Town file

Eufaula, Oklahoma

Eufaula, Oklahoma (McIntosh County, Oklahoma) is the town in one episode of Small Town Murder, the comedy true-crime podcast: episode 24, "Bad Decisions, Deadly Results" (28 June 2017). Robert Pendley, 80, was a Second World War veteran who fought with the 87th Infantry Division in the Battle of the Bulge.

Town
Eufaula
County
McIntosh County
State
Oklahoma
Country
USA
Episodes
24
Approximate location
35.292, -95.586
N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Episode 24 / 28 June 2017 / 65 min / full

Bad Decisions, Deadly Results

"James says they are going to Ufala, Oklahoma, in the eastern central part of the state, and that it is in Macintosh County." about 0:04:03

The case: Murder of Robert and Vivian Pendley (August 1, 1999). Read the case file.

The figures, as told in 2017

Population
2,936
Median age
42.2
Median household income
$33,627
Median home value
$99,000
Two-bedroom rent
$658
Cost of living
88
Religious
42.9%
Property crime
▲ almost double
Violent crime
▼ a good deal lower

History, in brief

  • The town's name comes from the Eufaula tribe of Native Americans, part of the Muscogee Creek Confederacy. about 0:08:04
  • The tribe was driven from the south-east to the area in the 1830s on the Trail of Tears. about 0:08:14
  • Native Americans used the area as a gathering ground and held powwows there. about 0:09:07
  • White settlers began arriving about 1872, after the coming of the railroad. about 0:09:31
  • The town was incorporated in 1898, technically in Indian Territory. about 0:10:01
  • Between 1907 and 1909, after Oklahoma became a state, the McIntosh County Seat War saw Eufaula refuse to hand its county records to Checotah, the designated county seat; armed men from Checotah tried to seize the records from the courthouse and were beaten back in a gunfight. about 0:11:09
  • About a year later Eufaula was designated the permanent county seat. about 0:12:15
  • Lake Eufaula is the largest lake contained entirely within Oklahoma, created by the Eufaula dam. about 0:06:57
  • The lake covers Standing Rock, a historical monument that can only be seen when the water is low. about 0:07:16
  • On September 25th, 1964, President Lyndon Johnson visited to dedicate the Eufaula dam. about 0:12:27
  • The Selman brothers, football players who played at the University of Oklahoma, are from Eufaula. about 0:12:35
  • The television show Dirty Jobs filmed two episodes in Eufaula, one about a worm dung farmer and one about catfish noodling. about 0:13:10
  • The town's slogan is visit for the weekend or stay for a lifetime. about 0:06:20
  • The zip code is 74432 and the area codes are 539 and, more recently, 918. about 0:05:56
  • The town covers about 9.6 square miles, of which about 6.6 square miles is land. about 0:06:04
  • Eufaula is about two hours from Oklahoma City, an hour and a half from Tulsa and 32 miles south of Muskogee. about 0:05:04

Open the episode file

Nearest Small Town Murder towns

Everything here is as told in the episode, on the date it went out; figures and places may have changed since. Endings are covered: open an episode and use the spoiler switch to read them.