FILE 161 / 5 March 2020 / 135 MIN / full

Killing On Consignment

Nashville, MichiganListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going all the way to Michigan. Nashville, Michigan... This is in Barry County, B-A-R-R-Y. about 0:05:29

History, in brief

1836

The initial plot of Nashville was purchased by John R. Pettibone in 1836.

about 0:07:13

1865

In 1865 a later owner platted 127 lots on the south side of the Thorn Apple River.

about 0:07:15

1865

Solomon Fainer got the sawmill running about 1865 and then sold it.

about 0:07:50

Town note

A gristmill followed, and the town grew around its grain elevator.

about 0:08:01
All 9 history facts

1836

The initial plot of Nashville was purchased by John R. Pettibone in 1836.

about 0:07:13

1865

In 1865 a later owner platted 127 lots on the south side of the Thorn Apple River.

about 0:07:15

1865

Solomon Fainer got the sawmill running about 1865 and then sold it.

about 0:07:50

Town note

A gristmill followed, and the town grew around its grain elevator.

about 0:08:01

1873

In 1873 a grain elevator was built alongside the railroad.

about 0:08:28

1916

In 1916 the flour mill sold what was called red-eye flour.

about 0:08:58

1869

In 1869 the town still had no name; Garudius Nash suggested his own name, and Nashville was the compromise.

about 0:09:59

Town note

Nashville was used as a halfway stopping point between the Jackson and Grand Rapids Railroad terminals.

about 0:10:16

1920

Before 1920 trains stopped overnight in Hastings and needed a hostler to tend the locomotives.

about 0:10:55

The figures, as told

Religious

23%

Biggest faith: Jewish, 0.0%

about 0:16:00

Who lives here

White 90% · Black 0.0% · Asian 0.1% · Hispanic 3.3%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ about one third under the national average

about 0:29:01

Violent crime
▲ almost double the national average

about 0:29:21

Money

Median home value$107,000
Two-bedroom rent$900 a month
Median household income$34,000 and change
Cost of livingabout 84
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2020

Property crime

"about one third under the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2020 about 0:29:01

Violent crime

"almost double the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2020 about 0:29:21

Population

"1,719"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:14:41

Population change

"up 4%"

Comparison: "since 1990". Direction: above.

As told in 2020 about 0:14:51

Female

"about 51%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:14:57

Median age

"about 34"

Comparison: "national average almost 38". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:14:59

Married

"about 48%"

Comparison: "usually 50-50". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:15:15

Religious

"23%"

Comparison: "usually 50% in the country". Direction: below.

As told in 2020 about 0:16:00

Unemployment

"barely over 4%"

Comparison: "higher than normal in the rest of the country". Direction: above.

As told in 2020 about 0:16:47

Median household income

"$34,000 and change"

Comparison: "almost $58,000 in the rest of the country". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:17:02

People making under $30,000 a year

"44%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:17:04

Manufacturing jobs

"31%"

Comparison: "usually about 10%". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:17:50

Cost of living

"about 84"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: below.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:42

Housing

"46 out of 100"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: below.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:48

Median home cost

"$107,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:18:50

Houses built before 1939

"55%"

Comparison: "15% in the rest of the country". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:19:02

Average home age

"78 years"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:19:11

Houses worth under $100,000

"about 70%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:19:27

Average two-bedroom rent

"$900 a month"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:21:18

Foreclosure listing

"$45,200"

Comparison: "three-bedroom, two-bath, 2,300 square feet". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:21:47

Three-bedroom family home

"$145,000"

Comparison: "two-bath, 1,622 square feet". No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:22:00

181-acre lot

"$149,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2020 about 0:22:16

The reviews

2.3 / 5 · average of 3

3 stars

“There are no big businesses, some mom-and-pop shops have poor service, but the restaurants are good; the best are Shirley's Chuck Wagon and R&D's Streetside Pizzeria. The grocery store, the only one between Nashville and Vermontville, has okay prices and very polite staff.”
about 0:11:32

2 stars

“A former resident would never recommend travelling there except for the ice cream from Mooville, which is the best the reviewer has found anywhere and the only bright spot in a run-down town.”
about 0:12:22

2 stars

“There are not many jobs available, and when there are openings it takes a long time for employers to get back to applicants.”
about 0:12:58

In Michigan

Closest episodes

  1. A Messy Web Of DeathHastings, Michigan · 22 July 202117 km / 11 miShow on map
  2. Sibling Death RivalryKalamazoo Township, Michigan · 9 May 202455 km / 34 miShow on map
  3. I Killed The Devil... You're WelcomeJackson, Michigan · 1 August 201969 km / 43 miShow on map
  4. Jeepers Creepers MurderColdwater, Michigan · 18 July 202573 km / 45 miShow on map
  5. A Seriously Crazy CuisineMorrice, Michigan · 29 June 202379 km / 49 miShow on map

The story

In 1985, in the rural country west of Nashville, Michigan, a passer-by saw what looked like an animal carcass beside a dirt track off Bevan's Road. It was the body of a small man, 5 feet 7 inches and 125 pounds, with a tattoo of a housefly on his arm. He had been killed by a close-range shotgun blast to the chest. His money and keys were still on him, and his car was later found at a bar in Potterville.

The story went back to May 1982, when Rodney came home on leave from the Army and stayed with his mother. Rodney met Cora, who was three years older and already had a toddler.

The household was already troubled. When Rodney moved in, the two men competed for Brian's attention. Cora later gave birth to a second son, Brad, who was not Rodney's child, and Rodney loved him as his own.

Early in 1985 Cora asked her mother to mediate.

Brian found their list of apartments and gave it to his grandmother.

On 2 October 1985 a man calling himself Rich Hoover telephoned Rodney and offered him 80 dollars for four hours' work unloading a truck. The meeting was set for the following evening at a bar in Potterville, then moved back a night because of supposed truck trouble.

On 3 October 1985 Rodney left home at about 7.30 in the evening. He also told Oswald that a child abuser was going to be picked up and 'bumped off and snuffed out'. The next day he went to Florida to collect a truck trailer, giving himself an alibi out of state.

He pulled off on to a country road, but instead of the toolbox he produced a sawed-off shotgun. This was the way grandma wants things done,' and shot him in the chest. He then left the body beside the road.

Rodney did not come home. Cora telephoned the bar and was told that his car was in the car park but that no one had seen him. On 6 October a passer-by found the body. The housefly tattoo identified him. Mary Fancher said later that when she heard her son still had his money and keys, and that his car was at the Blinker Light bar, she knew it was 'a setup job, a real grudge job'.

For weeks the police searched for a man called Rich Hoover, or Jim Hoover, or Hoovy. No such person existed. James Oswald then came forward. The motorcycle used as part of the payment belonged to him.

The judge said that in all his years on the bench he had never seen such a senseless killing, calling it cold and calculated.

By then the shotgun had been found. The gun had been fired so close to Rodney that plastic wadding was found in the chest wound, and the marks on the wadding matched the jagged end of the sawn-off barrel. Sergeant Millard Holton made the comparison, but he had been injured when a cider press tipped over on him, so another officer repeated the tests and testified.

The case

Murder of Rodney Fancher

Victims

Rodney Fancher. Army veteran, 5 feet 7 inches and 125 pounds, with an eighth-grade education; lived with his mother, Mary, and was dating Cora .

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 5 March 2020.

Accused

Accused

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Brad. Cora's second son, born while she was with Rodney; not Rodney's child.
Mary Fancher. Rodney's mother, who lived next door to the s.
James Oswald. friend in Bay City; owner of the motorcycle used as collateral, who went to the police.
Rhonda Howlett. cellmate, who testified that admitted the killing.
Catherine Wright. cellmate, who testified about admissions.
Millard Holton. State police sergeant who matched the shotgun wadding to the sawn-off barrel.

The timeline

  1. 1939 is born.about 0:34:29
  2. 1978 Cora son Brian is born.about 0:37:28
  3. 1979 and return to Michigan to bury Jennifer and be near family. (Michigan)about 0:39:16
  4. 1982 The family moves to Lansing, Michigan. (Lansing)about 0:38:12
  5. May 1982 Rodney Fancher, on leave from the Army, comes home to stay with his mother next door to the s. (Mary Fancher's house)about 0:40:27
  6. 1982 Rodney meets Cora , who is three years older and has a young son, Brian. (Lansing)about 0:44:01
  7. Seven months later, early 1983 Rodney is discharged from the Army and moves into the crowded house. ( house)about 0:44:22
  8. 1983 Cora gives birth to a second son, Brad, who is not Rodney's child. (Lansing)about 0:55:52
  9. June or July 1984 and move to a small town near Lansing. (small town near Lansing)about 0:49:16
  10. Early 1985 Cora asks to mediate the dispute over how much time and spend with Brian. ( house)about 0:51:04
  11. Summer 1985 and speak on the telephone almost every day to complain about Rodney.about 0:58:35
  12. Late September or October 1985 Cora and Rodney secretly look for an apartment.about 0:54:39
  13. Early October 1985 Brian finds the apartment list and gives it to , who realises they plan to leave. ( house)about 0:54:57
  14. October 2, 1985 A man calling himself Rich Hoover telephones Rodney and offers him 80 dollars for four hours' work unloading a truck.about 1:05:00
  15. October 3, 1985 Rodney leaves at about 7.30 p.m. to meet the man at the Blinker Light bar in Potterville. (Blinker Light bar)about 1:05:46
  16. October 3, 1985 proposes a toast at 8.30 p.m. at a Bay City bar to establish his alibi and tells James Oswald a child abuser is going to be killed. (Bay City bar)about 1:09:42
  17. October 3, 1985 picks Rodney up at the bar, smokes a joint with him, pulls off the road and shoots him in the chest with a sawed-off shotgun. (Dirt road off Bevan's Road)about 1:16:37
  18. October 4, 1985 Rodney fails to come home; Cora calls the bar and is told his car is in the car park but he has not been seen. (Blinker Light bar)about 1:12:07
  19. October 6, 1985 A passer-by finds Rodney's body beside a dirt road off Bevan's Road. (Dirt road off Bevan's Road)about 0:34:21

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode