FILE 704 / 29 May 2026 / 76 MIN / express

Mystery On The Path

Simsbury, ConnecticutListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

we're going to simsbury connecticut ... this is in north central connecticut ... this is in hartford county about 0:04:10

History, in brief

1643

In 1643 John Griffin and Michael Humphrey started a tar and turpentine business in Simsbury.

about 0:05:49

Town note

A few years later a man named Manna Hannah Noose started a fire that destroyed all of Griffin's tar.

about 0:06:05

1859

On Tuesday December 20th, 1859 the two-storey patent safety fuse factory near the centre of town exploded, killing seven women and one man and injuring several other people including the factory owner.

about 0:06:18

Town note

The factory made fast-burning cord fuses used for blasting, such as the fuse for dynamite.

about 0:06:34
All 4 history facts

1643

In 1643 John Griffin and Michael Humphrey started a tar and turpentine business in Simsbury.

about 0:05:49

Town note

A few years later a man named Manna Hannah Noose started a fire that destroyed all of Griffin's tar.

about 0:06:05

1859

On Tuesday December 20th, 1859 the two-storey patent safety fuse factory near the centre of town exploded, killing seven women and one man and injuring several other people including the factory owner.

about 0:06:18

Town note

The factory made fast-burning cord fuses used for blasting, such as the fuse for dynamite.

about 0:06:34

The figures, as told

Crime / national average

Homicides
first homicide since 2012

about 0:23:05

Registered sex offenders in town
four

about 0:31:23

Reward offered for information
$40,000

about 0:30:11

Money

Median home value$392,400
Median household income$134,688
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2026

Median household income

"$134,688"

Comparison: "just about double the national average". Direction: above.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:23

Median home cost

"$392,400"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:05:37

Population

"24,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:22:55

Homicides

"first homicide since 2012"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:23:05

Registered sex offenders in town

"four"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:31:23

Reward offered for information

"$40,000"

No direction stated.

As told in 2026 about 0:30:11

The reviews

3.0 / 5 · average of 3

5 stars

“Feels like a Hallmark movie sometimes: a quaint New England town with lots of trees, a little main street with shops, loads of snow in winter, safe, great schools and beautiful parks, though it could be boring if you are single and looking for nightlife; New York City is two and a half hours away.”
about 0:07:16

2 stars

“A lot of underemployed middle-aged people, including the reviewer, have been unemployed or had a very hard time finding work in their field for what they are worth.”
about 0:08:04

2 stars

“There are tons of restaurants but the nightlife is awful and it is very family oriented, so it is a good place to settle down but not a party town.”
about 0:08:46

In Connecticut

Closest episodes

  1. Is Granny A Psychopath?Barkhamsted, Connecticut · 20 October 202214 km / 9 miShow on map
  2. The Sick RipperNew Britain, Connecticut · 17 July 202522 km / 14 miShow on map
  3. Music Box MurderAgawam, Massachusetts · 25 July 202426 km / 16 miShow on map
  4. Detective FitbitEllington, Connecticut · 5 September 202432 km / 20 miShow on map
  5. Scrap Metal & Sexual UrgesBantam, Connecticut · 3 February 202238 km / 24 miShow on map

The story

Melissa Joan Millan was born in Hartford, Connecticut, on October 30th, 1960, to parents known as Bunny and Tito, and grew up in Simsbury with a couple of brothers. At Simsbury High School she was secretary of her senior class, co-captain of the cross-country team and played in the orchestra. She graduated from Middlebury College in Vermont in 1984 and went straight into the insurance business. By 2014 she was a senior vice president running a retirement services portfolio with more than a billion dollars under management, and was the eighth-highest-paid person at the company. A daughter, Victoria, was born in 2002. She was a triathlete who competed around the north-east. She divorced in 2012 and paid her ex-husband $8,000 a month in alimony.

On the evening of November 20th, 2014 she went out to jog six miles in a headlamp and reflective vest. At about 8 p.m. a driver heading south on Iron Horse Boulevard saw a woman lying bleeding in the road and called 911, thinking she might have fallen off a bicycle. She was unresponsive, lying on her left side next to the footpath near the Rotary Park playground. First responders began CPR and took her to hospital, where she was pronounced dead before 9 p.m., less than an hour after the call.

An autopsy found a single stab wound to the chest that punctured her heart and lung, with no other injuries, no sign of a struggle and no weapon. Police first worked on the theory of a hit and run. The killing shocked the town: it was Simsbury's first homicide since 2012. The Connecticut State Police major crime squad came in, the chief state's attorney's office was briefed and the FBI later joined. Detectives looked first at her ex-husband, who had a rock-solid alibi, cooperated and was cleared, though a shroud of suspicion stayed over him in town. They examined everyone she dealt with at MassMutual, and they ran down the town's four registered sex offenders.

He received probation, paid $431 in restitution and $6,000 in fees, gave a DNA sample and registered as a sex offender. In August 2011 his grandparents took him in in Simsbury. In August 2013 he got a job at Fresh Market in Avon and rose to front end manager, and in the spring of 2014 he met Carrie Bennett, who worked in the bakery. Through her he began attending Open Gate Ministries, a very small evangelical church run out of a house by pastors Michael Traszynski and Colette, and became a member in March 2015.

He was friendly, denied everything, and his child offence did not fit the profile of a stranger attack on an adult woman, so they moved on. In November 2015 police closed Iron Horse Boulevard and Rotary Park for four days and searched with the FBI evidence response team, finding nothing; an anonymous donor put up a $40,000 reward.

He said he had committed a crime, then that he had killed the woman on Iron Horse Boulevard. She called her pastor; they met at the pastors' house, where he said he was sure, stopping for ice cream on the way. On September 19th, 2018 at 9 p.m. he went with Traszynski, another church member and Bennett to the Simsbury police station, walked in at 9.15 and said he was turning himself in for the murder on Iron Horse Boulevard almost four years earlier.

He described the night: the therapy group in Hartford, the headache and loneliness, the flip phone battery coming out in the car park, the knife in the glove compartment he said was a gift for his grandmother, and the woman in pink and black running clothes. He said he crossed the road, ran at her and bumped her, then drew the knife and stabbed her once in the chest. She pushed him away, the knife came free, and she fell over the guardrail into the road. He drove off, threw the knife out of the window, and later destroyed it in the trash compactor at work.

He led them to a glove hidden in a crevice in a small outbuilding on his grandparents' property. Melissa Millan is buried at St Andrew's Episcopal Church cemetery in Hartford County.

The case

Murder of Melissa Millan

Victims

Melissa Millan (54). Senior vice president at Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance; out for a six-mile evening jog in a headlamp and reflective vest

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 29 May 2026.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Michael Traszynski. co-pastor of Open Gate Ministries; went with him to the police station
Colette. co-pastor of Open Gate Ministries, whose home the church met in
Zachary. her son
Victoria. her daughter
Bunny. her mother
Tito. her father
John Griffin. the 1643 tar and turpentine businessman, unrelated to the case

The timeline

  1. October 30th, 1960 Melissa Millan is born in Hartford, Connecticutabout 0:15:03
  2. 1984 She graduates from Middlebury College in Vermont with a bachelor of arts (Middlebury College)about 0:16:13
  3. 1999 She marries, and her son Zachary is bornabout 0:16:28
  4. 2001 She joins Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance in Springfield, Massachusetts (MassMutual headquarters)about 0:17:25
  5. 2002 Her daughter Victoria is bornabout 0:17:37
  6. 2009 , aged 17, sexually assaults an 11-year-old girl in Colorado Springs over a period of monthsabout 0:33:59
  7. August 2011 Aged 20, he moves into his grandparents' house on Goodrich Road in Simsbury (Goodrich Road house)about 0:37:25
  8. 2012 Millan divorces and is ordered to pay her ex-husband $8,000 a month in alimonyabout 0:18:17
  9. August 2013 starts work in the produce department at Fresh Market in Avon (Fresh Market)about 0:42:00
  10. Spring 2014 He meets Carrie Bennett, who works in the bakery, at Fresh Market (Fresh Market)about 0:42:25
  11. 2014 Bennett invites him to services at Open Gate Ministries (Open Gate Ministries)about 0:42:54
  12. November 20th, 2014 In the afternoon attends his weekly sex offender therapy group in Hartford, leaving around 6.30 p.m.about 0:54:23
  13. November 20th, 2014 At about 8 p.m. Millan is stabbed once in the chest as she jogs on the bike path (Simsbury Greenway bike path)about 1:05:31

Last meals

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode