FILE 279 / 30 April 2022 / 63 MIN / express

Bumbling In Blood

Ambridge, PennsylvaniaListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

This is Ambridge, Pennsylvania. It's in western Pennsylvania. about 0:02:41

History, in brief

Town note

Originally called Old Economy; locals shortened the name to Economy.

about 0:02:53

Town note

Renamed Ambridge after the American Bridge Company, which owned most of the town and made steel there; it was a company town.

about 0:03:11

1983

The American Bridge Company ended its operations in Ambridge in 1983.

about 0:03:48

Town note

A local man wrote 'Rustbelt Boy', a book about the town's decline and the loss of the steel industry.

about 0:04:18
All 4 history facts

Town note

Originally called Old Economy; locals shortened the name to Economy.

about 0:02:53

Town note

Renamed Ambridge after the American Bridge Company, which owned most of the town and made steel there; it was a company town.

about 0:03:11

1983

The American Bridge Company ended its operations in Ambridge in 1983.

about 0:03:48

Town note

A local man wrote 'Rustbelt Boy', a book about the town's decline and the loss of the steel industry.

about 0:04:18

The figures, as told

All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population in 1930

"over 20,000"

Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:48

Population at the time of the story

"7,000"

Comparison: "down from over 20,000 in 1930". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:53

The reviews

No rated reviews

No reviews recorded.

In Pennsylvania

Closest episodes

  1. Bloodthirsty Murder & Stupid PeopleDaugherty Township, Pennsylvania · 9 December 202118 km / 11 miShow on map
  2. Born To Be BadWheeling, West Virginia · 28 March 202470 km / 44 miShow on map
  3. That Can't Be An AccidentBrookfield Township, Ohio · 9 January 202077 km / 48 miShow on map
  4. The Dark Prince Of Belmont CountyBellaire, Ohio · 20 December 202578 km / 48 miShow on map
  5. Just My ImaginationHowland Township, Ohio · 14 May 202684 km / 52 miShow on map

The story

Ambridge is a steel town in western Pennsylvania, in Beaver County. It was first called Old Economy, which locals shortened to Economy, then took the name Ambridge from the American Bridge Company, which owned most of the town and made steel there; when the company closed in 1983 the town lost its main employer. In 1930 more than 20,000 people lived there; at the time of the story there were about 7,000. A local man wrote Rustbelt Boy about the decline. He grew up in Aliquippa and moved to Ambridge in the middle of his childhood. His mother drank heavily and his father, a guitar player, beat her. The couple divorced and his father walked out of a custody hearing, saying he wanted none of the children. His mother later married Arthur Hurley, a drifter who also drank and beat her. He graduated in 1966 with a citizenship award and joined the Marine Corps, which threw him out after 18 months for going absent without leave in a stolen garbage truck; a military court gave him five years' probation and a discharge. He returned to Ambridge, married a woman named Linda and worked in manufacturing before moving to Virginia in 1971 and becoming a professional fireman. His wife divorced him while he was inside, remarried and let her new husband adopt their two daughters. His foreman was John Lucick, who had bought an older house at Dust Avenue from the Strano family. John and his wife Denice, 27, had two children, Danielle, eight, and John Jr, four. He told co-workers he was going to kill John, and late in 1980, riding with David Catrell, he suggested going to John's house to rape his wife, adding that they would have to kill John if he turned up. Owers refused and told the rest of the crew. That afternoon Denice and John Jr visited her friend Paulette Batisti; they went home around 3.30 and Denice talked on the phone to Robin Mamay for about 45 minutes from 4 p.m. At about five Paulette sent her daughter to borrow two eggs and Denice waved to her from the back porch. Between 4.45 and 5.15 the next-door neighbour, Stella Ricci, heard shouting from the house. He was covered in blood, had no glasses, a cut on his nose and a towel round one hand. He said he had fallen off a ladder, then said he had gone to give an estimate and found the family dead, and asked them not to tell anyone. At 6.04 he walked into the police station, still bloody. Police arrived at 6.15 and found Denice and John Jr side by side in a small upstairs bedroom, and Danielle in the adjoining room, strangled and stabbed through the heart with a screwdriver, a blood-smeared pillow in her mouth. Denice had been strangled and had her throat cut; John Jr died of slash wounds to the throat. Blood from all three victims was on his shirt and trousers, and a bloody palm print on the pillow matched him. He put the pillow back and fell downstairs, breaking his glasses. His wife Deborah ran from the courtroom in tears. John Lucick moved away from Ambridge to live with relatives.

The case

Murder of the Lucick family

Victims

Denice Lucick (27). John Lucick's wife and mother of two
Danielle Lucick (8). their daughter
John Lucick Jr (4). their son

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 30 April 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

John Lucick. foreman at the roofing company; husband and father of the victims
Raymond Owers. co-worker asked to help kill the family; star witness for the prosecution
David Catrell. co-worker suggested raping Denice to
Paulette Batisti. Denice's friend, at whose house she spent the afternoon
Robin Mamay. friend who telephoned Denice that afternoon
Stella Ricci. next-door neighbour who heard shouting from the house
Robert Pilts. Strano warehouse employee who saw covered in blood
Jeff Joseph Durban. Strano warehouse employee who saw covered in blood
Rose. sister, who told of his childhood and of the knife-point rape
Lillian. mother
Arthur Hurley. stepfather
Linda. first wife

The timeline

  1. , the third of four children of Lillian and Eugene, grows up in Aliquippa and moves to Ambridge in the middle of his childhood (Aliquippa)about 0:09:04
  2. At a custody hearing father stands up, says he wants none of the children, and walks out, never to returnabout 0:11:05
  3. At eight, ties another boy to a tree and burns him with the heads of lit matchesabout 0:18:45
  4. 1966 graduates from high school with a citizenship award and joins the Marine Corpsabout 0:20:50
  5. After 18 months is thrown out of the Marines for going AWOL in a stolen garbage truck; a military court gives him five years' probation and a dischargeabout 0:22:38
  6. returns to Ambridge, marries Linda and works a series of manufacturing jobs (Ambridge)about 0:22:48
  7. 1971 moves to Virginia with his wife and becomes a professional firemanabout 0:22:48
  8. begins an affair with his wife's 14-year-old sister that lasts about a yearabout 0:23:09
  9. 1979 is hired by the FD Strano Company and works on the crew remodelling the Lucicks' new house (FD Strano Company)about 0:29:24
  10. John and Denice Lucick buy an older house at Dust Avenue from the Strano family (Lucick house)about 0:28:37
  11. marries and invites his co-workers, including John and Denice Lucick, to the weddingabout 0:31:26
  12. the autumn of 1980 John Lucick yells at in front of a homeowner; confronts him afterwards and holds a grudgeabout 0:31:46
  13. late 1980 Riding in a truck with David Catrell, suggests going to John's house to rape his wife, saying they would have to kill John if he appearedabout 0:33:05
  14. August 4, 1981 asks Raymond Owers to help him kill John's wife and children; Owers refuses and tells the other crew membersabout 0:34:17
  15. August 4, 1981, about 3.30 p.m. Denice Lucick and her four-year-old son leave Paulette Batisti's house to go home (Paulette Batisti's house)about 0:36:15
  16. August 4, 1981, 4 p.m. Robin Mamay telephones Denice and they talk for about 45 minutes (Lucick house)about 0:36:56
  17. August 4, 1981, about 5 p.m. Paulette Batisti sends her daughter to borrow two eggs; Denice waves to her from the back porch (Lucick house)about 0:37:54
  18. August 4, 1981, between 4.45 and 5.15 p.m. Next-door neighbour Stella Ricci hears shouting from the Lucick house (Lucick house)about 0:45:33
  19. August 4, 1981, just before 6 p.m. Robert Pilts and Jeff Joseph Durban see running a the park towards the Strano warehouse, covered in blood and without his glasses (park a from the Strano warehouse)about 0:38:32
  20. August 4, 1981, 6.04 p.m. walks into the Ambridge police station covered in blood and says the family is dead (Ambridge police station)about 0:41:22
  21. August 4, 1981, 6.15 p.m. Police arrive at the house and find Denice and John Jr dead in an upstairs bedroom and Danielle dead in the adjoining room (Lucick house)about 0:41:43

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

park a from the Strano warehouse

landmark

about 0:38:32

Heard in this episode