FILE 210 / 11 February 2021 / 148 MIN / full

A Secret In Every Hole

Hartland, MaineListen

The town

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

We're going to Hartland, Maine, and this is in Somerset County. about 0:04:25

History, in brief

Town note

Two explanations are given for the name: the old English word for deer, 'heart', meaning land of the deer, or because the community sits in the heart of the hills.

about 0:06:31

1811

The community had a tavern by 1811, known as the Hartland House.

about 0:08:25
All 10 history facts

Town note

Two explanations are given for the name: the old English word for deer, 'heart', meaning land of the deer, or because the community sits in the heart of the hills.

about 0:06:31

1811

The community had a tavern by 1811, known as the Hartland House.

about 0:08:25

1820

First incorporated as Warrentown in 1820, then changed its name.

about 0:08:45

1903

The area did not get a library until 1903, with books kept in the town hall.

about 0:08:53

1935

From 1935 to 1990 the library collection was in a building that now houses a tannery outlet.

about 0:09:21

1862

Wool mills began operating in 1862, making blue material for soldiers' uniforms.

about 0:11:10

Town note

The tannery owned by Erving Tanning Company has been there forever.

about 0:11:24

The figures, as told

Who lives here

White 98.5% · Black 0.0% · Asian 0.0% · Hispanic 0.4%

Ethnicity can overlap race.

Crime / national average

Property crime
▼ a little bit under the average

about 0:26:02

Violent crime
▼ under half of the average

about 0:26:13

Money

Median home value$80,300
Two-bedroom rent$856 a month
Median household income$31,331
Cost of living76.1

For sale

$64,900

Two-bedroom, two-bath house on 13.2 acres

about 0:20:40

For sale

$164,900

Five-bedroom, two-bath house on over an acre

about 0:21:05

For sale

$599,900

Three-bedroom, two-bath house on 9.22 acres

about 0:21:38
All figures and comparisons, as told in 2021

Property crime

"a little bit under the average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:26:02

Violent crime

"under half of the average"

Comparison: "national average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:26:13

Population

"1,676"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:17:07

Population change since 1990

"down about 7%"

Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:17:11

Male share

"54% male"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:17:15

Married share

"50-50"

Comparison: "50-50 is the normal". No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:17:42

Native American

"0.9%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:18:04

Two or more races

"0.2%"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:18:04

Median household income

"$31,331"

Comparison: "about $57,000 in the rest of the country". No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:18:50

Overall cost of living

"76.1"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:19:35

Housing cost index

"34.7"

Comparison: "100 is average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:19:43

Median home cost

"$80,300"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:19:45

Homes worth less than $100,000

"more than half the houses"

Direction: above.

As told in 2021 about 0:19:52

Average two-bedroom rental

"$856 a month"

Comparison: "less than the average". Direction: below.

As told in 2021 about 0:20:15

Two-bedroom, two-bath house on 13.2 acres

"$64,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:20:40

Five-bedroom, two-bath house on over an acre

"$164,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:21:05

Three-bedroom, two-bath house on 9.22 acres

"$599,900"

No direction stated.

As told in 2021 about 0:21:38

The reviews

1.8 / 5 · average of 5

3 stars

“A small town with access to stores and community resources, friendly townspeople, about 1,800 residents and a tannery that tans hides into leather.”
about 0:12:03

3 stars

“Hartland has its ups and downs, advantages and disadvantages; a long-time resident always thinks about safety but would not rather live anywhere else.”
about 0:13:29

1 star

“Lots of drugs, lots of stealing, lots of rats, no gas station and very untrustworthy people, with one restaurant serving bad food; an amazing place to become a drug dealer or user.”
about 0:14:04

1 star

“Wants people who use substances to get help instead of being on the streets at night screaming and waking residents.”
about 0:15:20

1 star

“Many people do not like to stay away from home for fear their home will be broken into.”
about 0:16:05

In Maine

Closest episodes

  1. Surprising Serial KillerCarmel, Maine · 4 December 202538 km / 24 miShow on map
  2. Facebook Catfish KillerOld Town, Maine · 24 August 202458 km / 36 miShow on map
  3. A Strangely Murderous GrudgeFayette, Maine · 1 May 202669 km / 43 miShow on map
  4. Behind The Murder MaskLitchfield, Maine · 11 July 202587 km / 54 miShow on map
  5. The Shining, But More QuaintNewry, Maine · 27 June 2019117 km / 73 miShow on map

The story

They had been married for 37 years, having wed in the early 1960s when she was about 18 and he about 25. Her father was a violent alcoholic, and when she was 11 she beat him unconscious with a pistol from his nightstand to stop him beating her mother. She married young partly to get out of that house. She worked at times as a butcher's assistant, and both she and Jean were keen hunters and fishermen. They lived on the Athens Road, at routes 43 and 151, in Hartland, Somerset County, Maine.

Neighbours described the Gogans as private people who kept to themselves, though Jean was the more sociable of the two and would walk up the road to talk to a neighbour's husband and son. The marriage was not peaceful. Police had been called to the house four times in the previous couple of years, three times by the sheriff's department and once by the state police. Another neighbour heard Jean threaten, in the front yard, to kill his wife, the family dog and himself and to burn the house down. Several people said the abuse had grown worse as Jean's health declined, and that it escalated sharply in 1999.

A short time later he forced her into the truck and drove her to a remote area of Mayfield Township, about 20 miles away, taking two loaded guns. He ordered her out of the truck. She believed he meant to shoot her there and refused, telling him that if he was going to shoot her he would have to do it in the truck. He drove home.

Jean fell asleep. She took a .22-calibre pistol and shot him in the left ear. The first bullet did not kill him; he sat up and reached for a loaded .38 beside the bed. She fired twice more into the right side of his head and he died. She then dismembered the body into 17 pieces, using the skills she had learnt as a butcher's assistant. She put the parts into black plastic bags and then into military duffel bags, drove them into the woods of Mayfield Township and hand-dug 17 holes, spacing the pieces out and covering each hole with leaves so that the ground looked undisturbed.

On 3 October her sister Carleen Pellettier stopped by the house unannounced. The sisters had seen each other only about four times in 30 years. Carleen persuaded her to report him missing, and that Sunday evening, at about five o'clock, they went to the police station. Asked whether it was true, she said only: 'It's true.'

The search that followed used a mobile crime scene laboratory, a helicopter and dogs. Jean's pickup was still at the house, and there was no sign that he had taken luggage or clothing. That same day a detective began searching the property believing he had a warrant, only to discover that no warrant had been signed. A second warrant was prepared on 5 October and a warrant was finally obtained on 7 October; a judge later ruled that the warrantless search had been lawful because the same evidence would have been found once the warrant arrived.

On 6 October police said publicly that Jean had 'met his demise'. Thirteen parts were found on the first night, the hands the next day, and the thighs were never recovered. Nearly a dozen firearms were taken from the house, but the .22 used in the killing and the butchering tools were never found. On 11 October a medical examiner's report confirmed that Jean had died from multiple gunshot wounds to the head.

On 9 November her lawyer opposed a state request for a court-ordered psychiatric examination, arguing that it would violate her right against self-incrimination. On 19 November, at a bail hearing, the judge set a $190,000 surety bond, allowed her brother's property to stand as security, ordered her to live with her brother and barred her from contact with 24 people, mostly Jean's relatives.

The case was moved from Somerset County to York County because of local publicity. In August 2000 the judge upheld the search.

She later lived in Maine under her maiden name, Pelletier, and the episode says she has not been in trouble since.

The case

Murder of Jean Gogan

Victims

Jean Gogan (62). husband, a hunter and fisherman with a heart condition

Accused and outcomes

As told in the episode, on 11 February 2021.

Accused

Outcome

Other people

Carleen Pellettier. sister, who persuaded her to report Jean missing and told police what had said
Margaret Dunn. neighbour who described the Gogans as neighbourly and private
Cynthia Spencer. Jean Gogan's niece, who said killed him out of rage, not fear

The timeline

  1. , aged 11, beats her violent alcoholic father unconscious with a pistol to stop him beating her motherabout 0:32:34
  2. early 1960s and Jean Gogan marry; she is about 18 and he about 25about 0:34:51
  3. June 1998 Sheriff's deputies stand by while gathers her belongings and leaves the Gogan home; she later returns because of Jean's heart condition (Gogan home)about 0:38:35
  4. 1999 Jean's abuse escalates and neighbours hear him threaten to kill , the family dog and himself and to burn the house down (Gogan home)about 0:48:33
  5. early October 1999 has stopped taking her sleeping pills and antidepressant and has barely slept, fearing Jean will kill her if she falls asleep (Gogan home)about 1:06:04
  6. October 1, 1999 During an argument Jean lifts into the air and her head strikes the bottom of a cupboard (Gogan home)about 1:06:31
  7. October 1, 1999 Jean forces into the truck and drives her to a remote area of Mayfield Township with two loaded guns; she refuses to get out and he drives home (Mayfield Township woods)about 1:06:59
  8. October 1, 1999 That night shoots the sleeping Jean three times in the head with a .22 pistol, killing him (Gogan home)about 1:08:32
  9. October 1, 1999 dismembers Jean's body into 17 pieces (Gogan home)about 1:10:49

Places and phrases

N ↑Public placePublic placePublic placeTown centre (approximate places)
Static locations; no street basemap. Places and details. OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap.

Places in the story

Public places are marked on the map.

Heard in this episode