Town file

Horseshoe Lake, Arkansas

Horseshoe Lake, Arkansas (Crittenden County, Arkansas) is the town in one episode of Small Town Murder, the comedy true-crime podcast: episode 548, "Kill And Let Live" (23 November 2024). Horseshoe Lake is a small town in Crittenden County in north-eastern Arkansas, about forty minutes from Memphis, with a population of 384.

Town
Horseshoe Lake
County
Crittenden County
State
Arkansas
Country
USA
Episodes
548
Approximate location
34.914, -90.308
N ↑Public placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Episode 548 / 23 November 2024 / 71 min / express

Kill And Let Live

"We're going to Horseshoe Lake, Arkansas, in north-eastern Arkansas, about 40 minutes outside of Memphis, and this is in Crittenden County." about 0:03:33

The case: Murders of Sally McKay and Lee Baker (September 10, 1996); Murder of Martha McKay (March 25, 2020). Read the case file.

The figures, as told in 2024

Population
384
Median household income
$48,827
Median home value
$98,200

History, in brief

  • The town is named after Horseshoe Lake, an oxbow lake at whose eastern tip it sits, in the Mississippi River flood plain. about 0:05:22
  • The lake was a summer recreation spot for people from Memphis, who kept vacation cabins there. about 0:05:40
  • The first visitors faced mosquito-borne diseases in the swamps. about 0:05:51
  • Soon after the War of 1812 the land was surveyed and given to soldiers who fought in the war as payment. about 0:06:03
  • In 1825 Crittenden County was carved out of another county and townships were made. about 0:06:15
  • Levees were built to drain the swamp and make the land more inhabitable. about 0:06:28
  • In the 20th century hunters and lumbermen arrived and dammed the lake, raising the water level by over six feet so timber could be floated to the Mississippi. about 0:06:33
  • The floods of 1927 and 1937 wrecked the whole lake area, after which a canal was dug for drainage. about 0:06:45
  • Two centuries ago the lake was a tight bend in the Mississippi; the New Madrid earthquakes of 1811 and 1812 shifted the main channel eastward and left the oxbow. about 0:43:02
  • Cotton plantations were established in the area; the Snowden family bought up land and came to hold about a thousand acres. about 0:43:35
  • The Snowden house, a 6,000-square-foot three-storey home, was used as a location for the film The Client in 1994. about 0:16:37
  • The Snowden house later functioned as a bed and breakfast and as Memphis's premier wedding venue. about 0:46:49

The reviews read out

5 stars

"Lived here all my life and never experienced any other place better; the people are interesting, the scenery is perfect and there's always something to do."
about 0:07:08

2 stars

"Grew up in Hughes and it was a great place to live, but around 1990 it started changing; there are now fewer than a thousand people, one store, and everybody moved when the state closed the school."
about 0:07:26

3 stars

"An overall good experience; the neighbourhood is safe and quiet, but there is no school or job opportunity and everything, including grocery stores and hospitals, is at least 20 miles away."
about 0:08:03

Open the episode file

Nearest Small Town Murder towns

Everything here is as told in the episode, on the date it went out; figures and places may have changed since. Endings are covered: open an episode and use the spoiler switch to read them.