FILE 290 / 9 June 2022 / 166 MIN / full

Missing Heads & Water Beds

Wellington, KansasListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

we're going to Wellington, Kansas; this is in Sumner County about 0:05:12

History, in brief

1871

Platted in 1871 and named after the Duke of Wellington.

about 0:07:46

Town note

Cattle herders came up the Chisholm Trail, which helped build the early town's economy.

about 0:08:23

1892

By around 1892 the town had 12,000 people and was steadily growing.

about 0:08:37
All 8 history facts

1871

Platted in 1871 and named after the Duke of Wellington.

about 0:07:46

Town note

Cattle herders came up the Chisholm Trail, which helped build the early town's economy.

about 0:08:23

1892

By around 1892 the town had 12,000 people and was steadily growing.

about 0:08:37

Town note

An estimated F4 tornado destroyed a hundred homes and many businesses, killed twelve townspeople and damaged a twenty-six block area.

about 0:09:12

Town note

The tornado stopped the town's growth momentum and many residents left.

about 0:09:32

Town note

A few years later a huge fire destroyed much of what was left of the town.

about 0:09:51

Town note

The actor David Carradine lived in Wellington for about a year in the 1980s while filming a movie called Americana.

about 0:10:21

The figures, as told

Religious

61.2%

Biggest faith: Jewish residents, 0.0%

about 0:16:30

Who lives here

White 83.1% · Black 1.9% · Asian 0.3% · Hispanic 9.5%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▲ almost double the national average

about 0:24:47

Violent crime
▼ slightly below average

about 0:24:58

Money

Median home value$67,600
Two-bedroom rent$695
Median household income$43,500
Cost of living73

For sale

$195,000

Four-bedroom, three-bath house price

about 0:19:42
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Property crime

"almost double the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:24:47

Violent crime

"slightly below average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:24:58

Population

"7,550"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:15:41

Women to men

"a few more females than males"

Comparison: "about normal". Direction: about the same.

As told in 2022 about 0:15:51

Median age

"38"

Comparison: "national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:15:54

Residents aged over 85

"a lot"

Comparison: "high". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:06

Married residents

"53%"

Comparison: "national average". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:13

White residents

"83.1%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:15

Black residents

"1.9%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:15

Asian residents

"0.3%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:15

Hispanic residents

"9.5%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:30

Religious residents

"61.2%"

Comparison: "higher than 50-50 is the normal". Direction: above.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:30

Jewish residents

"0.0%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:52

Sumner County Republican presidential vote

"74%"

Comparison: "24% Democrat and 2.1% independent". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:16:58

Median household income

"$43,500"

Comparison: "national average of about $54,000". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:17:17

Cost of living index

"73"

Comparison: "100 is the average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:17:26

Housing index

"28 out of 100"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:17:28

Median home cost

"$67,600"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:17:31

Average two-bedroom rent

"$695"

Comparison: "about half the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:18:20

Three-bedroom house price

"$59,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:19:42

Four-bedroom, three-bath house price

"$195,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:19:42

Four-bedroom, four-bath house price

"$499,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:20:58

The reviews

2.3 / 5 · average of 7

4 stars

“Safety is not an issue; you have to be smart, but the community is safe and watches out for one another.”
about 0:11:20

3 stars

“A great community for a quiet, reserved life; the population is mainly elderly and middle-aged, there is little to do in summer except the pool, and druggies roam the streets but are not dangerous unless bothered.”
about 0:11:41

3 stars

“The only thing you can really do is fish; there is not much else outdoors.”
about 0:13:10

2 stars

“I do not like this town, I cannot wait to move, and there is not much to do here.”
about 0:13:17

2 stars

“Winter storms cause ice, spring storms bring tornadoes and summer is usually drought.”
about 0:13:56

1 star

“The worst of the worst, full of druggies or people out to scam you; stay away if you can.”
about 0:14:25

1 star

“Worse than terrible; a good place to be if you are homeless because you will feel right at home.”
about 0:14:58

“There is nothing to do here and everyone knows it; you will think you are living in a nightmare.”
about 0:15:25

In Kansas

Closest episodes

  1. The Neighborhood MonsterArkansas City, Kansas · 1 June 202340 km / 25 miShow on map
  2. Dead With No HeadKingman, Kansas · 19 October 202475 km / 47 miShow on map
  3. Double Life, Double MurderNewton, Kansas · 21 February 202685 km / 53 miShow on map
  4. A Strangle Here, A Strangle ThereHutchinson, Kansas · 21 November 201998 km / 61 miShow on map
  5. Sexy Sunday School Teacher SlaughterEnid, Oklahoma · 20 March 2025105 km / 65 miShow on map

The story

Michelle Tate was sixteen years old in December 1992, a high school junior living in Wellington, Kansas. She had moved there from Hutchinson about a year earlier, after her parents divorced, with her mother, two brothers and a sister. She wanted out of Wellington: she talked about college and about becoming a model, and she liked to drink and party with her friends. He had been married once, to a woman called Marla, divorced in 1985, and had no children. According to Marla, he had threatened her before the divorce, promising to kill her and cut off her head and fingers so nobody could identify the body. A young woman he knew also told police that on December 4, 1992, he turned up at her house at two in the morning and offered her money to masturbate him. She refused and he left; an hour later he came back, apologised, offered the same money for her simply to undress, and when she refused again he pushed her against the wall and fondled her until she kicked him twice in the shin and he ran off.

They found him at the house of his friend Chuck Flynn, thirty-six, watching television. They asked whether he would buy them alcohol later; he said he would. That evening, at about eight, they saw him walking along the street, picked him up and asked again. He went into a liquor store and bought two bottles of Everclear, then told them he would not be home that night but that they could have the run of his house. The girls went there and played a drinking game with Everclear mixed with Pepsi. Within an hour most of the Everclear was gone and Michelle was badly drunk and being sick. A teenage friend called Buck Rowan, who was around their age, was driving them about. The plan was for Buck to leave Melinda and the other girl at the Coastal Mart, take Michelle to the Scotsman's restaurant for coffee to sober her up, and meet the others back at the Coastal Mart at midnight. Buck drove past the Scotsman's because a sheriff's car was parked outside. He and his brother carried her inside, laid her on the couch, took off her shoes and put a blanket over her. It was about two in the morning.

At half past three they went back and the house was empty, with nobody on the couch. He told Melinda that a man had brought Michelle to the house, that he had told her she had to find somewhere else to stay, that he went to the bathroom and when he came out she was going out of the door. They looked in his pickup but saw no blood and no sign of Michelle.

He and Roe then went to a laundromat and washed a jacket. That same Sunday three coyote hunters, Daryl Oostman, Dave Kelly and Thane Juncker, saw a blue and white or blue and silver pickup backing out of an abandoned farmstead.

In the same interview he changed his story repeatedly: first he had slept all night, then he had gone to the Town and Country for coffee, then he had gone out to find a carving knife to cut deer ribs, then he had driven around near Oxford. He finally said he had lied because he was nervous about having bought alcohol for minors. Chuck Flynn also told police three different stories.

Police then searched the abandoned farmstead. In a cistern they found a headless body floating in the water. It was Michelle, almost naked, her jeans pulled down to her ankles, a red shirt looped over one wrist and a white bra looped over both. They drained the cistern and found her head at the bottom. Dr William Eckert performed the autopsy and found that she had been shot in the head with a .22, bitten, slashed and stabbed repeatedly, and decapitated. The fatal wound was a .22 gunshot from the back to the left side of the head. There was circulation at the time of the shooting, ten minutes of bleeding would have been enough to kill her, and there were signs she still had circulation when she was decapitated. She had three deep stab wounds to the right side of the neck, no defensive injuries and no powder burns. A tar-like stain on the back seat of his pickup contained human blood, and sections of the seat had been cut out. In his house police found a new jar of Vaseline with .22 cartridges pushed into it.

Chuck Flynn then gave what he called the real story. Flynn went outside. Flynn helped. They drove out into the country between Wellington and South Haven. He took the rifle, Michelle began to come round, and he told her to be quiet or he would shoot her. Flynn walked away and heard her scream and then a gunshot. The next morning he borrowed a petrol can, saying he wanted to burn insulation off copper wire. The following Wednesday he told Flynn that Michelle was missing and that they needed to get their story straight, that he had not killed her, and that Flynn should say they were together until two in the morning.

It deliberated about two hours on the Wednesday evening and two hours the next morning before imposing the hard forty.

The case

Murder of Michelle Tate

Victims

Michelle Tate (16). High school junior who had moved to Wellington from Hutchinson about a year earlier; wanted to go to college and become a model

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 9 June 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Melinda Koehn. Michelle's best friend, 16; brother's stepdaughter, who brought Michelle to house
Buck Rowan. Teenager who drove Michelle to house and left her asleep on the couch
Marla. ex-wife, divorced in 1985; said he threatened to cut off her head and fingers
Captain Harold Thatcher. Wellington police captain who interviewed
Dr. William Eckert. Medical examiner who performed the autopsy
Scott Roe. friend, who went with him to wash a bloodstained jacket
Debbie Mandeville. Rural resident who found a bloody nylon vest on a blacktop road
Daryl Oostman, Dave Kelly and Thane Juncker. Coyote hunters who saw a blue and white or blue and silver pickup at the abandoned farmstead
Erleen Strickland. Runs the Shoe Fly shop in Wellington and spoke to the press
Jeff Bevin and Jason Meslin. Teenagers who drove Melinda and her friend around in the early hours
Charlie Callahan and Josh Wolf. Teenagers driving around with Melinda that night

The timeline

  1. 1991 Michelle Tate moves to Wellington from Hutchinson with her mother, two brothers and sister after her parents divorceabout 0:57:28
  2. 1985 and his wife Marla divorceabout 0:37:32
  3. December 4, 1992 comes to a young woman's house at 2 a.m. and offers her money for a sex act; she refuses, he returns an hour later and fondles her until she kicks him twice in the shin (young woman's house)about 0:39:51
  4. December 5, 1992, afternoon Michelle Tate, Melinda Koehn and another girl find at Chuck Flynn's house and ask him to buy them alcohol later (Chuck Flynn's house)about 0:59:28
  5. December 5, 1992, about 8 p.m. The girls see walking, pick him up and he buys two bottles of Everclear at a liquor store (liquor store in Wellington)about 1:01:43
  6. December 5, 1992, evening The girls drink Everclear mixed with Pepsi at house; Michelle becomes badly drunk and starts vomiting ( 's house)about 1:04:40
  7. December 6, 1992, 1.30 a.m. Melinda and her friend call at house looking for Michelle and find nobody home ( 's house)about 1:22:16
  8. December 6, 1992, about 2 a.m. Buck Rowan and his brother carry the unconscious Michelle into house and leave her on the couch with a blanket ( 's house)about 1:13:24
  9. December 6, 1992, about 2 a.m. arrives home, complains that she is on his couch because he sleeps there, and Buck leaves ( 's house)about 1:14:55
  10. December 6, 1992, 2.30 a.m. Melinda and her friend meet Buck at the Scotsman's and he tells them Michelle is at house (Scotsman's restaurant)about 1:23:55
  11. December 6, 1992, 3.30 a.m. The girls go to house, find it empty and the couch vacant ( 's house)about 1:24:23
  12. December 6, 1992, about 4 a.m. Jeff Bevin and Jason Meslin begin driving Melinda and her friend around townabout 1:25:41
  13. December 6, 1992, about 5.30 a.m. The girls return to house to collect Melinda's driving licence and still find nobody there ( 's house)about 1:27:00
  14. December 6, 1992, before 7 a.m. The girls return again, find pickup outside and sitting in a chair with a gun cleaning rod; he says Michelle left after he told her to go ( 's house)about 1:27:55
  15. December 6, 1992, about 8 a.m. After searching the streets on foot the girls give up and sleep on water bed ( 's house)about 1:29:20
  16. December 6, 1992, 9 a.m. wakes the girls and drives them to South Haven for clean clothes, then back to his houseabout 1:29:54
  17. December 6, 1992, 10.30 a.m. The girls leave house and search for Michelle again, including in his pickup ( 's house)about 1:31:54
  18. December 6, 1992, about 1 p.m. asks Scott Roe's mother how to get pheasant blood out of a jacket, then he and Roe wash the jacket at a laundromat (Scott Roe's house)about 1:32:39
  19. December 6, 1992 Three coyote hunters see a blue and white or blue and silver pickup backing out of an abandoned farmstead (abandoned farmstead)about 1:37:29
  20. December 6, 1992 Debbie Mandeville finds a bloody nylon vest on a blacktop road and leaves it there (blacktop road outside Wellington)about 1:39:03
  21. December 7, 1992, 12.18 a.m. Captain Harold Thatcher interviews , who gives four different accounts of the night before admitting he lied because he was nervous about buying alcohol for minorsabout 1:41:05
  22. December 8, 1992, 4.15 p.m. Thatcher visits house and notices two bare patches in the snow near the rubbish bins; claims his bins were stolen ( 's house)about 1:43:01
  23. December 10, 1992 Police collect rubbish and find the front panel of women's flowered underpants, bloodstained Pepsi bottles, tissues and denim scraps with hair fibres, a bread bag with blood and a ponytail tie ( 's house)about 1:49:36
  24. December 10, 1992 Police search the abandoned farmstead and find Michelle's headless body floating in the cistern, then her head at the bottom after draining it (abandoned farmstead)about 1:53:25

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

country roadside between Wellington and South Haven

crime scene

about 2:04:27

Heard in this episode