FILE 327 / 15 October 2022 / 67 MIN / express

Beer, Sex & Jealousy

Albia, IowaListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are in Albia, Iowa, in south central Iowa, population 3,713; the murder itself happened about 45 minutes away in Derby, but all the people are from Albia. about 0:03:04

History, in brief

Town note

Named after Albia, New York, the home town of an early settler.

about 0:04:18

1877

A room and pillar coal mine about two and a half miles west of Albia opened around 1877.

about 0:04:50

1893

On February 14, 1893, a gunpowder charge ignited a dust explosion in the mine; one miner was killed and seven more died of their injuries.

about 0:04:42

Town note

By the time of the explosion the mining extended more than a thousand yards from the hoisting shaft and employed 60 miners and 20 other men.

about 0:04:55
All 5 history facts

Town note

Named after Albia, New York, the home town of an early settler.

about 0:04:18

1877

A room and pillar coal mine about two and a half miles west of Albia opened around 1877.

about 0:04:50

1893

On February 14, 1893, a gunpowder charge ignited a dust explosion in the mine; one miner was killed and seven more died of their injuries.

about 0:04:42

Town note

By the time of the explosion the mining extended more than a thousand yards from the hoisting shaft and employed 60 miners and 20 other men.

about 0:04:55

Town note

Coal mining ran through the area in the 1900s and every town was a little company town; when the mine closed everybody left, as at Derby.

about 0:05:47

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$115,800
Median household income$43,877
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"3,713"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:50

Median household income

"$43,877"

Comparison: "about $10,000 less than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:56

Median home cost

"$115,800"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:04:07

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 2

3 stars

“Everyone knows each other and teachers have better relationships with students, but there are few opportunities or stores and you have to drive to bigger cities; school life could be more challenging but there are no resources.”
about 0:06:14

4 stars

“The police and fire departments do their job; the fire department is strictly volunteer and the police patrol the area.”
about 0:07:19

In Iowa

Closest episodes

  1. Onion Of LiesAgency, Iowa · 27 July 202442 km / 26 miShow on map
  2. Power Saws, Little Red Wagons & Corpse Finding CatsLibertyville, Iowa · 27 August 202064 km / 40 miShow on map
  3. Six Unthinkable ThingsNorwalk, Iowa · 18 October 201790 km / 56 miShow on map
  4. It's Always The Quiet OnesBonaparte, Iowa · 24 January 201992 km / 57 miShow on map
  5. Be My BabyKeokuk, Iowa · 2 January 2025137 km / 85 miShow on map

The story

Albia, Iowa, is a small town of 3,713 people in the south central part of the state, where the median household income is $43,877 and the median home costs $115,800. The murder this episode follows did not happen in Albia itself but about 45 minutes away in Derby, a near ghost town of 90 people with a post office open from eight until noon. Everybody involved, however, was from Albia.

That autumn he had started spending time with a distant cousin, 18-year-old Jeff Willems, and had moved into the house where Willems lived with his mother Susan and stepfather Ivan Snow in Derby. Willems had a reputation as a hothead who drank too much and had once punched his father in the face over a comment about a girl.

On Wednesday 23 November 1983, the day before Thanksgiving, Ivan Snow sharpened a knife and gave it to Willems, telling him it was illegal to carry it. In the early evening they drove to the Albia home of Willems's 17-year-old ex-girlfriend, Stephanie Clark, and drank with her until about ten. The three of them then set off in the truck, drinking as they went, and after midnight they arrived back at the Snow house and carried on. Ivan and Susan Snow came home around two in the morning and joined the party. Between noon and four in the morning the two young men got through about 60 beers.

At about four in the morning Clark went upstairs to bed. The two men went outside and sat in Willems's truck, Willems in the driver's seat, and drove off.

A block or two away the truck stopped. Snow knocked him to the ground, punched him and threatened to kill him, then ran to the truck with Susan Snow and Clark. Willems was lying across the driver's seat, bleeding from a stab wound about three inches deep that had damaged his heart. They laid him in the back of the car and drove 14 miles to the Lucas County Hospital in Chariton.

He crashed it after two blocks, stole a second car, passed a deputy sheriff going the other way, crashed that one too and ran off into the snow. The hospital had called the sheriff's department, and a manhunt of about 40 officers, including the highway patrol, the Bureau of Criminal Investigation and a plane from Des Moines, followed his footprints to a barn on the Archangel Farm south of Chariton on Highway 14. They found him huddled under lumber and scrap metal, frostbitten from the knees down, with the loaded rifle beside him.

He claimed he had stolen the cars only to rush to the hospital. No knife was found in the truck; the blade was still in Willems's chest when he reached hospital.

His defence argued accident and involuntary manslaughter, pointing out that he was left-handed and would not have put the knife in his right pocket; the prosecution argued intentional killing, that he provoked the fight and that only deadly force can answer deadly force. A reporter said it was like someone popped his balloon and he shrank in his seat.

The case

Murder of Jeff Willems

Victims

Jeff Willems (18). distant cousin; Willems lived with his mother and stepfather in Derby and had taken in

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 15 October 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Stephanie Clark. Willems's 17-year-old ex-girlfriend, the key prosecution witness
Ivan Snow. Willems's stepfather, who sharpened the knife and gave it to him; knocked down and helped drive Willems to hospital
Bert Muer. deputy sheriff sent to the hospital to investigate
Rick Masner. deputy who passed stolen car and saw him run from the wreck

The timeline

  1. the fall of 1983 starts hanging out with his distant cousin Jeff Willems and moves into the Snow house (Snow house)about 0:13:02
  2. November 23rd, 1983 The day before Thanksgiving, Ivan Snow sharpens a knife and gives it to Willems, warning him it is illegal to carry (Snow house)about 0:16:37
  3. about 10 a.m., November 23rd, 1983 and Willems start drinkingabout 0:21:06
  4. around noon, November 23rd, 1983 They leave the Snow house in Willems's pickup and spend the day drinking and running errands; they get through about 60 beers between them by 4 a.m. (Snow house)about 0:17:38
  5. early evening, November 23rd, 1983 They drive to Stephanie Clark's home in Albia and drink with her until about 10 p.m. (Clark house)about 0:22:42
  6. about 10 p.m., November 23rd, 1983 The three of them leave in the truck, drink as they drive, and head for Derbyabout 0:23:13
  7. after midnight, November 24th, 1983 They arrive at the Snow house and carry on drinking (Snow house)about 0:24:12
  8. about 2 a.m., November 24th, 1983 Ivan and Susan Snow come home and join the party (Snow house)about 0:24:37
  9. about 4 a.m., November 24th, 1983 Stephanie Clark goes upstairs to bed; follows her and they have consensual sex (Snow house)about 0:26:32
  10. about 4 a.m., November 24th, 1983 Willems pulls off her and tells him to come downstairs; opens a knife, says he will kill Jeff if he has to to win the fight, and puts it open in his right front pocket (Snow house)about 0:28:49
  11. shortly after The two men go out to Willems's truck to talk and drive offabout 0:31:17
  12. Clark tells Ivan Snow she thinks will stab Jeff, and they follow the truck in Snow's car (Snow house)about 0:32:09
  13. The truck stops, gets out and says 'I stuck him'; Ivan Snow knocks him to the ground and threatens to kill himabout 0:32:44
  14. Willems is found bleeding from the chest in the truck and is driven 14 miles to the Lucas County Hospital in Chariton, where he is dead on arrival (Lucas County Hospital)about 0:33:48

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.