FILE 346 / 17 December 2022 / 68 MIN / express

The Bondage That Ties

Atchison, KansasListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

"we're going to atchison kansas atchison atchison uh population 10,427" about 0:03:15

History, in brief

1854

In 1854 men from Platte City, Missouri crossed the Missouri River and staked out a town, naming it for David Atchison, a Missouri senator.

about 0:04:05

1849

David Atchison was president of the United States for one day, 4 March 1849, when Zachary Taylor refused to take the oath of office on a Sunday.

about 0:04:40

Town note

During the great Mormon migration westward the city leaders persuaded the Mormons to stop there to resupply, which made business boom while other towns around it withered.

about 0:05:15

1958

In 1958 two flash floods destroyed the downtown area in the same year; the town rebuilt and became known as 'the city that refused to die'.

about 0:05:59
All 4 history facts

1854

In 1854 men from Platte City, Missouri crossed the Missouri River and staked out a town, naming it for David Atchison, a Missouri senator.

about 0:04:05

1849

David Atchison was president of the United States for one day, 4 March 1849, when Zachary Taylor refused to take the oath of office on a Sunday.

about 0:04:40

Town note

During the great Mormon migration westward the city leaders persuaded the Mormons to stop there to resupply, which made business boom while other towns around it withered.

about 0:05:15

1958

In 1958 two flash floods destroyed the downtown area in the same year; the town rebuilt and became known as 'the city that refused to die'.

about 0:05:59

The figures, as told

Crime / national average

Homicides in one week
three

about 0:51:03

Calls from residents reporting a fourth body
25

about 0:51:21

Money

Median home value$92,900
Median household income$41,283
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2022

Population

"10,427"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:15

Median household income

"$41,283"

Comparison: "lower than the national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:44

Median home price

"$92,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:03:51

Homicides in one week

"three"

Comparison: "in a town of 10,000 people". No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:51:03

Calls from residents reporting a fourth body

"25"

No direction stated.

As told in 2022 about 0:51:21

The reviews

2.4 / 5 · average of 5

5 stars

“Charming historic town with incredible homes built in the late 1800s, more millionaires per capita than anywhere else, brick-lined streets, the most haunted town in Kansas with haunted history trolley tours, Lewis and Clark history, Amelia Earhart's grandparents' home, rolling hills along the Missouri River, the riverfront park and the bridge to Missouri lit up at night; a transplant calls it the smaller San Francisco of the midwest.”
about 0:06:21

3 stars

“People can find jobs but they aren't good ones.”
about 0:07:47

2 stars

“The homes are old and most are unclean.”
about 0:07:56

1 star

“The air is gross from the factories in town and the weather is always muggy from the humidity, so it is not an outdoorsy atmosphere.”
about 0:08:13

1 star

“Not much happens there; lots of crime and people not caring about the community, not many pleasant people, no entertainment other than the local movie theatre, and the reviewer does not recommend it at all.”
about 0:08:59

In Kansas

Closest episodes

  1. Yes, No, I Don't Know...Oskaloosa, Kansas · 5 December 201841 km / 25 miShow on map
  2. The Imperfect StormRulo, Nebraska · 27 June 201860 km / 37 miShow on map
  3. Behind A Serial Killer's MaskLenexa, Kansas · 6 March 202572 km / 45 miShow on map
  4. Brilliant BrutalityPrairie Village, Kansas · 25 September 202577 km / 48 miShow on map
  5. A Wild Night At The Trailer ParkCameron, Missouri · 13 May 202380 km / 50 miShow on map

The story

They met at the Medical Lodge, where both worked, and by the winter of 1991 he was living with her though she was married. Trina had grown up in Atchison and on 9 April 1986 married Thomas E. Smith; they had two daughters, China Dawn and Tommy Joe.

The marriage was violent and the affair was no secret. Trina told friends and co-workers she was torn between the two men, and police had repeatedly been called to mediate.

Trina filed for divorce that December but neither pursued it. On 5 February 1992, after an argument with her, Thomas set himself on fire and was taken to hospital, where he was still recovering on the night she died.

The next afternoon two men driving a dirt road a few miles outside Atchison found a body about twenty yards over the bank, in a wooded area: Trina, five foot two and about 200 pounds, naked, with leaves and mud on her body and feet. The earth up the embankment was disturbed, as though she had been dragged down.

She was elaborately bound: a nylon rope tied at her wrists ran up her back and around her neck several times, then down to her ankles, and pantyhose were wrapped around her neck beneath the ropes. The ropes were so tight the pathologist had to pull them while an assistant cut them away. There were no marks of a struggle except an abrasion on her forehead. He concluded she died of ligature strangulation, the ligatures tight enough to cut off her air and kill her within five minutes, and that a self-induced strangling would more likely have been an accident than deliberate. He found recent stretching and a small tear of the anal mucosa, possibly from anal intercourse but unconfirmed. Sheriff Dennis Parker said the body was found at 4.35 p.m. and that the strangulation had happened ten to sixteen hours earlier.

On the day the body was found he gave two accounts. He first said he had taken her to her house, made love, argued and left her at his new girlfriend's. Hours later he changed everything: they had gone to the cemetery, where she knew he had always wanted to have sex with her; he tied her up, they had sex in the back seat and at her invitation he gagged her with pantyhose. He said he attempted anal sex but stopped because he did not want to hurt her. Afterwards she straightened her legs, the rope round her neck tightened and he could not undo it. He drove towards Atchison with her bound, heard a gurgle and opened the back door; she rolled out, and seeing headlights he rolled her to the side of the road meaning to return, and she rolled down the hill.

Within a day investigators searched his apartment and car. They photographed restraint devices hooked under both sides of his bed, white cord on the bedroom floor and handcuffs on the front-room wall, and seized two notebooks he called his captain's logs, more than 200 typed pages of fantasy and diary from 1989 to 1992, which the state said set out plans to control women and sometimes to kill them and make the deaths look like suicides. They also took a dog choker chain with a padlock and no key from his car, and a bible marked at 2 Kings 9:30, the passage about Jezebel's violent death, from the trunk.

His ex-wife testified that they had engaged in bondage 40 to 50 times during their marriage, that he demanded it, sometimes tied her up by force when she objected and often left her tied up.

In 2021 he was found with contraband again.

The case

Murder of Trina Smith

Victims

Trina Smith (23). nurse at the Mount Saint Scholastica convent infirmary; married to Thomas E. Smith; mother of two daughters

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 17 December 2022.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

China Dawn Smith. her daughter
Tommy Joe Smith. her daughter
Dennis Parker. Atchison County sheriff

The timeline

  1. September 17th, 1960 is bornabout 0:11:53
  2. April 9th, 1986 Trina marries Thomas E. Smithabout 0:13:45
  3. 1989 begins the notebooks he calls his captain's logs, kept until 1992about 0:53:04
  4. August 25th, 1991 Trina is hospitalised after a suicide attempt, first claiming injected her with drugs and later saying she injected herselfabout 0:16:26
  5. December 1991 Trina files for divorce and neither party takes any actionabout 0:28:00
  6. February 5th, 1992 After an argument with Trina, Thomas Smith sets himself on fire and is hospitalised with burnsabout 0:29:11
  7. February 11th, 1992 reports Trina for breaking his car window and she is issued a summonsabout 0:29:40
  8. February 18th, 1992 Trina clocks out of the convent at 11 p.m. and leaves with (Mount Saint Scholastica convent)about 0:31:55
  9. February 18th, 1992 says they drive to the cemetery, where he binds her and they have sex in the back seat (Atchison cemetery)about 0:41:26
  10. February 19th, 1992 Two men driving a dirt road find Trina's bound, naked body about 20 yards over the bank (Dirt road outside Atchison)about 0:32:22

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode