FILE 680 / 7 March 2026 / 74 MIN / express

Brutal Idiocy

Gadsden, AlabamaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Gadsden, Alabama... this is Etowah County, Etowah County, ETOWAH. about 0:03:46

History, in brief

Town note

It was founded by John Riley near the natural springs on the Coosa River.

about 0:04:51

1871

It was incorporated in 1871, about fifty years after it was founded.

about 0:04:51
All 7 history facts

Town note

It was founded by John Riley near the natural springs on the Coosa River.

about 0:04:51

1871

It was incorporated in 1871, about fifty years after it was founded.

about 0:04:51

1853

It was renamed after Colonel James Gadsden, noted for the 1853 purchase.

about 0:04:51

Town note

In the 1800s it became Alabama's second most important commercial and industrial centre after Mobile.

about 0:05:11

1960

It had its highest population in 1960, with 58,000 people, when there was a lot of industry: steel, Goodyear tyres, coal and iron.

about 0:05:29

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$84,100
Median household income$35,776
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Population

"34,317"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:04:11

Median household income

"$35,776"

Comparison: "about half of the rest of the country". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:04:23

Median home cost

"$84,100"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:04:34

Peak population, in 1960

"58,000"

Comparison: "the most people the town has ever had". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:29

US adults who were illiterate in 1986

"13%"

Comparison: "more than one in ten". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:16:08

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“Born in Gadsden and moved away after high school to Wichita, Atlanta and Tampa; had kids in Tampa and moved back to raise them, the best decision ever made. Says the new mayor is changing Gadsden to draw more people and the river is better than anywhere.”
about 0:06:01

3 stars

“Likes that everything is in driving distance and that some people are friendly; wishes it could become a better place to live instead of a retirement town.”
about 0:06:34

1 star

“Gadsden is a terrible city to live, do not move here (all caps). Jobs do not pay much and unless you are in the Gadsden Click or know someone good you cannot prosper; houses are run down and antique and the rent is outrageous; the city looks run down and trashy, advertising downtown, the boat dock and Noccalula Falls while the neighbourhoods are full of abandoned buildings, storm-downed trees and trash. The city pulls in money with nothing to show, so bypass this dump.”
about 0:06:58

In Alabama

Closest episodes

  1. The Alabama ZodiacJacksonville, Alabama · 4 November 202133 km / 21 miShow on map
  2. A Sinister & Murderous PlotAnniston, Alabama · 7 June 201742 km / 26 miShow on map
  3. Hello, I'm My Sister...Anniston, Alabama · 26 November 202042 km / 26 miShow on map
  4. Savage Murder & Strange MilkshakesArab, Alabama · 24 September 202657 km / 35 miShow on map
  5. The Murder DanceSection, Alabama · 5 January 202364 km / 40 miShow on map

The story

Her son, Shey Ledbetter, was 12. She had moved with him into a mobile home on Tidmore Bend Road, in a trailer park off Pope Road. Rebecca had begun seeing William David Robinson, a Navy man from Georgia.

He later broke into Rebecca's trailer, beat her and got away before police arrived. Robinson brought a gun to the house so that she could defend herself.

In August 1986 Holiday was in Nashville, calling himself Bobby Hill of Gadsden. On August 23 he told a man he had recently met, Richard John Hardy, that if his ex-wife Becky did not stop seeing her new boyfriend he would kill her.

On the evening of August 24, 1986, five people were at the trailer: Rebecca, Shey, her sister Katrina, Robinson and Larry Thomas Jr, a 16-year-old neighbour who was spending the night with Shey. Larry walked out to go home for a snack and was shot twice in the darkness, mistaken for Robinson. Holiday forced his way in, shoved Katrina aside and went down the hallway. Shey and Katrina escaped next door to call the police and found Larry's body in the front yard. In the back bedroom Holiday shot Rebecca as she crouched on the floor; the bullet entered the back of her head and came out through her right breast. He shot Robinson in the chest and arm.

The search became the biggest manhunt in the county's history, with state, federal and local officers, bloodhounds, helicopters and planes. On August 29 Holiday telephoned a former neighbour, Doris Ruth Nance, and said he had done a bad thing. He said he had not meant to kill the boy, but that Rebecca and David deserved what they got.

On September 6, 1986, Doyle Embry Wallace, a retired Alabama state trooper and Rebecca's uncle, was killed at his home in Southside, Alabama. A man kicked in the door shouting 'I'm the sheriff', shot Wallace once in the neck at close range and left with jewellery. Wallace's wife was hiding in the bedroom closet and survived. Bullets from the scene matched the gun used at the trailer.

On October 9, 1986, police in Gainesville, Florida, were called about a peeping tom. Holiday ran from one officer, was cornered by a deputy, grabbed at the deputy's revolver and was shot three times in the abdomen, arm and chest. At the hospital he was read his rights and said: 'My name is n Holliday. I shot and killed four people in Alabama.' He added that people said he had killed five over a woman, then laughed and winked. A hand-drawn map of interstate routes was found in his car.

Holiday took the stand and claimed he had been in Nashville and that the witnesses had confused him with someone else.

The 2002 decision in Atkins v.

The case

Murders of Rebecca Holiday, Larry Thomas Jr and David Robinson

Victims

Rebecca Ledbetter Holiday (31). Holiday's ex-wife
Larry Thomas Jr (16). neighbour, spending the night with Rebecca's son; shot by mistake
William David Robinson. Rebecca's boyfriend, a Navy officer

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 7 March 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Katrina. Rebecca's sister, survived and testified
Shey Ledbetter. Rebecca's 12-year-old son, survived and testified
Larry Thomas Sr. Larry Jr's father, who searched for Holiday himself
Howard Corson. carjacked at gunpoint and forced to drive the escapees to Georgia
Doris Ruth Nance. former neighbour Holiday telephoned while on the run
Calvin Holiday. brother, shot and killed by police; family awarded $270,000
Red Blanks. Gadsden barber shop owner quoted about the case
Roy McDowell. county sheriff at the time

The timeline

  1. 1986 Rebecca Ledbetter Holiday, 31, and , 37, are divorced; she moves into a mobile home with her son Shey. (Holiday mobile home)about 0:27:26
  2. after the escape, 1986 Holiday breaks into Rebecca's trailer, beats her and gets away before police arrive. (Holiday mobile home)about 0:31:32
  3. 1986 David Robinson brings a gun to the trailer so Rebecca can protect herself. (Holiday mobile home)about 0:31:52
  4. August 1986 In Nashville, Holiday meets Richard John Hardy and introduces himself as Bobby Hill from Gadsden. (Nashville)about 0:32:51
  5. August 23, 1986 At Hardy's house Holiday says that if his ex-wife Becky does not stop seeing her new boyfriend he will kill her. (Richard Hardy's house)about 0:33:19
  6. August 24, 1986, evening Holiday waits outside Rebecca's trailer while five people are inside. (Holiday mobile home)about 0:33:53
  7. August 24, 1986 Larry Thomas Jr, 16, steps outside to go home for a snack and is shot twice; Holiday had mistaken him for David Robinson. (Holiday mobile home)about 0:35:53

Murder of Doyle Embry Wallace

Victims

Doyle Embry Wallace. retired Alabama state trooper, Rebecca Holiday's uncle

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 7 March 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Doyle Wallace's wife. hid in the bedroom closet and survived

The timeline

  1. September 6, 1986 Holiday arrives at Doyle Wallace's house in the morning, kicks the door in shouting 'I'm the sheriff'; Wallace's wife hides in the bedroom closet. (Doyle Wallace's house)about 0:42:00
  2. September 6, 1986 Wallace is shot once in the neck at close range and dies. (Doyle Wallace's house)about 0:42:53

Murder of Elton Barksdale

Victims

Elton Barksdale. elderly antique collector

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 7 March 2026.

Accused

Outcome

The timeline

  1. November 1985 Elton Barksdale, an elderly antique collector, is found fatally shot inside his burned home in the Duck Springs community. (Elton Barksdale's home)about 0:56:32

Last meals

  • Larry Thomas Jr. baked Lay's crisps he went home for a snack on August 24, 1986 and was shot before he got itabout 0:36:02

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode