FILE 599 / 22 May 2025 / 184 MIN / full

Madness Of A Murderous Maniac

Summerville, GeorgiaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Somerville, Georgia. This is in northwest Georgia, way up in the corner... This is in Chattuga County. about 0:04:43

History, in brief

1838

Founded in 1838 as the seat of the newly formed Chattooga County.

about 0:05:47

1939

Incorporated as a town in 1939 and as a city in 1909.

about 0:06:00

Town note

Named Summerville because it was a popular summer resort.

about 0:06:05

Town note

A lot of Civil War action happened around here; James says the march to the sea started with Summerville.

about 0:06:18
All 7 history facts

1838

Founded in 1838 as the seat of the newly formed Chattooga County.

about 0:05:47

1939

Incorporated as a town in 1939 and as a city in 1909.

about 0:06:00

Town note

Named Summerville because it was a popular summer resort.

about 0:06:05

Town note

A lot of Civil War action happened around here; James says the march to the sea started with Summerville.

about 0:06:18

1863

The biggest battle was the Battle of Trion Factory, fought in September 1863 where present-day First Street is, near the site of the East Trion Church of God.

about 0:06:34

2009

In 2009 the Chattooga County Camp 507, Sons of Confederate Veterans, the Missionary Ridge Camp 63, Sons of Union Veterans, and local groups erected a memorial to the first battle of Trion Factory and the soldiers in unmarked graves from both sides.

about 0:06:55

Town note

A Confederate general, brother-in-law to Mary Todd Lincoln, fought here and was killed five days after the Battle of Trion Factory at Chickamauga.

about 0:07:42

The figures, as told

Religious

under 50%

Biggest faith: Baptist, 33%

about 0:13:02

Who lives here

White 76.5% · Black 21.2% · Hispanic 1.3%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ about half the national average

about 0:20:19

Violent crime
▼ about one quarter of the national average

about 0:20:32

Money

Median home value$152,300
Two-bedroom rent$760 a month
Median household income$23,827
Cost of livingabout $72

For sale

$24,000

Two-bedroom one-bath trailer, 672 square feet, on an acre and a half

about 0:14:59

For sale

$525,000

Four-bedroom four-bath house, 3,559 square feet, on 1.8 acres

about 0:15:30

For sale

$1.2 million

Four-bedroom five-bath house, 2,952 square feet, on 56 acres

about 0:15:59
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Property crime

"about half the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:20:19

Violent crime

"about one quarter of the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:20:32

Population

"4,389"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:02

Women

"54%"

Comparison: "well out of whack of anything we usually see". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:09

Median age

"about 41"

Comparison: "a couple of years over the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:16

Married

"36%"

Comparison: "well under the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:44

Single with children

"30%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:12:44

Religious

"under 50%"

Comparison: "surprising for rural Georgia". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:02

Unemployment

"slightly below the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:18

Median household income

"$23,827"

Comparison: "almost $70,000 in the U.S.". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:27

Cost of living

"about $72"

Comparison: "average $100". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:38

Median home cost

"$152,300"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:41

Average two-bedroom rent

"$760 a month"

Comparison: "about half the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:09

Two-bedroom one-bath trailer, 672 square feet, on an acre and a half

"$24,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:59

Four-bedroom four-bath house, 3,559 square feet, on 1.8 acres

"$525,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:15:30

Four-bedroom five-bath house, 2,952 square feet, on 56 acres

"$1.2 million"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:15:59

The reviews

2.7 / 5 · average of 3

4 stars

“A very small community where everyone knows everyone, with very limited activities because of how small it is; many people ride through without a glance, but it will always be the reviewer's beloved hometown.”
about 0:08:21

3 stars

“An old town of around 4,000 people; the reviewer's mother's family lives there and it was home after his parents' divorce; after 12 years he enjoys having family close, but the roads in his predominantly black neighbourhood are full of potholes while nicer neighbourhoods are paved smooth.”
about 0:08:52

1 star

“Summerville should be graveled over and fenced off like an old factory so the crackheads cannot get in; it is a filter point on the Olazapine Trail, the river is incredibly polluted and the reviewer has been an unfortunate resident for two years.”
about 0:09:57

In Georgia

Closest episodes

  1. A Betrayal Of Hearts & KnivesRome, Georgia · 19 December 201928 km / 17 miShow on map
  2. He's Dead... Where's My Beer?Fort Oglethorpe, Georgia · 29 April 202251 km / 32 miShow on map
  3. You Want One Of Her Bones?Whiteside, Tennessee · 4 February 202159 km / 37 miShow on map
  4. The Murder DanceSection, Alabama · 5 January 202359 km / 37 miShow on map
  5. Brutal IdiocyGadsden, Alabama · 7 March 202681 km / 50 miShow on map

The story

His father served 19 years in the US Army before settling in Ohio to work at the Ford plant in Sandusky, and the family lived in New London. In 1979 he enlisted in the Army in Cleveland, trained as a motor transport operator and joined the 102nd Quartermaster Company, earning a citation for delivering aviation fuel to the 101st Airborne Division. He was honourably discharged in August 1985.

On 11 October 1985 he married Sherry Jane Brown, and their daughter Crystal was born in February 1986. The marriage turned violent.

He lived on disability and Social Security, mostly around Norwalk and Greenwich, Ohio, and passed through at least nine mental hospitals and clinics in about a decade. He checked himself in voluntarily and left when he chose, so doctors told his family they could not hold him. He said his apartment was bugged, that satellites controlled his alarm clock and his mind, that a banshee beamed thoughts into his head, that federal agents had set fire to his apartment, that his sperm was being extracted and implanted in women around the world, and that people in town were trying to bite off his penis. In November 1998 he told Greenwich police chief Randall Kilgore that something evil had a hold of him; the same day he had been found sitting in the mayor's new Lincoln Town Car. On Christmas Day 1998 he followed a driver from Utica to Nick's Saloon in Newark, Ohio, and told officers the reason was top secret.

In the summer of 1999 he dated Cheryl Jones for about three months. She broke it off in July, and in late August or early September she introduced him to Patricia Ann Booher, who was born in 1975 and lived in the same complex at Firelands Village in Norwalk. Patricia had grown up in a trailer near Olena, Ohio, had been repeatedly molested as a child, and was under the care of Huron County Human Services, classified as mildly retarded. She volunteered at the Salvation Army, a soup kitchen and a food bank, and in January 2000 she was five weeks pregnant.

They broke up and reconciled repeatedly in the last two weeks of 1999. She gave the ring back on 13 January 2000, and three days later he told his aunt that an angel was talking to him. On 19 January he sold a Winchester 12-gauge shotgun for $150. On 20 January he visited Norwalk police sergeant David Light, a friend, and said a doctor had taken him off some medication; the drugs stopped included Haldol, Cogentin and Prozac, all of which had been taken three times a day. On 21 January Patricia learned at a clinic that she was pregnant and was happy about it.

At three o'clock on the morning of 22 January he visited a cousin of his ex-wife and said the government had planted a bug in his head, that he had great demonic powers and that the police were trying to take them away. Hours later he and Patricia left Ohio for Winter Haven, Florida, to visit his parents. She took only a coat and purse; he had a few dollars and two long knives in the back seat. They spent the night of 22 January in the car in a motel car park in Chattanooga, Tennessee, in freezing rain.

On the morning of Sunday 23 January 2000 they crossed into Georgia. He then followed a woman in a green Nissan Maxima to her driveway and told her they were lost.

On County Road 641 near Mentone, Alabama, he rammed the back of a pickup driven by Rhea Perch. Her husband Donald, 52, who had broken three ribs on New Year's Day, got out to exchange insurance details. Rhea ran to the highway for help. He stabbed James in the abdomen without warning, grabbed Sue by the collar and stabbed both of the couple's chocolate Labradors to death. James survived a five-inch wound.

Mentone police chief Jeff Bain spotted the Lincoln, and at the junction of U.S. Highway 11 and Alabama 117 officers Johnny Ferguson and Wayne Wooten boxed it in at gunpoint. Wooten found Patricia's body in the passenger seat, seatbelt fastened, her clothing arranged over a gaping chest wound. Her throat had been cut from ear to ear, her heart and liver removed, her eyes taken out, her left hand cut off at the wrist and her right leg cut off at the knee. Her hand, heart and liver lay on the floorboard.

He told investigators that he was a Secret Service agent with badge number 666, on a top secret mission to terminate a double agent and black witch, that he had cut off her hand and leg so that she could not come back at him, and that voices from a satellite implant behind his left ear had directed the whole rampage. A surveillance tape placed the couple in a discount food mart outside Trion, Georgia, at 2.24 p.m.; the killing is thought to have happened in the car park there at about 2.36 p.m. The car was covered in blood, with 12 cuts in the front seat upholstery.

He lost more than half his body weight in custody. In 2003 a deputy bought the Lincoln at the county auction.

The case

Murder of Patricia Ann Booher

Victims

Patricia Ann Booher. girlfriend, born 1975; 4 ft 10 in and 105 pounds; classified as mildly retarded and under the care of Huron County Human Services; five weeks pregnant

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 22 May 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Sherry Jane Brown. first wife, married October 1985; divorced March 1989 after domestic violence
Crystal. daughter with Sherry, four years old in 1989
Leonard Brown. Sherry's brother, threatened by
Teresa Goebel. second wife, married June 1991; separated but never divorced
Cheryl Jones. girlfriend in 1999; broke up with him and introduced him to Patricia
Charlene. Patricia's sister
Donald Perch. run down and dragged more than 200 yards on the hood of the Lincoln; survived with broken legs, knee and wrists
Rhea Perch. Donald's wife, driving the pickup that rammed
James Pumphrey. stabbed in the abdomen at his home; survived; both of his dogs were killed
Sue Pumphrey. James's wife; held off with a .22 rifle
David Light. Norwalk police sergeant and friend, named by him as his Secret Service supervisor
Mike Ruggles. Norwalk police chief and friend
Randall Kilgore. Greenwich police chief
Hoyt Baugh. court-appointed lawyer
Joanne Bloodheart. neighbour who said controlled Patricia's every move
Cecil Reed. DeKalb County sheriff
Jeff Bain. Mentone police chief who spotted the Lincoln
Johnny Ferguson. Mentone police chief at the roadblock
Wayne Wooten. Valley Head assistant chief who found Patricia's body
James Harris. Georgia Bureau of Investigation agent
Jimmy Harris. sheriff's department lieutenant

The timeline

  1. March 28th, 1962 is born, the second of three sons of Howard and Magdalena .about 0:21:02
  2. 1979 He enlists in the Army in Cleveland and is trained as a motor transport operator.about 0:25:29
  3. 1979 to August 1981 Assigned to the 102nd Quartermaster Company, he delivers aviation fuel to the 101st Airborne Division and receives a citation for meritorious performance.about 0:26:22
  4. August 1985 He is honourably discharged from the Army.about 0:28:04
  5. October 11th, 1985 He marries Sherry Jane Brown.about 0:30:45
  6. February 1986 Their daughter Crystal is born.about 0:30:50
  7. March 20th, 1989 Sherry returns to the police station after threatens her brother Leonard, and reports that he said he would have the child taken away. (Norwalk Police Department)about 0:33:50
  8. March 29th, 1989 The divorce is granted; Sherry keeps custody and is given visitation rights.about 0:37:41
  9. April 12th, 1989 An agreement is filed allowing visitation on alternate weekends and holidays.about 0:37:50
  10. July 5th, 1989 A woman reports that her 1985 Ford pickup was damaged during a fight between and another man downtown.about 0:40:17
  11. June 1991 He marries Teresa Goebel; they later separate but never divorce.about 0:42:55
  12. December 1991 At the Dreamland Motel he threatens to cut up a clerk's mail and says he will kill a foreigner when it gets dark. (Dreamland Motel)about 0:40:52
  13. 1997 His father calls a doctor about being discharged from a mental hospital and is told he admitted himself and must be let go.about 0:45:24
  14. 1997 He tells a counsellor his apartment is bugged, that he was given truth serum in a shot and in candy, and that people are out to get him.about 0:48:01
  15. February 1998 During a hospital stay he says satellites control his alarm clock and his mind and that people in town are trying to bite off his penis.about 0:49:45
  16. November 17th, 1998 He stares at Greenwich police chief Randall Kilgore in a grocery store and then tells him something evil has a hold of him; the mayor finds him sitting in his new Lincoln. (Greenwich police office)about 0:50:53
  17. December 1998 He tells psychiatrists that a banshee is beaming thoughts into his head.about 0:53:45
  18. Christmas Day, 1998, about 11.30 p.m. Police in Newark, Ohio, answer a man with a gun call at Nick's Saloon; has followed a driver from Utica and says his reason is top secret, and he is taken for a psychological evaluation. (Nick's Saloon)about 0:54:55
  19. March 1999 Still in treatment, he tells a doctor that voices told him to urinate in his milk and drink it to cure lice he did not have.about 0:56:16
  20. Spring 1999 He has a mental breakdown, smoking cannabis with his prescription drugs; his apartment catches fire and he is taken to hospital with a burned arm and then transferred for psychiatric care.about 0:57:11
  21. July 1999 Cheryl Jones breaks up with him after about three months of dating.about 1:01:58
  22. August 1999 Cheryl Jones accuses him of calling her and threatening to kill her; police tell both parties to stay away from each other.about 1:03:38
  23. Late August or early September 1999 He starts dating Patricia Ann Booher, who lives in the same apartment complex at Firelands Village. (Firelands Village Apartments)about 1:04:18
  24. December 1999 He visits Leonard Brown's house talking about being on a mission, gives Patricia an engagement ring and becomes increasingly controlling.about 1:16:17
  25. Before Christmas 1999 Patricia breaks up with him, then reconciles after he talks her round; they break up and get back together about five times in the last two weeks of the year.about 1:18:53
  26. January 13th, 2000 Patricia gives the ring back and breaks up with him, returns to the Friendship Club and starts selling Avon.about 1:20:07
  27. January 16th, 2000 He tells his aunt that an angel is talking to him and that Patty gave the ring back and then wanted to make love.about 1:20:55
  28. January 19th, 2000 He sells a Winchester 12-gauge shotgun to a store called The Outdoorsman for $150. (The Outdoorsman)about 2:06:28
  29. January 20th, 2000 Patricia checks out books on relationships, depression and babies from the Norwalk Public Library. (Norwalk Public Library)about 2:05:38
  30. January 20th, 2000 He visits Sergeant David Light at the Norwalk police station, saying a doctor at a veterans facility in Cleveland has taken him off some medication. (Norwalk Police Department)about 1:23:16
  31. January 21st, 2000 Patricia is tested at a clinic and learns she is pregnant; she is happy and makes plans for parenting counselling.about 1:25:33
  32. January 22nd, 2000, 3 a.m. He visits a cousin of his ex-wife and says the government and police have planted a bug in his head, that they want him to murder someone, and that he has great demonic powers.about 1:26:29
  33. January 22nd, 2000 He and Patricia leave Ohio for Winter Haven, Florida; she takes only a coat and purse and he has two long knives in the back seat. They spend the night in the car in a motel car park in Chattanooga, Tennessee, in freezing rain.about 1:28:47
  34. January 23rd, 2000, about 7.30 a.m. They pull into the Burger King drive-through in Summerville, Georgia, where he asks about a trade day and the way to the I-59 flea market in Alabama. (Burger King)about 1:31:51
  35. January 23rd, 2000, morning He follows a woman in a green Nissan Maxima into her driveway and tells her, when she asks, that they are lost.about 1:33:59
  36. January 23rd, 2000, about 10.30 a.m. Two women walking up the road find the Lincoln stopped with its hazard lights on; he says he is letting the transmission cool down and Patricia has been crying.about 1:35:33
  37. January 23rd, 2000 On County Road 641 near Mentone he rams the Perches' pickup, runs Donald Perch down and drags him more than 200 yards on the hood before throwing him into a ditch. (County Road 641)about 1:38:18
  38. January 23rd, 2000 He stabs James Pumphrey in the abdomen at his mobile home, grabs Sue Pumphrey and stabs both of their dogs to death; the couple hold him off with a .22 rifle that jams. (Pumphrey mobile home)about 1:45:53
  39. January 23rd, 2000 He drives back at the crowd around Donald Perch, smashes into a tractor and swerves at the people before racing down Highway 117. (Highway 117)about 1:53:49
  40. January 23rd, 2000 Patricia's body is found in the passenger seat of the Lincoln, mutilated; a six-inch section of her esophagus is in shirt pocket and he tries to eat it. (Junction of U.S. Highway 11 and Alabama 117)about 1:59:29

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode