FILE 593 / 1 May 2025 / 174 MIN / full

Jerry Springer Show Murder

Sarasota, FloridaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We are going down to Sarasota this week. Sarasota, Florida. It is south of Tampa down there, southwestern Florida. about 0:04:25

History, in brief

Town note

The origin of the name is disputed; some claim it comes from Sarah, the daughter of the conquistador De Soto, and others from a Native phrase meaning an area of land easily observed.

about 0:05:48

Town note

The town has used the mottos May Sarasota Prosper and Where Urban Amenities Meet Small Town Living, and the nickname Circus City.

about 0:05:13

1883

Around 1883 the Florida Mortgage and Investment Company of Edinburgh bought 60,000 acres in Sarasota for development, selling plots to Scottish settlers.

about 0:06:22

1911

From 1911 onward Mabel and John Ringling spent their winters in Sarasota and bought a large parcel of property as their permanent winter headquarters, drawing other members of the Ringling family there.

about 0:07:05
All 7 history facts

Town note

The origin of the name is disputed; some claim it comes from Sarah, the daughter of the conquistador De Soto, and others from a Native phrase meaning an area of land easily observed.

about 0:05:48

Town note

The town has used the mottos May Sarasota Prosper and Where Urban Amenities Meet Small Town Living, and the nickname Circus City.

about 0:05:13

1883

Around 1883 the Florida Mortgage and Investment Company of Edinburgh bought 60,000 acres in Sarasota for development, selling plots to Scottish settlers.

about 0:06:22

1911

From 1911 onward Mabel and John Ringling spent their winters in Sarasota and bought a large parcel of property as their permanent winter headquarters, drawing other members of the Ringling family there.

about 0:07:05

Town note

Charles Ringling and his wife Edith built a large Bayfront winter retreat, and he died soon after it was finished.

about 0:07:59

2022

In September 2022 Hurricane Ian made landfall, with winds in Sarasota County exceeding 85 miles an hour inside a 200-mile-an-hour wind field.

about 0:09:22

Town note

Sarasota County suffered 10 fatalities in the storm, the second highest county total behind Lee County.

about 0:09:41

The figures, as told

Religious

44%

about 0:14:30

Who lives here

White 64.8% · Black 13.7% · Asian 1.4% · Hispanic 18.3%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ almost twice

about 0:22:23

Violent crime
▲ slightly above average

about 0:22:37

Money

Median home value$454,200
Two-bedroom rent$1,580
Median household income$62,615
Cost of living$105

For sale

$199,000

Two-bedroom, two-bath, 1,480-square-foot house listing

about 0:16:30

For sale

$625,000

Three-bedroom, two-bath, 1,802-square-foot house listing

about 0:16:56

For sale

$24,700,000

Six-bedroom, nine-bath, 8,929-square-foot beach house listing

about 0:17:59
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2025

Population

"53,786"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:18

Women

"about 53.5%"

Comparison: "well out of whack with the normal". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:32

Median age

"49"

Comparison: "about 12 years older than the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:13:40

Married

"about 41%"

Comparison: "below the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:02

Single with children

"21%"

Comparison: "about double the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:06

White

"64.8%"

Comparison: "within a couple of percentage points of the national breakdown". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:14:13

Median household income

"$62,615"

Comparison: "national average about $69,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:15:04

Cost of living index

"$105"

Comparison: "national average $100". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:15:15

Median home cost

"$454,200"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:15:28

Average two-bedroom rent

"$1,580"

Comparison: "a couple of hundred over the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:15:53

Two-bedroom, two-bath, 1,480-square-foot house listing

"$199,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:16:30

Three-bedroom, two-bath, 1,802-square-foot house listing

"$625,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:16:56

Six-bedroom, nine-bath, 8,929-square-foot beach house listing

"$24,700,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 0:17:59

Grand Cayman Street house value at purchase

"$103,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 1:24:41

Grand Cayman Street house Zestimate

"$450,800"

No direction stated.

As told in 2025 about 1:24:45

Property crime

"almost twice"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:22:23

Violent crime

"slightly above average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2025 about 0:22:37

The reviews

2.7 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“Sarasota has it all: every store and restaurant you could imagine, beautiful parks and beaches, lots of walking paths and the Legacy Trail to Venice, good for biking; the only complaints are traffic and awful public schools.”
about 0:10:57

2 stars

“Overpopulated by people moving in mostly from the Northeast; traffic crashes nonstop, schools are overcrowded, crime is growing, homeless people everywhere, new unaffordable neighbourhoods going up and infrastructure not keeping up, beaches impossible at weekends; a lifelong resident takes beach holidays elsewhere and hopes to sell to a fool from New York.”
about 0:11:43

1 star

“A Boston transplant says do not move to Florida: rude people, everyone has two jobs, crazy drivers, beyond expensive, poor pay, high rent, constant chain restaurants and weird people, Twilight Zone weird.”
about 0:12:50

In Florida

Closest episodes

  1. A Man Named "Hillbilly"Fruitville, Florida · 5 November 20208 km / 5 miShow on map
  2. The Unluckiest WinnerPlant City, Florida · 12 February 202686 km / 53 miShow on map
  3. A Deadly RecipeAlturas, Florida · 5 December 2019102 km / 63 miShow on map
  4. Natural Porn KillersNew Port Richey, Florida · 18 March 2023102 km / 63 miShow on map
  5. The Explosive Enigma MurdersNaples, Florida · 27 August 2026152 km / 94 miShow on map

The story

In 1996 Nancy Campbell, a widow from Michigan who had raised two sons on her own, was introduced by friends to AOL chat rooms. They talked online for about a year, and in 1997 he flew to the United States and married her almost at once.

The marriage was volatile from the start. Court records show a pattern of injunctions filed and withdrawn, of separations and reconciliations. On 25 July 1998 she filed an injunction against him.

He told Eleanor that Nancy was stalking them and that they needed to confront her. Instead of a mediator, they took the dispute to The Jerry Springer Show, which taped an episode titled Secret Mistresses Confronted on 7 May 2000, Nancy's 48th birthday.

She did not know he had married Eleanor. Nancy learned from the audience reaction that she was the mistress, not Eleanor. Nancy said, "That's fine, bye," and walked off. Backstage, producers told her that if she did not go back out she would not get her return ticket. She refused, and the show put her out on the streets of Chicago with her suitcase, no hotel, no money and no flight. A stranger who saw her distress bought her a Greyhound ticket to Sarasota.

When a deputy went to serve it, Eleanor produced a conflicting injunction from Manatee County and the sheriff left, unable to decide who had the right to be there.

On the morning of 24 July 2000 Nancy was in court. He then went to a bar, where the Jerry Springer episode was airing that afternoon, and drank heavily as he watched it, at one point telling a stranger, "I'm going to kill her." His nephew Marcus and Eleanor came and went, clearing belongings from the house.

He threw himself on the bed in the master bedroom, then climbed out of a window when police arrived and told the others to meet him at a 7-Eleven. Eleanor later said that she found him running down the street in a daze and picked him up. Marcus, meanwhile, ran to a neighbour, Ron Shin, saying his uncle was drunk and killing his ex-wife and himself. Shin found the front door barricaded from inside and called 911. Neighbours reported a man and a woman fighting, a woman screaming "don't do this", and Eleanor standing in the street screaming towards the house, looking as though she had seen a ghost.

Police arrived at about 7.30 p.m. and broke in at 7.35. Nancy Campbell was on the floor in a pool of blood, strangled and beaten beyond recognition. Her facial bones had been separated from her skull, there were shoe prints in the blood on the kitchen floor and on her face, and the tread carried a Skechers logo. A first-degree murder warrant was issued and Eleanor was wanted as a material witness. They flew from Maine to Florida and surrendered, and were held without bail.

She was given immunity in exchange for answering detectives' questions. She said she saw no blood on her husband and could not imagine he had killed Nancy.

His defence was led by Jeffrey Fieger, the Michigan lawyer known for representing Dr Kevorkian and for suing the Jenny Jones show.

Nancy's sons Gary and Jeffrey and her sister asked for life. He also criticised Jerry Springer and his producers for manipulating the trio to increase their humiliation, asking whether ratings were more important than the dignity of human life. The show issued a statement denying responsibility, noting that the murder happened nearly three months after the taping, on the day it aired.

The case

Murder of Nancy Campbell Panitz

Victims

Nancy Campbell Panitz (48). Born in 1948 in Michigan; widow who raised two sons alone; Panitz's ex-wife; beaten and strangled in her home

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 1 May 2025.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Jeffrey Campbell. Nancy's son
Gary Campbell. Nancy's son
John Wilbur. Nancy's roommate in 1999, hit with a motorcycle helmet by
Ron Shin. neighbour across the street who found the door barricaded and called 911
Judge Robert Bennett. judge who signed the permanent injunction against on July 24, 2000
Charlie Roberts. prosecutor
Jeffrey Fieger. defence attorney, a Michigan lawyer known for defending Dr Kevorkian and suing the Jenny Jones show
Judge Thomas Gallen. 12th Circuit Chief Judge who complained to the Florida Bar about Fieger
Toby Yoshimura. Jerry Springer Show producer interviewed in the documentary
Richard Dominick. former Jerry Springer Show producer

The timeline

  1. 1948 Nancy Campbell is bornabout 0:26:27
  2. the mid-1960s Nancy marries young and has two sons, Jeffrey and Gary, in Michiganabout 0:27:01
  3. the mid-1960s Nancy's husband dies while the boys are toddlers; she raises them aloneabout 0:27:22
  4. 1996 Friends introduce the 48-year-old Nancy to AOL chat rooms and she meets Panitz onlineabout 0:30:26
  5. about a year later Nancy and talk online regularly for about a yearabout 0:32:40
  6. 1997 flies to the United States and marries Nancy almost immediatelyabout 0:35:23
  7. not long after the wedding throws Nancy on the floor and she hits her head; she leaves and files for divorceabout 0:36:49
  8. July 25, 1998 Nancy files an injunction to keep away from her (40th Court East home)about 0:41:15
  9. February 1999 and Nancy divorceabout 0:42:17
  10. February 1999 meets Eleanor onlineabout 0:42:28
  11. July 4, 1999 visits Nancy, argues with her roommate John Wilbur and hits him on the head with a motorcycle helmet while Wilbur is on the phone to 911 (40th Court East home)about 0:44:44
  12. February 2000 Nancy asks the court to dissolve her injunction against , writing that she has no reason to fear him (Sarasota County Courthouse)about 0:51:03
  13. March 17, 2000 marries Eleanor Isaacabout 0:51:30
  14. May 7, 2000 The Jerry Springer Show tapes the episode Secret Mistresses Confronted on Nancy's 48th birthday (Jerry Springer show studio)about 1:00:54
  15. May 7, 2000 Nancy walks off the stage and is left in Chicago without a hotel, money or return ticket; a stranger buys her a bus ticket to Sarasota (Jerry Springer show studio)about 1:19:18
  16. June 10, 2000 Eleanor files for an injunction against , saying Nancy is still stalking them (Sarasota County Courthouse)about 1:23:20
  17. June 15, 2000 Nancy and buy a house together at Grand Cayman Street on a lease-to-buy basis (Grand Cayman Street house)about 1:24:11
  18. June 20, 2000 files for divorce from Eleanor (Sarasota County Courthouse)about 1:25:56
  19. early July 2000 starts messaging Eleanor again, asking her to take him backabout 1:26:05
  20. July 10, 2000 moves himself and Eleanor into Nancy's house; all three are living there (Grand Cayman Street house)about 1:27:04
  21. July 10, 2000, 8.14 a.m. A sheriff's deputy removes Nancy from her own home after Eleanor calls about a disturbance (Grand Cayman Street house)about 1:27:33
  22. July 11, 2000 Nancy is refused an injunction to get back into her house and says she has gone to stay with her aunt and uncle in Manatee County (Sarasota County Courthouse)about 1:28:43
  23. July 11, 2000 nephew Marcus Panitz obtains an injunction against Nancy, claiming she threatened him (Sarasota County Courthouse)about 1:29:37
  24. July 13, 2000, 11.15 a.m. tells a deputy his garage door was open and wallpaper paste and a grey metal box were stolen, blaming Nancy (Grand Cayman Street house)about 1:31:09
  25. about a week and a half later Nancy obtains an injunction keeping Eleanor 500 feet away and an order of protection against , and is given exclusive possession of the Grand Cayman Street house (Sarasota County Courthouse)about 1:33:24
  26. July 24, 2000 Nancy attends court; Judge Robert Bennett signs a permanent injunction against , served that evening (Sarasota County Courthouse)about 1:37:39
  27. July 24, 2000 watches the Jerry Springer episode in a bar, drinking heavily, and tells a stranger he is going to kill Nancyabout 1:38:25
  28. July 24, 2000 , Marcus and Eleanor drive to the house; climbs out of a window when deputies arrive and says to meet him at the 7-Eleven (Grand Cayman Street house)about 1:41:41
  29. July 24, 2000 Eleanor runs up to Marcus at the 7-Eleven saying is in the house trying to kill Nancy (7-Eleven)about 1:43:26
  30. July 24, 2000 Marcus tells neighbour Ron Shin his uncle is drunk and killing his ex-wife and himself; Shin finds the door barricaded and calls 911 (Grand Cayman Street house)about 1:44:13
  31. July 24, 2000, about 7.30 p.m. Two neighbours call police about a man and a woman fighting and a woman yelling don't do this (Grand Cayman Street house)about 0:23:42
  32. July 24, 2000, 7.35 p.m. Police break down the barricaded door and find Nancy strangled and beaten beyond recognition (Grand Cayman Street house)about 1:47:05

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode