Town file

Blackfoot, Idaho

Blackfoot, Idaho (Bingham County, Idaho) is the town in one episode of Small Town Murder, the comedy true-crime podcast: episode 252, "A Skull In The Wood Stove" (2 December 2021). Blackfoot, Idaho, is the seat of Bingham County in the south-east of the state, a potato town of about 12,000 people.

Town
Blackfoot
County
Bingham County
State
Idaho
Country
USA
Episodes
252
Approximate location
43.195, -112.347
N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Episode 252 / 2 December 2021 / 163 min / full

A Skull In The Wood Stove

"Blackfoot, Idaho, south-eastern Idaho, what I like to call the second panhandle; Bingham County" about 0:05:26

The case: Murder of David Lee Davis (February 2017). Read the case file.

The figures, as told in 2021

Population
12,000
Median age
31.4
Median household income
$43,000
Median home value
$254,400
Two-bedroom rent
about $700 a month
Cost of living
82
Religious
70%
Property crime
▲ 15% high
Violent crime
▼ about 15% low

History, in brief

  • The county seat was meant to be Eagle Rock, the original name for Idaho Falls; the night before the legislation was signed, men from Blackfoot bribed a clerk to erase Eagle Rock and write in Blackfoot, and the governor signed it. about 0:08:43
  • Blackfoot residents called the bribery story 'disparaging rumours, intimating some skullduggery on Blackfoot's part' and said it was completely unfounded. about 0:09:53
  • Fred Dubois, a Yale graduate and leader of the south-eastern Idaho anti-Mormons, settled in Blackfoot in 1880. about 0:09:11
  • A newspaper began in 1880; its first issue listed four general merchandise stores, one jewellery store, a livery stable, four saloons, a hotel, a meat market, two blacks' shops, one barber shop and a lumber yard. about 0:10:10
  • A land office was established in 1889 and processed 300 homestead entries in its first three months. about 0:10:31
  • The land office opened to settlement on May 7th, 1907, the ' of the Run', when several thousand homesteaders staked their ground and hurried to Blackfoot to file a claim. about 0:10:49
  • The town motto is 'potato capital of the world'. about 0:07:05
  • The mayor's alternative slogan was 'a trailer in every lot, meth in every pipe'. about 0:07:54

The reviews read out

5 stars

"Loves Blackfoot and the small town atmosphere; everybody is kind and loving and you immediately feel part of the Blackfoot family."
about 0:11:54

5 stars

"Great place to raise a family, close to mountains, skiing, fishing, camping and four wheeling, and 30 minutes from two larger towns for shopping, restaurants and nightlife."
about 0:12:07

2 stars

"Not a neighbourhood the reviewer feels comfortable living in; neighbours are rude and noisy late into the night, houses and lots are unkempt, trash is everywhere and friendly neighbours keep moving away."
about 0:12:26

0 stars

"Grew up there and returned after living in San Francisco; the economy is terrible, there is only potato factory or Walmart work, a management job that paid fifty thousand dollars in California paid eleven dollars an hour, and women are pushed into the lowest paid jobs."
about 0:15:01

1 star

"Lots of Mexicans, trashy people and run-down houses, plan to travel for basic needs, schools near the lowest in the country, overwhelmingly Mormon influenced, no white nightlife and very few restaurants."
about 0:16:43

Open the episode file

Nearest Small Town Murder towns

Everything here is as told in the episode, on the date it went out; figures and places may have changed since. Endings are covered: open an episode and use the spoiler switch to read them.