FILE 426 / 23 September 2023 / 72 MIN / express

The Chief, The Floozie & The Church Lady

Lyons, NebraskaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

"This is Lyons, Nebraska. It is like north of Omaha there, by Iowa... near Sioux City"; had been a Burt County deputy sheriff about 0:03:26

History, in brief

1866

The first settlers came in 1866, right after the Civil War, drawn by the fertile soil.

about 0:04:53

1884

The railroad came through and the town was incorporated in 1884, named for Waldo Lyon, a prominent citizen whose land the plots were laid out on.

about 0:05:02

1891

One of the finest trotting tracks in the country opened in 1891.

about 0:05:32

Town note

Famous horses broke world records at the trotting track.

about 0:05:57
All 6 history facts

1866

The first settlers came in 1866, right after the Civil War, drawn by the fertile soil.

about 0:04:53

1884

The railroad came through and the town was incorporated in 1884, named for Waldo Lyon, a prominent citizen whose land the plots were laid out on.

about 0:05:02

1891

One of the finest trotting tracks in the country opened in 1891.

about 0:05:32

Town note

Famous horses broke world records at the trotting track.

about 0:05:57

1893

Hard times came and the trotting track closed in 1893, two years after it opened.

about 0:06:05

Town note

The town is known as "the sod capital of America"; sod is grown there and trucked away.

about 0:04:26

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$95,800
Median household income$34,327
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2023

Population change

"down 26%"

Comparison: "since 2020". Direction: below.

As told in 2023 about 0:03:45

Median household income

"$34,327"

Comparison: "more than $20,000 less than the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2023 about 0:03:56

Median home price

"$95,800"

No direction stated.

As told in 2023 about 0:04:07

The reviews

4.0 / 5 · average of 1

4 stars

“The reviewer lives outside the city limits and absolutely loves it: a small town with lots of wonderful people, a school whose teachers promote healthy learning, and a great, quiet area to live in.”
about 0:06:23

In Nebraska

Closest episodes

  1. Body Part Scavenger HuntEmerson, Nebraska · 10 July 202643 km / 27 miShow on map
  2. Covering Your Murder TracksYutan, Nebraska · 15 August 202577 km / 48 miShow on map
  3. In Colder BloodMurdock, Nebraska · 23 March 2023113 km / 70 miShow on map
  4. The Devil's GiftAlvo, Nebraska · 8 October 2022118 km / 73 miShow on map
  5. Cold Blooded "Hero"Early, Iowa · 2 April 2026123 km / 76 miShow on map

The story

Anna Marie Miller was born in Washington, D.C., in 1952 and grew up in a small town in Iowa. Friends described her as an attractive, petite, energetic girl who experimented with drugs and was nicknamed Spacey. She drifted through a series of religions, from Catholicism to the Bahai faith, Rosicrucianism and Episcopalianism, before returning to the Catholic Church. In 1975 a one-car crash nearly killed her. Afterwards she dragged one leg and walked with a cane, and she had facial scars that she covered with make-up.

She married a manual labourer named Tom Anton, but the marriage ended in divorce and she came away with $1,000, some appliances from her father and three Irish setters. For a time she lived rent-free in an elderly man's farmhouse in Iowa, an arrangement made through the local Catholic church, until the owner died and the estate sold the property. In October 1986, with nowhere else to go, she moved to Lyons, Nebraska, a town of 712 people which, as the mayor Mary Piper said, gave her no logical reason to be there.

He told Anna that the downstairs flat of the pink house where he lived was free, and she took it, with his cruiser parked outside and the chief living above her.

In town Anna presented herself as intensely devout, hostile to drink and drugs, and frightened of her ex-husband, whom she said had shot out the windows of the farmhouse and whose drug ring she claimed to have reported. She told her neighbour Shirley Edgecomb that she feared for her life and gave her an envelope with the name of an Iowa friend, Sylvia Nelson, to contact if anything happened to her. None of the story was true.

On 15 December 1986 Anna was not seen. Her cane was gone, and her three dogs were shut in the basement with no arrangements made for them. Twelve days later, after Christmas, a farmer collecting hay from leased land on the Winnebago reservation drove down County Road G, an unmaintained dirt road about twenty miles from Lyons, and saw an arm sticking out of the grass. Anna was naked and wrapped in a blanket, with frost on her and three .38 bullet holes, two in the side and one in the head.

On 28 December he denied sleeping with her, then said they had slept together on her first night in town and never again. Blood was found in her flat, in the hallway and on the stairs, and the laboratory confirmed it was her blood type. On 30 December the mayor saw him leaving the First National Bank; he had withdrawn $3,500 and he was gone. On 7 January he telephoned a deputy named Douglas in Oakland, Nebraska, to ask whether his name was on the national crime computer, and told him that he had woken to find Anna dead on the kitchen floor, had wrapped her in a sheet and dumped her in a field. Douglas did not pass the account on for eleven days.

He travelled through Belize, Guatemala City and Costa Rica, ran out of money and crossed back into the United States at Nogales. He now lives in retirement in Daytona Beach and still maintains that a former girlfriend killed Anna in a jealous rage. Anna is buried in Greenville cemetery in Clay County, Iowa.

The case

Murder of Anna Marie Miller Anton

Victims

Anna Marie Miller Anton (34). born Anna Marie Miller in 1952, divorced from Tom Anton, disabled after a 1975 car crash and living on disability income; known as Susie and as Spacey

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 23 September 2023.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Shirley Edgecomb. neighbour across the street who was to drive her to the food pantry and raised the alarm
Sylvia Nelson. her friend in Iowa, named in the envelope to be opened if anything happened to her
Mary Piper. mayor of Lyons, who said there was no logical reason for Anna to move there
Spike Going. former mayor who believed was fleeing the killers rather than the law
Krieger. investigator who tracked down in Florida
Douglas. substitute officer in Oakland, Nebraska, whom telephoned from the road
Pam Gilroy. Florida woman with five children who lived with and knew he was a fugitive

The timeline

  1. 1952 Anna Marie Miller is born in Washington, D.C. and grows up in a small town in Iowaabout 0:11:42
  2. 1975 A one-car crash nearly kills her; afterwards she drags one leg and walks with a cane and has facial scarsabout 0:18:26
  3. 1977 leaves the Burt County sheriff's department to serve as a paid mercenary in Rhodesia; he injures a knee in training and comes home after ten weeksabout 0:33:56
  4. 1981 attends a Soldier of Fortune training camp in Arizonaabout 0:35:14
  5. Anna marries Tom Anton, a grumpy manual labourerabout 0:18:53
  6. The marriage ends in divorce; she gets $1,000, appliances from her father and three Irish settersabout 0:20:06
  7. She lives rent-free in an elderly man's farmhouse in Iowa until he dies and the estate sells the property (farmhouse in Iowa)about 0:20:38
  8. October 1986 Anna moves into the downstairs flat of the pink house in Lyons, the flat told her about after they met at the Dry Dock Lounge (pink house)about 0:21:21
  9. October 1986 On the night a friend from Iowa helps her move in, Anna sleeps upstairs in flat (pink house)about 0:41:40
  10. about a month later She writes to the friend that she plans a trip to Iowa with and does not know if she can stand to be with him that longabout 0:41:54
  11. December 15th, 1986 Anna is not seen by anyone in townabout 0:42:24
  12. December 16th, 1986 Shirley Edgecomb comes to take her to the food pantry and gets no answer; later says this is the day she died (pink house)about 0:42:24
  13. December 17th, 1986 files a missing persons report on herabout 0:44:21
  14. twelve days later, after Christmas A farmer collecting hay from leased land on the Winnebago reservation finds an arm sticking out of the grass; Anna is naked, wrapped in a blanket and shot three times with a .38 (County Road G)about 0:44:49

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode