1871
Founded in 1871 and named after Newton, Massachusetts.
about 0:04:54Spoilers are covered until your reading preferences load.
FILE 676 / 21 February 2026 / 72 MIN / express
This is Newton Kansas... central Kansas... This is in Harvey County about 0:04:16
Founded in 1871 and named after Newton, Massachusetts.
about 0:04:54Home of some of the Santa Fe railroad stockholders.
about 0:05:07In August 1871 the gunfight at Hyde Park occurred, in which eight men were killed.
about 0:05:16The gunfight began with an argument between two local cops, Billy Belly and Mike McCluskey.
about 0:05:35Founded in 1871 and named after Newton, Massachusetts.
about 0:04:54Home of some of the Santa Fe railroad stockholders.
about 0:05:07In August 1871 the gunfight at Hyde Park occurred, in which eight men were killed.
about 0:05:16The gunfight began with an argument between two local cops, Billy Belly and Mike McCluskey.
about 0:05:35Because of that, Newton became known as bloody and lawless and as the wickedest city in the West.
about 0:05:56Shortly after incorporation in 1872, the council passed an ordinance prohibiting the running at large of buffalo or other wild animals.
about 0:06:19"18,576"
No direction stated.
As told in 2026 about 0:04:16
"$59,586"
Comparison: "about $10,000 below the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2026 about 0:04:30
"$143,600"
Comparison: "well below the national average". Direction: below.
As told in 2026 about 0:04:30
2.4 / 5 · average of 6
“The town's overall rating on Niche.”about 0:06:50
“A quiet town, good for raising kids, though the reviewer would like to see fewer meth problems.”about 0:06:59
“A great size: not so small that everybody knows your business, but small enough to make connections; four grocery stores and decent eating out.”about 0:07:15
“Lived there ten years; crime and meth infested, with a 50% chance of packages being stolen by addicts.”about 0:07:39
“The PD is awful and corrupt to the bone, though the sheriff's department is great and it is a pretty little town.”about 0:08:40
“The Newton PD is very corrupt and offers no help; the reviewer called the cops on himself and was arrested, and calls it by far the worst place in Kansas.”about 0:08:53
“A corrupt little town full of residents who lie, cheat and steal from hard-working people.”about 0:09:47
Rhonda Lou Kriebel was born in Newton, Kansas, on August 21st, 1957, the daughter of Robert and Mary Lou Schmidt. She grew up there, went to college, and met Von Andros Kriebel. They married in 1980 and raised three daughters in what friends described as a happy, noisy house. Rhonda stayed at home, worked in nurseries, taught Sunday school and belonged to the Christian Women's Club, which met regularly at the Newton Inn.
Rhonda asked for the manager.
On May 20th, 1994, Rhonda chaperoned a school field trip to Wichita with her two eldest daughters. She came home at about two o'clock with her six-year-old, Natalie, and Natalie's five-year-old friend, and gave the girls ice cream in front of the television. Shortly after three there was a knock. Rhonda told the girls to keep eating and went to the door. She came back down the hall with a tall, thin man in a red baseball cap bearing a Christian fish symbol and aviator sunglasses. She did not introduce him. Both went towards the master bedroom.
At around ten past three Natalie walked towards her mother's room and found the man standing alone in the hall. She asked where her mother was and got no answer. Looking past him she saw Rhonda on the bed, hands and feet bound, mouth taped, trying to speak. The man carried Natalie and her friend upstairs, pushed them into a closet in Natalie's room and shut the door. From inside they heard seven or eight heavy bangs and thought their mother was being shot.
The friend's mother arrived between half past three and twenty to four. Rhonda's car was in the driveway and the front door was unlocked, but nobody answered. She called repeatedly, then telephoned Von in Wichita, who rang a cousin, Kevin, who had a key. Kevin let himself in between four and a quarter past, found Rhonda's purse, heard muffled crying and opened the closet. Natalie told him 'the bad man hurt mommy'. He called 911 and was told to take the girls outside.
Newton police arrived at about half past four and found Rhonda dead in the master bedroom. She had been bound at wrists and ankles with her own pantyhose, gagged with white masking tape from a dresser roll, and a white tube sock had been knotted round her neck. She had been struck on the head thirteen times and her skull was fractured. The medical examiner found signs of an interrupted sexual assault. Everything used on her came from the house. Outside, under the living room window, police found quantities of cigarette ends; a pair of aviator sunglasses was found under the bed. Neither belonged to the family.
Detective Walton led the inquiry. Von was cleared at once, being at work thirty miles away. The case went cold. Months later the forensic artist Lois Gibson, who held the Guinness record for identifications from sketches, sat with Natalie and drew a long-haired, gaunt-faced man with piercing blue eyes in a red cap.
On September 16th, 1995, Janetta Jody McCown, a thirty-year-old woman working the streets on South Broadway in Wichita, got into a car with a man who offered her $200 for an overnight stay. A friend noted the licence plate. Jody never came back. He had a record for theft, car theft and burglary, and had spent part of his childhood locked in closets by an alcoholic mother who died when he was thirteen.
His wife, Vicky, had known him only as Matt. She told police that two nights before Jody vanished she had gone looking for him at his rented storage shed and seen a blonde woman slumped motionless in the front seat of his car; he said she was a friend of a friend who had drunk too much. Police found nylon rope, duct tape and zip ties in the shed. The shed and the halfway house where he had lived were three blocks from Rhonda's home, and he walked past her house daily on his way to the inn.
Jody's body was found on October 11th, 1995, on the side of a rural road east of Newton. Her wrists and ankles were hog-tied with nylon cord, her mouth taped with an edge that matched the roll in the shed, and the cause was asphyxiation. Detective Walton said the scene was Rhonda's all over again. Vicky's marriage was annulled on October 25th, 1995. The same cigarette brand was found outside Rhonda's window, he wore aviators, and he came to work after the killing with a swollen eye.
Kansas had not yet reinstated the death penalty, so the prosecutor sought the hard 40. Late in the 1990s DNA from the sunglasses matched him, at odds of one in 5.5 billion. The judge called the crime especially heinous, atrocious and cruel and imposed another hard 40 and $21,272 in restitution. He was last reported at Lansing Correctional Facility, having served about thirty years with fifty-eight still to go.
May 20th, 1994 / her home in Newton, Kansas
As told in the episode, on 21 February 2026.
Accused
September 16th, 1995 / Wichita, Kansas, with her body found east of Newton
As told in the episode, on 21 February 2026.
Accused
Public places are marked on the map.
crime scene
about 0:19:52business
about 0:15:39other
about 0:54:45other
about 0:59:09road
about 0:50:43home
about 0:51:53other
about 1:00:18body found
about 1:01:06