Town file

St. Johnsbury, Vermont

St. Johnsbury, Vermont (Caledonia County, Vermont) is the town in one episode of Small Town Murder, the comedy true-crime podcast: episode 127, "Menage a Nope in St Johnsbury, Vermont" (11 July 2019). St. Johnsbury sits in Caledonia County in the north-east of Vermont, a small town of about 7,375 people, a little below its peak of 9,600 around 1930.

Town
St. Johnsbury
County
Caledonia County
State
Vermont
Country
USA
Episodes
127
Approximate location
44.430, -72.009
N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Episode 127 / 11 July 2019 / 152 min / full

Menage a Nope in St Johnsbury, Vermont

"We're going to St. Johnsbury, Vermont ... It's in Caledonia County." about 0:05:27

The case: Murder of Melissa Jenkins (March 2012). Read the case file.

The figures, as told in 2019

Population
7,375
Median age
44.9
Median household income
about $40,000
Median home value
$141,500
Cost of living
88
Religious
33%
Property crime
▼ about 25% under the average
Violent crime
▼ just above half of the national average
Registered sex offenders
30

History, in brief

  • The town was originally granted in 1760 as part of the New Hampshire grants and named Bestborough. about 0:08:11
  • It was regranted by Vermont in 1786 as Dunmore. about 0:08:24
  • Settlement is dated to 1786. about 0:08:40
  • Early settler Jonathan Arnold was a member of the Continental Congress and wrote Rhode Island's Act of Secession from Great Britain in 1776. about 0:08:42
  • Arnold left Rhode Island in 1787 and, with six other families, built homes in what is now the centre of St. Johnsbury. about 0:08:59
  • By 1790 the settlement had 143 people. about 0:09:10
  • The first town meeting was held in Jonathan Arnold's home, where the town adopted its name. about 0:09:44
  • Ethan Allen proposed naming the town Saint John in honour of his friend Jean de Crèvecoeur, known in America as J. Hector St. John. about 0:10:04
  • The name St. Johnsbury was chosen to distinguish it from St. John in New Brunswick. about 0:11:32
  • In 1916 F. B. Sandborn gave a talk to the Old Planter Society of Salem called Hector St. John, an old evasive planter. about 0:11:45
  • By the mid-1800s the town had manufacturing, including scales; the platform scale was invented there in 1830. about 0:13:15
  • It also produced maple syrup and maple syrup products. about 0:13:23
  • The Boston to Montreal railroad line came through in the 1850s and the town began to grow and became the county seat. about 0:13:38
  • George C. Cary founded the Cary Maple Sugar Company in 1904. about 0:14:05
  • Cary promoted maple syrup for flavouring plug tobacco and as a flavouring agent in cigarettes. about 0:14:10
  • He built a large plant on Portland Street, known as Maple Grove Farms of Vermont. about 0:15:26
  • The company now operates a museum and a sugar house on the site. about 0:15:34
  • St. Johnsbury became known as the maple centre of the world. about 0:15:42
  • The first aeroplane flight in Vermont took place at the fair in St. Johnsbury on April 19th, 1910. about 0:15:57
  • In the 1940s local industries included Fairbanks scales, a maple sugar candy company and a maker of bowling pins. about 0:16:05
  • The town had a population of 7,000 in 1900. about 0:19:43
  • Its peak population was about 9,600 around 1930. about 0:19:54

The reviews read out

one star

"The town is full of empty stores and has a major drug problem; the elementary school is a nightmare because of a serious bully problem, the eight-year-olds are mean, and it is pretty much just a reform town for people who just get out of prison."
about 0:17:03

Open the episode file

Nearest Small Town Murder towns

Everything here is as told in the episode, on the date it went out; figures and places may have changed since. Endings are covered: open an episode and use the spoiler switch to read them.