FILE 150 / 19 December 2019 / 154 MIN / full

A Betrayal Of Hearts & Knives

Rome, GeorgiaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to Rome, Georgia; it's in Floyd County, in northwestern Georgia. about 0:05:19

History, in brief

Town note

The land was originally Cherokee territory; Cherokee leaders Major Ridge and John Ross had plantations here.

about 0:09:21

Town note

Major Ridge's house, the Chieftain's house, is preserved as a museum.

about 0:09:21

Town note

In the 1700s European demand for deer skins brought white traders, who traded with the Cherokee.

about 0:09:51

Town note

Missionaries followed the traders and then more settlers arrived.

about 0:11:26
All 16 history facts

Town note

The land was originally Cherokee territory; Cherokee leaders Major Ridge and John Ross had plantations here.

about 0:09:21

Town note

Major Ridge's house, the Chieftain's house, is preserved as a museum.

about 0:09:21

Town note

In the 1700s European demand for deer skins brought white traders, who traded with the Cherokee.

about 0:09:51

Town note

Missionaries followed the traders and then more settlers arrived.

about 0:11:26

1793

In 1793 a Cherokee raid into Tennessee was answered by a retaliatory raid led by Tennessee governor John Sevier, the Battle of Hightower.

about 0:12:04

1802

In 1802 Georgia gave up its western land claim to the Mississippi River in exchange for removing the Cherokee from the state.

about 0:12:33

1834

The removal edict was not immediately enforced and federal lawsuits tried to stop it; removals began in the early 1830s, about 1834, on the Trail of Tears under Andrew Jackson.

about 0:13:56

Town note

Rome became the county seat; it had previously been in Livingston.

about 0:14:40

Town note

Cotton became the main economy in the 1800s; the cotton gin, developed in the late 1700s, made it more profitable, and the fertile area was called the black belt.

about 0:14:50

1849

In 1849 the railroad reached Rome, running from the Gulf of Mexico north into the rest of the United States.

about 0:15:49

Town note

In the late 1920s a US company built a rayon plant in a joint project with an Italian company.

about 0:16:23

1929

In 1929 Italy honoured Rome, Georgia, and Mussolini sent a replica statue of Romulus and Remus suckling the wolf, which was placed outside the courthouse.

about 0:16:45

Town note

Anti-Italian sentiment during the Second World War led the city commission to move the statue into storage and replace it with an American flag.

about 0:20:26

1952

The statue was returned to the courthouse in 1952.

about 0:20:51

Town note

Coach Dan Reeves, most notably of the Broncos and the Falcons, was from Rome.

about 0:21:52

Town note

Blues singer Ma Rainey, the mother of the blues, and wrestler Arn Anderson were from Rome.

about 0:23:36

The figures, as told

Religious

64%

Biggest faith: Baptist, 39%

about 0:26:13

Who lives here

White 53% · Black 27% · Asian 3% · Hispanic 15%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Violent crime
▲ almost double

about 0:31:39

Property crime
▲ almost double

about 0:31:29

Murders a year in the county
maybe two

about 1:58:50

Money

Median home value$124,600
Two-bedroom rentabout $770 a month
Median household incomeabout $37,500
Cost of living87

For sale

$90,000

Asking price, four-bedroom two-bath house of 1,572 square feet on 2.2 acres

about 0:29:00

For sale

$789,900

Asking price, four-bedroom four-bath house of 4,000 square feet

about 0:29:43
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2019

Violent crime

"almost double"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2019 about 0:31:39

Property crime

"almost double"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2019 about 0:31:29

Murders a year in the county

"maybe two"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 1:58:50

Population

"36,029"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:24:13

Population growth

"up 19%"

Comparison: "since 1992". Direction: above.

As told in 2019 about 0:24:22

Median age

"about 35"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:24:27

Married population

"about 45%"

Comparison: "lower than normal". Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:24:47

Single with no children

"15%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:25:03

White

"53%"

Comparison: "usually about 61%". No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:25:09

Black

"27%"

Comparison: "a little over twice the average". Direction: above.

As told in 2019 about 0:25:09

Asian

"3%"

Comparison: "under the average". Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:25:09

Hispanic

"15%"

Comparison: "close to the average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:09

Unemployment

"under five percent"

Comparison: "higher than the rest of the country". Direction: above.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:57

Median household income

"about $37,500"

Comparison: "about $57,500 nationally". No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:27:07

People making under $15,000 a year

"20%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:27:13

People making under $30,000 a year

"38%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:27:17

Floyd County Democrat vote

"26%"

Comparison: "69% Republican, 4% independent". No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:46

Religious

"64%"

Comparison: "way over the average". Direction: above.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:13

Catholic

"about 5%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:26:27

Cost of living

"87"

Comparison: "100 is the average". Direction: below.

As told in 2019 about 0:28:02

Housing cost

"62"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:28:05

Median home cost

"$124,600"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:28:11

Average two-bedroom rent

"about $770 a month"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:28:31

Asking price, four-bedroom two-bath house of 1,572 square feet on 2.2 acres

"$90,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:29:00

Asking price, two-bedroom one-bath fixer-upper of 1,338 square feet

"$25,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:29:00

Asking price, four-bedroom four-bath house of 4,000 square feet

"$789,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2019 about 0:29:43

The reviews

No rated reviews

No reviews recorded.

In Georgia

Closest episodes

  1. Madness Of A Murderous ManiacSummerville, Georgia · 22 May 202528 km / 17 miShow on map
  2. The Alabama ZodiacJacksonville, Alabama · 4 November 202173 km / 45 miShow on map
  3. He's Dead... Where's My Beer?Fort Oglethorpe, Georgia · 29 April 202274 km / 46 miShow on map
  4. A Perverted MindVinings, Georgia · 1 April 202380 km / 50 miShow on map
  5. The Murder DanceSection, Alabama · 5 January 202381 km / 50 miShow on map

The story

Rome, Georgia, lies in Floyd County in the north-west corner of the state, roughly an hour and ten minutes from Atlanta. Her parents divorced while she was at elementary school and her father died when she was thirteen, leaving her the youngest of three children and the only girl, doted on by her mother and two older brothers. She was a pretty, outgoing cheerleader at Pepperell High School. In 1985 she spotted Thad Reynolds, the football player who wore number 15, and the two became the golden couple of their year. Their first date was a tractor pull in Atlanta followed by dinner at his family's house, where nerves made her sick. In January 1986 he gave her his class ring; ten minutes later, as they watched television, the space shuttle Challenger exploded. They were homecoming king and queen, graduated in 1986 and married on 15 August 1986 at Hollywood Baptist Church, choosing the date because it matched his football number. They were barely out of school.

Within two years they had bought a house, a camcorder and a cruise, and in March 1991 their first daughter, Olivia, was born. The marriage was less happy than it looked. Thad took it badly. He rented a small apartment, sat in the dark in a closet praying for his wife to return, and stood up in church asking the congregation to pray for the same thing. In 1997, after four years apart, they went to counselling and remarried, repeating the wedding at Hollywood Baptist Church with their daughter present. Church members helped them build a house on the same plot of land as Thad's parents, and three more daughters followed.

Thad worked his way up to district manager at Frito-Lay. He sang in the church choir, served as a deacon, and told people his real ambition was to be a missionary. The family homeschooled the girls to shield them from the secular world.

A plan to buy a resort in Gatlinburg, Tennessee, fell through when a higher offer arrived, and Thad returned from a missionary trip to Cuba wanting to quit his job and 'see where Jesus leads me'. They exchanged emails, including explicit ones, and talked about running away to Portland, Oregon, using the city as a code word in front of other people.

Her language became less direct and more pointed. On Friday 2 July he waited outside a restaurant for Thad but could not go through with it. On the Sunday evening before the murder he emailed her to 'stop me if you have any hesitations'; she replied that she was ready, told him to be observant of his surroundings and careful, and said she could not wait to be his bride.

Before dawn on Monday 5 July 2004 a driver arriving at the Frito-Lay distribution centre in Rome saw a man in the doorway of the office, then watched him take off his shirt beside a red minivan and drive away. Inside, the employee found Thad Reynolds on the floor, stabbed about nineteen times. He was pronounced dead at 6.27 a.m. There was blood inside and outside the entrance. The weapon was gone, a sheath from a hunting knife lay near where the minivan had been, and a pair of prescription glasses lay on the floor. The sheriff said the county normally had about two murders a year.

He said he had injured the hand lifting weights and had left the glasses at the gym. He drove a burgundy minivan. A man who worked on the phone systems at Floyd Medical Center then called the detectives. He monitored the hospital's email and calls as part of his job, had watched the affair develop for months, and handed over the emails after hearing that police were looking for a burgundy van. The emails had not been deleted. He denied the affair. When Page asked whether he knew anything about the murder, he replied, 'Do you realise what you're asking me?' He agreed to a search of his van.

Security footage from Kmart showed him buying the knife. Thad's parents took in the four girls, who were thirteen, seven, five and two.

They talked about getting married and asked each other how Portland was this time of year. Police also learned that Thad's insurance policy would pay her about $250,000.

In 2008 the evidence was admitted. In her statement she said that morally she was responsible because without the affair none of it would have happened.

In September 2014 a judge allowed her eldest daughter, by then over eighteen, to visit her if she wished; the younger three were barred until they turned eighteen.

The case

Murder of Thad Reynolds

Victims

Thad Reynolds (36). Frito-Lay district manager, husband of and father of four daughters

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 19 December 2019.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Olivia Reynolds. Thad and eldest daughter
Thad's parents. took in the four girls after the murder
Hollywood Baptist Church pastor. told to get a lawyer and turn himself in
Floyd Medical Center phone systems worker. monitored the emails and reported the affair to police

The timeline

  1. 1969 is born in Georgiaabout 0:32:43
  2. when was in elementary school Her parents divorceabout 0:34:40
  3. when was 13 Her father diesabout 0:34:46
  4. 1985 Cheerleader meets Thad, the football player who wears number 15 (Pepperell High School)about 0:41:12
  5. late 1985 into 1986 Their first date is a tractor pull in Atlanta followed by dinner at his family's houseabout 0:44:57
  6. January 28th, 1986 Thad gives his class ring; ten minutes later they watch the Challenger explodeabout 0:49:40
  7. 1986 They graduate from high school (Pepperell High School)about 0:53:35
  8. August 15th, 1986 They marry, choosing the date for his football number (Hollywood Baptist Church)about 0:53:49
  9. late 1988 They have bought a house, a camcorder and a cruise, and start trying for children (Reynolds house)about 0:58:35
  10. March 1991 Their daughter Olivia is bornabout 0:59:25
  11. 1993 files for divorceabout 1:03:05
  12. after the divorce Thad prays in a closet for his wife's return and asks the congregation to pray for itabout 1:08:19
  13. 1997 After four years apart they go to counselling and remarry at the same church (Hollywood Baptist Church)about 1:09:17
  14. after the remarriage Church members help them build a house on his parents' land, and they have three more daughters (Reynolds house)about 1:12:52
  15. about 2004 wants to buy a Gatlinburg resort; a higher offer takes it first (Gatlinburg resort property)about 1:27:50
  16. 2004 Thad returns from a missionary trip to Cuba and wants to quit his job to follow Jesusabout 1:30:53
  17. 2004 tells she has naughty thoughts about him and he says the sameabout 1:32:19
  18. 2004 Thad hears God on Christian radio and gives his last $35 to the stationabout 1:33:23
  19. 2004 Thad tells to stay away from about 1:37:46
  20. 2004 sends explicit emails including pages from the Kama Sutraabout 1:39:43
  21. 2004 On a shared camping trip loses Thad's hunting knifeabout 1:41:06
  22. the summer of 2004 and first have sex in her SUV in the hospital car park (Floyd Medical Center)about 1:41:42
  23. 2004 The affair continues in motels and cars while they plan to run away to Portlandabout 1:42:42
  24. July 1st, 2004 buys a replacement hunting knife at Kmart (Kmart)about 1:51:48
  25. July 2nd, 2004 waits outside a restaurant for Thad but cannot confront himabout 1:52:12
  26. July 4th weekend, 2004 At the family gathering Page criticises tank top; emails Thad's Monday location to about 1:54:19
  27. Sunday, July 4th, 2004 writes 'stop me if you have any hesitations'; replies that she is ready and cannot wait to be his brideabout 2:13:36
  28. July 5th, 2004 Before dawn Thad is found stabbed about 19 times and is pronounced dead at 6.27 a.m. (Frito-Lay distribution center)about 1:56:54

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode