FILE 614 / 18 July 2025 / 74 MIN / express

Jeepers Creepers Murder

Coldwater, MichiganListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to Michigan this week ... this is in Coldwater, Michigan, one word ... this is in Branch County about 0:02:15

History, in brief

1829

Branch County was laid out in 1829; in 1830 towns including Coldwater, Bronson and Quincy began springing up.

about 0:04:00

1842

Masonville was the first county seat; Coldwater competed for it and won it in 1842.

about 0:04:25
All 2 history facts

1829

Branch County was laid out in 1829; in 1830 towns including Coldwater, Bronson and Quincy began springing up.

about 0:04:00

1842

Masonville was the first county seat; Coldwater competed for it and won it in 1842.

about 0:04:25

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$178,700
Median household income$45,021
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"13,764"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:03:12

Median household income

"$45,021"

Comparison: "national average of about $69,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:03:27

Median home cost

"$178,700"

Comparison: "about half the rest of the country". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:03:30

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 4

5 stars

“Such a great town, family friendly, proud to have grown up here; you can walk a couple of blocks to a friend's house and it feels like home even when home is far away.”
about 0:04:55

5 stars

“Small town, great for raising a family, country living with a lot of nature, low crime rates and a sense of security.”
about 0:05:36

1 star

“Coldwater is trash: city officials are incompetent, the town is going to be the weed hub of the state, the money is squandered, and old man Clemens has taken control and ruined the town.”
about 0:05:54

1 star

“Almost by far the worst county in Michigan, almost as bad as Hillsdale County; Michigan cops are corrupt and so are the courts.”
about 0:06:35

In Michigan

Closest episodes

  1. I Killed The Devil... You're WelcomeJackson, Michigan · 1 August 201959 km / 37 miShow on map
  2. Sibling Death RivalryKalamazoo Township, Michigan · 9 May 202461 km / 38 miShow on map
  3. Satan's CarnivalAuburn, Indiana · 3 June 202164 km / 40 miShow on map
  4. Killing On ConsignmentNashville, Michigan · 5 March 202073 km / 45 miShow on map
  5. A Messy Web Of DeathHastings, Michigan · 22 July 202182 km / 51 miShow on map

The story

Marilyn Lee McLenahan was born in Detroit on 24 January 1941, the daughter of Dallas Arnold McLenahan and his wife Betty. She studied at Michigan State University and Wayne State University, then became a guidance counsellor at Coldwater High School in Branch County, Michigan, where she was well liked. They married within about eighteen months, bought a house in a quiet, tree-lined neighbourhood and had three children: Jennifer Dawn in 1974, Julie in 1976 and Scott about 1982.

The divorce was final in December 1989. Marilyn changed the locks, but he let himself in when the house was empty and rifled through her papers.

Julie refused to go, and eight-year-old Scott also said he did not want to go. He carried her up, put her in the passenger seat of his 1984 Chevrolet van and told the children he was taking her to hospital. Jennifer ran to a neighbour's house and called the police.

Somewhere on the road he put a .357 to the back of Marilyn's head and shot her. Ray and Marie Thornton, who were on their regular Sunday drive, saw the van pass them aggressively and Marie noted that its number plate began with GZ. A few minutes later they saw a man behind the schoolhouse struggling with a bloodstained white sheet near a hole. Further on the van pulled in behind them and followed for several miles. When Ray turned off, the van stopped, and as they drove back past it they saw the driver crouched down changing the rear plate, with the passenger door open and the interior covered in blood. They returned to the schoolhouse, found the sheet in the hole and called the Michigan State Police, who found the sheet, pools of blood and tyre tracks.

Police at the family home called every hospital within 50 miles; Marilyn had not been admitted anywhere. On 16 April 1990, highway workers found her body beside a deserted road in Bethel Township, about halfway between the house and the schoolhouse. She had been beaten and shot once in the back of the head.

About two weeks after the killing, letters began arriving, postmarked from Virginia, Iowa, Oklahoma and elsewhere. He sent 17 in all, blaming Marilyn, her lawyer and the school staff, and quoting scripture. A 13-page letter followed after three months, and an 11-page unsigned letter to the Battle Creek Inquirer, postmarked Des Moines, called the killing a life for a life and said it was his final communication. After about eight months the letters stopped.

He had gone to Dallas, Texas, where he obtained documents in the name of Hank Queen. He met Mary Blizzard at a Halloween party at a Dallas nightclub, and by Christmas 1990 he had moved into her house in Grapevine. He told her he had graduated from Michigan State and worked as an illustrator for a publishing company. A friend of Mary's recognised him, and Mary produced the number plate she had written down when they met.

Four hours after the tip, Louisiana state troopers spotted the van on Interstate 20 heading towards Mississippi. He refused to stop and led a 15-mile chase across state lines, running two road blocks. Officers shot out his tyres, and at 4 a.m. on 21 March 1991 the van stopped on the streets of Vicksburg. He was found slumped over the wheel with his thumb on the trigger and $16,000 in his pocket. Bloodstains in the van were later identified as Marilyn's. He was buried in LaGrange County, Indiana; Marilyn was buried in Oakland County, Michigan. The opening of the 2001 film Jeepers Creepers was based on the Thorntons' account.

The case

Murder of Marilyn DePue

Victims

Marilyn DePue. guidance counsellor at Coldwater High School, mother of three, born Marilyn Lee McLenahan in Detroit in 1941

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 18 July 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Jennifer Dawn DePue. oldest daughter, born 1974; ran to a neighbour's house to call the police
Scott DePue. son, born about 1982; eight or nine at the time and refused to go with his father that morning
Ray Thornton. Sunday driver who saw the van, the sheet and the plate being changed
Marie Thornton. his wife, who read the number plate and spotted the bloody sheet
Mary Blizzard. DePue's girlfriend in Dallas, who knew him as Hank Queen
Betty. Marilyn's mother
Dallas Arnold McLenahan. Marilyn's father
Claude DePue. father
Elma Murrell DePue. mother

The timeline

  1. January 24th, 1941 Marilyn Lee McLenahan is born in Detroitabout 0:09:33
  2. June 13th, 1943 is born in Sturgis, Michiganabout 0:14:50
  3. 1971 Marilyn, then 30 and a guidance counsellor, meets about 0:14:01
  4. 1974 Daughter Jennifer Dawn is bornabout 0:19:07
  5. 1976 Daughter Julie is bornabout 0:19:07
  6. about 1982 Son Scott is bornabout 0:19:07
  7. 1988 Marilyn starts telling friends her marriage is bad and is more controllingabout 0:25:32
  8. December 1989 The divorce is final; gets weekly visitation and keeps the guest house as his office (DePue family home)about 0:34:02
  9. April 15th, 1990 Easter Sunday: arrives about 11 a.m. to collect the children, and Julie and Scott refuse to go (DePue family home)about 0:37:24
  10. April 15th, 1990 throws Marilyn down the basement stairs and punches and kicks her in front of all three children (DePue family home)about 0:39:22
  11. April 15th, 1990 He carries her to his 1984 Chevy van and drives off saying he is taking her to hospital (DePue family home)about 0:41:02
  12. April 15th, 1990 Jennifer runs to a neighbour's house and calls the police (DePue family home)about 0:41:57
  13. April 15th, 1990 shoots Marilyn in the back of the head with a .357 in the van (Snow Prairie Road)about 0:45:07
  14. April 15th, 1990 Ray and Marie Thornton see the van pass aggressively and Marie notes the plate begins with GZ (Snow Prairie Road)about 0:43:41
  15. April 15th, 1990 The Thorntons see a man behind the abandoned schoolhouse struggling with a bloodstained white sheet near a hole (abandoned schoolhouse)about 0:44:44
  16. April 15th, 1990 The van follows the Thorntons for several miles; they see the driver changing the rear plate and blood inside the van (Snow Prairie Road)about 0:48:43
  17. April 15th, 1990 The Thorntons find the bloody sheet in the hole and contact the Michigan State Police (abandoned schoolhouse)about 0:49:35
  18. April 15th, 1990 Police find the sheet, pools of blood and tyre tracks behind the schoolhouse (abandoned schoolhouse)about 0:49:51
  19. April 15th, 1990 Police call every hospital within 50 miles and find Marilyn has not been admitted anywhereabout 0:50:37
  20. April 16th, 1990 Highway workers find Marilyn's body beside a deserted road in Bethel Township (Bethel Township roadside)about 0:51:33

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode