Town file

Monticello, Florida

Monticello, Florida (Jefferson County, Florida) is the town in one episode of Small Town Murder, the comedy true-crime podcast: episode 10, "A British Tourist Murdered" (22 March 2017). In September 1993, Gary Collie, a 34-year-old truck driver from Wilson, Bradford, in West Yorkshire, was on holiday in Florida with his girlfriend, Margaret Jagger.

Town
Monticello
County
Jefferson County
State
Florida
Country
USA
Episodes
10
Approximate location
30.542, -83.872
N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Episode 10 / 22 March 2017 / 63 min / full

A British Tourist Murdered

"This week we are in Montecello, Florida ... It's in Jefferson County, which is on the border of Georgia." about 0:02:59

The case: Murder of Gary Collie (September 14, 1993). Read the case file.

The figures, as told in 2017

Population
2,411
Median age
44.2
Median household income
$40,000
Median home value
$90,000
Two-bedroom rent
$680 average
Cost of living
84 out of 100
Religious
62%
Property crime
right about the U.S. average
Violent crime
▲ more than twice the average rate
Killing of a tourist in Florida in the past year
the ninth
Florida tourism industry
$30 billion a year
Florida tourism
20% decline between 1993 and 1995

History, in brief

  • As of 1850 there were only 320 people living in Monticello; by 1860 there were a thousand, after the railroad arrived. about 0:05:04
  • Jefferson County was formed in 1827 and is named after Thomas Jefferson. about 0:06:42
  • Monticello is named after Thomas Jefferson's home, Monticello, though Floridians pronounce it Montecello. about 0:06:52
  • In the 1850s and 1860s the railroad let the town ship cotton, and the land was cleared for cotton fields. about 0:07:59
  • In 1882 William Ceradew brought the first shipment of watermelon seeds to the region. about 0:08:38
  • By the 1920s Jefferson County produced 80% of the world's watermelons. about 0:08:47
  • The courthouse was built in 1908 with one-foot-thick concrete interior walls and is still in use. about 0:09:36
  • The courthouse was modernised for heating and cooling in 1968, but the judge's bench and jury box are original. about 0:09:50
  • Monticello is called the most haunted small town in America, especially the Jefferson County correctional facility. about 0:10:01
  • The Monticello Historic District has 42 nineteenth-century buildings within 27 blocks. about 0:20:16
  • The annual Monticello Watermelon Festival is held outside the Monticello Opera House on June 27th. about 0:20:34

Open the episode file

Nearest Small Town Murder towns

Everything here is as told in the episode, on the date it went out; figures and places may have changed since. Endings are covered: open an episode and use the spoiler switch to read them.