FILE 490 / 4 May 2024 / 70 MIN / express

Hot Tub Horrors

Hot Springs, MontanaListen

The town

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going to Hot Springs, Montana, in western Montana all the way over by Idaho, in northwestern Montana near the Idaho border, about an hour and 20 from Missoula. about 0:03:05

History, in brief

1929

The town was founded as the settlements of Pineville and Camas in the 1890s and incorporated in 1929.

about 0:05:40

Town note

It was previously known as Camas and Camas Hot Springs, after the camas plant that grows in the area.

about 0:05:48
All 15 history facts

1929

The town was founded as the settlements of Pineville and Camas in the 1890s and incorporated in 1929.

about 0:05:40

Town note

It was previously known as Camas and Camas Hot Springs, after the camas plant that grows in the area.

about 0:05:48

1931

The town burned down again in 1931 and was rebuilt.

about 0:06:31

Town note

The sawmill burned down at a time when the hospital was closed.

about 0:06:50

Town note

The Hot Springs Mercantile burned to the ground in the 1980s.

about 0:07:05

1990

Cattle prices fell and logging was curtailed, and the population dropped to 400 by 1990.

about 0:07:12

1913

The Wild Horse Hot Springs was developed in 1913 when a well driller hit 128-degree water.

about 0:16:29

1912

It was originally known as the Camp Aqua Bathhouse and was found by Mollie Bartlett in 1912 while a well was being drilled for drinking water.

about 0:16:50

Town note

Mollie Bartlett was the daughter of Robert B. Smith, the third governor of Montana.

about 0:17:15

1941

In 1941 she raised money for the Montana Warm Water Project for Crippled Children and built the Camp Aqua polio treatment centre.

about 0:17:23

Town note

A public resort was built later, and in the 1980s it was funded by a Montana renewable energy grant.

about 0:17:37

Town note

It was renamed the Wild Horse Hot Springs in the early 1990s when it changed from public to private ownership.

about 0:17:43

Town note

The springs are fed by the Mother Dragon Geyser and the water runs from about 100 to 128 degrees.

about 0:18:01

The figures, as told

Who lives here

White 90%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Money

Median home value$224,100
Median household income$19,659
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2024

Median household income

"$19,659"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:05

Median home price

"$224,100"

Comparison: "lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2024 about 0:04:28

White residents

"90%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2024 about 0:08:50

The reviews

4.0 / 5 · average of 1

4 stars

“A longtime resident loves the town and its people but says the small community makes the drug problems and poverty stand out.”
about 0:07:25

In Montana

Closest episodes

  1. Talkative Serial KillerKellogg, Idaho · 15 May 2025110 km / 68 miShow on map
  2. One Drifter, Two MurdersOvando, Montana · 19 April 2017130 km / 81 miShow on map
  3. Mystery Of The Fake DadSandpoint, Idaho · 3 February 2024159 km / 99 miShow on map
  4. The Zombie Apocalypse Has BegunCoeur d'Alene, Idaho · 4 August 2022160 km / 99 miShow on map
  5. Family Murder TreePost Falls, Idaho · 24 July 2026171 km / 106 miShow on map

The story

Hot Springs is a small town in western Montana, close to the Idaho border and about an hour and twenty minutes from Missoula. James describes it as a pretty place in a valley surrounded by mountains, with a population of 618, a median household income of $19,659 and a median home price of $224,100. The town began as the settlements of Pineville and Camas in the 1890s, was incorporated in 1929 and was known as Camas and Camas Hot Springs before taking its present name. Fires destroyed most of Main Street in 1918 and the town burned again in 1931; the sawmill burned, the hospital closed and, after the Hot Springs Mercantile burned in the 1980s, falling cattle prices and curtailed logging cut the population to about 400 by 1990. Its motto is 'limp in, leap out', a reference to the supposedly healing waters.

In 2003 he rented a friend's Ford Ranger, fell asleep at the wheel on the way back from visiting his grandmother in Browning, wrecked the truck and injured himself; he was eventually ordered to pay $2,500 restitution by August 11, 2004.

Kenmille was married to Terry and had four children, and sang with the Elmo-based Chief Cliff drum group.

Employees saw Kenmille become increasingly drunk and unsteady. Dave Smith heard glass breaking and what sounded like men roughhousing and laughing. Eusta checked the room several times and eventually found Kenmille slumped, apparently unconscious, with the water around him tinted red and blood on broken glass from the sauna door. Rigor mortis prevented them from putting him in a car, so they called 911 and Eusta began CPR. Kenmille was taken to the hospital in Plains and pronounced dead.

A post-mortem found blunt force injuries to the head, abdomen and limbs, a deep gash on the right arm, and drowning, along with anal dilation, rectal bruising and internal lacerations.

The state was allowed to use the earlier attack on JB as evidence of motive, intent, preparation and plan.

The Wild Horse had been operating without a licence since about 2009. In 2019 the pool where Kenmille died was sealed and torn down during renovations. On September 16, 2020, the county health department ordered the resort to cease operations.

The case

Murder of Lawrence Kenmille

Victims

Lawrence Kenmille (27). Nicknamed La; married to Terry and had four children; sang with the Elmo-based Chief Cliff drum group.

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 4 May 2024.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

JB. 40-year-old cousin; diabetic with two recently amputated toes; assaulted by the week before the murder.
Basu Aeneas. Teenage cousin who went to the springs with and JB the week before.
Eusta Aeneas. 16-year-old cousin, Basu's younger brother; went with and Kenmille on May 25 and raised the alarm.
Terry Kenmille. Lawrence's wife.
Derek Smith. Wild Horse employee who checked on Lawrence and helped pull him from the tub.
Dave Smith. Derek's father, working at the Wild Horse.

The timeline

  1. 2003 rents a friend's Ford Ranger for $20, falls asleep at the wheel on the way back from visiting his grandmother in Browning and totals the truck, injuring himself.about 0:12:30
  2. mid-May 2013 and his teenage cousin Basu Aeneas ask cousin JB, 40, to drive them to the Wild Horse Hot Springs; they drink beer and whiskey in the car on the way.about 0:15:51
  3. mid-May 2013 In room four rubs JB's inner thigh, sends Basu out, tells JB to turn around and drop his trunks, and pushes him back into the water when he tries to leave; JB gets out and flees. (Room four)about 0:25:27
  4. mid-May 2013 drives JB and Basu home erratically; JB gets out and walks, and returns about 20 minutes later and takes him the rest of the way.about 0:31:23
  5. May 25, 2013 buys two bottles of rum and eats a late breakfast at his aunt's house, where Lawrence Kenmille is staying. (Aunt's house)about 0:32:13
  6. May 25, 2013 , Lawrence Kenmille and 16-year-old Eusta Aeneas arrive at the Wild Horse Hot Springs about 3 p.m., already drunk on rum. (Wild Horse Hot Springs)about 0:34:59
  7. May 25, 2013 Around 5 p.m. and Kenmille put on swim trunks and get into the hot tub in room four; Eusta waits in the lobby. (Room four)about 0:36:04
  8. May 25, 2013 Employees see Kenmille become increasingly drunk, with slurred speech and leaning on walls for support. (Wild Horse Hot Springs)about 0:35:38
  9. May 25, 2013 Dave Smith hears glass breaking and what sounds like men roughhousing and laughing from the direction of room four. (Room four)about 0:40:30
  10. May 25, 2013 Eusta finds Kenmille slumped with his eyes closed and the water around him tinted red; broken sauna glass on the floor is speckled with blood. says Kenmille slipped, is playing possum and is fine. (Room four)about 0:38:00
  11. May 25, 2013 Derek Smith checks room four and sees Kenmille face down in the corner with patting his back; says they need nothing. (Room four)about 0:39:30
  12. May 25, 2013 asks Derek to help pull Kenmille out; his grip slips and Kenmille's face goes under without any reaction. Bruising shows on his shins and blood pools under his head. (Room four)about 0:41:04
  13. May 25, 2013 They try to put Kenmille in car but rigor mortis has set in; they call 911 and Eusta starts CPR. (Wild Horse Hot Springs)about 0:42:20
  14. May 25, 2013 An ambulance takes Kenmille to the hospital in Plains, where he is pronounced dead. (Plains hospital)about 0:42:52

Death of Kerry Ann Allison

Victims

Kerry Ann Allison (39). From Polson, Montana.

Outcome

Other people

The timeline

  1. 2020 Kerry Ann Allison, 39, of Polson, is found dead in one of the hot springs at the Wild Horse. (Wild Horse Hot Springs)about 1:05:39

Last meals

  • Lawrence Kenmille. a late breakfast at his mother's house the morning of the murder, May 25, 2013about 0:33:58

Places and phrases

N ↑Town centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode