FILE 321 / 25 September 2022 / 68 MIN / express

Sins Of The Stepfather

Lemmon Valley, NevadaListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Lemon Valley, Nevada... in northwestern Nevada... a suburb of Reno, about 15 minutes to Reno. about 0:02:56

History, in brief

Town note

The valleys outside Reno, including Sun Valley, Panther Valley and Lemmon Valley, are known for massive trailer parks and vast numbers of trailers.

about 0:04:40

Town note

The area's sewage system rules stopped conventional building, so people put trailers there instead.

about 0:04:52

1974

In 1974 the area was trailers on sand dunes, with little air conditioning and Reno itself concentrated in the city.

about 0:10:27

Town note

Reno was known for a few casinos and for six-week divorces: a person could establish residency for six weeks and then divorce there.

about 0:12:11
All 4 history facts

Town note

The valleys outside Reno, including Sun Valley, Panther Valley and Lemmon Valley, are known for massive trailer parks and vast numbers of trailers.

about 0:04:40

Town note

The area's sewage system rules stopped conventional building, so people put trailers there instead.

about 0:04:52

1974

In 1974 the area was trailers on sand dunes, with little air conditioning and Reno itself concentrated in the city.

about 0:10:27

Town note

Reno was known for a few casinos and for six-week divorces: a person could establish residency for six weeks and then divorce there.

about 0:12:11

The figures, as told

Crime / national average

Crime overall
▲ higher than Damonte Ranch and Spanish Springs combined

about 0:07:53

Neighbourhood speeding
▲ up to 40 miles an hour

about 0:06:28

Money

Median household income$54,000 a year
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"5,362"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:17

Median household income

"$54,000 a year"

Comparison: "about average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:24

Home price

"$293,000"

Comparison: "about average". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:24

Crime rate

"higher than Damonte Ranch and Spanish Springs combined"

Comparison: "those two areas combined". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:07:53

Neighbourhood speeding

"up to 40 miles an hour"

Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:06:28

The reviews

3.6 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“There is very little crime because criminals do not want to travel that far; police are always visible and a motorist can barely speed down Lemmon Drive without being pulled over; the only recent trouble was a miscreant breaking into cars five years ago and people stealing unlocked bikes; the reviewer worries about neighbourhood speeding up to 40 miles an hour because children walk to school.”
about 0:05:25

4 stars

“The best part is being far enough from the casinos to see the stars at night; it is quiet and the people are friendly.”
about 0:06:59

4 stars

“The roads are well maintained and the fire department can be counted on to turn up.”
about 0:07:11

4 stars

“Some police staff genuinely care, but a small portion is corrupt and only looking to fill quotas; you are more likely to be pulled over and ticketed in Reno than in most cities.”
about 0:07:33

1 star

“Crime has been brought to Lemmon Valley; it is much smaller than new-build areas like Damonte Ranch and Spanish Springs but has more crime than both combined; houses are cheaper, the area is broken up by open land and looks rural and suburban at once, and incomes are definitely lower.”
about 0:07:49

In Nevada

Closest episodes

  1. Anger, Obsession, RevengeSun Valley, Nevada · 6 December 201710 km / 6 miShow on map
  2. Murder On Slide MountainIncline Village, Nevada · 11 January 202548 km / 30 miShow on map
  3. Maybe Satan Did ItDayton, Nevada · 2 August 201852 km / 32 miShow on map
  4. Bloody Plot TwistsMinden, Nevada · 27 December 202581 km / 50 miShow on map
  5. Murder & WorseSouth Lake Tahoe, California · 29 March 201785 km / 53 miShow on map

The story

In July 1974 Lemmon Valley, Nevada, was a scattered community of trailers on sand dunes outside Reno, reached by dirt roads and home to a good many horses. The eldest was fifteen-year-old Blythe Harrington, a quiet girl who rode horses regularly along the trails toward Antelope Valley.

On July 2, 1974, at the start of the Fourth of July weekend, Blythe left the trailer at about 5.15 p.m. on her dark horse, heading north on Lemmon Valley Road toward Antelope Valley. She took a route she used all the time. He would later be estimated to have ridden about nineteen miles that evening.

He said he had searched on horseback, failed to find her, returned for his truck because the horse was tired, and then found the spot with his wife. Deputies drove out to a remote place beside a little-used dirt road and found Blythe in the sagebrush. Her horse was tied to a tree nearby, unharmed.

The officers roped off a radius of only fifteen feet around the body and, lacking lights, waited until daylight, leaving her on the ground overnight. More officers arrived in the morning and the pathologist reached the scene at about 10.30 a.m. An autopsy established that Blythe had been shot three times in the back with a .22 and that she had recently had sexual intercourse.

A few days later deputies searched the trailer. A small box on a closet shelf was knocked down and burst open, spilling torn scraps of paper. One scrap carried the word 'love' in a young woman's handwriting. Painstakingly reassembled, the scraps formed a diary in which Blythe described a sexual relationship with her stepfather and said she had loved him since she was eight.

Blythe's father went to court and regained custody of the five surviving children. In September 1974 the house in Sparks where the couple were living with defence attorney Vivian Ruben was burgled; the intruder took between $25 and $30 in pennies and $80 in change.

The defence failed to suppress the diary, and it was admitted as evidence of motive. A young woman who initially said she had been riding a dark horse in the area then changed her story, saying she had been in Sun Valley on a similar horse, and later alleged that deputies had pressured her. A discarded drinks can was found at a cattle crossing she mentioned.

The assistant had thrown away the sperm slide and the swab had not been preserved.

In 1979 the Nevada Supreme Court held that the unreported test was direct exculpatory evidence and that the state could not benefit from its own mishandling. Because the swab was gone and the slide intentionally discarded, a fair retrial was impossible.

The case

Murder of Blythe Harrington

Victims

Blythe Harrington (15). stepdaughter, a quiet girl who rode horses on the local trails

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 25 September 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

June Campbell. neighbour who saw a girl resembling Blythe riding north at about 5.15 p.m. and a man resembling following about 30 minutes later
Lorne Butner. detective commander who denied the horse-rider witness's claims of harassment
Dan Koppa. sergeant and the witness's former junior-high government teacher
Vivian Ruben. defence attorney at whose Sparks house the s lived
Joseph K. Jr.. attorney whose wife administered a reward fund; he said publicly that he did not represent
the young woman on the dark horse. witness who first placed herself in Lemmon Valley, then said she rode in Sun Valley and that deputies coerced her statement
Blythe's father. went to court after admission and regained custody of the five surviving children

The timeline

  1. 1940 is born.about 0:12:34
  2. July 1973 marries Chicolata Ann Harrington, Blythe's mother. ( trailer)about 0:12:52
  3. July 2, 1974 At about 5.15 p.m. Blythe Harrington rides off on her horse toward Antelope Valley, a route she rides all the time. (Lemmon Valley Road)about 0:15:49
  4. July 2, 1974 Shortly before 5 p.m. comes home from his construction job, saddles his horse without changing and follows the same path. ( trailer)about 0:16:29
  5. July 2, 1974 Between 11 and 11.30 p.m. the family realise Blythe is not home; calls the sheriff to say he has found her nude body on Antelope Mountain. (Antelope Mountain)about 0:17:43

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode