Town file

Cottonwood, California

Cottonwood, California (Shasta County, California) is the town in one episode of Small Town Murder, the comedy true-crime podcast: episode 292, "A Liar, A Killer & An Idiot" (16 June 2022).

Town
Cottonwood
County
Shasta County
State
California
Country
USA
Episodes
292
Approximate location
35.346, -118.986
N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Episode 292 / 16 June 2022 / 170 min / full

A Liar, A Killer & An Idiot

"Cottonwood, California, and this is in Shasta County, between Redding and Red Bluff inland." about 0:05:35

The case: Murder of Carol Garton (May 16, 1998); Conspiracy to murder Dean Noyes (1996 to 1998). Read the case file.

The figures, as told in 2022

Population
3,280 people
Median household income
$42,000 a year
Median home value
$322,000
Two-bedroom rent
$11.88 a month
Cost of living
$102,000
Religious
27%
Property crime
▼ slightly below
Violent crime
▲ slightly above

History, in brief

  • Cottonwood began as a stagecoach town, a stop on the way to the Gold Rush and the Oregon Trail. about 0:06:16
  • The first post office opened in 1852. about 0:06:27
  • It was established as a settlement in 1849, during the Gold Rush. about 0:06:31
  • In 1849 it was known as a stop for supplies and food before heading up to the Oregon Trail. about 0:06:53
  • It sits between Redding and Red Bluff, inland. about 0:06:44
  • In 1859 a Bavarian immigrant named Jacob Foster purchased 240 acres on the north side of Cottonwood Creek, and that is the town of Cottonwood now. about 0:07:02
  • Foster built a hotel on his land, and the settlement grew into a real town. about 0:07:21
  • In 1872 it became a big shipping point for cattle, lumber and agricultural products from the Sacramento River Valley. about 0:07:33
  • The railroad came through, and the town kept growing. about 0:07:47
  • In 1997 the film Almost Heroes, Chris Farley's last movie, was shot there. about 0:08:57
  • In 1961 Hell is for Heroes, starring Steve McQueen, was filmed there, and it was Bob Newhart's first appearance in anything. about 0:09:10

The reviews read out

5 stars

"A slow pace of life in a small, quaint town; ranchers raise cattle, some have horses, goats, gardens and pets; mountains all around and twenty-five minutes from Shasta and Whiskeytown Lakes; homes sit on acres and Mount Shasta is visible; Holiday Market sells farm-raised beef and chicken, local honey and organic food; no traffic or pavements and five minutes from the freeway."
about 0:10:02

4 stars

"Kind people, good surrounding schools and great teachers, but there are a lot of drug addicts and gang life is huge and it is not very safe; nearby cities are not safe either; cute shops, small-town feel, good sports and weather despite the droughts."
about 0:11:16

Open the episode file

Nearest Small Town Murder towns

Everything here is as told in the episode, on the date it went out; figures and places may have changed since. Endings are covered: open an episode and use the spoiler switch to read them.