FILE 283 / 14 May 2022 / 63 MIN / express

Frying The Gambler

Hammond, IndianaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Indiana today, to Hammond, Indiana, which is not really a small town... in northwestern Indiana... about 30 minutes outside of Chicago, so it's technically a suburb of Chicago. about 0:02:47

History, in brief

1918

On June 22nd, 1918 the Hammond Circus Train wreck happened about 5.5 miles east of the city, killing 86 people and injuring 127.

about 0:03:50

Town note

Hammond has been in decline since the 1970s and 1980s.

about 0:05:16
All 2 history facts

1918

On June 22nd, 1918 the Hammond Circus Train wreck happened about 5.5 miles east of the city, killing 86 people and injuring 127.

about 0:03:50

Town note

Hammond has been in decline since the 1970s and 1980s.

about 0:05:16

The figures, as told

All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"94,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:05:21

Population

"83,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:05:21

Population

"about 75,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:05:21

The reviews

1.0 / 5 · average of 1

1 star

“A one-star review from a man named Frank: living in Hammond has been a really bad experience, with ignorant people outside all hours blasting music and having parties, the reviewer feeling unsafe every day and being approached by men in cars, and screaming children in the summer.”
about 0:05:46

In Indiana

Closest episodes

  1. Marriage, Murder, Malice & The MobPalos Park, Illinois · 16 July 202628 km / 17 miShow on map
  2. BONUS - The Prisoner Dating Game!Chicago, Illinois · 8 July 201929 km / 18 miShow on map
  3. Dreaming Of MurderOak Park, Illinois · 12 December 202439 km / 24 miShow on map
  4. Sex, Lies & Duct TapeVilla Park, Illinois · 9 August 201850 km / 31 miShow on map
  5. Dismembering GrandmaTrail Creek, Indiana · 29 April 202354 km / 34 miShow on map

The story

Hammond, Indiana, lies in the north-west of the state, about thirty minutes from Chicago and technically one of its suburbs. In 1983 it was a city of some 83,000 people already in decline, and it is the setting for one of the most brutal murders the hosts have covered. Paul Sr drank from the morning, had emphysema and a recent heart operation, and beat his wife and son. Paul Jr later said his father had beaten a stutter into him, had held a gun to his head and had once chased him down the street threatening to shoot him in the back. The police treated the violence as a domestic disturbance.

The couple lived on drugs and theft, sometimes on the run from the Chicago police, and their son Jason was left with his grandparents.

She did not object, asking only that it be done away from the house so that she would not have to clean it up. They considered shooting Paul Sr outside his bar but decided it was too public. Next they substituted rat poison for his pills, and again he was ill without dying. A second dose of nitroglycerine failed when food poisoning left him too ill to take his pills.

At one o'clock in the morning on March 20, 1983, the pair let themselves into the house. The cause of death was decapitation.

She filed a missing person report and then told the police he was dead and cut up in bags by the lake, which they took for a joke until they walked the shore and found the remains in half a dozen plastic bags fifty feet from the water.

The first 2,300 volts left him breathing; the current was applied again and three more times before he was pronounced dead seventeen minutes later.

Paul Jr was freed again in 2010, was nearly killed in a bicycle crash that left him in a coma for 22 days and required seven operations, and lost his suit against the city when the court found he had been drunk and riding the wrong way.

The case

Murder of Paul Comyati Sr

Victims

Paul Comyati Sr (65). retired construction worker, heavy drinker and violent father and husband

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 14 May 2022.

Accused

Accused

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Jason. young son and Paul Sr's grandson, who was asleep on Paul Sr's shoulder during one attempt and was the only person Paul Sr was kind to

The timeline

  1. 1983 Paul Comyati Sr, 65, a retired construction worker, lives in Hammond with his wife , his son Paul Jr, 17, and his grandson Jason; he drinks from morning and beats the family. (Comyati house)about 0:08:22
  2. Early February 1983 and Van leave the house; Paul Sr refuses to let her take Jason with her. (Comyati house)about 0:25:13
  3. Mid-February 1983 Paul Jr and talk about killing their father and bring into the plan; she does not object but asks that it not happen in the house. (Comyati house)about 0:26:35
  4. February 1983 Van returns to Hammond and is brought into the plot as the one with criminal experience. (Comyati house)about 0:27:40
  5. February to mid-March 1983 The family discuss shooting Paul Sr outside his bar and reject it as too risky and too public. (local bar)about 0:29:02
  6. February 1983 First attempt: buys nitroglycerine from the pharmacy where she works, and Paul Jr crush the tablets outside a Dairy Queen and substitute them for Paul Sr's medication; he has nausea, dizziness and a headache but does not die. (Dairy Queen)about 0:30:39
  7. Second attempt: rat poison is substituted for his pills; he is sick but recovers, and stops when he says he will see a doctor. (Comyati house)about 0:32:12
  8. Third attempt: and supply a syringe and a vial of 'liquid poison', which puts in his coffee; nothing happens. (Comyati house)about 0:35:34
  9. Fourth attempt: more nitroglycerine is prepared, but food poisoning makes Paul Sr too ill to take his pills. (Comyati house)about 0:37:49
  10. Fifth plan: is to knock him out with ether so an air bubble can be injected into a vein; it is abandoned when the family find Jason asleep on Paul Sr's shoulder. (Comyati house)about 0:39:04
  11. and drive towards Georgia, reach Louisville, then turn back for Hammond after telephones in a panic. (Louisville)about 0:40:05
  12. March 20, 1983 At 1 a.m. and enter the house; and Paul Jr go into Paul Sr's bedroom. (Comyati house)about 0:40:59
  13. March 20, 1983 Paul Jr holds his father down while tries to smother him with a pillow; Paul Sr cries out to his son and calls for . (Comyati house)about 0:41:25
  14. March 20, 1983 stabs him with a fish filleting knife, by his own account more than 100 times; the coroner finds about 40 wounds, 34 of them deep. (Comyati house)about 0:42:25
  15. March 20, 1983 They hit him over the head five or six times with a gun and he is still alive. (Comyati house)about 0:43:00
  16. March 20, 1983 saws his head off with a hacksaw while he is still alive; the cause of death is decapitation. (Comyati house)about 0:44:01
  17. March 20, 1983 The family have a drink together, then and Paul Jr dismember the body and bag it. (Comyati house)about 0:45:19

Last meals

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode