Town file
Monticello, Florida
Monticello, Florida (Jefferson County, Florida) is the town in one episode of Small Town Murder, the comedy true-crime podcast: episode 10, "A British Tourist Murdered" (22 March 2017). In September 1993, Gary Collie, a 34-year-old truck driver from Wilson, Bradford, in West Yorkshire, was on holiday in Florida with his girlfriend, Margaret Jagger.
- Town
- Monticello
- County
- Jefferson County
- State
- Florida
- Country
- USA
- Episodes
- 10
- Approximate location
- 30.542, -83.872
Episode 10 / 22 March 2017 / 63 min / full
A British Tourist Murdered
"This week we are in Montecello, Florida ... It's in Jefferson County, which is on the border of Georgia." about 0:02:59
The case: Murder of Gary Collie (September 14, 1993). Read the case file.
The figures, as told in 2017
- Population
- 2,411
- Median age
- 44.2
- Median household income
- $40,000
- Median home value
- $90,000
- Two-bedroom rent
- $680 average
- Cost of living
- 84 out of 100
- Religious
- 62%
- Property crime
- right about the U.S. average
- Violent crime
- ▲ more than twice the average rate
- Killing of a tourist in Florida in the past year
- the ninth
- Florida tourism industry
- $30 billion a year
- Florida tourism
- 20% decline between 1993 and 1995
History, in brief
- As of 1850 there were only 320 people living in Monticello; by 1860 there were a thousand, after the railroad arrived. about 0:05:04
- Jefferson County was formed in 1827 and is named after Thomas Jefferson. about 0:06:42
- Monticello is named after Thomas Jefferson's home, Monticello, though Floridians pronounce it Montecello. about 0:06:52
- In the 1850s and 1860s the railroad let the town ship cotton, and the land was cleared for cotton fields. about 0:07:59
- In 1882 William Ceradew brought the first shipment of watermelon seeds to the region. about 0:08:38
- By the 1920s Jefferson County produced 80% of the world's watermelons. about 0:08:47
- The courthouse was built in 1908 with one-foot-thick concrete interior walls and is still in use. about 0:09:36
- The courthouse was modernised for heating and cooling in 1968, but the judge's bench and jury box are original. about 0:09:50
- Monticello is called the most haunted small town in America, especially the Jefferson County correctional facility. about 0:10:01
- The Monticello Historic District has 42 nineteenth-century buildings within 27 blocks. about 0:20:16
- The annual Monticello Watermelon Festival is held outside the Monticello Opera House on June 27th. about 0:20:34
Nearest Small Town Murder towns
- Bristol, Florida66 miles
- Donalsonville, Georgia69 miles
- Greenwood, Florida80 miles
- Starke, Florida113 miles
- Daleville, Alabama121 miles
- McIntosh, Florida124 miles
Everything here is as told in the episode, on the date it went out; figures and places may have changed since. Endings are covered: open an episode and use the spoiler switch to read them.