Town file

American Fork, Utah

American Fork, Utah (Utah County, Utah) is the town in one episode of Small Town Murder, the comedy true-crime podcast: episode 166, "Starting Your Own Religion Can Be T..." (9 April 2020). The Lafferty brothers grew up in Payson, Utah, in a family of six boys and two girls.

Town
American Fork
County
Utah County
State
Utah
Country
USA
Episodes
166
Approximate location
40.378, -111.795
N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Episode 166 / 9 April 2020 / 163 min / full

Starting Your Own Religion Can Be T

"We're going to American Fork, Utah ... this is in Utah County, about 30 minutes outside of Salt Lake City" about 0:05:18

The case: Murders of Brenda and Erica Lafferty (July 24, 1984); Deaths of the Strack family (September 2014). Read the case file.

The figures, as told in 2020

Population
28,507
Median age
27.8
Median household income
$71,000
Median home value
$352,500
Two-bedroom rent
about $1,050
Cost of living
112.3
Religious
95.7%
Property crime
▼ just under the national average
Violent crime
▼ about one-third

History, in brief

  • The area was used as a seasonal hunting and fishing ground by the Ute Indians. about 0:08:31
  • American Fork was settled in 1850 by Mormon pioneers. about 0:08:40
  • It was first named Lake City in 1852. about 0:08:44
  • The first settlers were Arza Adams and Stephen man, who settled along the American Fork River. about 0:09:13
  • In the 1850s there was fighting between the incoming Mormons and the Native Americans already there. about 0:09:34
  • At a meeting at the schoolhouse in 1853, Lorenzo Snow and Parley Pratt convinced the settlers to move into one central fort. about 0:09:56
  • The fort was built on a 37-acre site to protect the settlers from native attacks. about 0:10:10
  • The town was renamed American Fork after the river to avoid confusion with Salt Lake City. about 0:10:26
  • It had a public school by the 1860s and was the first community in the Utah territory to offer public education. about 0:10:53
  • American Fork had a rail access point for mining in the 1870s. about 0:11:02
  • The town feuded with Lehi after the Utah Sugar Company chose Lehi as its factory site instead of American Fork. about 0:11:11
  • The population expanded during the Second World War because the Columbia Steel Plant was built there. about 0:11:38
  • The town's annual summer celebration was renamed Steel Days in the forties. about 0:11:52
  • The city built a hospital in 1937. about 0:12:12
  • The 1992 film The Sandlot was filmed around Salt Lake City, and its carnival scene was shot in American Fork on State Street by Robinson Park. about 0:12:20
  • Scenes from Footloose were filmed in American Fork, including the opening church scene, the front porch scene and the gas station scene. about 0:13:15
  • The first ward of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in the area was organised in 1851. about 0:14:04
  • The majority of the population is Mormon, and there is also a Catholic parish in the town. about 0:14:15
  • Steel Days was formerly Timber Day, then Liberty Day, then for years Poultry Day. about 0:28:41
  • It became Steel Day in 1945 for the war effort, after the mayor decided Poultry Day no longer reflected the city's economy. about 0:28:55

The reviews read out

2 stars

"A tiny town in Utah County that is prominently white and Mormon, with an extreme lack of diversity, extremely conservative and rural; there is nothing to do and bored teenagers get into trouble, though it is perfect for a quiet retirement in your sixties."
about 0:14:28

2 stars

"The area's crime is bad and the police services are worse; the reviewer and friends have been affected by theft, drug violence, gang-related crime and police brutality."
about 0:15:26

2 stars

"The area is populated with families, and as a result its restaurants and diversity are not great."
about 0:16:01

"Do not try to find a diner, restaurant or fast food place open after 11, and the few places that are open do not offer kind service."
about 0:16:11

"Titled Don't Live Here: the schools are awful and years behind Milwaukee, Colorado Springs and Denver, the teachers are sub-standard, the people are especially ignorant, almost everyone is Caucasian and Mormon, there is nothing to do, and the county has high prescription abuse, pornography and illicit drug use."
about 0:16:31

Open the episode file

Nearest Small Town Murder towns

Everything here is as told in the episode, on the date it went out; figures and places may have changed since. Endings are covered: open an episode and use the spoiler switch to read them.