FILE 673 / 12 February 2026 / 185 MIN / full

The Unluckiest Winner

Plant City, FloridaListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

this is in Plant City, Florida ... This is in Hillsborough County about 0:04:36

History, in brief

Town note

Originally called Itchy Puckasasa during the middle 1800s, named after a Native American village.

about 0:06:14

1860

Renamed Cork in 1860 because the postmaster was from Ireland and that was his hometown.

about 0:06:52

Town note

Renamed Plant City after Henry B. Plant of the South Florida Railroad, who brought the railroad in so farmers could move their crops.

about 0:07:06

1911

Reincorporated as the town of Plant City in 1911, then again as the city of Plant City.

about 0:07:20
All 6 history facts

Town note

Originally called Itchy Puckasasa during the middle 1800s, named after a Native American village.

about 0:06:14

1860

Renamed Cork in 1860 because the postmaster was from Ireland and that was his hometown.

about 0:06:52

Town note

Renamed Plant City after Henry B. Plant of the South Florida Railroad, who brought the railroad in so farmers could move their crops.

about 0:07:06

1911

Reincorporated as the town of Plant City in 1911, then again as the city of Plant City.

about 0:07:20

Town note

Motto: preserving the past, embracing the future, or a great place to live, work and play.

about 0:05:28

Town note

Nicknamed the winter strawberry capital of the world.

about 0:05:56

The figures, as told

Religious

40%

Biggest faith: Jewish, 0.6%

about 0:12:46

Who lives here

White 50.4% · Black 14.7% · Hispanic 30.3%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ about one-third above

about 0:21:56

Violent crime
▲ just above

about 0:22:04

Crime rate in Polk County
▼ lower 10%

about 0:22:59

Money

Median home value$322,400
Two-bedroom rent$1,460
Median household income$57,025
Cost of living104
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Property crime

"about one-third above"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:21:56

Violent crime

"just above"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:22:04

Crime rate in Polk County

"lower 10%"

Comparison: "on the spectrum of Florida". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:22:59

Population

"39,272"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:11:51

Women

"51.7%"

Comparison: "usually about 50.1%". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:12:01

Median age

"36.8"

Comparison: "national average, within a year or two". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:12:11

Single with children

"23%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:12:16

Religious

"40%"

Comparison: "low for Florida". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:12:46

Catholic

"barely edges out Baptist"

Comparison: "Baptist". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:12:52

Unemployment rate

"under the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:13:11

Median household income

"$57,025"

Comparison: "national average, usually about $69,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:13:18

Cost of living

"104"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:13:28

Median home cost

"$322,400"

Comparison: "cost of living index". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:13:33

Average two-bedroom rent

"$1,460"

Comparison: "above the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:14:03

Manufactured home price

"$15,000"

Comparison: "1,232 square foot two-bedroom, two-bath". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:15:05

Foreclosure home price

"$229,000"

Comparison: "three-bedroom, two-bath, 1,440 square feet". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:15:47

Five-bedroom home price

"$2,600,000"

Comparison: "4,577 square feet on 24.71 acres". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:16:22

The reviews

3.5 / 5 · average of 6

5 stars

“Everyone knows everyone.”
about 0:07:40

5 stars

“110% country living mixed with modern amenities; the town is beautiful, especially downtown and the historical areas.”
about 0:07:50

5 stars

“Very quiet, peaceful and booming, an up and coming community with farms around it.”
about 0:09:10

3 stars

“Liked the idea of a small town but there were limited resources and a large problem with graffiti and gang violence.”
about 0:09:35

2 stars

“Where they live is in the woods, so there is not a lot of that stuff; at least they have not seen it.”
about 0:10:46

1 star

“People are rude and always in a hurry; on the bright side the schools are good and the teachers helpful, but there is not much for younger ones to do.”
about 0:11:01

In Florida

Closest episodes

  1. A Deadly RecipeAlturas, Florida · 5 December 201947 km / 29 miShow on map
  2. Natural Porn KillersNew Port Richey, Florida · 18 March 202364 km / 40 miShow on map
  3. A Man Named "Hillbilly"Fruitville, Florida · 5 November 202083 km / 52 miShow on map
  4. Jerry Springer Show MurderSarasota, Florida · 1 May 202586 km / 53 miShow on map
  5. Webcam Model MadnessChuluota, Florida · 4 July 2024120 km / 75 miShow on map

The story

Abraham Lee Shakespeare was born on 24 April 1966 in Lakeland, Florida, the youngest of four children of seasonal orange pickers. He left school after the seventh grade and never learned to read or write. He worked in the citrus fields as a teenager and later took manual jobs: dishwasher, garbage man, hauling concrete blocks, sweeping floors at a friend's barber shop. He had two sons, Moses, born in 1998 to Antoinette Andrews, and later Jeremiah, with Santoria Butler.

On 15 November 2006 he was on a delivery run to Miami with the driver Michael Ford when they stopped at a convenience store in Frostproof. Shakespeare had five single dollars in his wallet. He handed two of them to Ford and asked him to buy two quick picks. The tickets won $30 million. He took the lump sum, about $17 million after taxes. He paid the child support, bought a $100,000 BMW and a truck, and bought a $1.1 million house with an indoor pool and a four-car garage on Red Hawk Bend Drive. He gave his stepfather a million dollars, each of his three stepsisters $250,000, paid off friends' mortgages, handed out cash to homeless people, and was called the Santa Claus of Lakeland. His mother refused to move into the new house, saying it had bad vibes and that the money was a curse.

In April 2007 Michael Ford sued him, claiming the lottery tickets had been stolen from his wallet, and demanded at least a million dollars. Shakespeare said he did not hold it against Ford and would have given him $250,000 if he had asked. By late 2008, however, he was down to $3.5 million.

Within weeks she had become his financial adviser.

On 2 January 2009 she transferred $246,493 from his Bank of America account into her company. On 9 January the ownership of his $1.1 million mansion was transferred to the company. On 15 January he signed an asset purchase agreement giving her the right to collect his outstanding loans; she allegedly paid him $185,000, money the prosecution later said had been his in the first place. She told the branch manager, Doug Hancock, not to give Shakespeare any money, and then produced minutes of a board meeting attended only by herself to give herself sole authority to write cheques. On 11 February $1,095,000 from his Prudential annuities account was deposited into the LLC account. A week later two cashier's cheques totalling $500,000 went to accounts controlled by her boyfriend, Shar Krasniqi. She bought him a 2008 Corvette for $70,390.86 and herself a 2009 Hummer for about $90,000.

It was the last day anyone saw him alive. He dug a hole about nine or ten feet deep with a front-end loader, and that evening, after dark, she called him back to fill it in. She paid him $200. A few days later a contractor poured a 30-foot by 30-foot concrete slab over the spot. Investigators would later say Shakespeare was shot twice in the chest with a .38 calibre revolver in her office, his body taken to the property in a trailer and put in the hole, covered with bags of lime, and buried.

She sent texts from his phone, and people noticed the messages were correctly spelt, which the illiterate Shakespeare could never have managed. She moved into his mansion, emptied out his belongings, and took his mother to dinner and to Disney World. On 9 November 2009 his cousin Cedric Edmondson reported him missing to the Polk County Sheriff's Office. Posters went up, including at the Super Choice Meat Market where he used to hang out.

On Christmas Day Elizabeth Walker received a call from a private number; she said the voice did not sound like her son. The number belonged to Krasniqi, but the call had been made by Gregory Todd Smith, the barber and friend to whom Shakespeare had lent $63,000 to save his mother's house. He admitted the call and agreed to wear a wire.

She said, 'I'm so deep in this with you right now. If you go down, I go down.' She talked of a drug dealer named Ronald who had killed Abraham, and then she and Smith forged a letter to his mother, typing it on a new laptop in a hotel room while she wore gloves and a hairnet. She asked Smith to find someone willing to take the fall for the murder and offered $50,000. The 'cousin' was in fact Mike Smith, an undercover narcotics officer with the Lake Wales Police Department. She told him there would be $67,000 in cash on the body and to bring marshmallows because they would have to burn it.

That night Smith called her to say police were at the property. On 29 January 2010, after three days of digging, Shakespeare's body was found six feet down beneath the slab and identified by fingerprints; the clothing matched the video from 6 April 2009.

Her ex-husband testified about digging the hole, Krasniqi about the gifts, Elizabeth Walker about the last time she saw her son and the fake Christmas call, Santoria Butler about being offered a house and a car to lie, and Greg Smith testified for three days.

In 2017 Antoinette Andrews, Moses's mother, won a million dollars on a scratchcard. Abraham's family were left to mourn a man the detectives described as a simple man who never hurt anyone and did not deserve what happened to him.

The case

Murder of Abraham Shakespeare

Victims

Abraham Lee Shakespeare. lottery winner and former truck driver's assistant, aged 42

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 12 February 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Gregory Todd Smith. barber and friend who made the fake Christmas call, then became a police informant and wore a wire
Shar Krasniqi. her boyfriend, received the Corvette and cash; later married and moved to Atlanta
Michael Ford. truck driver who bought the lottery ticket and later sued
Elizabeth Walker. Abraham's mother
Antoinette Andrews. mother of his son Moses
Santoria Butler. mother of his son Jeremiah, refused a bribe to lie
Cedric Edmondson. cousin who reported him missing and delivered a forged card for $5,000
Barbara Jackson. realtor who introduced to Shakespeare
David Clark. Polk County detective who led the investigation
Grady Judd. Polk County sheriff
Mike Smith. undercover narcotics officer from Lake Wales who posed as the cousin
Judy Hagens. mutual friend listed as an officer of Abraham Shakespeare LLC
Cindy Parrot. websleuths user who helped investigate
Marissa Green. Lakeland Ledger reporter who covered the case

The timeline

  1. July 25th, 1972 Emma Donigan, later , is born in Tampaabout 1:13:32
  2. 1992 She marries James , an excavation workerabout 1:22:30
  3. 1995 Driving a Hummer on State Road 33, she crosses the centre line and kills a 17-year-old driver; she is briefly hospitalisedabout 1:23:49
  4. 2001 She fakes her own kidnapping and rape in Wimauma, claiming three Hispanic men abducted her (Wimauma ditch)about 1:29:34
  5. 2002 She files for bankruptcyabout 1:33:36
  6. April 24th, 1966 Abraham Lee Shakespeare is born in Lakeland, the youngest of four childrenabout 0:24:35
  7. 1998 His son Moses is born to Antoinette Andrewsabout 0:36:15
  8. November 15th, 2006 On a delivery run to Miami he stops at a Frostproof convenience store and gives Michael Ford two dollars for two quick picks (Frostproof convenience store)about 0:42:04
  9. November 2006 The tickets win $30 million; he takes the lump sum of about $17 million after taxesabout 0:43:07
  10. April 2007 Michael Ford sues him, claiming the tickets were stolen, and demands at least a million dollarsabout 1:00:21
  11. late 2008 He is down to $3.5 millionabout 1:12:51
  12. October 2008 He meets , introduced through his realtor Barbara Jacksonabout 1:13:35
  13. November 2008 At a small business conference in Kissimmee, meets Barbara Jackson and claims she is in a wheelchairabout 1:14:10
  14. January 2nd, 2009 $246,493 is transferred from Abraham's Bank of America account to American Medical Professionals (Bank of America branch)about 1:34:53
  15. January 9th, 2009 Ownership of his $1.1 million mansion is transferred to company (Shakespeare mansion)about 1:35:06
  16. January 15th, 2009 He signs an asset purchase agreement giving her the right to collect his outstanding loans for an alleged $185,000about 1:35:30
  17. February 2009 Abraham Shakespeare LLC is formed with , Shakespeare and Judy Hagens as officers; alone can access the accounts (Bank of America branch)about 1:36:16
  18. February 11th, 2009 $1,095,000 from his Prudential annuities account is deposited into the LLC account (Bank of America branch)about 1:39:12
  19. February 18th, 2009 Two cashier's cheques totalling $500,000 are drawn and paid into accounts controlled by Shar Krasniqi (Bank of America branch)about 1:39:31
  20. three days later She buys a 2008 Corvette for her boyfriend for $70,390.86about 1:39:53
  21. March 2nd, 2009 She buys a 2009 Hummer for herself for about $90,000about 1:40:28
  22. April 6th, 2009 She videos Abraham at home; it is the last day anyone sees him alive and the last activity on his phone (Shakespeare mansion)about 1:41:06
  23. April 7th, 2009 James digs a nine- or ten-foot hole on the State Road 60 property; that evening he returns and fills it in for $200 (State Road 60 property)about 1:42:21
  24. a few days later A contractor pours a 30-foot by 30-foot concrete slab over the grave (State Road 60 property)about 1:44:15
  25. November 9th, 2009 His cousin Cedric Edmondson reports him missing to the Polk County Sheriff's Office (Polk County Sheriff's Office)about 1:49:05
  26. December 2009 sells her Hummer to Stingray Chevrolet for $49,000 in three cheques (Stingray Chevrolet)about 1:55:14
  27. Christmas Day, 2009 Greg Smith calls Elizabeth Walker pretending to be Abraham; she says the voice is wrongabout 2:03:52
  28. late December 2009 Detectives track the phone to Lakeland Square Mall, see pay Smith, and he agrees to wear a wire (Lakeland Square Mall)about 2:06:26
  29. January 25th, 2010 takes Greg Smith to the State Road 60 property, shows him the grave, marks it with rebar and gives him the .38 revolver (State Road 60 property)about 2:13:14
  30. January 29th, 2010 After three days of digging, Abraham's body is found six feet down beneath the slab and identified by fingerprints (State Road 60 property)about 2:19:03

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode