Town note
Depoy was a stop on the Illinois Central Gulf Railroad and was named for a railroad agent named Elmer DePoister, shortened to Depoy.
about 0:06:00Spoilers are covered until your reading preferences load.
FILE 698 / 8 May 2026 / 73 MIN / express
The murder happened in a town called DePoy, spelled D-E-P-O-Y, so small there are no stats; it is six minutes from Greenville in Muhlenberg County, western Kentucky. about 0:03:55
Depoy was a stop on the Illinois Central Gulf Railroad and was named for a railroad agent named Elmer DePoister, shortened to Depoy.
about 0:06:00Greenville was settled in about 1799 on an estate donated by local landowner William Campbell to establish a new seat of government for a new county.
about 0:06:17Greenville was incorporated as a city in 1848, about 50 years after it was settled.
about 0:06:29Greenville may have been named for Revolutionary War General Nathaniel Green, though the episode says that is only the best guess.
about 0:06:33Depoy was a stop on the Illinois Central Gulf Railroad and was named for a railroad agent named Elmer DePoister, shortened to Depoy.
about 0:06:00Greenville was settled in about 1799 on an estate donated by local landowner William Campbell to establish a new seat of government for a new county.
about 0:06:17Greenville was incorporated as a city in 1848, about 50 years after it was settled.
about 0:06:29Greenville may have been named for Revolutionary War General Nathaniel Green, though the episode says that is only the best guess.
about 0:06:33In 1987 the Encyclopedia of Kentucky called Greenville the unofficial capital of the Black Belt, meaning coal and dark tobacco production rather than people.
about 0:06:45Insanity defence success rate
▼ well under 1%
"4,507"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:05:28
"$34,295"
Comparison: "about half the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2026 about 0:05:33
"$127,300"
Comparison: "about a third of the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2026 about 0:05:41
"well under 1%"
Comparison: "national rate". Direction: below.
As told in 2026 about 1:05:47
4.0 / 5 · average of 3
“The job market is very slim and the town is in the middle of nowhere; the county depended on coal, and stricter regulations have closed companies and cost jobs.”about 0:07:10
“The area is great because everyone is friendly and welcoming, and it is a beautiful town that is growing.”about 0:07:50
“Everyone knows everyone and Walmart is the social centre, but the reviewer has met many ignorant people who yell racial slurs and wants that to change.”about 0:08:04
In June 1999 Depoy, an unincorporated community on a gravel road a few minutes from Greenville in Muhlenberg County, western Kentucky, was home to the Wimberley family. Adele and Eugene Wimberley had raised two daughters, Beverly and Jean, on Wimberley Lane. Beverly had married Todd Wedding, a newspaper delivery man, and Jean had married Johnny Vincent, who worked for a food distributor. The cousins grew up close, and in the 1990s both settled on the same lane, Joey in a grey mobile home with his wife Amy and their daughter Brooklyn, born in July 1997.
Joey was a Greenville police officer and pastor of New Cypress Baptist Church in nearby Graham. Amy, whose maiden name was Hambrick, was a waitress at John and Sue's, the community's only restaurant. Relatives described him as a big, muscular man with a high, feminine voice, a hunter who had taken up karate. In 1998 doctors diagnosed bipolar disorder and prescribed lithium. For a time he seemed better, but in early to mid-June 1999 he stopped taking the medication.
On Tuesday 15 June 1999 Beverly, frightened by his behaviour, asked Amy to drive her to the courthouse in Greenville, where she obtained a 72-hour mental health warrant, formally an emergency protection and involuntary admission order. At a hearing the hospital decided he no longer met the threshold for detention, and he was sent home, angry with his parents, Joey and Amy.
On 24 June Amy told a friend she did not expect to live much longer and that she felt watched. Just after 6.15 a.m. on Sunday 27 June, Joey was carrying Brooklyn to the family car so Amy could take the sick child to the emergency room. Amy's brother Derek Hembrick, who had stayed overnight, called 911.
When officers arrived they found Joey dead between the door and the car and Amy dead inside, four months pregnant. He had given her ice cream and a banana and put cartoons on. Inside the house police found ammunition staged in every room and firearms hidden behind a portable fireplace; a Dodge Intrepid outside had been hosed out.
In a second interview at 4.30 p.m. he described killing his parents. On Saturday 26 June he had asked Todd to drive him to a nearby cemetery to visit his grandmother's grave, then attacked him there with an aluminium baseball bat and left him in the wetland. He returned, shot Beverly in the head with a 10-gauge as she sat in her Dodge pickup, and dumped her body in the same wetland. A search team found both bodies in standing water about 15 feet off the road. He had also taken about $1,200 in cash. He said he killed the four because they had been involved in committing him.
Jean and Johnny Vincent raised Brooklyn. The four funerals were held together, and the case was later the subject of an Investigation Discovery American Monster episode, A Wedding and Four Funerals.
June 1999 / Wimberley Lane, Depoy, Kentucky
As told in the episode, on 8 May 2026.
Accused
Public places are marked on the map.
road
about 0:13:29business
about 0:13:18home
about 0:13:57home
about 0:28:19landmark
about 0:32:52hospital
about 0:41:11church
about 0:31:03school
about 0:29:57school
about 0:20:48school
about 0:20:48other
about 0:59:30body found
about 0:56:24police
about 0:30:08police
about 0:39:41business
about 0:16:56business
about 0:08:04