Ford Escort. Maria, twenty-five, was a Philippine-born lab technician and one of eleven siblings who had vanished on March 16th on her way to a half-day shift and was reported missing on March 18th.

In 1978, married to a woman named Tammy, he shot and killed Larry Carrier over a parking space at his Las Vegas apartment complex with a .22 rifle. In January 1979, while still on bail, he shot Sherry Naumann in the leg with a shotgun in Sparks.

That year he married Joyce, a nursing assistant he met at Doylestown Hospital, and abused her; he was simultaneously engaged to Mary Rumer and dating other women, and he had stalked dozens, keeping items belonging to as many as forty women in a storage locker.

He said he followed Amy from the bar, stopped her on Interstate 476 with a fake police badge, told her she had been swerving, punched her unconscious when she argued, drove her to an abandoned building in Chester, took her clothes, raped her and killed her with blows to the head. He then took Rumer on a tour of the places where he had left the car and the body.

The Escort was traced to a towing company where it had sat for over a year after an accident. Its Firestone 440 thirteen-inch tyres matched the impressions at the scene, and its oil pan matched the patterned burn on Amy's body. Blood in the car matched her; DNA from his blood matched the semen, with odds of one in 500 million for the black population, one in 1.6 billion for white people and one in 800 million for Hispanic people. Hairs in his car matched Amy, his DNA was under her fingernails, and blood in his trunk matched.

A psychiatric examination found him competent, noting a paranoid personality disorder but no psychosis.

The case

Murder of Amy Willard

Victims

Amy Ellen Willard (22). Born June 8th, 1974, youngest of three, daughter of Chester police captain Paul Willard and nurse Gail Willard; star lacrosse and soccer player at Notre Dame de Namur and George Mason University, where she set school records with 50 goals and 29 assists in 1996; studying physical education to become a teacher and high school lacrosse coach; 5 foot 2, 120 pounds, with a Nike logo tattooed on her ankle

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 5 June 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Gail Willard. Amy's mother, a nurse at Riddle Memorial Hospital in Lima; she opposed the death penalty and her subpoena was quashed so she would not testify against it
Paul Willard. Amy's father, a Chester police captain who believed someone bumped her car at the traffic light
Jeff Pirey. Philadelphia Police Department homicide detective who described the body at the vacant lot
Patty Jordan. 19-year-old woman who reported a man in a black Honda following and bumping her car before the Ardmore doorbell incident
Gerald Cook. forensic psychologist who testified for the defence about low IQ and borderline personality disorder
Reverend Glenn Serino. character witness who recalled seeing in his Bucks County church on March 10th, 1997
Sonny. brother, who testified that he did not want his brother to die
Mr. Much. defence attorney

The timeline

  1. June 8th, 1974 Amy Ellen Willard is bornabout 0:19:14
  2. 1996 Amy sets George Mason school records with 50 goals and 29 assists in lacrosse (George Mason University)about 0:26:26
  3. June 1996 Amy comes home for the summer between her junior and senior years (Willard house)about 0:30:27
  4. June 19th, 1996 Her friends talk her into going to Smokey Joe's and she drives her mother's blue 1995 Honda Civic (Smokey Joe's)about 0:30:50
  5. about 8.30 p.m., June 19th, 1996 Police stop six blocks from where Amy's car will be found five hours later (Route 1 exit ramp from Interstate 476)about 2:24:42
  6. 10.30 p.m., June 19th, 1996 Amy arrives at Smokey Joe's in Wayne with friends (Smokey Joe's)about 0:33:18
  7. 1.40 a.m., June 20th, 1996 Amy leaves Smokey Joe's and heads for Interstate 476 (Smokey Joe's)about 0:33:30
  8. about 2 a.m., June 20th, 1996 An ambulance crew finds her abandoned Civic on the exit ramp to Route 1, engine running, driver's door open, lights and radio on, with a pool of blood, a bloodied tire iron and tyre impressions nearby (Route 1 exit ramp from Interstate 476)about 0:33:52
  9. the next morning, June 20th, 1996 Police find her underwear and sneakers half a mile away, dry although it rained, suggesting they were planted after the scene was cleared (Route 1 exit ramp from Interstate 476)about 0:39:33
  10. about 5 p.m., June 20th, 1996 Children playing in the vacant lot find Amy's body, naked, face down and with two plastic bags over her head (Vacant lot at 16th Street and Indiana Avenue)about 0:49:08

Murder of Maria Cabuenos

Victims

Maria Cabuenos (25). Native of the Philippines, one of eleven siblings, a lab technician at Smith-Kline Beecham in Montgomery County who lived with two brothers; disappeared on her way to a half-day shift and was reported missing when she missed an overnight shift

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 5 June 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Donna. Maria's sister, who expected her for Sunday lunch and thought she might have gone shopping

The timeline

  1. March 10th, 1997 Reverend Glenn Serino sees at his Bucks County church, five days before Maria disappears (Bucks County church)about 2:33:22

Murder of Larry Carrier

Victims

Larry Carrier. Man who argued with group over a parking space at the apartment complex

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 5 June 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Tammy. wife in 1978
Blondie K. woman with the group outside the apartment when Larry Carrier argued with them
Service Station Bob. man with the group outside the apartment
Sherry Naumann. 18-year-old grocery store clerk shot in the leg with a shotgun in Sparks in January 1979
Joanne Naumann. Sherry's mother, sitting with her on the couch when the gunman entered
Melvin Seenaw. L&L Roofing supervisor who reported a shotgun fired at him days later

The timeline

  1. March 3rd, 1959 is born in Milwaukeeabout 1:12:55
  2. July 25th, 1978 Larry Carrier argues with group over a parking space; goes inside, returns with a .22 calibre rifle and shoots him dead (Larry Carrier apartment complex)about 1:22:19

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Vacant lot at 16th Street and Indiana Avenue

body found

about 0:49:19

Heard in this episode