FILE 213 / 4 March 2021 / 173 MIN / full

Building A Murder Fence

Fishkill, New YorkListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

This Fishkill, New York ... it's in southeastern New York ... this is in Duchess County, zip code 12524 about 0:06:16

History, in brief

Town note

The area was the territory of the Wappinger people.

about 0:07:40

Town note

The name is Dutch: fish, and kill meaning stream or creek; the Fishkill Creek runs there.

about 0:08:05

1996

In 1996 PETA asked the town to change its name to something less suggestive of violence toward fish; the town said no.

about 0:08:32
All 13 history facts

Town note

The area was the territory of the Wappinger people.

about 0:07:40

Town note

The name is Dutch: fish, and kill meaning stream or creek; the Fishkill Creek runs there.

about 0:08:05

1996

In 1996 PETA asked the town to change its name to something less suggestive of violence toward fish; the town said no.

about 0:08:32

Town note

The village was a crossroads in the overland transportation network linking New York City, Albany, Connecticut and the ports from Massachusetts.

about 0:09:50

1776

The New York Provincial Congress convened in Fishkill in May 1776.

about 0:10:25

Town note

Fishkill became part of one of the largest colonial military encampments of the Revolutionary War.

about 0:10:36

Town note

Alexander Hamilton lived in Fishkill for a long time.

about 0:10:42

1756

Trinity Church on Hopewell Avenue was organised in 1756 and used as a hospital during the Revolutionary War.

about 0:12:02

Town note

The Dutch Reformed Church was used as a military prison during the Revolutionary War.

about 0:12:11

1871

In 1871 a schoolhouse was built on Church Street; it belonged to the Fishkill Reformed Church and its land was used as pasture for the pastor's cow.

about 0:12:20

1876

In 1876 a fire destroyed the village, which was rebuilt in brick; those structures still stand.

about 0:12:32

The figures, as told

Religious

about 54%

Biggest faith: Catholic, 36.8%

about 0:26:32

Who lives here

White 61.5% · Black 11.5% · Asian 6.9% · Hispanic 16.1%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ about 25% under the national average

about 0:35:17

Violent crime
▼ about one third of the normal average

about 0:35:17

Newburgh murder rate
▲ highest in the United States

about 0:17:49

Money

Median home value$297,500
Two-bedroom rentabout $1,475
Median household income$82,946
Cost of living118

For sale

$155,000

One-bedroom, one-bath 900 sq ft condo

about 0:29:04

For sale

price raised by $10,000

Three-bedroom, two-bath 1,310 sq ft house

about 0:29:27

For sale

$710,000

Four-bedroom, five-bath 5,705 sq ft house on an acre

about 0:30:02
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2021

Property crime

"about 25% under the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:35:17

Violent crime

"about one third of the normal average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:35:17

Newburgh murder rate

"highest in the United States"

Comparison: "double the South Bronx". Direction: above.

As told in 2021 about 0:17:49

Population

"23,508"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:24:49

More males than females

"a little more males"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:25:11

Median age

"41 and a half"

Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:25:52

White

"61.5%"

Comparison: "62% nationally". No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:26:08

Black

"11.5%"

Comparison: "12.3% nationally". No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:26:13

Asian

"6.9%"

Comparison: "5.3% nationally". No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:26:20

Hispanic

"16.1%"

Comparison: "17.6% nationally". No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:26:20

Share who are religious

"about 54%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:26:32

Median household income

"$82,946"

Comparison: "usually $57,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:27:29

Cost of living index

"118"

Comparison: "100 is the regular average". Direction: above.

As told in 2021 about 0:27:42

Housing index

"129"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:27:49

Median home cost

"$297,500"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:27:52

Average two-bedroom rent

"about $1,475"

Comparison: "higher than normal". Direction: above.

As told in 2021 about 0:28:49

One-bedroom, one-bath 900 sq ft condo

"$155,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:29:04

Three-bedroom, two-bath 1,310 sq ft house

"price raised by $10,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:29:27

Four-bedroom, five-bath 5,705 sq ft house on an acre

"$710,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:30:02

The reviews

3.4 / 5 · average of 7

5 stars

“A unique Hudson Valley town, geographically diverse from riverside to mountains, very safe, with plenty of shopping and restaurants near I-84 and the Taconic Parkway, minutes from the Hudson Line Metro North station and Beacon, close to New York City and near Newburgh and Peekskill.”
about 0:17:57

5 stars

“Lived here all my life; it has changed a lot with the influx of Westchester and New York City people, but the area is still beautiful, especially in the fall when the leaves change.”
about 0:19:01

2 stars

“Most of the jobs are set in stone and everything is bribery and nepotism; my mother has been trying to get a job up here for three years and has not even had a reply.”
about 0:20:32

3 stars

“There's nothing here, but it's still better than Beacon.”
about 0:22:31

3 stars

“Lived in Fishkill my whole life; it's a sleepy little town but has access to an abundance of things to do a short drive or train ride away.”
about 0:23:27

3 stars

“We have people come and go.”
about 0:23:37

3 stars

“Would not want to live here anymore.”
about 0:23:56

In New York

Closest episodes

  1. Murder, Table For OneNew Paltz, New York · 29 June 202229 km / 18 miShow on map
  2. Murder By MoonlightChappaqua, New York · 12 June 202543 km / 27 miShow on map
  3. A Blaze Of GloryRedding, Connecticut · 25 July 201849 km / 30 miShow on map
  4. Wood Chipping The WifeNewtown, Connecticut · 30 March 202450 km / 31 miShow on map
  5. Too Fat To KillRamsey, New Jersey · 20 May 202357 km / 35 miShow on map

The story

The Mori family lived in a small two-storey rented house at 203 Route 82 in Fishkill, New York. Manuel Mori III, known as Tony, was thirty-three and had been born in Peekskill in 1973. He had quit his job in 2006 and described himself as a self-employed fence installer, and he sold cocaine in small amounts to a circle of friends, keeping his drugs in a lock box under his bed. His wife Tina, née Coler, was thirty, born in Nyack, and worked as a cashier at the Mobil station in Fishkill. They had three sons: Tony junior, thirteen, who went to Van Wyck Junior High and played football and wrestled; Adam, ten, at Brinkerhoff Elementary; and Ryan, six. The landlord, Tom Scarva, said they had stopped paying rent on 1 November 2006 and were being evicted. He also said Tony tore up the yard with a quad bike and that the couple held parties on the front lawn every weekend.

Tina had told a colleague at the Mobil that she planned to leave Tony and take the boys to Virginia.

At about 3.20 am on Friday 19 January 2007 a woman driving on Route 82 reported a house heavily engulfed in flames. Firefighters brought it under control at about 4.20 am. Less than a mile away, at about 3.35 am, a purple Kia, the family car, was found burning. Once the rubble could be searched the remains of Tony and Tina were found on top of each other beneath a living-room sofa, burned so badly that investigators first thought there was one body. Both had been shot with a .22 rifle: Tony once through the neck, Tina in the face and in the back. Ryan was found downstairs near the front door, where he had been running to escape. He had been stabbed and then beaten about the head, and the blow did not kill him; he died of smoke inhalation when the house was set alight. Tony junior had eighty-three stab wounds, many of them defensive, to his hands and face. Adam was asleep; he was stabbed in the side of the head, so hard that the knife went through into the pillow.

The investigation was round the clock. Police checked hospitals for anyone with burns or cuts to the hands. On 25 January they said there were no signs of forced entry and that the murder weapon was a .22 calibre rifle. A mobile plate reader on a police car patrolling Route 82 had photographed a Nissan Xterra at 1.14 am on 19 January, about five hundred feet from the house.

Then he said they had called to ask Tony to sell them cocaine. Then he said they had bought cocaine from a man in Beacon and later called Tony for more. Tony wanted to check with Tina, and she said no.

He called in to Royal Carting at three in the morning.

He told police, "I didn't do it, but if I did, I don't recollect it." She also said he knew Tony had been shot in the neck before that detail was published. Under cross-examination she admitted she had recently been in a psychiatric hospital after firing a gun in her own house.

He testified to what he had told the police.

He agreed that he and Tony were like brothers and denied stabbing the children. He admitted lying to police about his movements.

Tina's mother, Arlene Cortes, gasped and wept. The judge said that in forty years he had never seen such brutality.

The burned house was demolished and two houses were built on the lot, one of them in 2008; the property was later listed for $574,569.

The case

Murder of the Mori family

Victims

Manuel 'Tony' Mori III (33). Self-employed fence installer and low-level cocaine dealer; shot once through the neck
Tina Mori (30). Cashier at the Fishkill Mobil, née Coler; shot in the face and in the back
Manuel 'Tony' Mori IV (13). Oldest son, Van Wyck Junior High student; suffered 83 stab wounds
Adam Mori (10). Middle son, Brinkerhoff Elementary student; stabbed in the side of the head as he slept
Ryan Mori (6). Youngest son; stabbed and bludgeoned near the front door and died of smoke inhalation

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 4 March 2021.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Tom Scarva. the family's landlord, who was evicting them for non-payment of rent
Arlene Cortes. Tina's mother
Patty Girch. gas station clerk who worked with Tina

The timeline

  1. 1973 Tony Mori is born in Peekskill. (Vaster House hospital)about 0:42:49
  2. Tina Coler is born in Nyack.about 0:50:22
  3. May 2006 Tony throws a four-day birthday party for himself and Tina costing $15,000, with four ounces of cocaine. (Mori house)about 1:21:41
  4. November 1, 2006 The family stops paying rent; the landlord begins eviction proceedings. (Mori house)about 0:52:50
  5. early January 2007 Tina tells her colleague Patty Girch she plans to leave Tony and take the boys to Virginia. (Fishkill Mobil)about 0:58:27
  6. January 15, 2007 Tina telephones her mother in a panic: Tony and had a big blowout and Tony told to stay away from the house. (Mori house)about 1:25:20
  7. January 18, 2007, about 10:30 pm and wait in a convenience store car park on Route 82, then says they should go to Tony's for cocaine. (Convenience store on Route 82)about 1:45:25
  8. January 19, 2007, 1:14 am A mobile plate reader photographs Nissan Xterra about 500 feet from the Mori house. (Mori house)about 1:41:09
  9. January 19, 2007, about 3:20 am A woman driving on Route 82 reports the house heavily engulfed in flames. (Mori house)about 0:36:15
  10. January 19, 2007, about 3:35 am A car fire is reported less than a mile away; it is the family's purple Kia.about 0:37:47
  11. January 19, 2007, about 4:20 am The fire is brought under control and firefighters find bodies in the rubble. (Mori house)about 0:38:59

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode