FILE 685 / 26 March 2026 / 175 MIN / full

Secrets Of Murder Pond

Nettie, West VirginiaListen

The town

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

this is in Netty, West Virginia ... this is in Nicholas County about 0:06:50

History, in brief

1824

Summersville was laid out in 1824 and named for Lewis Summers, a local judge.

about 0:07:33

Town note

Summersville was home to both Union and Confederate encampments during the Civil War, on opposite sides of town.

about 0:07:40

1884

The town was mostly burnt to the ground by Confederate spy Nancy Hart Douglas during the war, and rebuilt in 1884.

about 0:07:55

Town note

Summersville is nicknamed the world's largest speed trap, because US 19 goes from a two-lane to a four-lane highway there and northern travellers get tickets.

about 0:06:54
All 10 history facts

1824

Summersville was laid out in 1824 and named for Lewis Summers, a local judge.

about 0:07:33

Town note

Summersville was home to both Union and Confederate encampments during the Civil War, on opposite sides of town.

about 0:07:40

1884

The town was mostly burnt to the ground by Confederate spy Nancy Hart Douglas during the war, and rebuilt in 1884.

about 0:07:55

Town note

Summersville is nicknamed the world's largest speed trap, because US 19 goes from a two-lane to a four-lane highway there and northern travellers get tickets.

about 0:06:54

Town note

The Summersville Dam holds back West Virginia's largest lake, a 2,790-acre lake.

about 0:08:38

Town note

A farming village called Gad existed from the 1800s to the 1960s where Summersville Lake now is; it was sold and flooded to build the dam.

about 0:09:05

Town note

Officials wanted to call it the Gad Dam but settled on Summersville Dam.

about 0:09:55

2016

On June 23rd, 2016 a huge flood hit Summersville, demolishing the middle school, which was relocated to trailers.

about 0:10:10

2018

Summersville and the surrounding locations such as Nettie are featured in the 2018 game Fallout 76.

about 0:10:30

1958

The town's only notable person is Buzz Nutter, an NFL centre and linebacker in 1958 and 1959, an NFL champion and member of the Virginia Tech Hall of Fame.

about 0:10:50

The figures, as told

Religious

33%

about 0:15:41

Who lives here

White 100%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Crime overall
▼ about half of the national average

about 0:23:32

Violent crime
▼ about one third beneath the national average

about 0:23:41

Money

Median home value$56,300
Median household income$23,485
Cost of living74

For sale

$39,000

Three-bedroom, two-bath trailer, 980 square feet, built 1985, on one acre

about 0:17:56

For sale

$298,000

Three-bedroom, two-bath house, 1,689 square feet, built 1955, on half an acre

about 0:18:18

For sale

$1,150,000

Seventeen acres with a four-bedroom, three-bath house, 5,676 square feet, built 1975

about 0:19:01
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Crime rate

"about half of the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:23:32

Violent crime

"about one third beneath the national average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:23:41

Median age

"44"

Comparison: "higher than the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:15:16

Married

"77.4%"

Comparison: "usually 50-50 is the normal". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:15:26

Single with children

"12.8%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:15:32

Largest denomination

"Baptist"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:15:51

Unemployment

"higher than average"

Comparison: "average". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:16:00

Median household income

"$23,485"

Comparison: "$69,000 in the rest of the country". No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:16:12

Cost of living

"74"

Comparison: "100 is regular in the rest of the country". Direction: below.

As told in 2026 about 0:16:15

Median home cost

"$56,300"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:16:15

Three-bedroom, two-bath trailer, 980 square feet, built 1985, on one acre

"$39,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:17:56

Three-bedroom, two-bath house, 1,689 square feet, built 1955, on half an acre

"$298,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:18:18

Seventeen acres with a four-bedroom, three-bath house, 5,676 square feet, built 1975

"$1,150,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:19:01

The reviews

3.6 / 5 · average of 5

3.8 stars

“Not bad for a West Virginia town in the middle of nowhere.”
about 0:11:18

5 stars

“Very friendly and caring people, multiple restaurants, summer activities at Summersville Lake, a good school board, well-maintained schools and New Life Christian Academy as a private option.”
about 0:11:25

4 stars

“Best known for its lake, with a small town said to be under the water; a beautiful little town with many friendly people.”
about 0:12:41

3 stars

“A resident of over 20 years would not recommend it: stagnant job market, outdated mindset, poor economy, closed-minded and rude people, nothing for kids to do, costly groceries and health care, a declining population; the only good thing is almost no crime.”
about 0:13:08

2 stars

“Horrible for anyone wanting progress or growth; not a sustainable environment.”
about 0:14:41

In West Virginia

Closest episodes

  1. The Trashy Tragic MurdersVictor, West Virginia · 28 August 202634 km / 21 miShow on map
  2. Meth, Marriage & MurderWebster Springs, West Virginia · 10 January 201838 km / 24 miShow on map
  3. A Brutal, Silly & Victimless MurderLayland, West Virginia · 30 April 202044 km / 27 miShow on map
  4. For Love Of My CousinBeckley, West Virginia · 28 July 202264 km / 40 miShow on map
  5. A Nearly Headless Horror ScenePemberton, West Virginia · 21 October 202372 km / 45 miShow on map

The story

Theresa Lucente Rollins was born in Clarksburg, West Virginia, in October 1954, one of five Italian-American sisters. Her parents were Joe and Velma, and her sisters were Maria, Joanne, Valerie and Regina. She graduated from Notre Dame High School in Clarksburg, married and divorced young, and by the late 1980s had opened her own beauty salon, Theresa's Total Look, across the road from her old school. She was outgoing, deeply religious, trusting to a fault, and she threw herself into the Italian Heritage Festival in Harrison County. Theresa's family disliked him on sight, but she was smitten, and they married within a year.

By 2000 the couple had bought a farm on Rollins Ridge Lane in Nettie, Nicholas County, in central West Virginia. The farm had a farmhouse, a storage building, fields, a cornfield and a pond used to irrigate the vegetables; Theresa loved to feed the fish and ducks at the pond. April was in her late twenties, a country girl with a baby and nowhere to live, and Theresa invited her to move into a spare bedroom in the farmhouse. The affair lasted more than a year, and he told her that he would get rid of Theresa and marry her.

He returned at 9 a.m. to meet the workers, and at 11.30 they all came in for lunch. Kay Rudd asked where Theresa was. April ran to her car for her phone and called 911 from about 85 yards away, over a hill that hid the pond, yet she immediately told the operator that Theresa was pinned under a tree in the pond and was not breathing. She was pronounced dead there. The tree was said to be 60 feet tall and to weigh more than a thousand pounds, with its stump 35 feet from the edge of the pond.

The autopsy was performed on 6 October 2009 by Dr Zia Sabbat of the West Virginia State Medical Examiners Office. He found small scratches on Theresa's face and bruising on her back, but no major injuries and no broken bones. When detectives returned on 7 October to take more photographs, the tree had disappeared. He repeated his story, called the affair with April a fling, volunteered that Theresa had been slow and would not have got out of the way of a falling tree, suggested they check for toxins and said nobody had killed his wife. On 20 October the medical examiner and chief medical examiner Dr James Caplin ruled the death an accidental drowning complicated by compression asphyxia, and the case was closed.

Theresa's family refused to accept it. The family contacted the forensic pathologist Dr Cyril Wecht of Pittsburgh, then worked their political contacts up to Governor Joe Manchin, who told the state police to look at the case again.

In January 2010 the medical examiners revised the cause of death to asphyxia due to probable strangulation and left the manner undetermined. Dr Wecht found no injuries consistent with a thousand-pound tree, but bruising consistent with forcible drowning, facial injuries consistent with her face being pushed into the pond bed, and zipper marks on her neck consistent with her jacket being held tight from behind. He ruled it a forcible drowning homicide.

The defence, led by van Biber, called Dr Joseph Cohen and argued accident and a politically driven reinvestigation.

Theresa's family were left with the knowledge that their persistence, and the photographs she took of her own bruises, had exposed the truth.

The case

Murder of Theresa Rollins

Victims

Theresa Lucente Rollins (54). beauty salon owner from Clarksburg, later a farmer's wife

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 26 March 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Tanya Wagner. farm worker who jumped into the pond, dragged Theresa to the bank and attempted CPR
Kay Rudd. farm worker who asked where Theresa was at lunch
Jimmy Thompson. friend and neighbour who saw abuse Theresa and photographed her bruises
Dr. Cyril Wecht. Pittsburgh forensic pathologist who performed the second autopsy
Dr. Zia Sabbat. West Virginia State Medical Examiners Office pathologist who performed the original autopsy
Dr. James Caplin. chief medical examiner who ruled the death accidental
Deputy Kenneth Sales. deputy who took account at the scene
Joe. Theresa's father
Velma. Theresa's mother
Maria. Theresa's sister
Joanne. Theresa's sister
Valerie. Theresa's sister
Regina. Theresa's sister
P.K. Milam. prosecutor
van Biber. defence attorney
Dr. Joseph Cohen. defence forensic pathologist
Cynthia Stanton. April Bales's public defender
Joe Manchin. West Virginia governor who ordered the state police to reopen the case

The timeline

  1. October 1954 Theresa is born in Clarksburgabout 0:27:34
  2. January 1958 is bornabout 0:32:24
  3. the late 1980s Theresa opens Theresa's Total Look across from Notre Dame High School (Theresa's Total Look)about 0:27:55
  4. January 1993 is cited in Cocoa, Florida for an expired vehicle registrationabout 0:36:16
  5. sometime in the 1990s arrives in Clarksburg with no job and no addressabout 0:33:41
  6. 1999 walks into Theresa's salon for a haircut and they begin a relationship (Theresa's Total Look)about 0:31:58
  7. within a year, late 1990s Theresa and marryabout 0:40:27
  8. 2000 They buy a farm on Rollins Ridge Lane in Nettie (Rollins farm)about 0:40:35
  9. 2006 is caught manufacturing a controlled substance in West Virginia (Rollins farm)about 0:37:38
  10. 2007 Tanya Wagner and Kay Rudd are working on the farm (Rollins farm)about 0:47:53
  11. 2008 April Bales is hired and moves into a spare bedroom at the farmhouse (Rollins farm)about 0:48:05
  12. July 2008 begins an affair with April (Rollins farm)about 0:50:23
  13. late 2008 into 2009 The affair continues and tells April he will get rid of Theresa and marry her (Rollins farm)about 0:51:54
  14. spring of 2009 Jimmy Thompson sees shake Theresaabout 1:42:04
  15. May 2009 Jimmy Thompson sees swat Theresa's headabout 1:42:30
  16. July 2009 Theresa has photographs taken of a bruise on her chest and another on her noseabout 1:43:00
  17. August 2009 A photograph is taken of a bruise on Theresa's thighabout 1:43:05
  18. August 2009 and April choose a new truck; he returns the next day with Theresa to sign the paperwork (Old dealership)about 0:52:23
  19. August and September 2009 buys two $500,000 life policies on Theresa, both with accidental death ridersabout 1:36:34
  20. September 4, 2009 tries to increase Theresa's cover by $300,000 but drops the natural death portion when a new physical is requiredabout 1:39:51
  21. October 5, 2009, 7.30 a.m. leaves the farmhouse saying he is going to clear a path for deer hunting (Rollins farm)about 0:55:24
  22. October 5, 2009, 9 a.m. returns to meet the farm workers and sets them to work (Rollins farm)about 0:56:14
  23. October 5, 2009, 11.30 a.m. At lunch Kay Rudd asks where Theresa is and begins searching (Rollins farm)about 0:56:37
  24. October 5, 2009 reports Theresa face down in the pond, pinned by a fallen tree, and calls for an ambulance (Farm pond)about 0:58:46
  25. October 5, 2009 April Bales calls 911 from about 85 yards away and says Theresa is pinned under a tree and not breathing (Rollins farm)about 1:00:27
  26. October 5, 2009 Tanya Wagner drags Theresa from the pond and attempts CPR; Theresa is pronounced dead (Farm pond)about 1:01:05

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode