FILE 381 / 20 April 2023 / 170 MIN / full

Hunting The Home Hermit

Caledon, OntarioListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

This is in Caledon, Ontario, in southern Ontario, in the Peel Region, about an hour outside Toronto. about 0:05:24

History, in brief

1869

In 1869 there was a village called Belfountain, population 100, in the township of Caledon, Peel County.

about 0:06:49

Town note

Belfountain was established on the river and stage coaches ran to and from it.

about 0:07:01

1973

In 1973 Caledon acquired more territory when another town dissolved, with most sections north of Mayfield Road transferred to the township.

about 0:07:16
All 8 history facts

1869

In 1869 there was a village called Belfountain, population 100, in the township of Caledon, Peel County.

about 0:06:49

Town note

Belfountain was established on the river and stage coaches ran to and from it.

about 0:07:01

1973

In 1973 Caledon acquired more territory when another town dissolved, with most sections north of Mayfield Road transferred to the township.

about 0:07:16

1974

It inherited the name Caledon Township of Peel County, Ontario in 1974.

about 0:07:36

Town note

The name came from settler Edward Ellis, who came from a place in Northern Ireland called Caledon.

about 0:07:36

Town note

The Cunnington Osborne complex was started by Daniel and Ellen Jane Cunnington, who moved to the property in the late 1880s.

about 0:38:17

1894

The octagonal barn was built in 1894 by Daniel Cunnington, using lighter timber framing for extra floor space and cheaper construction.

about 0:38:31

The figures, as told

Religious

58.5%

Biggest faith: Catholic, 38.2%

about 0:17:23

Who lives here

White 66%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ 62% less

about 0:23:48

Violent crime
▼ 60% less

about 0:23:58

Money

Median household income$83,454

For sale

$6,799,000

Six-bedroom, five-bath house with indoor basketball court

about 0:21:25
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

Property crime

"62% less"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:23:48

Violent crime, murder, robbery and assault

"60% less"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:23:58

Population in 1991

"34,965"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:15:44

Population now

"about 70,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:15:55

Median age

"a little under 41"

Comparison: "a few years older than the average". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:02

Italians

"23.2%"

Comparison: "largest ethnic group". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:16

White residents

"66%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:48

Visible minorities

"32.8%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:16:48

Religious residents

"58.5%"

Comparison: "higher than the US average, which is 50-50". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:23

Catholic

"38.2%"

Comparison: "highest denomination". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:28

Median dwelling value

"$474,087"

Comparison: "national average $280,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:17:55

Median household income

"$83,454"

Comparison: "Canadian national average $54,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:18:11

Four-bedroom, two-bath house

"$1,398,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:19:39

Five-bedroom, seven-bath house

"$3,999,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:20:29

Six-bedroom, five-bath house with indoor basketball court

"$6,799,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:21:25

The reviews

1.8 / 5 · average of 4

4 out of 5 stars

“Arrived without a reservation, met by friendly professional staff, checked in quickly, tidy clean room that smelled nice, mini fridge and microwave, quiet stay, positive overall.”
about 0:09:21

1 out of 5 stars

“Doors do not close safely, the guest was robbed, staff offered no help and the front manager is always late; the owner replied apologising and promising a security review.”
about 0:10:56

1 out of 5 stars

“A Nike sweater and Under Armour tee left behind were denied by staff; the owner replied offering to help locate lost items.”
about 0:13:29

1 out of 5 stars

“Booked through Hotwire, charged for the room, then told on arrival after a six-hour drive that the reservation was cancelled with no notice by rude, arrogant staff; the trip was cut short.”
about 0:14:07

In Ontario

Closest episodes

  1. Deadly, Disturbed & LazyOshawa, Ontario · 7 September 202484 km / 52 miShow on map
  2. Murderer MayorPembroke, New York · 21 March 2026154 km / 96 miShow on map
  3. A Serial SlasherStrathroy, Ontario · 24 January 2018170 km / 106 miShow on map
  4. Suburban Ax Murder MysteryBrighton, New York · 26 December 2024204 km / 127 miShow on map
  5. The Kinky KillerPenfield, New York · 11 January 2024213 km / 132 miShow on map

The story

In October 1991 a forty-seven-year-old woman named Carolyn Case vanished from the Jeweled Elephant, a gift shop in Toronto where she worked. A couple of days later her white Mercedes-Benz was found in a ditch near Caledon, Ontario, blood-stained, with no trace of her. Months later a skeleton, probably hers, was found in the woods 457 metres from where the car had been left.

He kept it and let it decay: paint peeling, grass uncut, curtains drawn in summer, and neighbours saying they never knew anyone lived there. He mostly lived in the attic and would disappear into the bush for weeks at a time, often barefoot, sleeping in the same clothes. A neighbour, Joyce Brundle, said the lights were never on. A twelve-year-old next door, Candice Schultz, said the local children were told to keep away because he slept in the attic.

Alison Shaw, Daris's wife, sold her paintings in a corner of his shop. His shop closed in April 1991. He also called him a walking time bomb.

He arranged a tour with the owners, Ian and Nancy Blackburn. Ian was fifty-five, a partner in the real estate firm Harrison and Blackburn; Nancy was forty-nine and a public health nurse. They had no children, had been together about twenty-five years, and used the Caledon farmhouse as a weekend escape. They wanted to sell the barn so it could be taken down and rebuilt elsewhere.

Instead, through the summer of 1991, he drifted between jobs, carrying a revolver in a briefcase and ordering ammunition at a gun shop. A labourer's employer, Kevin de Solinares, later testified about the gun and the missing bullets. Around the same time a rash of cottage break-ins hit the Caledon area: intruders left pornographic magazines, large bottles of urine and faeces wrapped in newspaper, and seemed to have been living in the cottages.

In the winter of 1991 Barry Barnet and his wife were walking near Green Lake with another couple when they checked on a friend's cottage. A pot of soup was simmering on the stove and a shaggy stranger came out of the shadows holding a revolver. He made three of them sit on the chesterfield for about ten minutes while he gathered his things, then left. Nobody was hurt, but the cottage community was frightened.

In April 1992 Ian Blackburn went alone to the Caledon farm, apparently to prepare it for the following weekend. He was jumped, beaten and bound as he came through the door. At 7.36 in the evening a three-minute call went from the farmhouse to the Blackburn home in Toronto, and Nancy was persuaded to drive up the next morning. When she opened the door she was attacked, stripped and choked, then sexually assaulted in front of the bound Ian. There he killed Ian and put him in the trunk beside his wife, then walked away.

On April 13 the Blackburns' nephew, Jamie Osborne, went to check on them after six days without word. He found newspapers piled on the step, blood-stained tissues in the car and, in the trunk, both bodies. The autopsy showed Ian died of asphyxia with a blunt-force injury to his neck; Nancy had been strangled and had multiple blunt-force injuries and ligature marks on her ankles, wrists, neck and mouth. Before long they found a garbage bag in a ditch near the murder site containing bottles of urine and newspaper-wrapped faeces, the same calling card as the cottage break-ins.

On June 29 a twenty-six-year-old manager alone in a clothing store was forced into the back room at gunpoint and raped; she escaped naked and handcuffed into the street. On July 3 Lenore Retray, twenty-one, disappeared from Sutter's Photo Studio at East Hastings Street. On July 11 he robbed a North Vancouver video rental store and abducted Monica Fast, nineteen, forcing her to drive her own Volkswagen Beetle to the camp. Police found the car, heard screaming and discovered both women tied to trees; Retray was catatonic after nine days.

He beat her, hogtied her, gagged her with her slip, put a plastic bag over her head and wrapped a wire around her neck. Jelanou spent five days in hospital with a separated breastbone and rib cage. She testified that he had told her he would fuck her to death, and that she had fought for her life for more than twenty minutes.

Relatives of the Blackburn family later sold the farm, though the octagonal barn was still standing.

The case

Murder of Ian and Nancy Blackburn

Victims

Ian Blackburn (55). partner in the real estate firm Harrison and Blackburn
Nancy Blackburn (49). public health nurse, his wife

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 20 April 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Jamie Osborne. the Blackburns' nephew, who found the bodies
Alison Shaw. author and former business associate who identified his handwriting
Daris Shaw. former business partner left with $2,600 in debts
Kevin de Solinares. employer who hired as a labourer and testified about the revolver
Barry Barnet. family friend who found in a cottage at Green Lake
Alex Raburn. cottage owner in the Green Lake party
Ian Blackburn's sister and brother-in-law. owned property next door to the farm

The timeline

  1. 1955 is born.about 0:25:00
  2. 1961 father dies of a heart attack when is six.about 0:25:45
  3. 1988 Daris and Alison Shaw move from Toronto to Orangeville and meet . (Orangeville)about 0:57:54
  4. early 1991 spots the octagonal barn while driving and arranges a tour with the owners, Ian and Nancy Blackburn. (Cunnington octagonal barn)about 0:37:50
  5. April 1991 Simply Timeless Antiques closes down. (Simply Timeless Antiques)about 0:49:07
  6. 1991 partnership with Daris Shaw sours and he leaves Shaw $2,600 in debts. (Orangeville)about 0:50:33
  7. August 1991 Kevin de Solinares last sees , about a week after walked off the job.about 2:21:21
  8. March 18, 1992 forces an elderly couple at gunpoint to drive him from their Midland-area cottage towards Toronto, then jumps out at a busy intersection and escapes. (Midland-area cottage)about 1:09:50
  9. April 1992 Ian Blackburn goes alone to the farm to prepare it for the following weekend. (Blackburn farmhouse)about 1:17:29
  10. April 1992 Ian is jumped, beaten and bound as he walks through the farmhouse door. (Blackburn farmhouse)about 1:18:13

Disappearance of Carolyn Case

Victims

Carolyn Case (47). worked at the Jeweled Elephant gift shop in Toronto

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 20 April 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Carolyn Case's husband. said police told him privately the skeleton was probably his wife

The timeline

  1. October 2, 1991 Carolyn Case, 47, disappears from the Jeweled Elephant gift shop in Toronto. (Jeweled Elephant)about 1:02:10

Kidnappings and sexual assaults in Vancouver

Victims

Unnamed clothing store manager (26). working alone in a Vancouver clothing store when attacked her on June 29, 1992
Lenore Retray (21). worked at Sutter's Photo Studio; abducted on July 3, 1992 and held for eight or nine days
Monica Fast (19). abducted from a North Vancouver video rental store on July 11, 1992 and tied to a tree
Dalia Jelanou (53). Lithuanian refugee and Auschwitz survivor, attacked at the restaurant where she worked

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 20 April 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Dr. Stanley Semrau. psychiatrist who testified about personality disorder
Sandra Gossin. woman who wrote to the Vancouver Sun saying she was the one held for nine days
Edna. Lenore Retray's grandmother

The timeline

  1. June 29, 1992 A 26-year-old manager alone in a Vancouver clothing store is forced into the back room at gunpoint and raped; she escapes naked and handcuffed out of the back door. (Vancouver clothing store)about 1:47:07
  2. June 29, 1992 Police do not connect the attack to because they believe he is in Toronto.about 1:47:42
  3. July 3, 1992 Lenore Retray, 21, disappears from Sutter's Photo Studio at East Hastings Street. (Sutter's Photo Studio)about 1:48:18

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode