FILE 285 / 20 May 2022 / 64 MIN / express

An Arrow For Your Thoughts

Berlin, New JerseyListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

This week we are in New Jersey ... We're going to Berlin, New Jersey ... It's in southwestern New Jersey. about 0:02:43

History, in brief

Town note

The town's original name was Long-A-Coming, from the local Native American Long-A-Coming trail; it was a stagecoach stop.

about 0:04:12

1853

The rail line was laid in 1853 and the Long-A-Coming railroad station was built.

about 0:04:19

1867

In 1867 the name was changed to Magnolia, which lasted only three months because another Magnolia already existed within twenty miles.

about 0:04:55
All 5 history facts

Town note

The town's original name was Long-A-Coming, from the local Native American Long-A-Coming trail; it was a stagecoach stop.

about 0:04:12

1853

The rail line was laid in 1853 and the Long-A-Coming railroad station was built.

about 0:04:19

1867

In 1867 the name was changed to Magnolia, which lasted only three months because another Magnolia already existed within twenty miles.

about 0:04:55

The figures, as told

All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

population

"about 5,800"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:29

The reviews

3.7 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“The town does a lot for the community and the children; the schools are outstanding academically and for each student's needs, there is next to no crime and a wonderful park for kids.”
about 0:05:35

3 stars

“The last storm sneaked up on the area and local agencies were not quick to get the snow plows out on the main road.”
about 0:06:30

3 stars

“There are all four seasons; bad winter storms and hurricanes happen but are normally not so bad.”
about 0:06:58

In New Jersey

Closest episodes

  1. A Scary Story On A Quiet StreetPitman, New Jersey · 31 October 201918 km / 11 miShow on map
  2. Angriest Serial Killer AroundChester, Pennsylvania · 5 June 202538 km / 24 miShow on map
  3. Dead In A DitchClaymont, Delaware · 9 September 202345 km / 28 miShow on map
  4. Meth, Meat, Money & MurderFallsington, Pennsylvania · 4 February 202345 km / 28 miShow on map
  5. The Serial Killing NerdBridgeport, Pennsylvania · 30 May 202449 km / 30 miShow on map

The story

Berlin, New Jersey, sits in the south-western corner of the state, about thirty minutes from Philadelphia, a small town of roughly 5,800 people crammed in among other towns rather than out in the country. It began as Long-A-Coming, named for the Native American trail, was a stagecoach stop, and got its rail line and station in 1853. In 1867 the town renamed itself Magnolia, but another Magnolia already stood within twenty miles, so after three months it became Berlin. Kelly Ripa was born there. On the night of 28 January 2013, Trisha Dulin, in her early twenties, was outside her family's house with its backyard barbecue area, talking to Vincent D. Philippus, known as Vinny D, a man she knew from high school and had not seen in years. At about ten o'clock her ex-boyfriend Karetti Paulson, twenty-five, turned up. The pair had recently split; Trisha's family blamed Paulson for getting her into heroin, and he wanted her back. He believed Vinny D was the new man in her life. Paulson approached Philippus and a fight started at once, punches and wrestling on the ground, ending when Trisha stepped in and the others pulled them apart. Trisha and Vinny D went inside; Paulson stayed in the driveway. The arrow struck Paulson in the abdomen, and he staggered into the yard of the neighbour, Joseph Cassis, and collapsed. Cassis shrugged and went back inside, but he had heard someone ask whether they were going to be shot with that and heard groans under his window, so his son called 911. At about 10.50 p.m. Berlin police arrived and found Paulson face down and apparently dead; he was pronounced dead at the hospital. The autopsy found an arrow wound to the abdomen, the arrow passing through the abdominal wall and stomach, striking the iliac vein and partly exiting his back, with two and a half litres of blood in the abdomen. An orange-capped syringe lay beside his body. Trisha told police she had not seen Paulson in weeks, and Philippus said his bloody knuckles came from sexual activity with her, a claim she denied. A search of Trisha's bedroom, consented to by her mother Helen and covered by a warrant, found drugs and orange-cap syringes identical to the one by the body, and Paulson carried matching drugs. In August 2016 Philippus came forward. He said that the morning after the killing, with Trisha's father Thomas waiting at the house, the family met in the living room and agreed to say Paulson had an HIV-positive needle so the shooting would look like self-defence, and that Ashley repeatedly pressed him to stick to the story. At the 2019 retrial an expert testified that pig-carcass tests showed the arrow penetrated sixteen inches at a full draw, 11.5 inches at seventy-five per cent, six inches at fifty per cent, and at twenty-five per cent fell harmlessly to the ground. On 24 July 2019 he and Ashley filed for bankruptcy. Paulson is buried at Cold Spring Presbyterian Cemetery in Cape May, New Jersey. His ex-girlfriend Lauren Palmer said he was a genuinely good person who was never malicious, and that their daughter Aurora, too young to remember him, would grow up knowing who her father was.

The case

Murder of Karetti Paulson

Victims

Karetti Paulson (25). Trisha Dulin's ex-boyfriend; restaurant and bar worker, musician, and father of a young daughter

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 20 May 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Ashley Dulin. Trisha's sister and fiancée
Vincent D. Philippus. known as Vinny D; the man Trisha was talking to, who fought Paulson and later came forward with the family's plan
Helen Dulin. Trisha's mother and the homeowner, who consented to the search
Thomas Dulin. Trisha's father, at the house the morning after
Joseph Cassis. neighbour who found Paulson in his yard and had his son call 911
Bertram Franks. neighbour who testified he saw aim the bow and did not see him trip
Lauren Palmer. Paulson's ex-girlfriend and mother of his daughter Aurora
Aurora. Paulson's young daughter

The timeline

  1. 2006 Paulson graduates from Eastern High School (Eastern High School)about 0:13:22
  2. before January 2013 Paulson and Trisha Dulin break up; her family say he got her into heroin and she got clean while he did not (Dulin house)about 0:17:48
  3. January 28, 2013, about 10 p.m. Paulson arrives at the Dulin house and finds Trisha talking to Vinny D; he and Philippus fight and are separated (Dulin house)about 0:11:54
  4. January 28, 2013 comes out with a compound bow and confronts Paulson from about 30 feet (Dulin house)about 0:28:32
  5. January 28, 2013 fires an arrow that strikes Paulson in the abdomen; Paulson staggers into the neighbour's yard (Cassis house)about 0:34:07
  6. January 28, 2013 Cassis finds Paulson on his lawn; says Paulson is drunk, and Cassis's son calls 911 (Cassis house)about 0:35:16
  7. January 28, 2013 uses Paulson's phone to call 911 pretending to be Paulson (Cassis house)about 0:38:23
  8. January 28, 2013, about 10:50 p.m. Berlin police arrive and find Paulson face down; he is pronounced dead (Cassis house)about 0:39:14

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode