FILE 668 / 24 January 2026 / 71 MIN / express

Hooters, Hitler & Horribleness

Ocean City, MarylandListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Ocean City, Maryland; this is in far southeastern Maryland; this is in Worcester County. about 0:05:03

History, in brief

Town note

Thomas Fenwick obtained the whole area from the indigenous people who lived there.

about 0:07:32

Town note

Isaac Coffin built a beachfront cottage to receive paying guests, the first such venture.

about 0:07:38

Town note

The land was cut up into a bunch of lots and sold.

about 0:08:02

1870

Before 1870 the area was known as the Ladies' Resort to the Ocean.

about 0:08:06
All 5 history facts

Town note

Thomas Fenwick obtained the whole area from the indigenous people who lived there.

about 0:07:32

Town note

Isaac Coffin built a beachfront cottage to receive paying guests, the first such venture.

about 0:07:38

Town note

The land was cut up into a bunch of lots and sold.

about 0:08:02

1870

Before 1870 the area was known as the Ladies' Resort to the Ocean.

about 0:08:06

1875

The Atlantic Hotel, the first major hotel in town, opened in 1875.

about 0:08:24

The figures, as told

Money

Median home value$433,600
Median household income$58,563
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Permanent population

"6,869"

Comparison: "about 6,800". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:06:12

Population on a summer weekend

"350,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:06:18

Median household income

"$58,563"

Comparison: "lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:06:48

Median home cost

"$433,600"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:06:51

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“A local who grew up there praises easy access to the beach, never a dull moment and a supportive community.”
about 0:08:33

3 stars

“A beautiful place that is becoming less family-friendly; families are told to avoid senior week, when high school graduates flood the town.”
about 0:09:09

1 star

“Claims Ocean City is full of radiation from 5G on condos and hotels, traffic lights and power lines, with over 300 towers; advises buying a meter.”
about 0:09:44

In Maryland

Closest episodes

  1. A Strange Way To TortureLaurel, Delaware · 15 July 202148 km / 30 miShow on map
  2. Gone Like A GhostPocomoke City, Maryland · 5 October 202456 km / 35 miShow on map
  3. A Tangled Tree Of DisasterBridgeville, Delaware · 14 March 201959 km / 37 miShow on map
  4. Two Dead, One MissingHouston, Delaware · 28 January 202169 km / 43 miShow on map
  5. Butchering FamilyHarrington, Delaware · 19 June 202673 km / 45 miShow on map

The story

Joshua Ford, 32, was an Army veteran from South Boston and an insurance underwriter. They met at a company Christmas party in Boston in December 1999 and moved in together in Fairfax County, Virginia, in April 2001.

A gifted basketball player, she won a scholarship to Mary Washington College in Virginia and graduated cum laude, but was anxious and obsessive.

They married within three weeks of meeting in Fredericksburg at the Silver Bell Wedding Chapel in Las Vegas, without telling either family. After a bad conduct discharge from the Navy in 2000 they moved to Altoona, opened a scrapbook shop called Memory Lane, collected Hooters memorabilia, kept snakes named Hitler and HIV, acquired a swastika tattoo on BJ's chest and became addicted to Xanax, Valium, ecstasy and cocaine.

On 25 May 2002 they checked into a penthouse at the Rainbow Condominiums, ate at Hooters and at 9 p.m. took a bus to Secrets, where they met Josh and Jeannie. The four drank until 2 a.m.; BJ vomited, was caught picking the ATM lock and was thrown out.

BJ produced a gun, made the couple strip and demanded the purse. BJ shot through the door, hit Josh in the shoulder, kicked it in and shot him in the head. BJ had hidden the purse under the bed. He asked her to photograph him holding both heads. They drove 30 miles into Delaware and left the parts in a dumpster behind a grocery store.

The next day they bought cleaning supplies and a replacement bathroom door at Home Depot, and BJ scrubbed the bathroom and patched the bullet hole. On 29 May they lured Todd Wright and Melissa Sealing to the penthouse and staged the missing purse, but the pair escaped. Just after midnight on 31 May a silent alarm at the Hooters on 123rd Street brought police, who found them loading merchandise into a Jeep Cherokee. Her purse held the victims' licences and a bloodstained ring; a sergeant recognised the missing persons flyer.

The penthouse search found bullets, drug residue and the victims' photographs on the coffee table, and blood and tissue throughout the bathroom, including scalp in the sink drain. A landfill dig in Delaware on 3 June found Jeannie's leg and Josh's torso and arms; the heads were never recovered. She accepted a deal to testify but admitted before the polygraph that she told BJ to kill them, and the deal was withdrawn.

The case

Murders of Joshua Ford and Martha 'Jeannie' Crutchley

Victims

Joshua Ford (32). insurance underwriter and mortgage broker from Boston; Army veteran raised in South Boston; Jeannie's boyfriend
Martha 'Jeannie' Crutchley (51). insurance executive from Cunningham, Kansas, working out of Chantilly, Virginia; Josh's girlfriend

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 24 January 2026.

Accused

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Mark Ford. Josh's brother
Gerald Grace. father, a successful contractor
Charlotte Grace. mother
Craig. BJ's father
Elizabeth. BJ's mother
Todd Wright. man lured to the penthouse on 29 May 2002 who escaped with Melissa Sealing
Melissa Sealing. woman lured to the penthouse on 29 May 2002 who escaped with Todd Wright
M. William Phelps. journalist who wrote Cruel Death about the case

The timeline

  1. 1970 Joshua Ford is born.about 0:13:23
  2. October 21st, 1977 is born in Iowa.about 0:26:44
  3. February 3rd, 1978 Grace is born in Altoona, Pennsylvania.about 0:22:06
  4. 1996 BJ completes Navy basic underwater demolition training in California, one of 18 graduates from 160 candidates.about 0:30:10
  5. December 1999 Josh and Jeannie meet at a company Christmas party in Boston.about 0:16:26
  6. 2000 BJ is given a bad conduct discharge from the Navy.about 0:34:36
  7. around April 2001 Josh and Jeannie move in together in Fairfax County, Virginia.about 0:16:51
  8. October 2001 Josh's 23-year-old niece is found decapitated and buried in a shallow grave on Cape Cod. (Cape Cod shallow grave)about 0:17:25
  9. late 2001 and BJ are sold Ajax in a cocaine deal; BJ buys acid at a hardware store and tests it on a rat.about 0:41:36
  10. They marry at the Silver Bell Wedding Chapel in Las Vegas within three weeks of starting to date. (Silver Bell Wedding Chapel)about 0:32:33
  11. They move to Altoona, Pennsylvania, and open a scrapbook store called Memory Lane. (Memory Lane)about 0:35:43
  12. They begin burglarising Hooters restaurants for merchandise.about 0:40:09
  13. early May 2002 BJ asks whether he can kill her family; she refuses.about 0:41:11
  14. May 11th, 2002 A Hooters in Spotsylvania, Maryland, is burgled. (Hooters Spotsylvania)about 1:07:26
  15. May 25th, 2002 BJ and arrive in Ocean City and check into the Rainbow Condominiums penthouse; they eat at Hooters. (Rainbow Condominiums penthouse)about 0:42:29
  16. 9 p.m., May 25th, 2002 They take a city bus to Secrets and meet Josh and Jeannie. (Secrets)about 0:42:50
  17. 9.30 p.m. to 2 a.m. They drink at Secrets; BJ vomits at the bar and is caught picking the lock of the ATM, and threatens the bouncer. (Secrets)about 0:43:11
  18. 2 a.m., May 26th, 2002 They collect cannabis at Josh and Jeannie's condo, then walk two blocks to the penthouse. (Atlantis Condominiums)about 0:44:02
  19. 2.30 a.m., May 26th, 2002 They arrive at the penthouse, drink and smoke; Josh and Jeannie change into bathing suits for the hot tub. (Rainbow Condominiums penthouse)about 0:44:18
  20. 3.01 a.m., May 26th, 2002 says her purse is missing. (Rainbow Condominiums penthouse)about 0:44:31
  21. 3 a.m., May 26th, 2002 calls 911 with slurred speech, saying strangers are in the house; she gives no address and no police respond. (Rainbow Condominiums penthouse)about 0:44:59
  22. shortly after 3 a.m., May 26th, 2002 BJ forces Josh and Jeannie to strip at gunpoint over the purse; they break away and barricade themselves in the master bathroom. (Penthouse bathroom)about 0:56:57
  23. shortly after 3 a.m., May 26th, 2002 BJ shoots Josh in the shoulder and then the head, shoots Jeannie in the shoulder, and stabs Jeannie twice. (Penthouse bathroom)about 0:57:52
  24. about 4 a.m., May 26th, 2002 buys black bags at the Dollar Tree while BJ cuts off the heads, arms and legs with knives and a hacksaw. (Dollar Tree)about 0:59:53
  25. the morning of May 26th, 2002 They drive 30 miles to Delaware and leave the body parts in a dumpster behind a grocery store. (Food Lion dumpster)about 1:01:05

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode